Old Fashioned Pizza Co.

- 202 New Main St, Yonkers, NY 10701

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers in the Westchester County area, the search for a truly exceptional, authentic, and satisfying pizza often leads to the doors of a neighborhood gem: Old Fashioned Pizza Co. Situated in the heart of Yonkers, this establishment has quickly garnered a reputation for perfecting the art of the pie, delivering a quality that, as one delighted customer noted, "tasted like Italy." It is more than just a local pizza spot; it's a dedicated Pizza restaurant focused on quality over quantity, as evidenced by its philosophy of offering a "Unique small menu but great quality."

Old Fashioned Pizza Co. specializes in turning simple ingredients into extraordinary comfort food. The single most compelling reason locals flock here is the crust—a defining characteristic that sets it apart in a region saturated with pizzerias. Customer reviews repeatedly highlight the crust’s perfection, describing it as "very crispy," "cooked well," and importantly, having "no gumminess." This dedication to a perfect bake ensures a fantastic bite with every single slice. Whether you are craving a traditional Pepperoni pizza or seeking modern, accommodating options, Old Fashioned Pizza Co. is committed to delivering a stellar product.

In a welcoming Casual setting, this restaurant provides a comfortable atmosphere for all. It’s acknowledged as being Good for kids, making it a great destination for a quick family dinner or an easy weeknight meal. The menu is designed to be approachable and focused, specializing in Comfort food and providing a satisfying Quick bite for those on the move. From its praised standard offerings to its commitment to specialty diets, Old Fashioned Pizza Co. is a dependable source of delicious, authentic pizza for the Yonkers community and beyond.

Location and Accessibility

Old Fashioned Pizza Co. is strategically located in the busy commercial hub of Yonkers, making it an easy and convenient stop for locals and visitors traveling through the area. You can find this highly-praised pizzeria at 202 New Main St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA. The central New Main Street address ensures that whether you're working in downtown Yonkers or residing in the surrounding Westchester neighborhoods, access is straightforward.

The restaurant's commitment to accessibility extends far beyond its physical location. Understanding the modern New Yorker's need for convenience, Old Fashioned Pizza Co. offers multiple service options that allow you to enjoy their quality pizza on your own terms:

• Dine-in: Experience the friendly service and Casual atmosphere in person. It’s a great spot for an easy meal, especially as it is Good for kids.
• Takeout: Perfect for those rushing home or looking to enjoy their meal elsewhere. Simply call ahead and pick up your order.
• Delivery: For maximum convenience, the restaurant offers dependable Delivery services. They even provide a No-contact delivery option, ensuring a safe and stress-free experience for those who prefer it.

The Yonkers location is well-served by local transport and is a familiar landmark for those familiar with the New Main Street area. This ease of access, combined with comprehensive service options, firmly establishes Old Fashioned Pizza Co. as a go-to choice for pizza lovers across the New York region.

Services Offered

As a dedicated Pizza restaurant, Old Fashioned Pizza Co. has streamlined its services to deliver maximum quality and convenience. The available services are thoughtfully designed to accommodate various needs, from a spontaneous Quick bite to a complete family meal.

• In-House Dining: Enjoy the Casual and simple setting, ideal for a relaxed meal. The environment is always welcoming and considered Good for kids, making family outings easy.
• Comprehensive Takeout Service: Efficient order placement and pickup services ensure your Comfort food is ready quickly and fresh for transport.
• Multiple Delivery Options: Offering both standard Delivery and the increasingly popular No-contact delivery, allowing customers to receive their order safely and conveniently at their home or office in the Yonkers area.
• Specialized Menu Offerings: Despite a Unique small menu, the quality is high. Key offerings include classic pizzas like the outstanding Pepperoni pizza and gourmet specialty pies.
• Accommodating Dietary Needs: A significant service feature is the availability of high-quality alternatives, such as their "fantastic gluten free spinach white pizza," ensuring everyone can enjoy a slice.
• Quality Customer Interaction: Customers consistently praise the staff, noting the friendly and attentive service. The "Woman that took my order seemed super nice," is a testament to the personalized and professional approach to service.
• Focus on Core Products: By keeping the menu focused, the restaurant ensures that every item, particularly the pizza, is made with great care and meets the high standards of quality that have earned it its reputation.

Features / Highlights

What makes Old Fashioned Pizza Co. a standout choice in the vibrant and competitive New York pizza landscape is a combination of old-world quality and modern convenience:

• The Perfect Crispy Crust: This is the defining feature of the restaurant. Customers repeatedly highlight the "very crispy crust no gumminess," which is a hallmark of a perfectly cooked and high-quality pizza, often drawing comparisons to authentic Italian pizza.
• Authentic, High-Quality Flavor: The pizza's quality is so high that patrons have claimed it "tasted like Italy." This speaks to the commitment to traditional methods and superior ingredients, resulting in an exceptionally flavorful pizza that is more than just a quick meal.
• Excellent Gluten-Free Options: Catering to dietary preferences with quality is a major highlight. The existence of a "fantastic gluten free spinach white pizza" demonstrates a dedication to inclusive dining that maintains high standards of taste and texture.
• Friendly and Personalized Service: The staff’s welcoming nature and professionalism are frequently noted. This friendly atmosphere contributes significantly to the overall positive dining and ordering experience, which is particularly valuable in a local, neighborhood restaurant setting.
• Focused 'Small but Great Quality' Menu: The strategic decision to maintain a Unique small menu ensures that resources are focused on perfecting the core offerings, guaranteeing consistency and excellence in their pizza.
• Safety and Convenience for Ordering: The implementation of No-contact delivery along with standard Delivery and Takeout options demonstrates responsiveness to customer needs and current health and safety concerns.

Contact Information

To place an order, inquire about the menu, or utilize any of their convenient services, please use the contact details provided below for Old Fashioned Pizza Co.:

Address: 202 New Main St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA

Phone: (413) 841-1980

Mobile Phone (Direct Line): +1 413-841-1980

What is worth choosing

Choosing Old Fashioned Pizza Co. is a choice for quality, authenticity, and a truly superior pizza experience in the Yonkers area. For the New York local, this pizzeria stands out because it delivers on a promise that many others fail to keep: a perfect crust. The distinction of having a "very crispy crust no gumminess" is crucial for any serious pizza enthusiast and is the key reason patrons return again and again. It moves the experience beyond simple Comfort food and into the realm of truly high-quality Italian-American cooking.

Furthermore, the value of their menu is defined by its quality-first approach. The simple, classic Pepperoni pizza is hailed as great, proving that even their most basic offerings are executed flawlessly. Their commitment to inclusivity, highlighted by the availability of a "fantastic gluten free spinach white pizza," ensures that everyone, regardless of dietary need, can partake in the culinary excellence.

Finally, the friendly, professional service and wide range of convenient options—from a pleasant, Casual dine-in experience that is Good for kids to reliable No-contact delivery—make Old Fashioned Pizza Co. a reliable and beloved fixture on New Main Street. If you are in the New York region and searching for pizza that genuinely tastes like a piece of Italy, offers a perfect crust, and comes with a friendly smile, this Yonkers pizzeria is unquestionably the best choice.

Old Fashioned Pizza Co.

202 New Main St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA