PEP Bakehouse and Coffee Shop: Bay Ridge's Artisanal Pastry and Specialty Coffee Haven

PEP Bakehouse and Coffee Shop Introduce

When New Yorkers talk about their local coffee shop, they’re not just looking for a caffeine fix; they’re searching for a destination—a place that offers comfort, quality, and a genuine connection to the community. PEP Bakehouse and Coffee Shop, nestled in the heart of Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, is precisely that kind of establishment. It stands out as an artisanal bakery and café, a true gem where the art of the baker’s craft meets the meticulous science of specialty coffee.

This family-owned bakehouse prides itself on being a modern version of a French patisserie, translating European elegance into a distinctly Brooklyn experience. They are fiercely dedicated to quality, incorporating only fresh, local, and natural ingredients into their entire product line. This commitment means that every croissant, every cake, and every cookie is made fresh daily in their Brooklyn production facilities, completely free of additives or preservatives. This focus on purity and freshness ensures a delightful experience that patrons can immediately taste and appreciate.

Beyond the exquisite pastries, PEP Bakehouse has become a neighborhood favorite for its welcoming atmosphere, which successfully blends aesthetics with flavor. The spacious interior, adorned with abstract artwork and often complemented by calming jazz music, creates a tranquil and visually appealing environment. It's the ideal setting for a variety of needs: a quiet spot for solo dining or working on a laptop, a cozy backdrop for meeting friends, or a quick, quality stop before starting a long trip or running errands around the city. From the moment you walk in, the shop invites you to slow down, savor your coffee, and enjoy a freshly baked delicacy, offering a much-needed break from the city's relentless pace.

The success of PEP Bakehouse is rooted in its dual expertise. While the ‘Bakehouse’ side continually impresses with flawless French macarons, eclairs, and magnificent cakes that have become absolute crowd-pleasers at New York gatherings, the ‘Coffee Shop’ component is equally rigorous. The baristas tirelessly select their beans—a specific blend of Colombian, Guatemalan, Ethiopian, and Kenyan coffees—to ensure that every espresso-based drink delivers a light, sweet, and perfectly balanced cup. For New Yorkers who appreciate a thoughtfully crafted morning ritual, PEP Bakehouse offers a standout experience.

Location and Accessibility

PEP Bakehouse and Coffee Shop is perfectly situated at 9413 3rd Ave, in the desirable Bay Ridge neighborhood of Brooklyn, NY 11209. This location on 3rd Avenue, a vibrant and bustling thoroughfare, makes it a central and convenient meeting spot for the local community.

For those traveling by car, the location offers a significant advantage. It is conveniently positioned near the approach to the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge, making it an easy and quick stop before heading out on a trip or returning home. Local customers have noted that street parking can often be found right in front of the shop, a pleasant surprise in a busy New York neighborhood. For public transportation users, 3rd Avenue is serviced by several bus routes, and the Bay Ridge Avenue R train station is within reasonable distance, ensuring the coffee shop is highly accessible whether you are walking, driving, or taking the subway. The charm of the Bay Ridge waterfront is just a short stroll away, allowing patrons to grab a coffee and a pastry to enjoy by the water.

Services Offered

Artisan Baking: Daily production of fresh, handmade products including croissants (Plain, Almond, Apricot, Hazelnut), eclairs, cookies (Amaretti, Linzer, Chocolate Chip), and a wide array of French macarons and quiches.
Specialty Cakes and Desserts: Serving full-sized cakes for special events and celebrations, such as the Raspberry Sacher, Red Flower, and the highly-praised Vanilla Hazelnut Cake, all created with a focus on delicate, light, and airy textures.
Full Coffee and Espresso Menu: Offering an extensive selection of hot and cold beverages, including drip coffee, espresso, Americano, Hot Latte, Iced Latte, Cold Brew, Mocha, and specialty options like Matcha Latte and Beetroot Latte.
Extensive Tea Selection: A great highlight for non-coffee drinkers, the shop offers a wide range of quality teas, with baristas available to provide recommendations for the perfect brew.
Breakfast and Quick Bite Options: Serving breakfast items such as Overnight Oats (with almond milk or chia pudding), and Yogurt Parfaits (with cherry or dates), alongside savory options like the popular Spinach Bistro.
Dine-In and Takeaway: Providing a spacious interior with ample seating for individuals and groups, as well as easy takeaway options for a quick stop.
Outdoor Seating: The venue offers an outdoor seating area, perfect for enjoying a coffee on a beautiful Brooklyn day.
Work-Friendly Amenities: Features free Wi-Fi and numerous outlets, making it an excellent location for students and remote workers.

Features / Highlights

The Vanilla Hazelnut Cake: Described as an 'absolute crowd pleaser,' this cake (often featuring macaron toppings) is famous for its light, airy textures and delicious mousses, making it a highly recommended alternative to traditional New York cakes.
Exceptional Pistachio Croissant: Customers rave about this specific pastry, listing it as a 'must-try' item. It is part of their freshly baked croissant selection that also includes Almond, Apricot, and Hazelnut variations.
Commitment to Clean Ingredients: The bakehouse uses only fresh, local, and natural ingredients, guaranteeing no additives or preservatives in their products, a major draw for health-conscious New Yorkers.
Artistic and Relaxing Atmosphere: The interior is noted for its beautiful aesthetic, featuring abstract art and a cozy, tranquil ambiance enhanced by soothing jazz music, creating a perfect spot for unwinding or working.
The 'Spinach Bistro': This savory item is a popular choice for a satisfying quick bite, providing a delicious, high-quality savory option alongside their sweet treats.
Custom Coffee Blend: Their expertly selected, light and sweet house espresso blend of Colombian, Guatemalan, Ethiopian, and Kenyan beans ensures a superior coffee experience across all their espresso-based drinks.
Warm and Helpful Service: The staff is consistently praised for being friendly, lovely, and helpful, often going the extra mile, such as providing necessary utensils and plates for to-go orders like cakes for a potluck.

