GoodFellas Restaurant

- 661 Midland Ave, Garfield, NJ 07026

When New Jersey locals talk about authentic Italian dining that captures the spirit of the 'old country' with a dash of classic American-Italian flair, GoodFellas Restaurant in Garfield, NJ, is consistently part of the conversation. More than just a place to eat, this establishment offers a complete dining experience, celebrated for its 'old-school Jersey Italian charm.' From the moment guests walk in, they are enveloped by a warm, cozy atmosphere that manages to be both upscale and genuinely welcoming. It’s a place where the dedication to culinary excellence is matched by an equal commitment to superb hospitality, ensuring every diner feels like a valued member of the family.

GoodFellas Restaurant has established itself as a premier destination in Bergen County for those seeking traditional, yet refined, Italian and Continental cuisine. The menu is a delightful journey through Italy's best, featuring beloved classics alongside sophisticated, market-driven seasonal offerings. Whether you're planning a quick but satisfying lunch, a full multi-course dinner, or a special celebration, the restaurant provides a backdrop of soft lights, attentive service, and an ambiance often enhanced by live music, creating a truly memorable evening out. This combination of delicious food, great drinks, and a captivating atmosphere is why local patrons rave about the whole experience, praising the staff's attentiveness and the owner's personal touches.

The Garfield, NJ, location serves as a perfect meeting point for groups and couples across the North Jersey area, consistently drawing a crowd ready to enjoy the rich, bold flavors of expertly prepared Italian dishes. GoodFellas stands out by seamlessly blending a casual comfort with an undeniable touch of romantic, upscale dining, making it ideal for groups looking to celebrate or solo diners seeking a delicious escape.

Location and Accessibility

GoodFellas Restaurant is conveniently located at 661 Midland Ave, Garfield, NJ 07026, USA. This central Bergen County address makes it easily reachable for residents throughout the region and provides multiple convenient options for parking and access.

Guests have several excellent parking options, including a free parking lot, available on-site parking, and complimentary free street parking. For added convenience, the restaurant even offers valet parking for a truly effortless arrival. In terms of accessibility for all patrons, the facility is fully equipped with a Wheelchair Accessible Entrance, Parking Lot, Restroom, and Seating, ensuring a comfortable and accommodating dining experience from start to finish. The atmosphere is described as being simultaneously casual and cozy, while maintaining an upscale and quiet elegance—a great blend for a relaxed yet special meal.

Services Offered

GoodFellas Restaurant ensures a superior experience through a wide range of services designed to meet the diverse needs of its local clientele:

• Dine-In Table Service: Enjoy the full, immersive dining experience in the cozy and romantic atmosphere for both lunch and dinner.
• Delivery & Takeout: Convenient options are available for those who wish to enjoy the delicious Italian cuisine at home.
• Catering: The restaurant offers catering services, bringing its celebrated Italian fare to your next event or gathering.
• Reservations Accepted: Given its popularity, dinner reservations are highly recommended to secure your table.
• Full Bar Service: An extensive bar is available on-site, featuring a Great Wine List, Cocktails (including highly-praised Sangria), Beer, and Hard Liquor. Happy Hour drinks and food specials are also offered.
• Private Dining Room: For special events, celebrations, or business functions, a private dining room is available.
• Payments: Accepts all major forms of payment, including Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments.
• Family Accommodations: The restaurant is Good for Kids and provides High Chairs and Has Changing Table(s) for the comfort of families.

Features / Highlights

The true essence of GoodFellas Restaurant is found in the exceptional features that enhance the dining experience:

• Authentic Italian Ambiance: The venue features a classic Italian-American atmosphere with soft lighting and a warm, inviting setting often described as having an 'Italian romance ambiance' and a 'Goodfellas theme.'
• Live Music Entertainment: A major highlight is the regular inclusion of Live Music, featuring singers and DJs on select nights (such as Wednesdays, Fridays, and Saturdays), playing classics from the 70s, 80s, and Frank Sinatra favorites, creating a truly festive and engaging atmosphere.
• Gourmet Menu Diversity: The menu offers high-end options, particularly within the 'Piatto Principale' (Main Course) section. Highlights include Bistecca al Forno (Black Angus Rib-Eye), Rack of Lamb with a rosemary reduction, and the 'surf & turf' Terra & Mare (petite filet mignon and lobster tail).
• Fresh Seafood Focus: The seafood offerings are exceptional, with standout dishes like Branzino Marechiara (filet with mussels and shrimp), Capesante Sul Risotto (pan-seared scallops), and the classic Linguini Frutti di Mare.
• Signature Pasta Dishes: Pasta is a core offering, featuring favorites like Rigatoni Ripieni (stuffed with ricotta) in a bolognese sauce and the unique Pappardella E' Salsiccia with Italian sausage, shrimp, and broccoli rabe in a light tomato broth.
• Premium Beverage Selection: Patrons consistently praise the high-quality drink selection, including Great Cocktails and a focus on a Great Wine List, perfect for pairing with the gourmet entrees.
• Accommodating Options: The kitchen caters to various dietary needs by offering a selection of Vegan Options, Vegetarian Options, and Organic Dishes, ensuring broad appeal to the community.

Contact Information

For reservations, catering inquiries, or general questions, please use the contact information below. Given the restaurant's popularity, especially for dinner and live music nights, calling ahead is advised.

Address: 661 Midland Ave, Garfield, NJ 07026, USA

Phone: (973) 478-4000

What is Worth Choosing

For any New Jersey local seeking a truly elevated, authentic Italian dining experience, GoodFellas Restaurant is a prime choice. What is most worth choosing here is the immersive atmosphere combined with their star dishes. The overall experience is what draws the highest praise—the combination of a cozy, slightly romantic setting, genuinely attentive service (with the owner often checking on tables), and high-quality food that arrives with impressive speed.

Among the menu highlights, the pasta is always a wise choice; the Rigatoni Ripieni is a signature dish, or the Ravioli All' Aragosta (lobster ravioli) for a richer, upscale indulgence. If you're celebrating, any of the main courses are spectacular. Consider the classic Vitello Parmigiana (veal parmigiana) or the decadent Terra & Mare for a perfect splurge. Their lighter starters are also excellent, with the fresh Burrata (served with roasted peppers and prosciutto) or the flavorful Shrimp & Avocado Salad making great choices.

However, the single most unique feature that elevates a dinner from a meal to an event is the Live Music. Planning your visit for a night with live entertainment—typically a Wednesday, Friday, or Saturday—is highly recommended, as the music, often featuring classic singers and DJs, perfectly complements the Italian ambiance and fine dining experience. The bar is also a highlight, so be sure to explore the Great Wine List or sample the famous and not-too-sweet Sangria. In short, choose GoodFellas Restaurant for an unforgettable night where quality food, a lively ambiance, and old-school Italian hospitality come together perfectly in Garfield, NJ.

GoodFellas Restaurant

661 Midland Ave, Garfield, NJ 07026, USA