Noche de Margaritas: Your Guide to Authentic Mexican Food on the Upper East Side

Noche de Margaritas Introduce

Welcome to our comprehensive guide to Noche de Margaritas, a vibrant and authentic Mexican restaurant that brings the flavors of Mexico to the heart of New York City's Upper East Side. This isn't just another spot for tacos and guacamole; it's a destination that promises a full sensory experience, from the lively atmosphere and spectacular decor to the rich, flavorful dishes and strong, handcrafted margaritas. Noche de Margaritas has quickly become a local favorite, celebrated for its commitment to traditional Mexican cuisine and its warm, welcoming service that makes every guest feel right at home. Whether you're planning a casual dinner, a lively brunch with friends, or a special celebration, this restaurant offers the perfect setting. We'll dive into what makes this spot a true gem, from its convenient location and accessibility to its extensive menu and standout features that have earned it rave reviews from New Yorkers who appreciate great food and a memorable dining experience.

The name "Noche de Margaritas" translates to "Margarita Night," and it's a fitting title for a place that's known for its expertly mixed drinks. But the experience extends far beyond the bar. The menu is a testament to the diversity of Mexican cuisine, offering everything from classic favorites like enchiladas and burritos to more unique and flavorful dishes like Carne Asada and various seafood creations. The atmosphere is consistently described as fun and festive, with one of its most unique highlights being the live mariachi nights on Sundays, where you can even request your favorite songs. This interactive element, combined with the colorful and inviting decor, creates a celebratory mood that is perfect for any occasion. The restaurant’s staff, described as attentive, hospitable, and sweet by customers, adds to the overall feeling of being taken care of. Read on to discover all the reasons why Noche de Margaritas should be your next go-to spot for an unforgettable Mexican dining adventure in NYC.

Noche de Margaritas is perfectly located at 1726 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10128, right in the bustling heart of the Upper East Side. This prime address makes it easily accessible for anyone living or working in the area, as well as those visiting from other parts of the city. For New Yorkers who rely on public transportation, the restaurant is conveniently situated near multiple subway lines. The 4, 5, and 6 trains at the 86th Street and Lexington Avenue station are just a few blocks away, providing a direct route from various boroughs. The Q train is also a short walk away. The central location makes it an ideal meeting spot for groups, offering a place that's easy to get to and from, no matter where your journey begins.

The accessibility of Noche de Margaritas goes beyond its location. It offers a variety of service options to cater to modern urban life. In addition to a comfortable indoor seating area and a popular outdoor seating option, the restaurant provides convenient choices like curbside pickup, no-contact delivery, and standard delivery. This ensures that you can enjoy their delicious food and drinks whether you’re dining in, grabbing a quick meal on the go, or having a cozy night in. The flexibility in service options is particularly valuable in a city like New York, where convenience is key. Whether you're coming for a leisurely brunch or need a quick and easy dinner solution after a long day, Noche de Margaritas is set up to meet your needs.

Services Offered:

A diverse menu featuring authentic Mexican cuisine, including appetizers, soups, salads, enchiladas, burritos, fajitas, meat and chicken entrees, and seafood dishes.
A dedicated kids' menu, with options like a cheeseburger with french fries, making it a family-friendly destination.
A full bar offering a wide variety of alcoholic beverages, including beer, wine, cocktails, and happy hour drink specials.
Multiple dining options: available for brunch, lunch, dinner, and dessert, with comfortable seating both indoors and outdoors.
Convenient service options including curbside pickup, no-contact delivery, standard delivery, and takeout.
Accepts major credit cards for easy payment.

Features / Highlights:

A lively and fun atmosphere with spectacular decor, making for a festive dining experience.
Mariachi nights on Sundays, where guests can request songs, adding a unique and memorable entertainment element.
Known for serving spectacular food, with customer reviews raving about dishes like ribeye steaks, birria tacos, and steak burritos.
Drinks are described as strong and flavorful, with a special focus on their signature margaritas.
Homemade and fresh items, as highlighted by a customer who praised the fresh, homemade tortilla chips with salsa and guacamole.
A highly attentive and hospitable staff, ensuring a pleasant and welcoming experience.
Generous portion sizes, with one customer noting that they could barely finish their steak burrito due to its size.
Highly recommended for brunch, based on the fun decor and overall vibe.

Contact Information:

Address: 1726 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10128

What is worth choosing Noche de Margaritas?

