New York Avenue Pizza

- 1727 New York Ave, Huntington Station, NY 11746

For residents of Long Island and the greater New York region, the search for authentic, high-quality pizza and Italian-American comfort food often leads straight to Huntington Station. New York Avenue Pizza, located directly on its namesake road, is a true local staple that embodies the spirit of a classic New York pizzeria while carving out its own distinct culinary identity. This establishment is recognized not just for offering a wide array of classic Italian dishes, but for delivering on the promise of a satisfying, generously portioned, and reliably delicious meal, whether you’re grabbing a slice or sitting down for dinner.

As a proud fixture in the Long Island food scene, New York Avenue Pizza effortlessly blends the traditional and the innovative. They serve the core Italian-American menu that locals expect—from robust pasta dishes like Seafood Marinara ($29.95) to deeply satisfying Chicken Parmigiana ($14.95) Heroes. Crucially, they are renowned for their signature take on the classic pizza pie. Customer reviews frequently highlight the pizzeria's unique "sweet sauce slice," a truly singular flavor experience that sets it apart from the competition across Long Island. This special sauce, often paired with a crispy crust featuring sesame seeds, has earned them a loyal following and a reputation as a must-try destination for any serious pizza enthusiast in the New York area.

The atmosphere inside New York Avenue Pizza is exactly what you hope for in a local spot: Casual and Cozy. It’s a place where Locals, College students, and Family-friendly groups all feel equally welcome. The restaurant is geared towards maximum convenience and comfort, offering an impressive range of service and dining options that make it suitable for almost any occasion, from a quick Late-night food run to a planned dinner outing that even accepts reservations.

Location and Accessibility

New York Avenue Pizza is strategically located in Huntington Station, making it an easy-to-reach spot for residents across Suffolk County.

The specific address is: 1727 New York Ave, Huntington Station, NY 11746, USA.

Located on a major thoroughfare, the restaurant ensures high visibility and simple navigation. Crucially for any popular New York establishment, New York Avenue Pizza has made extensive efforts to ensure its facility is fully accessible to all community members. These features significantly enhance the user experience and underscore the restaurant's commitment to serving everyone:

• Wheelchair Accessibility: The premises boast both a Wheelchair accessible entrance and designated Wheelchair accessible parking lot.
• Inclusive Seating: They provide Wheelchair accessible seating options, allowing all patrons to enjoy the cozy dine-in experience comfortably.
• Convenient Parking: The availability of an accessible parking lot removes one of the most common hassles associated with dining in busy Long Island areas.

This attention to accessibility, combined with the central location, makes New York Avenue Pizza a highly practical and inclusive choice for lunch, dinner, or a quick bite for New York locals.

Services Offered

Reflecting the fast-paced, high-demand dining culture of New York, New York Avenue Pizza offers a full spectrum of service options focused on customer convenience and flexibility.

• In-House Dining: Enjoy a relaxing meal with Seating available for Dine-in, complemented by a comfortable and Casual atmosphere.
• Outdoor Seating: On pleasant days, customers can enjoy their pizza and Italian meals using the available Outdoor seating.
• Takeout and Pickup: Quick and efficient Takeout is available, along with contactless Curbside pickup for maximum convenience and speed.
• Delivery Service: For those preferring to stay in, reliable Delivery service brings their full menu of Italian favorites right to your door.
• Group and Event Planning: The restaurant Accepts reservations for groups and also offers full Catering services, making it a viable option for parties, meetings, and family events.
• Payment Flexibility: Transactions are easy with multiple payment options, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and modern NFC mobile payments.

These comprehensive service options ensure that New York Avenue Pizza is perfectly equipped to handle the demands of the Huntington Station community, whether it's a weekday solo lunch or a weekend gathering.

Features / Highlights

New York Avenue Pizza stands out in the crowded Long Island pizza market due to several key features, blending classic Italian-American standards with locally beloved innovations.

• The Signature Sweet Sauce Pie: This is a major highlight, frequently mentioned in customer praise. The option for a "sweet sauce" on their large pies or slices offers a distinct and highly enjoyable flavor profile that is truly unique to the area.
• Diverse Pizza Selection: The menu offers something for every pizza lover, including:
  • The popular Plain White Pie ($26.95) (Ricotta, Mozzarella, Parmesan).
  • Classic square-cut styles like the Grandma and Sicilian (available per search results).
  • Specialty options such as Meat Lover ($34.95), BBQ Chicken Pizza ($34.95), and the ever-popular Buffalo Chicken Pizza ($34.95).
• Hearty Heroes and Rolls: Perfect for a filling lunch or dinner, these oversized sandwiches and rolls are a cornerstone of the menu:
  • Classic Chicken Parmigiana ($14.95) and Sausage & Peppers ($14.95) Heroes.
  • Popular baked items like the Chicken Roll ($10.95) and Sausage Roll ($10.95).
• Full Italian Entrees: Beyond pizza, the menu offers full-service Italian entrees, including high-end options like Seafood Marinara ($29.95) and other pasta standards like Fettuccine Alfredo (as per search results), making it a versatile dinner spot.
• All-Day Dining and Comfort Offerings: The restaurant is "Popular for Lunch, Dinner, and Solo dining," offering true Comfort food, Quick bite options, and even Late-night food. They also offer Wine to complement the dining experience.

These highlights cement New York Avenue Pizza's status as a go-to spot for both traditional Italian staples and unique local favorites in Huntington Station.

Contact Information

To place your order for a classic specialty pie, inquire about catering services, or make a reservation for seating, please use the following contact details. The staff is ready to assist with a friendly, professional service approach that is valued by the local community.

Address: 1727 New York Ave, Huntington Station, NY 11746, USA

Phone: (631) 683-5078

The easy-to-reach location and accessible phone line ensure that all Long Island residents can connect quickly and conveniently to arrange their dining or takeout needs.

What is Worth Choosing New York Avenue Pizza

For those in the New York area, particularly on Long Island, choosing New York Avenue Pizza is choosing a place that genuinely understands and executes classic Italian-American cuisine with a notable twist. The sheer breadth of their menu—from traditional Cheese Pie and Sicilian Pizza to specialty items and full pasta entrees—ensures that every family member, friend, or coworker will find a favorite. This deep menu variety makes it an incredibly reliable choice for groups and parties.

What truly makes this restaurant worth choosing, however, is its signature pizza. The highly praised "sweet sauce" option, often combined with a sesame seed-crusted undercarriage, provides a unique and memorable flavor that has earned it local legend status. As one customer stated, the pepperoni pizza "tastes just as good" as it looks, highlighting the quality and attention to detail. This distinctive offering gives local New Yorkers a compelling reason to choose this spot over the countless others available.

Beyond the food, the level of service and accessibility is paramount. The dedication to a Family-friendly, Casual environment that also caters to College students and offers Late-night food makes it a universal community hub. The commitment to full Wheelchair accessible amenities further solidifies its role as an inclusive and considerate local business. When you need authentic Italian food that delivers comfort, quality, and a truly unique Long Island flavor, New York Avenue Pizza is the definitive choice.

New York Avenue Pizza

1727 New York Ave, Huntington Station, NY 11746, USA