Montville Pizzeria & Restaurant

- 263 Changebridge Rd, Pine Brook, NJ 07058

The vibrant local dining scene in Pine Brook, New Jersey, has recently welcomed a compelling new addition: Third Proof Pizzeria. Located at the long-standing 263 Changebridge Road address, which was home to the beloved Montville Pizzeria & Restaurant for three decades, Third Proof Pizzeria is carrying on the tradition of a great local pizza spot while bringing its own distinct, high-quality style to the area. While the name is new, the location remains a hub for neighbors craving quality Italian-American comfort food. The focus here is on meticulously crafted pizza, specializing in both thin-crust and airy, crispy square pies. This dedication to a superior product is immediately evident in their detailed approach to dough, sauce, and premium toppings.

Third Proof Pizzeria is quickly earning praise for its authentic and carefully executed pizza styles. The menu highlights specialties like the New Haven Style—a very crispy, thin crust with light mozzarella and heavy sauce—and the airy, crispy Grandma/Sicilian style square pizza. The establishment maintains a friendly, professional tone and provides a casual, quiet atmosphere that is perfect for families, groups, or a relaxed solo dining experience. Building upon the legacy of its predecessor, the restaurant offers full dining services for lunch and dinner, alongside convenient options for quick bites, takeout, and delivery across the Pine Brook and greater Montville region. This ensures the community continues to have a reliable and high-quality local option for their Italian food cravings.

The change in ownership and concept has been met with enthusiasm, as the new pizzeria has established itself as a must-try for local pizza aficionados. The commitment to quality ingredients, such as organic milled tomatoes and fresh, whole milk mozzarella, along with specialty items like crispy cupping pepperoni, speaks to a passion for authentic and elevated pizza making that New Jersey diners will appreciate. The core of the business remains centered on providing fantastic comfort food in a welcoming, accommodating environment.

Third Proof Pizzeria is centrally located at 263 Changebridge Rd, Pine Brook, NJ 07058. This address is well-known in the local community and offers excellent accessibility for residents in Pine Brook, Montville, and surrounding areas. Its location makes it easy to incorporate into a daily routine, whether stopping by for a lunch break or picking up dinner on the way home.

The restaurant prioritizes accessibility for all patrons, featuring comprehensive amenities to ensure a comfortable visit:

• Wheelchair Accessible Entrance: Provides barrier-free entry to the restaurant.
• Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot: Dedicated on-site parking spaces are available for easy access.
• Wheelchair Accessible Restroom: Ensures comfort and convenience for all guests.
• Wheelchair Accessible Seating: Offers appropriate seating arrangements within the dining area.
• Parking Options: Includes a free parking lot and the availability of free street parking nearby, providing ample choices for visitors.

These physical amenities, coupled with the establishment's welcoming atmosphere, make Third Proof Pizzeria an ideal and accommodating venue for families and groups across the community.

Third Proof Pizzeria is structured to provide flexible service options that cater to the modern New Jersey lifestyle, ensuring their quality food is available whenever and wherever customers prefer it.

• Dine-In Service: Provides comfortable seating and a casual, quiet atmosphere perfect for enjoying Lunch, Dinner, or Dessert on-site.
• Takeout and Delivery: Offers speedy service for orders placed for pickup or home delivery across the local region.
• Curbside Pickup: A convenient option for guests who prefer to remain in their vehicle, offering efficiency and ease.
• No-Contact Delivery: Prioritizes safety and preference with a secure delivery method.
• Dining Accommodations: Includes amenities such as a clean Restroom, High Chairs for children, and a specialized Kids' Menu, ensuring a positive experience for family-friendly crowds.
• Flexible Payments: Accepts all major payment methods, including Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and modern NFC Mobile Payments.
• Catering Services: As an Italian restaurant, they are positioned to provide large orders for gatherings, utilizing their extensive pizza and classic Italian menu items.

Third Proof Pizzeria’s menu and atmosphere are designed to offer an elevated yet comforting Italian-American dining experience in Pine Brook.

• Specialization in Pizza Styles: Highly focused on authentic pizza, featuring both traditional thin-crust and airy, crispy square/Grandma styles, and unique options like the crispy New Haven Style.
• Elevated Pizza Offerings: Signature pies include the Pepperoni Hot Honey, Vodka Sauce, White Pizza with garlic ricotta cream, and the Buffalo Chicken, all utilizing high-quality ingredients.
• High-Quality Ingredients: Commits to using premium components such as organic milled tomatoes, fresh, whole milk mozzarella blend, and grated 24-month Parmigiano Reggiano on their square pies.
• Family-Friendly Atmosphere: The casual and quiet vibe is ideal for a relaxed meal. The venue is 'Good for kids' and prepared to handle family groups.
• Full Italian Menu: While pizza is the specialty, the full Italian restaurant type suggests a menu that includes Appetizers (like Mussels and Minestrone), Salads (including Tossed and Cold Antipasto), Cold Sandwiches (such as Chicken Gyro and Ham and Swiss Cheese), and a range of desserts.
• Focus on Comfort Food: The offerings are categorized as 'Comfort food,' 'Quick bite,' and 'Small plates,' making it an excellent choice for satisfying, no-fuss meals throughout the day.
• Legacy Location: Operates out of the location of the former, highly-regarded Montville Pizzeria & Restaurant, carrying forward a long history of serving the local community's pizza needs.
• Appetizer Highlights: Features classic starters like Mussels in a choice of Hot, Sweet, or White Sauce, and traditional Minestrone soup, appealing to a wide range of tastes.
• Highly Positive Local Reception: The mention of the predecessor being a 'great local pizza stop' and customer loyalty over decades suggests the location itself is known for delivering a preferred thin-slice pizza style, a tradition the new establishment appears eager to uphold and enhance.

For inquiries, to place an order for delivery or takeout, or to check on current hours of operation for the Pine Brook location:

Address: 263 Changebridge Rd, Pine Brook, NJ 07058

Phone: (973) 227-7702 (Based on the historical number for the location, now typically redirected to the new establishment).

Third Proof Pizzeria is the perfect choice for New Jersey locals seeking a modern, high-quality take on classic pizza styles, backed by decades of community history at its location. What makes it truly worth choosing is its specialization in multiple, expertly crafted pizza formats—from the thin, crispy New Haven Style to the thick, airy square Grandma—ensuring every pizza preference is catered to with excellence. For the local connoisseur, this offers a higher standard of pizza artistry.

The complete dining package is also a major draw. It offers a comfortable, casual, and quiet environment for a relaxing dinner, while also providing the full spectrum of modern convenience with no-contact delivery, curbside pickup, and easy mobile payment options. This versatility makes it ideal for a quick solo lunch or a leisurely family dinner. Furthermore, the commitment to full accessibility, from parking to seating and restrooms, ensures that every member of the community feels welcome. By choosing Third Proof Pizzeria, you are supporting a local establishment that is not only continuing a legacy of great neighborhood pizza but also raising the bar with refined techniques, premium ingredients, and exceptional customer accommodations. For Pine Brook and Montville residents, it is the new standard for quality Italian comfort food.

Montville Pizzeria & Restaurant

263 Changebridge Rd, Pine Brook, NJ 07058, USA