Choosing Noche de Margaritas means opting for more than just a meal; it means choosing an experience. The restaurant distinguishes itself by combining the highest quality food and drinks with a vibrant, celebratory atmosphere that is hard to find elsewhere. The menu is a journey through Mexico's culinary landscape, from classic comfort food to sophisticated entrees. Dishes like the ribeye steaks and birria tacos are described as "spectacular" by a real customer, while the steak burritos are praised for their awesome flavor and generous portion size. The use of fresh, homemade ingredients, such as the tortilla chips and guacamole, shows a commitment to authenticity and quality that discerning New Yorkers appreciate. This attention to detail elevates the entire dining experience, making every bite feel special.

Beyond the food, the vibrant ambiance is a huge part of the appeal. The "fun" decor and festive vibe make it a great place for any gathering, from a casual dinner with a loved one to a group celebration. The live mariachi nights are a standout feature that sets Noche de Margaritas apart from its competitors. The ability to request songs creates a personal connection and a sense of shared joy that is truly unique. This focus on creating a lively and engaging environment makes the restaurant an excellent choice for a memorable night out. Furthermore, the strong and flavorful drinks, particularly the margaritas, are a major draw. As one customer noted, the drinks are "on fire," ensuring that your dining experience is as spirited as the atmosphere.

Lastly, the exceptional service is a defining factor. Multiple reviews praise the staff for being attentive, hospitable, and sweet. Feeling "at home" in a bustling city restaurant is a rare and valued quality. The staff’s dedication to making guests feel welcome contributes significantly to the overall enjoyment of the visit. This combination of spectacular food, a lively atmosphere, and genuine hospitality makes Noche de Margaritas a standout choice for anyone in New York looking for an authentic and unforgettable Mexican dining experience. It is a place where every element, from the decor to the dessert, comes together to create a truly special moment.

Noche de Margaritas Vibe

Appetizers / Aperitivos
Margarita Nachos $10.00
Corn Tortilla Chips, Topped with Choice of Shredded Chicken, Ground Beef or Chorizo, Along with Refried Beans, Melted Cheese and Pickled Jalapeños. Garnished with Pico De Gallo
Calamares Asados O Fritos $10.00
Grilled or Deep Fried Marinated Calamari Served with Our Special Spicy Dippin Sauce on the Side
Chile Con Carne $9.00
Ground Beef Bean Chili, Jalapeños, Melted Cheese and Side of Tortillas
Margarita Quesadilla
Large Flour Tortilla with Cheese and Any Choice of Meat. All Are Served with Lettuce, Guacamole, Sour Cream Red and Green Sauce
Margarita Tacos
Three Corn Tortilla Choice Crispy or Soft with Any Choice of Meat Below, Garnished with Pico De Gallo & Side of Spicy Sauce
Chicken Flautas $12.00
Three Crispy Tortillas Rolled with Chicken, Onion, Peppers & Cheese, Topped with Refried Beans, Red & Green Sauce with Sour Cream, Lettuce and Cream
Margarita's Queso Fundido $12.00
Choice of Vegetables, or Mexican Sausage, Served in a Hot Sizzling Plate with Melted Cheese and Onions and Peppers. Accompanied with a Side of Flour Tortillas.

Salads / Ensaladas
Ensalada de naranja $8.00
Spinach, lettuce, apples, sliced orange, celery and avocado. Served with balsamic dressing

Soups/ Sopas
Sopa de tortillas $8.00
Shredded chicken, vegetables & rice in a chicken broth, with crispy tortillas strips
Black bean soup $7.00
Prepared with Mexican spices, crispy tortilla strips, chopped cilantro & sour cream
Pozole poblano $11.00
Hominy corn soup with chicken & oregano finished with pico de gallo & slice avocado

Enchiladas Y Burritos
Tacos Azteca $15.00
Three crispy hard shelled tacos with either chicken or ground beef, topped with lettuce, sour cream, cheese & guacamole, with refried beans and rice
Chimichangas $14.00
Two fried flour tortillas stuffed with shredded chicken or beef, topped with green or red sauce, sour cream. Served with refried beans, rice, lettuce & guacamole
La Cena de Noche $16.00
Poblano pepper stuffed with cheese, chicken tamales & a beef burrito, with two different sauces, black beans, rice, lettuce, guacamole and sour cream.
Enchiladas Suizas $15.00
Two soft corn tortillas, rolled with chicken, topped with green sauce, sour cream & melted cheese. Served with black beans, rice, lettuce & guacamole
Enchiladas mi bandera $16.00
Three soft corn tortillas, rolled with cheese, one with chicken and another with beef, topped with three different sauces. Served with refried beans rice, lettuce and guacamole
Burritos norteño $14.00
Two flour tortillas rolled with shredded chicken or ground beef, onion, peppers and red sauce. Served with white rice, black beans, lettuce, sour cream & guacamole
Super burrito relleno
Large flor tortilla rolled with lettuce, guacamole, black beans, rice & topped with melted cheese,pico de gallo, red & green sauce, and stuffed with any of the three meat options
Burritos fajitas $16.00
Two flour tortillas rolled with grilled marinated chicken, onions, peppers, mushrooms and fresh tomatoes, black beans, rice, lettuce and guacamole
Tamales poblanos $14.00
Two corn dough stuffed with your choice of beef or chicken. served with rice, beans, lettuce, tomato, guacamole topped with red & green sauce and melted cheese, garnish with sour cream
Red snapper burritos $15.00
Two flour tortillas rolled with red snapper, onions, peppers and green sauce. Served with refried beans, rice, lettuce and guacamole
Chile rellenos $17.00
Two poblano peppers with stuffed choice of ground beef, chicken or cheese, topped with melted cheese and red sauce. Served with refried beans, rice, lettuce and guacamole. Whole wheat tortilla available and spinach tortilla

