Pizza Pete's

- 528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024

In a city overflowing with pizza joints, finding a spot that truly captures the authentic New York slice experience can feel like a quest. It's a taste that's both a part of the city’s identity and a deeply personal preference for every resident. The ideal New York slice is a perfect balance of a satisfyingly crunchy crust, a generous layer of savory cheese, and a sauce that holds everything together without overpowering the other flavors. It's a quick, affordable, and delicious meal that's perfect for any time of day. While many places claim to have the best slice, there are a few neighborhood institutions that locals swear by. Pizza Pete's, located on the Upper West Side, is one of those places. It's a humble spot that prioritizes what truly matters: an incredible slice of pizza that leaves a lasting impression.

Pizza Pete’s is a testament to the old-school New York charm that many pizzerias have forgotten. It might not have a modern, polished interior, but that's part of its appeal. The well-worn decor tells a story of a place that has been serving up exceptional food for years, focusing on substance over style. The true warmth of the establishment comes from its incredibly friendly staff, who make every person who walks through the door feel like a regular. Their genuine hospitality creates a welcoming and memorable atmosphere, transforming a simple takeout spot into a cherished local gem. It's the kind of place where you can grab a quick meal and feel like you're part of the neighborhood, whether you're a college student grabbing a quick bite or a tourist who stumbled upon it by chance.

What really sets Pizza Pete's apart is the quality of its pizza. Each slice is a masterpiece of texture and flavor, featuring a crunchy crust that provides the perfect foundation for the rest of the ingredients. The cheese is generously applied, creating that glorious, satisfying stretch with every bite that a true pizza lover seeks. They don't just stop at a classic New York slice; their menu is surprisingly diverse, offering a range of styles to suit every craving. Whether you’re in the mood for a hearty slice of Sicilian, a rich deep-dish Chicago-style pizza, or a classic New York slice with a twist, Pizza Pete’s has you covered. This variety, combined with their commitment to high-quality ingredients and a consistently delicious product, makes it a spot worth seeking out.

Pizza Pete's is conveniently located at 528 Columbus Ave, on the Upper West Side of Manhattan. Its prime location makes it an ideal stop for anyone in the area, especially those visiting the nearby attractions. Situated just a stone's throw away from the American Museum of Natural History and the vast expanse of Central Park, it’s the perfect spot to grab a bite to eat after a day of exploring. The location is easily accessible for both locals and tourists, with various transportation options available. While the restaurant has limited seating, it is well-suited for a quick stop-in or for taking your food to go. Its proximity to some of the city’s biggest landmarks makes it a popular choice for those looking for a delicious and convenient meal.

For those traveling by subway, the 81st Street–Museum of Natural History station (B and C trains) is a short walk away. This makes it easy to get to from almost anywhere in the city. If you’re coming from the west, the 79th Street station (1 train) is also a manageable walk. Parking can be a challenge in this bustling area, but there are paid street parking options available. For those with pets, the outdoor seating area is dog-friendly, allowing you to enjoy a slice with your furry companion. The casual and welcoming atmosphere makes it a no-fuss spot that prioritizes great food and friendly service.

Pizza Pete's understands the diverse needs of its customers, offering a variety of service options to ensure you can enjoy their food in the way that best suits you. Whether you're in the mood to dine in, grab a quick meal on the go, or have it delivered right to your door, they have a system in place to make it easy and convenient. Their focus is on providing quick and efficient service without compromising the quality of the food.

• Dine-in: While seating is limited, you can enjoy a casual meal in their cozy atmosphere, perfect for a quick lunch or dinner.

• Takeout & Delivery: For those who prefer to eat at home or are on the go, Pizza Pete's offers fast and reliable takeout and delivery services, including no-contact delivery and curbside pickup for added convenience.

• Quick Bite: The restaurant is known for its speed and efficiency, making it a perfect spot for a quick bite to eat during a busy day. Their counter service and focus on slices ensure you won’t be waiting long.

• Payments: They make it easy to pay for your meal, accepting credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

What makes Pizza Pete's stand out from the competition isn't just one thing, but a combination of factors that create a memorable experience. It’s a place that has perfected the art of the classic New York slice while also offering unique options that cater to different tastes. The atmosphere, while unassuming, is what makes it feel so authentic and beloved by its patrons. The staff’s welcoming nature and the quality of the food are consistently highlighted as reasons for its popularity.

• Exceptional Pizza: The most significant highlight is, of course, the pizza itself. It's consistently praised for its crunchy crust, generous cheese, and delicious flavor. The quality of the ingredients shines through in every bite.

• Variety of Styles: Pizza Pete's goes beyond the standard New York slice, offering Chicago-style deep-dish and Sicilian pizzas, providing a unique and satisfying alternative for those looking for something different.

• Friendly Staff: The staff's genuine warmth and friendliness create a welcoming and comfortable environment that makes customers feel right at home. It’s a major reason why many people become repeat visitors.

• Casual and Relaxed Atmosphere: The casual setting is perfect for a laid-back meal. It’s a no-frills establishment that lets the food speak for itself, making it a perfect spot for a relaxed lunch or dinner with friends or family. They also often have sports television playing, adding to the easy-going vibe.

For more information, to place an order, or to inquire about their menu, you can reach Pizza Pete's using the contact information below. Their team is ready to help you with anything you need.

Address: 528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024

Phone: (212) 787-3153

With a menu that offers so many tempting options, deciding what to order at Pizza Pete's can be tough. While everything is delicious, there are a few standout items that you absolutely must try. These are the dishes that have earned the restaurant its loyal following and stellar reputation. Whether you’re a long-time New Yorker or just visiting, these choices will give you a true taste of what makes this place special.

For a classic New York experience, you can't go wrong with a simple Cheese Pizza slice. It’s the perfect representation of their quality and attention to detail. The crust is crispy, the cheese is abundant, and the sauce is perfectly balanced. If you’re looking for something with a bit more substance, the Buffalo Pizza is a favorite, offering a spicy and flavorful kick. The Fresh Mozzarella Pizza is another excellent choice, providing a lighter, fresher taste that highlights the quality of their ingredients.

For those who love a heartier pizza, the Chicago Style Pizza is a must-try. It’s a rich and filling deep-dish option that is a departure from the traditional New York slice but is equally delicious. If you prefer a thick, pillowy crust, the Sicilian Cheese is a perfect choice. And to round out your meal, be sure to grab some Garlic Knots or a Sausage & Pepper Roll, which are beloved sides that are perfect for sharing. With so many great options, Pizza Pete's makes it easy to find your new favorite slice in the city.

Pizza Pete's

528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA