Pizza Mania NJ

- 390 Midland Ave, Garfield, NJ 07026

In New Jersey, a local pizzeria is often the beating heart of a neighborhood, and in Garfield, that role is expertly filled by Pizza Mania NJ. Located right on Midland Avenue, this establishment is much more than your standard take-out pizza place; it’s a full-service Italian-American kitchen that has become a local hot-spot since its founding by Gaetano in 1997. Gaetano’s dream was to bring authentic Italian pizza to the locals, sourcing fresh ingredients, even importing flour from Italy, and perfecting the craft of the perfect crust. That dedication to quality and authenticity has cultivated a loyal customer base and a reputation for serving exceptional food throughout Northern New Jersey.

Pizza Mania NJ offers an extensive menu that caters to every possible craving, from classic New Jersey-style plain pies to inventive gourmet specialty pizzas, hearty pasta dishes, generous salads, and an array of hot and cold sandwiches. This variety ensures that whether you’re planning a family dinner, grabbing a quick lunch, or catering a large event, you can find exactly what you need. Customers often describe the atmosphere as casual, cozy, and trendy, making it a comfortable place for college students, groups, and even solo diners to enjoy a quality meal.

The emphasis here is on flavorful food, fresh ingredients, and huge portions—a combination that perfectly aligns with the high standards of a New Jersey audience. While the pizza is, of course, the main event, the entire menu is crafted with care, offering everything from quick bites to full, satisfying comfort food meals. This commitment to a diverse and quality-driven menu is why Pizza Mania NJ has been a long-standing favorite in the Garfield area and beyond.

***

Pizza Mania NJ is centrally and conveniently located at 390 Midland Ave, Garfield, NJ 07026, USA. This Bergen County location is easily accessible for residents across Garfield and neighboring communities like Lodi and Saddle Brook, making it a prime spot for both spontaneous and planned visits. The location along Midland Avenue places it on a main thoroughfare, which is ideal for quick pickups and dine-in traffic.

A major advantage of this location is the extensive focus on accessibility, ensuring a welcoming environment for all patrons. The amenities include:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance, parking lot, restroom, and seating.
• Free parking lot and free street parking, which is a major convenience in a busy suburban area.
• On-site parking available for customers.

This thoughtful attention to guest convenience, from ample parking to full accessibility, reflects a commitment to serving the entire community, making it a stress-free destination for families and groups of all sizes.

***

Pizza Mania NJ offers a full suite of services designed to meet the modern dining needs of Bergen County residents:

• Dine-in: Offering a casual, cozy, and trendy atmosphere with comfortable seating and table service, perfect for enjoying a meal with family or friends.
• Delivery and Takeout: Convenient options for fast food service, ensuring fresh and hot meals are delivered quickly or available for easy pickup.
• Catering Services: Providing menu options for events and groups, including specialty pizza pies, pasta dishes, and salads that are popular hits for parties and corporate functions.
• Lunch and Dinner Service: Open for extended hours, typically from 10:00 AM to the late evening, catering to both lunch specials and dinner crowds.
• Family-Friendly Amenities: Good for kids, with high chairs available, making it an excellent choice for family dining.
• Payment Options: Accepts all major forms of payment including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for customer convenience.

***

The menu at Pizza Mania NJ is famously large and highly praised, combining traditional Italian recipes with inventive, gourmet creations. The standout features and crowd favorites truly distinguish this restaurant:

• Specialty and Gourmet Pizzas: Beyond the perfectly balanced classic slice, the restaurant is known for its inventive specialty pies. Highlights include the creamy and savory Vodka Chicken Pizza, the robust Philly Cheesesteak Pizza (described as "very filling and absolutely delicious" by customers), and the unique Potato and Onion Square Pizza. Other square-style favorites are the Sicilian, Grandma Pie, and Brooklyn Square Pie.
• The Vodka Chicken Wrap Panini: This is a massive customer favorite, often called the "BEST. WRAP. EVER!" by patrons. It features a tangy vodka sauce and blackened chicken, delivering an amazing burst of flavor that has earned it a reputation as a must-try local specialty.
• Extensive Italian Entrees and Comfort Food: The offerings go far beyond pizza. Customers consistently recommend the pasta, noting the quality of the Penne Vodka and the traditional comfort of dishes like Chicken Parmigiana, Chicken Marsala, and Chicken Francese.
• Gourmet Salads and Healthy Options: For those seeking lighter fare, the deli-quality salads are fresh and surprisingly amazing, featuring unique options like the Tropical Salad (with mandarin oranges and caramelized walnuts) and the Pear and Walnut Salad. The menu also features a "Healthy Choice" section with Whole Wheat Wraps and Turkey Sandwiches.
• Specialty Sandwiches and Cheesesteaks: The menu boasts a strong selection of hot and cold heroes, including the classic Italian Sub, the popular Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich, and a range of Philadelphia Style Steaks, such as the P.M. Steak Supreme and the Buffalo Cheese Steak.

***

For placing an order, confirming catering details, or general inquiries, please use the following contact information:

Address:

390 Midland Ave

Garfield, NJ 07026, USA

Phone:

(973) 859-0855

***

Choosing what to order at Pizza Mania NJ can be a delightful challenge given the vastness of the menu, but focusing on their celebrated strengths will always lead to a satisfying New Jersey dining experience. For the purist, the plain pizza is a necessity; reviews confirm the crust offers that "perfect crunch with just the right amount of chew," a hallmark of a great local pie. However, the true value lies in exploring their unique creations and specialty meals.

For a unique and highly recommended experience, the Vodka Chicken Wrap Panini is the undisputed champion. It is a local favorite that has built a cult following for its perfect blend of quality blackened chicken and rich, flavorful vodka sauce. If you are looking for a show-stopping pizza, you cannot go wrong with the Philly Cheesesteak Pizza or the Chicken Parmigiana Pizza, both known for their generous, high-quality toppings.

Beyond the pizza, if you're settling in for a full meal, the pasta dishes are consistently lauded as "delicious" and "flavorful," with the Penne Vodka being a standout choice. For families or groups, be sure to take advantage of their excellent Family Specials, which often pair two large pizzas with a two-liter soda at a great value, making it a steal for a Friday night tradition.

It's important to set your expectations when navigating such a large menu; while the majority of feedback is overwhelmingly positive, particularly regarding the pizza, specialty wraps, and pasta, some reviews mention inconsistency in certain non-core items like wings or burgers. Therefore, sticking to the authentic Italian and specialty items is highly recommended for the best experience. The incredible quality, large portions, and friendly staff have solidified Pizza Mania NJ’s place as a top-tier Garfield pizzeria and a reliable, high-value choice for any local looking for an exceptional taste of Bergen County Italian-American cuisine.

Pizza Mania NJ

390 Midland Ave, Garfield, NJ 07026, USA