Nate’s Detroit Pizza: Authentic Square Slices and Full Pies on Court Street, Brooklyn

Nate’s Detroit Pizza Introduce

Introduction / Overview

For Brooklyn locals craving a slice of something different,

Nate’s Detroit Pizza

on Court Street is serving up a distinctive culinary experience that is quickly becoming a neighborhood favorite. Located in the charming Carroll Gardens area of Brooklyn, NY 11231, Nate’s isn't just another

Pizza restaurant

; it's a dedicated specialist in the regional American delicacy known as Detroit-style pizza. This style is instantly recognizable by its signature square shape, thick yet light and airy crust, and crispy, caramelized cheese edges—a true form of elevated

Comfort food

Nate’s Detroit Pizza is more than just a place to grab a quick bite; it's a spot where the owner, Nate, often runs the show himself, offering a friendly, personal touch and genuine pride in his product. This dedication to craft is evident in the quality of the food, from the perfectly balanced, fresh-tasting sauce to the exceptional dough and crust. It’s a

Casual

atmosphere that draws in

Locals

for

Lunch

and

Dinner

, establishing itself as a true neighborhood gem in the heart of Brooklyn. The restaurant successfully merges an authentic regional pizza style with the demanding taste of the New York food scene, offering full pies in Medium and Large sizes, as well as convenient slices for a fast meal.

Location and Accessibility

Nate’s Detroit Pizza is conveniently situated at

451 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA

. This Court Street address places it firmly within the highly sought-after Carroll Gardens neighborhood, known for its mix of classic Brooklyn brownstones, local businesses, and excellent dining.

For New Yorkers prioritizing convenience and accessibility, the location offers important amenities. The facility features a

Wheelchair accessible entrance

, ensuring that the delicious pizza is available to all members of the community.

For customers traveling by car, there is

Paid street parking

available nearby, which, while not always abundant in this part of Brooklyn, provides an option for quick takeout stops. However, given its central location on Court Street, many locals find it easily accessible on foot or via public transportation (the F/G subway lines are within walking distance), making it a prime destination for a

Solo dining

experience or a family meal.

The restaurant maintains a comfortable, intimate setting—described as a "Lovely little Pizza Shop"—with some indoor seating available and a small table set up outside, perfect for enjoying a slice of authentic Detroit pizza while soaking in the neighborhood ambiance. The vibe is enhanced by a fun, retro touch, featuring album covers and pictures of singers on the walls.

Services Offered

Nate’s Detroit Pizza is committed to serving its Brooklyn clientele through a variety of flexible service options:

Full Dine-in Service: Enjoy the specialty pizza right on-site in the establishment's welcoming,
Casual
setting for
Lunch
or
Dinner
.
Takeout: A quick and simple option for picking up a single slice or an entire pie for at-home consumption.
Delivery: Reliable service that brings the authentic Detroit pizza experience directly to your door within the local Brooklyn delivery radius.
Individual Slices: Perfect for a
Quick bite
, the menu includes a generous variety of specialty options available by the slice (e.g.,
That Hot Honey Slice
,
Truffle Slice
).
Whole Pizza Ordering: Pies are available in both
Medium
($25.00 - $56.00) and
Large
($36.00 - $56.00) sizes, catering to families, small groups, and large parties.

Features / Highlights

What sets Nate’s apart from the competition in the crowded New York pizza market is its dedication to the unique Detroit style and its premium, inventive toppings:

Authentic Detroit-Style Pizza: The core feature is the signature pizza style—square, with a crispy, caramelized cheese edge and a light, airy internal dough structure, setting a "high bar" for the style in NYC.
Exceptional Crust and Sauce Quality: Customers consistently praise the "perfect dough and crust" and the "fresh and perfectly balanced" sauce, indicating a high-quality product from the foundation up.
Unique and Gourmet Specialty Pies: The menu goes beyond the standard, offering highly distinctive and popular options such as
That Hot Honey
(available as a slice and a whole pie),
Truffle Pizza
, and
Large Vodka Truffle Pizza
, appealing to a sophisticated palate.
Creative Topping Combinations: Nate’s features unusual, mouth-watering combinations like
Large Broccoli Rabe And Sausage
and the exquisite
Large Calabrian Chili And Stracciatella
pizza, ensuring a memorable and unique flavor profile.
Owner-Operated Personal Service: Nate, the owner, is frequently on-site, providing a welcoming and personal customer experience that many patrons appreciate, noting his "pride in the product" and "nicest guy" demeanor.
Flexible Pricing and Options: The availability of slices ($5.50 to $8.50) and multiple sizes of pies ensures that whether a customer needs a cheap
Quick bite
or a premium, full meal, Nate’s provides reasonable options for its gourmet product.

