Paulie's Pizzeria

- 76 E Pulaski Rd, Huntington Station, NY 11746

For Long Island residents craving the unmistakable flavor of authentic, old-school **New York City-style pizza**, **Paulie's Pizzeria** in **Huntington Station, NY**, is quickly becoming the must-visit spot. Specializing in a thin, crispy crust and rich, flavorful sauce, Paulie's is dedicated to bringing a taste of nostalgia reminiscent of the best pizzerias from the 1970s. This is not the typical thick, doughy slice often found on Long Island; it's a meticulously crafted pie using an old-school poolish and a 48-hour dough fermentation process, resulting in a product that is light, flavorful, and reheats exceptionally well.

More than just a place to grab a **Regular Cheese Pie** ($19.00), Paulie's Pizzeria is a full-service **Italian restaurant** offering a diverse menu that includes specialty square pies, classic pasta dishes, hearty heroes, and fresh chopped salads. Locals in the **New York** region appreciate the warm, welcoming atmosphere, which features a charming retro vibe complete with red-and-white checkered tablecloths, enhancing the old-school experience.

Whether you are looking for a quick **Lunch**, a family **Sunday Dinner Special**, or delivery after a long day, Paulie's Pizzeria is committed to providing a high-quality finished product that stands out in the crowded Long Island pizza scene. It combines the heritage of classic NYC flavor with a modern, friendly service approach.

---

Paulie's Pizzeria is conveniently situated in the heart of Huntington Station, making it easily accessible for customers in Huntington, Melville, and other neighboring Suffolk County towns. The prime location on a major road ensures it is a simple stop for both planned visits and spontaneous takeout.

76 E Pulaski Rd, Huntington Station, NY 11746, USA

The restaurant offers practical amenities that contribute to a stress-free experience for local users:

• **Ample Parking:** The location provides a dedicated **Free parking lot**, which is a significant convenience in this busy area of Huntington Station.
• **Easy Access:** Positioned on **E Pulaski Rd**, the location is simple to navigate to, whether you are arriving from nearby residential areas or major thoroughfares.

The goal of Paulie's is to be the true "neighborhood pizzeria"—the easy, reliable place for all community gatherings and weeknight meals.

---

Paulie's Pizzeria is structured to offer maximum flexibility and convenience, catering to the diverse needs of the Huntington community. Their service options ensure that customers can enjoy their thin-crust pizza and Italian specialties in the way that best suits their day.

• **Dine-in Service:** The restaurant features a casual dining area where guests can enjoy the retro atmosphere and prompt, friendly service.
• **Takeout & Pickup:** Easy and efficient ordering for pickup is available, making it simple to grab your meal and go.
• **Delivery:** For residents within the local service radius, Paulie's offers reliable **Delivery** service, bringing their high-quality pies directly to your door.
• **Lunch Specials:** Affordable **Lunch** options are offered, making it a popular destination for area workers and local residents looking for a delicious midday meal.
• **Online Ordering:** Customers can order online through various platforms for both pickup and delivery, streamlining the entire ordering process.
• **Special Dinner Packages:** They feature a popular **Sunday Dinner Special** ($49.00) which includes a generous portion of Spaghetti & Meatballs, a House Salad, and Garlic Knots—perfect for feeding a family of four.

---

What truly sets Paulie's Pizzeria apart is the unique combination of old-school authenticity and creative, modern specialty pies. The menu is carefully designed around its signature, superior-quality crust and sauce.

• **Signature Thin & Crispy Crust:** The defining feature of Paulie's, achieved through a 48-hour dough fermentation process, resulting in a lighter, crispier slice reminiscent of classic NYC pizzerias from the 1970s.
• **Authentic Square Pies:** The menu boasts a strong selection of square pies, including the classic **Grandma Pie** ($28.00/$23.00) and the recommended **Upside Down Square Pie** ($28.00/$23.00), where the sauce is spread on top of the cheese.
• **Creative Specialty Pizzas:** Paulie's is known for unique creations like the **Spicy Stracciatella Square Pie** ($32.50/$27.00), which features creamy burrata filling, pepperoni, and a drizzle of hot honey, and the flavor-packed **Vodka Pestoroni Pie** ($30.00/$25.00).
• **Rich Tomato Sauce:** Customers consistently praise the tomato sauce for its rich, tangy flavor, which is a perfect complement to the cheese blend.
• **Speciality Heros:** The hero menu includes highly creative and popular options like the **M.V.P Hero** and the decadent **Spicy Vodka Hero** ($21.75), featuring fried chicken cutlet, pepperoni, spicy vodka sauce, and fresh mozzarella.
• **Classic Italian Comfort Food:** Beyond pizza, they offer a full range of classic Italian pasta dishes, including **Baked Ziti Parmigiana**, **Stuffed Shells Parmigiana**, and the satisfying **Spaghetti & Meatballs** ($21.75).
• **Homemade Sides:** Appetizers are not an afterthought; highlights include the homemade **Meatballs** ($14.50), savory **Wings**, and golden **Fried Ravioli**.

---

For placing an order, confirming operating hours, or any questions, please contact Paulie's Pizzeria directly at their Huntington Station location:

**Address:** 76 E Pulaski Rd, Huntington Station, NY 11746, USA

**Phone:** (631) 629-4935

The mobile number provided is:

**Mobile Phone:** +1 631-629-4935

Checking the website or calling ahead is always recommended for the most current information regarding daily specials and operating hours.

---

Choosing **Paulie's Pizzeria** means opting for an authentic, high-quality pizza experience that purposefully deviates from the typical Long Island style. What is truly worth choosing here is the crust—the painstaking effort put into the 48-hour fermented dough is the core of their offering. This dedication ensures a consistently thin, crispy base that carries the toppings without becoming heavy or chewy. As one reviewer noted, the crust is "perfect," making it a standout among local options.

For the first-time visitor, exploring their unique pizza varieties is highly recommended. The **Upside Down Pie** (available in both Round and Square) is a signature item that truly showcases the quality of their tomato sauce, as the sauce is exposed to the high heat of the oven, deepening its flavor. Additionally, the **Spicy Stracciatella Pie** has garnered attention for its blend of spicy and sweet elements, offering a unique flavor profile that elevates it beyond standard pepperoni slices.

Furthermore, Paulie's commitment to creating a welcoming and friendly environment is consistently praised. The combination of "great flavor" and "great service" makes it a top contender in the Huntington dining landscape. It is an ideal destination for New Yorkers who cherish classic Italian-American flavors and appreciate a commitment to quality ingredients, from their signature thin-crust pizza to their delicious **Homemade Meatballs** and satisfying family pasta dinners. It is a genuine neighborhood spot that has quickly earned its place among the **Top 5 pizza shops in Huntington**.

Paulie's Pizzeria

76 E Pulaski Rd, Huntington Station, NY 11746, USA