Hunter's Steak & Ale House Brooklyn: Dry-Aged Steaks and Classic New York Vibe in Bay Ridge

Hunter's Steak & Ale House Introduce

Hunter's Steak & Ale House: A Bay Ridge Institution for Over 30 Years

Introduction / Overview: Old New York Charm Meets High-Quality Cuts

Hunter's Steak & Ale House is not just a restaurant; it is a Bay Ridge institution, having been a staple in the neighborhood for over 30 years. Located on 4th Avenue, this large bar/restaurant offers a unique and welcoming atmosphere that many locals describe as feeling like "old New York from Scorsese movies." With its wood-paneled walls, comfortable decor, and white tablecloths, it successfully embraces the aesthetics of a classic New York City steakhouse, yet maintains a comfortable, friendly, and unpretentious neighborhood feel.

The culinary focus is primarily on Irish/American cuisine, specializing in high-quality steaks that are dry-aged to perfection on-site, a dedication to quality that sets it apart. While steaks like the Ribeye, Porterhouse, and Filet Mignon are the main event, the menu is broad, offering everything from comfort food and burgers to fresh seafood and pasta. Customers consistently praise the entire dining experience, noting that the service is very good, polite, and careful, and the prices are considered very reasonable for this kind of food and service in New York City. Hunter's Steak & Ale House is truly a culinary gem that appeals to both those seeking a fine dining steak experience and those just looking for a hearty, quality meal and a fresh and tasty beer.

Location and Accessibility: The Hub of Bay Ridge, Brooklyn

Hunter's Steak & Ale House is conveniently situated at 9404 4th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA. This address places it firmly in the heart of the Bay Ridge section of Brooklyn, a vibrant and well-established neighborhood known for its local flavor and community spirit.

The location on 4th Avenue makes it easily accessible for Brooklynites and visitors alike:

Neighborhood Anchor: As a long-standing staple in Bay Ridge, it is a well-recognized local landmark and community gathering place.
Transit Proximity: The area is well-served by local buses and is not far from the subway lines, offering convenient travel from other parts of Brooklyn and Manhattan.
Parking Options: For patrons driving in, the restaurant provides the exceptional New York amenity of Valet parking on Friday and Saturday starting at 5 PM, with availability during the week for special events, simplifying the urban dining experience.
Outdoor Seating: The venue features Outside Seating, offering an opportunity to enjoy the neighborhood atmosphere during pleasant weather.

Services Offered: A Full Dining Experience and Event Hosting

Hunter's Steak & Ale House operates as a large bar/restaurant providing a comprehensive array of dining and hospitality services:

Lunch and Dinner Service: Serving a full lunch menu (typically Tuesday–Sunday 12 PM–3 PM) and a full dinner menu (with varying hours, generally extending later on weekends).
Full-Service Bar: Featuring a well-stocked bar specializing in beer and mixed drinks, with customers praising the quality of the draught beer.
Dry-Aged Steaks: Offering premium cuts like Porterhouse, T-Bone, Ribeye, New York Sirloin, and Filet Mignon, all dry-aged to perfection on-site.
Comprehensive Menu: The Irish/American cuisine includes Soups (like French Onion Soup), Salads, Sandwiches, Appetizers (such as Homemade Crab Cakes and Shrimp Cocktail), Pasta, and Seafood (including fresh salmon and broiled sole).
Comfort Food Section: The menu features hearty options like Shepherd's Pie, Chicken Pot Pie, and Fish & Chips.
Special Deals: Offering an Early Bird Prix Fixe Special on select weekdays and Happy Hour at the bar Tuesday–Friday.
Catering and Private Dining: The restaurant provides a Private party room available for all occasions and offers sample party and catering menus for full and half trays of food.

Features / Highlights: Authenticity, Quality, and Community

Hunter's Steak & Ale House stands out in the competitive New York dining scene due to its unique blend of features:

On-Site Dry Aging: The commitment to quality is highlighted by the practice of dry-aging high-quality steaks on the premises, ensuring phenomenal flavor and tenderness, as noted by steak-lovers.
"Old New York" Atmosphere: The interior evokes a classic, "Scorsese movies" feel, offering a warm, traditional, and upscale yet unpretentious environment perfect for both a romantic night out and a casual gathering.
Reasonable Pricing: Patrons consistently mention that the prices are very reasonable for the high quality of food and service offered, making fine dining accessible.
Community and Staff: The restaurant has deep roots in Bay Ridge, having been a fixture for decades. The friendly and helpful staff and the presence of an Irish brogue overheard at the long oak bar contribute to a welcoming, neighborly feel.
Highly-Rated Classics: Beyond the steaks, the French Onion Soup is frequently cited as delicious and made the right way, and the burgers are praised for being very good with a nice-sized patty.