Contact Information

To place an order for delivery or takeout, or for general inquiries, please use the following contact details:

Address: 451 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA

Phone: (347) 294-4679

What is Worth Choosing

When visiting or ordering from Nate’s Detroit Pizza, the decision largely hinges on whether you prefer the classic Detroit experience or one of the shop’s unique, gourmet specialties.

For first-timers or purists, the best place to start is with the classic square slice. The

Cheese Slice

($5.50) is lauded for its perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio and crispy crust, setting a high benchmark for Detroit-style pizza. Alternatively, the

Pepperoni Slice

($6.50) is a timeless favorite that showcases the quality of the fundamental ingredients.

If you are looking for the highly-praised, unique offerings that locals rave about, you must try

That Hot Honey Slice

($8.00). The combination of classic pizza with a drizzle of spicy-sweet honey is a contemporary pizza staple that Nate's executes exceptionally well. For a truly decadent experience, consider the

Vodka Truffle Slice

($8.00) or the

Truffle Slice

($8.50), which incorporate luxurious truffle notes into the savory pizza base.

If ordering a full pie for a group, the

Large Vodka Pizza

($42.00) or the

Supreme Large Pizza

($48.00) offer substantial, satisfying meals. The specialty option, such as the

Large Calabrian Chili And Stracciatella

($56.00), is an investment in a genuinely exceptional and memorable flavor combination. The consistent quality of the dough and the careful application of fresh, high-quality sauce mean that any choice, from a simple slice to a complex specialty pie, delivers a superior

Comfort food

experience. Nate’s Detroit Pizza is a must-try destination for any New Yorker looking for the next great pizza obsession in Brooklyn.

Nate’s Detroit Pizza Vibe

Large Pizzas
Cheese Large Pizza $36.00
Mozz, sauce, parm, basil.
Pepperoni Large Pizza $42.00
Mozz, sauce, parm, basil, hand cut pepperoni.
Supreme Large Pizza $48.00
Mozz, sauce, parm, basil, hand cut pepperoni, thick-cut bacon, sausage.
The Best Hawaiian Large Pizza $48.00
Fresh mozzarella, tomato, pineapple, Canadian bacon, aged Parmesan, flaky salt, house made hot honey.
That Hot Honey Large Pizza $48.00
Fresh mozzarella, sauce, pepperoni, thick cut bacon, house made hot honey, Maldon salt, aged Parmesan, basil.
Truffle Large Pizza $56.00
Medium (9x9). mozz, ricotta, truffle gouda, done for black truffle sauce, garlic, parm, basil, black truffle salt.
Naked Supreme Large Pizza $48.00
Mozz, sauce, parm, basil, hand cut pepperoni, thick-cut bacon, sausage.
Large Vodka Pizza $42.00
Tomatoes, fresh mozz, vodka cream sauce, aged Parmesan, maldon salt, basil
Large Vodka Truffle Pizza $56.00
Fresh mozzarella and garlic topped with our creamy truffle vodka sauce, fresh ricotta and aged Parmesan
Large Broccoli Rabe And Sausage $48.00
Broccoli rabe, garlic, crushed red pepper, Italian sausage, fresh mozzarella, aged Parmesan
Large Calabrian Chili And Stracciatella $56.00
Calabrian chili, stracciatella (inside of a burrata), fresh mozzarella, sliced garlic, aged Parmesan, maldon salt, basil

Slices
That Hot Honey Slice $8.00
Pepperoni Slice $6.50
Mozz, sauce, parm, basil, hand cut pepperoni.
Cheese Slice $5.50
Mozz, sauce, parm, basil.
Supreme Slice $7.50
Mozz, sauce, parm, basil, hand cut pepperoni, thick-cut bacon, sausage.
Truffle Slice $8.50
Medium (9x9). mozz, ricotta, truffle gouda, done for black truffle sauce, garlic, parm, basil, black truffle salt.
The Best Hawaiian Slice $8.00
Fresh mozzarella, tomato, pineapple, Canadian bacon, aged Parmesan, flaky salt, house made hot honey.
Vodka Slice $6.50
Tomatoes, fresh mozz, vodka cream sauce, aged Parmesan, maldon salt, basil
Vodka Truffle Slice $8.00
Fresh mozzarella and garlic topped with our creamy truffle vodka sauce, fresh ricotta and aged Parmesan
Broccoli Rabe And Italian Sausage $7.00
Broccoli rabe, garlic, crushed red pepper, Italian sausage, fresh mozzarella, aged Parmesan
Calabrian Chili And Stracciatella $8.00
Calabrian chili, stracciatella (inside of a burrata), fresh mozzarella, sliced garlic, aged Parmesan, maldon salt, basil

