North Shore Pizza

- 1376 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302

Welcome to North Shore Pizza, a true staple of the Staten Island dining scene and a must-visit spot for anyone craving authentic, satisfying New York-style pizza and Italian-American comfort food. Located right on Forest Avenue in the Westerleigh neighborhood, this pizzeria has built a loyal following over the years by consistently serving up delicious, generously portioned meals at prices that keep the community coming back. It’s a place where locals have been grabbing a slice for years, and the friendly, casual atmosphere makes it a perfect stop for a quick lunch, a family dinner, or a hearty take-out meal.

North Shore Pizza is more than just a typical slice shop; it's a full-service Italian restaurant focusing on quality ingredients and an expansive menu that covers everything from classic cheese pies to elaborate gourmet creations, baked pastas, heroes, and even full seafood entrées. They take pride in their ability to cater to a wide range of tastes and hunger levels, ensuring every customer walks away satisfied. Whether you’re stopping by for a slice of the classic cheese that so many locals rave about or diving into one of their unique, fully loaded specialty pies, you’re in for an authentic, delicious experience. The commitment to maintaining the size and quality of their food, despite changes in the city's dining landscape, is what truly sets them apart as a beloved local institution.

The reviews from long-time patrons frequently speak to the nostalgic connection they have with the spot, recalling visits from childhood and praising the enduring quality of the food. It's clear that the restaurant holds a special place in the hearts of many Staten Islanders, reflecting the best of neighborhood pizzerias—where the food is great, the service is fast, and the atmosphere is welcoming to all, including families with children.

---

North Shore Pizza is conveniently situated at 1376 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302, placing it centrally in the Westerleigh area and easily accessible for residents and visitors throughout the North Shore. The Forest Avenue location is a well-known thoroughfare, making it simple to find whether you’re traveling by car or local bus routes. As a local business, the pizzeria aims to be as accommodating as possible to all its customers.

For those concerned with physical accessibility, the restaurant offers a wheelchair accessible entrance, making it a welcoming and convenient spot for all members of the community to enjoy a meal. The focus on a casual, neighborhood-friendly atmosphere means you can always expect a straightforward and comfortable dining experience without any fuss. Being located on Forest Ave means it's a bustling spot, perfect for grabbing a quick bite during the workday or picking up dinner on the commute home.

---

North Shore Pizza provides a variety of services designed to meet the needs of their Staten Island clientele, whether you're looking for a meal on-site or want their delicious food brought right to your door.

• Dine-in: Enjoy your meal in the casual, welcoming, and family-friendly atmosphere of the restaurant. It's a great spot for an easy lunch or dinner.
• Takeout: Perfect for a quick and convenient pick-up. Call ahead or stop by to take your favorite pizza, heroes, and entrées to go.
• Delivery: Offering the ultimate convenience, the restaurant provides delivery service so you can enjoy their full menu without leaving your home or office.
• Catering: For parties, office meetings, or large family gatherings, North Shore Pizza offers catering services, allowing you to bring their full menu of Italian favorites to your event.
• Lunch Specials: Numerous budget-friendly lunch specials are available, offering great value on personal pizzas, baked pasta, sandwiches, and more.

---

North Shore Pizza shines with its commitment to a varied menu, fast service, and a comfortable, relaxed environment. Here are some of the key features that make it a local favorite:

• Expansive Pizza and Italian Menu: Beyond traditional pizza slices and pies (like the classic New York and Sicilian options), they offer a diverse selection of Gourmet Pies, including the popular Vodka Pie, Grandma Pie, Taco Lovers Pie, Lasagna Pie, and pies based on classic Italian dishes like Chicken Marsala, Francese, and Carbonara.
• Substantial Non-Pizza Menu: The offerings extend far past pizza to include baked pastas (Lasagna, Baked Ziti), full entrées (Chicken Francese, Eggplant Rollatini), Hot and Cold Heroes, Paninis, Wraps, and even a "From The Grill" section featuring burgers and **Lamb or Chicken Gyros**.
• Stuffed Garlic Knot Sandwiches: A creative and popular highlight, these massive sandwiches feature fillings like Chicken Vodka Parm and Shrimp Parmigiana served inside their famous stuffed garlic knots.
• Fast Service: Customers consistently highlight the quick and efficient service, making it an ideal choice for those on a tight schedule during lunch or dinner.
• Atmosphere: The dining environment is described as casual, making it a comfortable, no-fuss place that is also good for kids.
• Beverage Offerings: The menu includes a selection of Alcohol, Cocktails, and Wine, in addition to standard beverages like Coffee, allowing for a more complete dining experience.

---

For easy ordering, questions about the menu, or catering inquiries, you can reach North Shore Pizza at the following:

Address: 1376 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302

Phone: (718) 447-1600

The restaurant also accepts various forms of payment for convenience, including Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments.

---

If you're looking for a truly satisfying meal at North Shore Pizza, there are several menu items and features that repeatedly win over local New Yorkers. The restaurant is particularly Popular for Lunch, Dinner, and Solo Dining due to its efficient service and great value.

The most acclaimed choice is, of course, the Pizza. Many loyal customers insist that the regular cheese slice or pie is one of the best and most consistent on Staten Island, often noting its generous size and superior price compared to competitors. If you want to sample some of the more unique offerings, the Margherita Pie, Vodka Pie, and Sicilian Pizza come highly recommended by those who’ve enjoyed them. For a quick, affordable, and filling meal, the Lunch Specials are an outstanding choice. These often include a personal pizza, baked pasta, or a hero/wrap paired with a drink or side, offering substantial value for money. For example, you can often find deals like a Personal Pizza with water for under ten dollars or an Any Baked Pasta special for under $15.

Beyond the pizza itself, the Hot Heroes and Paninis are a must-try. Their large size and generous fillings—from the classic Chicken Parmigiana Hero to a variety of Philly Cheesesteak and Grilled Chicken Panini options—make them a complete and hearty meal. And for a truly unique appetizer or side, make sure to add an order of their signature Garlic Knots or one of the full Stuffed Garlic Knot Sandwiches, a local twist on the classic hero. For those looking for more traditional Italian comfort food, the Baked Ziti and Lasagna from their Baked Pastas selection are always a solid, satisfying choice. The menu’s depth means there is something for every craving, solidifying North Shore Pizza's reputation as a reliable and high-quality spot on the island.

North Shore Pizza

1376 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302, USA