Contact Information

Address: 9413 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA

Phone: (917) 482-1167

What is Worth Choosing

For New Yorkers in search of their next favorite spot, PEP Bakehouse and Coffee Shop offers compelling reasons to visit, centering around a few standout items that truly showcase their artisanal quality.

The undeniable 'must-try' for any first-time visitor is the selection of fresh, daily-baked croissants. Specifically, the

pistachio croissant

has generated significant buzz among local patrons. Its flaky texture and rich, quality filling make it a perfect pairing for one of their specialty coffees, such as an

iced oat milk caramel latte

or a classic

cappuccino

. The bakery's dedication to making every croissant fresh ensures a truly memorable bite—a characteristic often hard to find in the city.

Another area where PEP Bakehouse truly excels is their cakes. While you may have another "fancy pastry shop" in mind, the

Vanilla Hazelnut Cake

is a certified showstopper. Customers rave about its light, airy texture and sophisticated flavor profile, often noting that it becomes an immediate crowd-pleaser at gatherings. For anyone needing a dessert that looks beautiful and tastes exquisite without the heaviness of traditional cakes, this is the definitive choice. The entire dessert display, featuring perfect eclairs and colorful French macarons, is a visual feast that underscores the shop’s patisserie pedigree.

For a savory morning or afternoon stop, the

Spinach Bistro

is the ideal pick. It’s a delicious, high-quality quick bite that perfectly complements their expertly crafted coffee. Speaking of coffee, make sure to try one of their signature espresso drinks. The unique, high-quality blend of coffee beans ensures a balanced and flavorful cup, distinguishing it from standard coffeehouse fare.

Ultimately, what is worth choosing at PEP Bakehouse is the combination of impeccable product quality and a welcoming atmosphere. It’s a cafe built on a philosophy of no additives, fresh ingredients, and genuine artistry. This commitment is palpable in every pastry and every sip, securing its place as a beloved, hidden gem in the Bay Ridge culinary landscape—a delightful haven where you can relax, work, or simply indulge in some of the best artisanal treats Brooklyn has to offer.

PEP Bakehouse and Coffee Shop Photos

PEP Bakehouse and Coffee Shop Location

PEP Bakehouse and Coffee Shop

New York Kings County Fort Hamilton 3rd Avenue

9413 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA

PEP Bakehouse and Coffee Shop Reviews

A quick & convenient stop before hopping on the Verrazano. We snagged street parking right in front. Staff was very friendly. Everything looks amazing. If we weren't on a long trip I would have got some of the desserts. The food and drinks we got were all good quality and yummy!Items ordered: iced oat milk caramel latte, iced coffee, plain croissant, pistachio croissant (must try!), spinach bistro (yum!)
July 17 · Nicole Quadrone
This unsuspecting coffee shop is a hidden gem for delicious cakes! I randomly stumbled into PEP for a matcha, but I left with a vanilla hazelnut cake for a potluck I had later that evening (it’s the white cake with macaroon on top).While I planned to go to another fancy pastry shop in the neighborhood, I’m glad I stumbled into PEP. The cake was an absolute crowd pleaser! 3 people asked me where I got it and they loved the light and airy textures with bites of cake/crunch.Additionally, the employee working the counter was lovely and helpful! Luckily, the shop had extra paper plates and utensils for me to bring to the potluck. Overall, it was a great experience and I will be back :).
April 28 · Tracy Shu
Complaint Regarding Repeatedly Poor Customer ServiceDear PEP BAKEHOUSE & COFFEE SHOPI am writing to bring to your attention repeated negative customer service experiences I have had with a staff member at your 9413 Third AveBrooklyn, NY 11209United States location.On 09/02/2025, I arrived at the shop at 6:55 a.m., unaware that it was not yet open. A staff member who is regularly on duty during my visits told me—very abruptly and without greeting—that the shop was closed. When I politely asked what time the shop would open, she replied “7 o’clock” in a similarly rude tone.When I returned at 7:00 a.m., the same staff member again displayed unprofessional behavior. She did not greet me as I entered, did not acknowledge my order when I placed it, and after preparing my coffee, placed it on the counter in a noticeably dismissive and unpleasant manner rather than handing it to me.Unfortunately, this was not an isolated incident. I have had multiple unpleasant interactions with this same staff member over time, and friends of mine who also frequent your shop have shared similar negative experiences. As a regular customer, I find this repeated behavior unacceptable, especially as it creates an unwelcoming start to my day.I value your coffee and the atmosphere your shop is known for, but I believe customer service is just as important as product quality. I hope this matter will be addressed promptly so that all customers are treated with courtesy and respect.Thank you for your attention to this matter. I look forward to hearing from you regarding any steps that will be taken.Sincerely,
September 02 · Rushana Khalilova
I’m giving all 5s on the review, but I didn't eat there—I grabbed an iced coffee during my day showing properties in the area. As a local realtor, I needed that pick-me-up, and being in Bay Ridge, I could have gone to a name brand, but I wanted to support local businesses. I was not disappointed! The staff was super friendly, and the coffee was very tasty. It gave me the pep I needed. Thanks again!
July 05 · Thomas P Smith NY REAL ESTATE
I was looking for a good local coffee shop within walking distance of where I'm staying and Pep seem to fit the bill. It is a tiny little hole in the wall of a place But super cute with a small but beautiful selection of pastries. I ordered a cherry almond croissant and a chai latte. I was super happy with both. The croissant was beautiful and flaky with the perfect amount of filling. My chai was good if a tad sweet. I would definitely come back to try some more of their pastry selections.
June 07 · Cindy C