Medium Pizzas
Pepperoni Medium Pizza $30.00
Mozz, sauce, parm, basil, hand cut pepperoni.
Supreme Medium Pizza $35.00
Mozz, sauce, parm, basil, hand cut pepperoni, thick-cut bacon, sausage.
Cheese Medium Pizza $25.00
Mozz, sauce, parm, basil.
The Best Hawaiian Pizza Medium $36.00
Fresh mozzarella, tomato, pineapple, Canadian bacon, aged Parmesan, flaky salt, house made hot honey.
That Hot Honey Medium Pizza $36.00
Truffle Medium Pizza $40.00
Medium (9x9). Mozz, ricotta, truffle gouda, done for black truffle sauce, garlic, parm, basil, black truffle salt.
Naked Supreme Medium Pizza $35.00
Mozz, sauce, parm, basil, hand cut pepperoni, thick-cut bacon, sausage.
Medium Vodka Pizza $36.00
Tomatoes, fresh mozz, vodka cream sauce, aged Parmesan, maldon salt, basil
Medium Vodka Truffle Pizza $40.00
Fresh mozzarella and garlic topped with our creamy truffle vodka sauce, fresh ricotta and aged Parmesan
Medium Broccoli Rabe And Sausage $36.00
Broccoli rabe, garlic, crushed red pepper, Italian sausage, fresh mozzarella, aged Parmesan
Medium Calabrian Chili And Stracciatella $40.00
Calabrian chili, stracciatella (inside of a burrata), fresh mozzarella, sliced garlic, aged Parmesan, maldon salt, basil

Salads
Lemon Vinaigrette $5.50
Lemon Vinaigrette, shaved parm, croutons
Caesar Salad $6.00
Romain lettuce, Anchovy, Parmesan, lemon, olive oil, croutons

Nate’s Detroit Pizza Details

Service options
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Comfort food
Quick bite

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner

Atmosphere
Casual

Crowd
Locals

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards

Children
Good for kids

Parking
Paid street parking

Nate’s Detroit Pizza Photos

Nate’s Detroit Pizza Location

Nate’s Detroit Pizza

New York Kings County Carroll Gardens Court Street

451 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA

Nate’s Detroit Pizza Reviews

An average rating of ★4.7 from 113 user reviews.

honeydetroit style pizzaslicepepperonipricevodkatrufflemusicrecord playershrimp scampi

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

This pizza is exceptional! Delicious sauce and perfect dough and crust.Other than the classic cheese and pepperoni with hot honey, I also tried the new shrimp scampi with lemon, and what a special bite that was.Loved the music and the choice of records on the walls, and Nate is the nicest guy. This is definitely becoming a regular stop.
September 11 · Dror Pikielny
Lovely little Pizza Shop. It's small but there is some seating and a small table outside. Nate himself is the one running the show. He is very nice. I loved his pride in the product. I had the Cheese slice (square). It was my first Detroit style Pizza and it set the bar high. The slice was crispy and yet light and airy inside. The Cheese to sauce ratio was perfect and the sauce tasted fresh and perfectly balanced. There are Álbum Covers and pics of singers on the wall. The prices are very reasonable. This place is a neighborhood gem.
September 12 · Vivianne Barretto
This pizza was awesome!! This was our last stop on a self guided pizza tour and it was the perfect note to end on. The hot honey pizza was incredible. The crust on all the pizzas is so crispy and delicious. The owner was so nice too. Will definitely be back!
May 12 · Kasey Levine
Crazy authentic Detroit slice, all the way down to vibe (dope record player) and hospitality (baked fresh Hot Honey for us, and gave us a cheese slice while we waited). Get the large size-more worth it.
May 23 · Yao Xen Tan
Such a good spot!! The pizza is AMAZING, so unique and just absolutely delicious. Nate is so sweet and genuinely loves his job! It was a really fun place to grab an incredible slice. The hot honey is sooo good!
March 08 · Diana Richardson