Sizziling Hot Fajitas
Steak or chicken fajita $19.00
Grilled marinated chicken or skirt steak with onion, zucchini, peppers, mushrooms and fresh tomatoes. with refried beans, rice & flour tortilla garnished with sour cream & guacamole
Fajitas Torito $22.00
Grilled filet mignon, chicken, calamari, shrimp, mexican sausage, cactus & vegetables. Served with rice, beans & flour tortillas

Vegetarian Delights
Nachos Supremos $11.00
Tortillas chips topped with refried beans, pickled jalapeños. Served with lettuce & guacamole
Quesadilla HuItlacoche $12.00
Grilled large flour tortilla folded in half with black corn, mushrooms,onions & jalapeños. Topped with red & green sauce. Served with lettuce & guacamole
Super burrito veggie $12.00
Two flour tortilla rolled with lettuce, guacamole, black beans, rice & vegetables. Topped with red & green sauce
Fajitas del campo $16.00
Sautée broccoli, mushrooms, peppers, string beans, carrots, cauliflower, spinach, zucchini & onions. served with rice, beans & tortillas

Meat - Res
Carne asada a la tampiqueña $20.00
Grilled hanger steak marinated with a smoked sauced topped with pico de gallo, cheese enchilada, tomato sauce & melted cheese. with black beans, lettuce & guacamole
Churrasco oxaqueño $23.00
Grilled skirt steak marinated with costeño chile-ginger dressing, garnished with a cactus-pineapple pico de gallo. Served with rice and black beans
Bisteck garibaldi $23.00
Grilled sirloin steak topped with onions, peppers & fresh tomato. Served with refried beans, rice, lettuce & guacamole

Combination Platters
Combinacion Toluca $22.00
Grilled steak and chicken topped with our BBQ sauce. Served over yellow rice and garnished with chorizo and crabmeat, shrimp. Comes with sweet fried plantains
La parrilla de la mama $20.00
Grilled chicken breast with mole, cheese quesadilla and beef taco, served with rice, beans and lettuce

Chicken - Pollo
Pollo Chipotle $16.00
Grilled chicken breast with spicy chipotle sauce. Served with refried beans & guacamole
Pollo mazatlan $16.00
Grilled chicken breast topped with peppers, onions, mushrooms, olives and fresh tomato topped with melted cheese. Served with black beans, rice, lettuce & guacamole
Pollo limon $16.00
Sauteed chicken breast with white wine, lemon and garlic. served with refried beans, rice, lettuce & guacamole
Pollo con mole poblano $16.00
Chicken breast topped with mole sauce & sesame seeds. Served with refried beans, rice, lettuce & guacamole

Seafood - del Mar
Camarones Horninos $20.00
Sauteed jumbo shrimp in a tequila mango sauce with onions, peppers and cilantro served with black beans and rice
camarones rellenos $22.00
Jumbo Shrimp stuffed with crabmeat, lightly breaded & fried topped with chipotle mayonnaise sauce. Served over a mango mesclun salad and a side of rice & beans
Salmon Cozumel $20.00
Grilled salmon topped with chipotle BBQ sauce. Served over green sauce and vegetables, garnished with fried plantains

Kids Menu
Cheeseburger with french fries $7.00

Quesadillas
French Fries $3.00
Rice & Beans $4.00
Jalapeños $2.00
Guacamole Side Order $7.00
Yellow Rice $3.00
Sour Cream $2.00
Pico de Gallo $2.00
Platano Maduro $4.00
Fried Plantains
Side of Cheese $3.00
Side Spicy Sauce $2.00
Side Red / Green sauce $3.00
Side of tortilla $2.00
Small bag of chips & salsa $3.00
Medium bag of chips & salsa $6.00

