My Hero

- 1005 Jerusalem Ave, North Merrick, NY 11566

If you're in the New York area, especially on Long Island, and find yourself on the hunt for a truly substantial and classic sandwich experience, look no further than My Hero in North Merrick, NY. More than just a simple "sandwich shop," My Hero operates as a full-service Deli and Takeout Restaurant that has cemented its status as a local institution, consistently delivering oversized portions of quality food that have patrons returning year after year. The essence of this spot is its commitment to tradition, quality, and a friendly, community-focused vibe, making it a reliable choice for everything from a quick lunch break to a catered family gathering.

The shop’s long-standing reputation for excellence has been faithfully maintained, even through a recent ownership change. Long-time customers who were dedicated fans of the previous owners, Dominic and Anthony, have praised the current owners, Chris and his partner, for not only preserving the original spirit and quality of the food but also for introducing improvements. They’re noted as being super hands-on and genuinely caring about the business and its customers, ensuring the food remains just as amazing—or even better—than it was before. This dedication to fresh ingredients, massive portions, and fair pricing keeps the classic deli experience alive and thriving.

---

My Hero is conveniently situated in the heart of the North Merrick community, making it an easy stop for local residents and those traveling through Nassau County. You'll find this popular spot at 1005 Jerusalem Ave, North Merrick, NY 11566.

Accessibility is a key priority at My Hero, ensuring a welcoming environment for all customers. The location offers free parking via a dedicated lot, and for those who find street parking, free street parking is also available. For ease of access, the deli features a wheelchair accessible entrance, a wheelchair accessible parking lot, and a wheelchair accessible restroom. The focus on being a truly community-friendly spot is evident in these details, ensuring that getting in and enjoying your meal is a stress-free experience.

---

My Hero understands that convenience is critical for the busy New Yorker, offering a wide array of service options to fit any schedule or need. Whether you're looking to dine in, grab a meal on the go, or feed a large group, they've got you covered.

• Onsite Services: Customers can enjoy their comfort food right there, with seating available in a casual and cozy atmosphere.
• Takeout and Quick Bites: Perfect for lunch on the run, takeout is a core offering, designed for a quick bite.
• Delivery Options: For ultimate convenience, the shop offers delivery and even no-contact delivery to bring those famous heroes right to your door.
• Curbside Pickup: If you're pressed for time but prefer to pick up your order yourself, curbside pickup is an option.
• Catering: My Hero also provides catering services, making it a superb choice for local businesses, parties, and events where substantial, crowd-pleasing food is a must.
• Counter Service: All orders are handled with efficient counter service.
• Dining Options: They offer food for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, ensuring their delicious options are available throughout the day.

---

What makes My Hero a standout amongst the countless delis on Long Island is a combination of its old-school charm, generous spirit, and diverse menu offerings. It's a place where the atmosphere is as comforting as the food.

• Generous Portions and Value: The sandwiches are notoriously massive, often described as a meal in themselves, ensuring you get excellent value for your money. Patrons consistently remark that the portions are huge and the prices are fair.
• Quality and Freshness: Everything is reported to be super fresh, with staff—including familiar faces from the past—knowing exactly how to make the classic items just the way locals remember them.
• Atmosphere: The vibe is distinctly Casual and Cozy, making it an inviting place to grab a bite. The deli also features Outdoor seating for when the weather is nice.
• Serving the Community: The deli proudly serves local specialty items, embracing its role as a neighborhood favorite. It’s also known for being a great spot to follow Sports.
• Inclusivity: The crowd is diverse and welcoming, including college students, family-friendly groups (complete with a kids' menu), tourists, and is noted as being LGBTQ+ friendly and a Transgender safespace.
• Pet-Friendly Options: For those with four-legged companions, My Hero is unique in that dogs are allowed and dogs are allowed outside, with some reports suggesting they may also be allowed inside.
• Menu Variety: Beyond the signature heroes, the menu includes popular comfort food items, coffee, and options for a quick bite.
• Updated Facility: Recent improvements have brought a nice update to the place, including an awesome new kitchen setup, all while retaining its original charm.
• Availability: The shop is now open seven days a week, a welcome change for loyal customers who no longer have to worry about showing up on a closed Monday.
• Payment Note: Customers should be aware that My Hero is a Cash-only establishment, though checks are also accepted. It's best to come prepared with cash.
• Popular Dining Times: The spot is particularly popular for Lunch and Dinner, and is a good option for Solo dining. Be advised that there is Usually a wait, a testament to its popularity.

---

For inquiries, placing an order, or coordinating catering, you can reach My Hero using the following details:

Address: 1005 Jerusalem Ave, North Merrick, NY 11566

Phone: (516) 785-9226

Mobile Phone: +1 516-785-9226

---

The "Hero" sandwich is the undisputed star of the show at My Hero. When you visit, you're not just getting a sandwich; you're getting a fully loaded, fresh-baked hero experience that’s a Long Island staple. While the entire menu is lauded for its quality, certain items have earned a legendary status among regulars and newcomers alike.

The Chicken Parm Hero is an absolute must-try, frequently described by patrons as one of the best parms they've ever had. It’s a classic, hearty choice where the generous portion of chicken parmigiana is guaranteed to satisfy.

Another hugely popular item is the Chicken Club. Built with a fresh chicken cutlet, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo, it’s a massive sandwich that ranks high among customer favorites. While one review noted a difference in the amount of meat compared to the Chicken Parm, the Chicken Club's overall flavor profile and popularity speak for themselves. The Chicken Cutlet itself, whether on a parm or club, is a central, high-quality ingredient at this deli.

Beyond the chicken options, the dedication to classic, overstuffed deli fare means that any of the hot or cold hero varieties are likely to impress. The commitment to fresh ingredients and friendly, attentive service means that no matter what you pick, you're getting a quality meal prepared with care. My Hero is more than a deli—it's a vibrant, essential piece of the North Merrick and wider Long Island dining scene.

My Hero

1005 Jerusalem Ave, North Merrick, NY 11566, USA