Contact Information: Reserve Your Brooklyn Steak Experience

To make a reservation, inquire about a private party, or check the daily specials, Hunter's Steak & Ale House can be contacted using the following information:

Address: 9404 4th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA

Phone: (718) 238-8899

Mobile Phone: +1 718-238-8899

What is Worth Choosing: The Steakhouse Experience Without the Manhattan Price Tag

For New Yorkers seeking a high-quality, authentic steakhouse experience that marries excellent food with genuine value, Hunter's Steak & Ale House is a must-visit. What makes it truly worth choosing is the premium quality of the product combined with a distinctly local, unpretentious charm.

The Dry-Aged Steaks: The primary draw is, unequivocally, the steak. Having dry-aged cuts available in a neighborhood restaurant—including the 20 Oz Ribeye and 26 Oz Porterhouse—at their reasonable price points, is rare. The commitment to preparing a well-cooked, flavorful steak, with the right amount of salt and a great sear, is consistently highlighted by customers.

The Atmosphere and Service: Hunter's offers a dining environment that is increasingly difficult to find in modern NYC: a place that feels simultaneously friendly and careful, where polite service is a given, and the décor feels both classic and comfortably local. It’s a place where you are genuinely happy to have "discovered this gem in New York."

The Versatile Menu: The wide range of Irish/American cuisine means this spot is perfect for nearly any occasion. Whether it is a celebratory Surf and Turf dinner, a quick and satisfying hamburger platter at the bar, or a comforting bowl of their perfectly made onion soup, Hunter's ensures a high standard across the entire menu. It provides the full fine-dining experience while also being a great everyday neighborhood spot.

Hunter's Steak & Ale House Photos

Hunter's Steak & Ale House Location

Hunter's Steak & Ale House

New York Kings County Fort Hamilton 4th Avenue

9404 4th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA

Hunter's Steak & Ale House Reviews

We really liked the atmosphere in this restaurant - it feels like old New York from Scorsese movies. The service was very good: polite and careful. The beer was fresh and tasty, not weak like in many other places in NYC. We had a ribeye steak, and it was cooked very well, with great flavor and the right amount of salt. I also had the onion soup - it was delicious and made the right way. The prices were very reasonable for this kind of food and service. We’re so happy to have discovered this gem in New York, and we’ll definitely be coming back!
April 20 · Mary F
The large bar/restaurant is located in the Bay Ridge section of Brooklyn. They primarily prepare Irish/American cuisine. Soups, salads, sandwiches, appetizers, various entrees including steaks and burgers are available. The full-service bar has beer and mixed drinks. The hamburger platter was very good with a nice-sized patty including french fries, lettuce, tomato and pickle. Friendly and helpful staff.
March 31 · Steven Nechamkin
My husband found this restaurant online. We went there for dinner. I didn't understand why it's called steak house. In fact, it's typical Italian restaurant, but we didn't know it and wanted to eat steaks. The oysters were very small that there was nothing to eat. There was a lot of oil in tomatoes with mozzarella. Both of us ordered ribeye steaks. I can say one thing to describe, my husband cooks steaks much better than in this restaurant. In addition, there were a lot of lives in my steak and it was tough. And what we really didn't like about the tablecloths covered with paper. If you want to eat steaks, find better place. We won't go to this place again. Dinner for two without drinks and alcohol cost us over $200 and we didn't have any pleasure spending Saturday night dinner there. As a summary, the prices are high and the service and food are very poor.P.S. During our stay, the bartender talked very loudly with co-workers.
September 05 · Olga Z
Delicious food, aged beef rough oysters on shell
August 13 · Rafal Ziomek
It's a good place. The steak is key. The bartenders are friendly except when you play Quick Draw in full bar. But you will have good time.
September 17 · Marco Pewe