Penny House Cafe

- 732 Washington Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238

For over a decade, Penny House Cafe has been a cherished institution in the vibrant Prospect Heights neighborhood of Brooklyn. Founded in 2009, this charming cafe and coffee shop has built a reputation for its warm hospitality, excellent coffee, and a menu of delicious comfort food that keeps locals coming back for more. It’s a place that feels like a home away from home, with a cozy, casual, and trendy atmosphere that makes it the perfect spot for a morning coffee run, a leisurely lunch, or an afternoon of work.

Penny House Cafe is more than just a place to grab a quick bite; it's a hub for the community. The owner is known for being “so warm and hospitable,” making sure everyone who walks through the door feels taken care of. This personal touch, a rare find in a bustling city like New York, elevates the entire experience. The menu is a highlight, offering a wide array of options to satisfy any craving. From fresh, daily-baked bagels with a variety of spreads to savory breakfast and lunch sandwiches, every item is crafted to be both satisfying and delicious. Whether you’re stopping by for their popular turkey bacon and egg sandwich or trying their famous homemade falafel burger, you're guaranteed a meal that's both "great" and "consistent."

Located at 732 Washington Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238, USA, Penny House Cafe enjoys a prime spot in the heart of Prospect Heights. This neighborhood is a true gem, bordered by iconic landmarks like Prospect Park, the Brooklyn Museum, and the Brooklyn Botanic Garden. Its central location makes it easily accessible for anyone in the area. For those traveling by car, there is paid street parking available, which is a convenient option in a busy area.

The cafe is also designed to be accessible to all. With a wheelchair accessible entrance, restroom, and seating, Penny House Cafe ensures that everyone can enjoy its offerings comfortably. While the space is described as being "pretty narrow," the layout is utilized efficiently to provide a welcoming environment for all. Though there is no outdoor seating, the cozy indoor space is a major draw, offering a tranquil retreat from the city streets. For those who prefer to enjoy their food elsewhere, the cafe provides seamless options for takeout, delivery, and even curbside pickup.

Penny House Cafe offers a variety of services to cater to the needs of its diverse clientele.

• Dine-in: Guests can enjoy their food and drinks in the casual, cozy, and trendy atmosphere of the cafe.
• Takeout: For those on the go, the cafe offers convenient and efficient takeout services.
• Delivery and Curbside Pickup: The cafe partners with delivery services to bring its delicious food right to your door, and also offers curbside pickup for quick and easy retrieval.
• Breakfast and Brunch: Serving breakfast and lunch all day, Penny House Cafe is a top spot for a satisfying morning or midday meal.
• Catering: The cafe provides catering services, perfect for feeding a group with a selection of their sandwiches, pastries, and coffee.
• Wi-Fi: Free Wi-Fi is available, making it a popular and convenient spot for solo diners or anyone looking to get some work done on their laptop.

Penny House Cafe stands out in the Brooklyn cafe scene due to its unique features and highlights.

• Exceptional Coffee and Tea: The cafe is celebrated for its great coffee and a high-quality tea selection from Harney and Sons. Their coffee, including various espresso beverages and specialty lattes like the Dirty Chai, is a key reason for their loyal customer base.
• Delicious Bagel and Sandwich Menu: Penny House is a go-to for breakfast and lunch, with a menu featuring fresh, daily-baked bagels and a variety of sandwiches, including customer favorites like the Turkey Bacon and Egg Sandwich and The Conflicted Sandwich.
• Homemade and Fresh Food: Reviewers often praise the quality and flavor of the food, noting that the ingredients are fresh and that even simple items like the homemade hummus and vegan lentil soup are incredibly flavorful.
• Cozy and Welcoming Atmosphere: The cafe’s atmosphere is a major draw, with its casual and cozy vibe making it a perfect spot for solo dining or a relaxed meet-up. The music and overall ambiance contribute to a comfortable setting.
• Attentive and Friendly Service: The staff, especially the owner, is frequently mentioned in reviews for being incredibly warm and hospitable. This high level of customer service is a significant highlight, making customers feel truly valued.

For more information, to place an order for pickup, or to simply get in touch, you can use the following contact information:

Address: 732 Washington Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238, USA

Phone: (347) 240-7281

For online ordering and delivery, Penny House Cafe can be found on various popular platforms.

When you're searching for a cafe in Brooklyn, there are many options, but Penny House Cafe is worth choosing for several key reasons. First and foremost, the food and drinks are consistently excellent. The cafe has perfected classic menu items like the breakfast sandwich, with their "Best Seller" and "Turkey Bacon and Egg Sandwich" receiving high praise for their great portion size and delicious taste. Their coffee is equally impressive, with a reputation for being a great cup of joe. The menu also offers appealing options for those with dietary preferences, including vegetarian options and a highly-rated vegan lentil soup.

Second, the atmosphere and service set it apart. In a city where quick and impersonal service can be common, the owner and staff at Penny House Cafe make a point of being friendly and attentive. This "good hospitality," as one reviewer called it, creates a welcoming environment that makes you want to return. It’s a comfortable and casual place where you can easily find a spot to relax, meet a friend, or get work done, thanks to the free Wi-Fi. Finally, the cafe's dedication to its community is palpable. It's a place loved by locals, and its consistency in quality and service has made it a reliable and cherished part of the neighborhood. Choosing Penny House Cafe isn’t just about getting a meal or a coffee; it’s about experiencing a genuine and friendly piece of Brooklyn's local culture.

Penny House Cafe

732 Washington Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238, USA