Main
Huevos con Chorizo $12.00
Scrambled eggs with mexican sausage, onion, peppers, green sauce & melted cheese. Served with lettuce & guacamole
Chilaquiles $12.00
Scrambled eggs with chicken, chilaquiles. With lettuce & guacamole
Huevos Tapatios $12.00
Spinach & cheese omelet topped with a touch of green sauce & guacamole
Huevos al Jardin $12.00
Omelet with mushrooms, zucchini, onion & peppers, lettuce & guacamole
Huevos Rancheros $12.00
Fried eggs served over a corn tortilla, topped with red sauce. Served with lettuce & guacamole
Huevos a la Mexicana $12.00
Scrambled eggs with onions, peppers, fresh tomato, jalapeño, cilantro & red sauce. Served with lettuce and guacamole
Huevos con Bistec $12.00
Eggs any style with grilled shell steak strips with lettuce & guacamole
Pancakes $9.00
with strawberries or bananas

Appetizers / Aperitivos
Fresh Guacamole $10.00
Prepared by your table sice enough to share
Margarita Nachos $10.00
Corn tortilla chips with ground beef and chicken, melted cheese, red sauce, jalapeño, lettuce and tomato
Tostaditas de Pollo $11.00
Crispy corn tortilla topped with chicken, melted cheese, lettuce, radish, tomato and sour cream
Quesadillas Rancheros $11.00
Soft corn tortilla folded over melted cheese and topped with green sauce, sliced grilled chicken, lettuce, sour cream and fresh tomatoes
Flautas de Pollo $11.00
Three crispy tortillas rolled with chicken, onion, peppers & cheese, topped with refried beans, red & green sauce with our sour cream
Margarita Queso Fundido $10.00
Choice of Mexican sausage sauteed with peppers and onions. served in a hot sizzling plate with melted cheese. Accompanied with a side of flour tortillas

Salads - Ensaladas
Ensalada de naranja $9.00
Spinach, lettuce, apples, sliced orange, celery and avocado. Served with balsamic dressing
Ensalada de margaritas $8.00
Mesculin greens, avocado, pepper, green olives and fresh tomatoes. Served with an apple dressing

Soups - Las Sopas
Sopa de frijol $6.00
Black bean soup with roasted tomato, onions, garlic and cilantro topped with crispy tortilla strips
Sopa de vegetales $7.00
Fresh vegetables in white broth
Pozole poblano $8.00
Hominy corn with shredded chicken, chicken broth, oregano, pico de gallo and avocado
Sopa de tortilla $7.00
Shredded chicken, vegetables & rice in a chicken broth, with crispy tortillas strips

Entrees
Super Burro Relleno
Large flor tortilla rolled with lettuce, guacamole, black beans, rice & topped with melted cheese, pico de gallo, red & green sauce, and stuffed with any of the three meat options
Enchilada de Mole Poblano $12.00
Corn tortilla rolled with chicken and mole sauce, topped with melted cheese. Served with refried beans and rice
Burrito de Pescado $13.00
Two flour tortilla filled with tilapia, onions, peppers and fresh tomatoes. Served with refried beans and rice
Enchiladas con Queso $11.00
Two soft corn tortillas rolled with cheese or vegetables. Served with black beans and rice and guacamol and lettuce
Enchiladas mi Bandera $14.00
Three soft corn tortillas rolled with chicken and another with cheese and beef, topped with three different sauces
Enchiladas Suizas $12.00
Soft corn tortilla rolled with chicken and topped with green sauce and Mexican cream. Served with rice, beans, guacamole and lettuce
Chiles Rellenos Estilo Poblano $12.00
Stuffed green poblano peppers with ground beef or cheese. Served with refried beans and rice and lettuce and guacamole
Tamales Poblano $13.00
Tamales stuffed with chicken or beef, cooked in corn husks and topped with green and red sauce and sour cream. Served with black beans and white rice, lettuce and guacamole
Margarita Tacos
Three corn tortilla choice crispy or soft with any choice of meat below, garnished with pico de gallo & side of spicy sauce
Margarita Quesadilla
Large flour tortilla with cheese and any choice of meat. All are served with lettuce, guacamole, sour cream red and green sauce.

