Niccolo Pizzeria

- 2127 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10032

In a city as saturated with pizza joints as New York, finding a place that truly stands out is a rare and delightful experience. Niccolo Pizzeria, situated in the heart of the Washington Heights neighborhood, is one such rarity. This pizza restaurant has quickly become a local favorite by expertly blending authentic Italian tradition with the bold, eclectic flavors of New York City. The result is a menu that is both familiar and innovative, and a culinary experience that has been described by a customer as the "best pizza I ever had." The atmosphere is casual, yet the quality of the ingredients and the passion behind the preparation are anything but. From the use of high-quality San Marzano tomatoes and fresh mozzarella to the careful preparation of the dough, every element is designed to create a superior product. This dedication to craftsmanship and hospitality is a major reason why Niccolo Pizzeria has garnered a loyal following, making it a true gem in the city's food scene. Whether you are a local resident or a visitor, Niccolo Pizzeria offers a warm welcome and a culinary journey you won't soon forget.

The menu at Niccolo Pizzeria is a carefully crafted celebration of Italian-American cuisine, extending far beyond the typical pizza joint offerings. The pizza itself is a major highlight, with a variety of "Whole Pies" in different sizes, including classics like "Cheese Pie" and "Pepperoni Pie," as well as more inventive creations such as the "Firebee" with Italian sausage and Mike's hot honey, and the "Bambola" featuring burrata and prosciutto. A customer review raves about the "Grandma Pie" and the "plain cheese pie" for its amazing crispness and cheese that "taste like it was straight from Italy." Beyond pizza, the menu features a selection of traditional and delicious items. The "Pasta Menu" includes both "Niccolo Meat Lasagna" and a "Vegetarian Lasagna," both served with garlic knots. The deli also offers a range of sandwiches, including "Chicken Parm" and "Meatball Parmigiana" on pizza dough, as well as unique "Focaccia" sandwiches like "Dolce Vita" with burrata and fig jam. For those looking for a quick bite, the menu includes "Garlic Knots," "Pizza Rolls," and "Soups." The dessert menu is also a must-try, with Italian treats like "Bombolone" and the "Nutella Calzone," which one reviewer called an "unforgettable dessert." The availability of various "Lunch Special" boxes provides an affordable and convenient option for a midday meal. The extensive and high-quality menu ensures that Niccolo Pizzeria offers something to satisfy every craving.

The charm of Niccolo Pizzeria is not limited to its food; it also lies in its warm and welcoming atmosphere. The setting is described as casual and is suitable for a variety of dining occasions, from a quick bite on your own to a family meal. The restaurant is "good for kids," and "dogs are allowed outside," making it a family-friendly and accommodating spot. As noted by a customer, the staff, including a "sweet and polite" old Italian man who works the counter, contributes to a genuinely caring environment. The story of him coming out to the car to give a gelato sample and helping with the pizza box highlights the personal and hospitable service that defines the place. This level of customer care and warmth is a rare find and a significant reason for the restaurant's popularity. The restaurant also offers catering services, making it a great option for events and larger gatherings. This combination of a high-quality product with exceptional customer service creates a dining experience that feels both authentic and personal. It's a place where you're not just a customer; you're treated like a part of the family.

Niccolo Pizzeria is conveniently located at 2127 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10032, USA. This places it in the vibrant Washington Heights neighborhood, a bustling area with a rich cultural tapestry. The deli's location on Amsterdam Avenue makes it easily accessible for local residents and visitors alike. The area is well-served by New York City's public transportation network, with several subway stations and bus stops within walking distance, making it a convenient destination from various parts of the city. While there are no specific details on parking, its location on a major avenue likely means street parking is available, as is common in the neighborhood. The restaurant offers a variety of service options, including dine-in, takeout, delivery, and "no-contact delivery," catering to the needs of a modern, fast-paced city. This flexibility in service, combined with its easy-to-find location, makes it a highly practical choice for a quick lunch, a relaxed dinner, or an order to be enjoyed at home. The restaurant also has an official website and is available on delivery apps, further enhancing its accessibility and convenience for a wide range of customers.

Services Offered:

• Onsite dining with a casual atmosphere.
• Takeout for a convenient grab-and-go option.
• Delivery and no-contact delivery for at-home enjoyment.
• Catering services for events and parties.

Features / Highlights:

• Authentic Italian-style pizza with fresh ingredients and innovative toppings.
• Diverse menu including focaccia sandwiches, pasta, and desserts.
• Known for friendly and polite staff, providing a warm atmosphere.
• Family-friendly and "good for kids."
• Dogs are allowed in the outdoor seating area.
• Perfect for lunch, dinner, and solo dining.
• Accepts credit cards and debit cards for easy payments.

Contact Information:

• Address: 2127 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10032, USA
• Phone: (646) 964-5061

What is worth choosing Niccolo Pizzeria? The answer is clear: it’s a place that offers a complete and exceptional experience, combining a passion for authentic Italian cuisine with a modern, New York sensibility. The quality of the food is a major draw, with one customer stating it's the "best pizza I ever had." The use of fresh, top-notch ingredients like San Marzano tomatoes and high-quality mozzarella sets it apart from typical pizza spots. Beyond the pizza, the menu is a treasure trove of delicious options, from the perfectly made lasagna to the unique focaccia sandwiches and the unforgettable Nutella calzone. The restaurant also prides itself on its outstanding service, treating customers like family and creating a genuinely welcoming environment. The flexibility in service options, including dine-in, takeout, and delivery, makes it a convenient choice for any occasion. For a local New Yorker, finding a place that delivers on both quality and hospitality is a major win. Niccolo Pizzeria is more than just a place to eat; it's a neighborhood institution that offers a slice of authentic Italy right in the heart of Washington Heights. It’s a place that is "definitely worth the price point" and is sure to become a new favorite pizza spot for anyone who visits.

Niccolo Pizzeria

2127 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10032, USA