Sizziling Hot Fajitas
Steak or chicken fajita $17.00
Grilled marinated chicken or skirt steak with onion, zucchini, peppers, mushrooms and fresh tomatoes. with refried beans, rice & flour tortilla garnished with sour cream & guacamole
Seafood Fajita $20.00
Marinated grilled salmon & red snapper, onions, peppers, tomatoes & zucchini, served with refried beans, rice & flour tortilla on the side
Fajita del chef $17.00
Chicken, steak, chorizo and mixed vegetables served with rice, beans, flour tortilla, lettuce, sour cream and guacamole

Chicken - Pollo
Pollo Chipotle $13.00
Grilled chicken breast with spicy chipotle sauce. Served with refried beans & guacamole
Pollo mazatlan $13.00
Grilled chicken breast topped with peppers, onions, mushrooms, olives and fresh tomato topped with melted cheese and served with black beans, rice, lettuce & guacamole
Pollo limon $13.00
Sauteed chicken breast with white wine, lemon and garlic. Served with refried beans, rice, lettuce & guacamole
Pollo con mole poblano $14.00
Chicken breast topped with mole sauce & sesame seeds. Served with refried beans, rice, lettuce & guacamole

Seafood - del Mar
Camarones al Ajillo $19.00
Sauteéd shrimp with garlic sauce. Served with black beans and rice
Camarones Cancun $19.00
Sauteéd shrimp with garlic, onions, peppers, cream, fresh tomatoes and mushrooms. Served with rice and beans
Tilapia Veracruzana $17.00
Pan-seared filet of tilapia jalapa Veracruz style with tomatillo broth, olives, cappers, roasted peppers and fresh herbs. Served with rice and beans
Calamares Sinaloa $12.00
Sauteéd calamari with green sauce, onions, green olives, spinach and coriander served over rice

Noche de Margaritas Details

Service options
Outdoor seating
Curbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Happy hour drinks

Dining options
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating

Children
Kids' menu

Noche de Margaritas Photos

Noche de Margaritas Location

Noche de Margaritas

New York New York County New York 2nd Avenue

1726 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10128, USA

Noche de Margaritas Reviews

An average rating of ★4.4 from 367 user reviews.

happy hourdrinkssalsachipsenchiladasnachosfrozenspicyfajitasmole

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

This new spot is so cool. They have mariachi nights on Sundays where you Request songs that you like. The Drinks are strong and flavorful. I ordered ribeye steaks and birria tacos and they were spectacular. The server was very attentive and came by to see if we needed anything.The decor is very fun and I seen myself throwing a brunch here on a Saturday or Sunday.If you were in the area definitely give it a try.
March 02 · Michelle Cardona
My boyfriend and I came here to celebrate our three months of going out. They gave us tortilla chips with salsa and guacamole. It was fresh homemade which I loved. 🥰 We had the steak burritos. 🌯They were awesome. It’s a big portion I could barely finish it. I forgot what the drinks were called but they were on fire.🔥 It was lit. The place looked great. Kathy (waitress) was very hospitable and sweet. We had desserts too but I was too into the moment to take pics. Bottom line: Food and drinks were great, people are nice (felt at home), and the dessert 🍮 was delicious! I enjoyed the time I spent there with him. 😋
August 24 · Peachy Revilleza
The customer service here it top tier! Raul was so attentive and kind, I felt very welcome! I offered to sit outside to not take up too much space but he said it was too cold for me to be out; better to take a full table. A KING, we stan. He also let me know immediately upon arrival that happy hour ($8 margaritas, mojitos, and others) was only for 15 more minutes so order quickly if I want to squeeze that in!The watermelon mojito is f*cking fantastic. The chips and salsa are reasonably priced for this neighborhood. They do have vegetarian options, including the fajitas, which I had. I love that they had a real vegetable blend, with zucchini, broccoli, cauliflower, carrots+ with guacamole. It was so flavorful, it wasn’t like eating vegetables at all! Definitely happy to give them all of my money!
March 14 · L Smith
Stephanie was amazing and so sweet, she made my experience at Noche De Margaritas amazing! I loved the food, and drinks and will definitely come back. If you have Stephanie as your waitress you’ll be under good hands!!
May 03 · Savannah Walker
If you like margs, this is the perfect place for you! They have so many different types of margaritas here, you’ll have a hard time deciding what to pick.We ended up going with the frozen coconut marg, frozen rainbow marg, and classic margs. To top each drink off, a nice flame is on top of the drink. All the drinks were pretty strong and tasty. The portion sizes of the drinks are also solid.For food, we got the nachos with beef, chicken quesadillas, and chimichangas. The food was probably more on the average side (there weren’t enough chips for the nachos, the chicken quesadillas could have had more flavor, and the rice and beans served with the chimichangas were alright).Would recommend coming here solely for the variety of margs and to snack on some light appetizers (chips and salsa/guac).
April 18 · Leah Cummings