Poetica Coffee Introduce
In the bustling urban tapestry of New York, where every street corner seems to offer a new experience, finding a truly exceptional coffee shop can feel like a rare and wonderful discovery. For those in Brooklyn, especially in the vibrant Smith Street neighborhood,
Poetica Coffee
has emerged as a beloved local gem. It’s more than just a place to grab a quick cup of joe; it's a destination for a moment of peace, a productive work session, or a friendly chat with a barista who remembers your name. With its cozy, trendy atmosphere and a menu that caters to both coffee purists and tea enthusiasts, Poetica Coffee has quickly become a go-to spot for locals seeking a high-quality, welcoming experience.This article will take you on a journey through everything that makes Poetica Coffee a must-visit spot in Brooklyn. We'll explore its convenient location and the accessibility options that make it a breeze to get to. We will also delve into the rich menu of beverages and pastries, highlighting why their coffee and tea selections are so highly praised. Furthermore, we’ll uncover the unique features that set Poetica apart, from its inviting outdoor seating to its reputation for superb customer service. Whether you're a long-time resident or just passing through the neighborhood, this guide will show you why Poetica Coffee is worth choosing for your next caffeine fix or a moment of respite.
Poetica Coffee is perfectly situated at 251 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, in a lively and easily accessible part of the borough. This prime location places it within walking distance for many residents and makes it a convenient stop for anyone exploring the area. For those who rely on public transportation, the coffee shop is well-connected, with multiple subway and bus stops nearby. This makes it a great spot to meet friends or to stop by on your way to or from work. For those who drive, paid street parking is available, offering a practical solution for a quick visit. Furthermore, the coffee shop's commitment to accessibility is evident with its wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring that everyone can enjoy its offerings without any hassle. This attention to location and accessibility makes Poetica Coffee a welcoming and inclusive space for all members of the community.
Poetica Coffee prides itself on offering a diverse range of services to cater to the modern New Yorker's lifestyle. They understand that a great coffee shop needs to be flexible, whether you're in a hurry or looking to linger for a while. Their service options are designed with customer convenience in mind.
Outdoor Seating: One of the most beloved features is their outdoor seating. This provides a perfect spot to enjoy your coffee and pastry on a beautiful day, watch the world go by, or have a relaxed conversation with friends. It’s a popular choice for those who want to enjoy the neighborhood's vibrant atmosphere.
Delivery: For days when you can't make it to the shop, Poetica Coffee offers delivery services. This means you can enjoy their delicious coffee and food from the comfort of your home or office, making it an excellent option for a work-from-home day or a lazy weekend morning.
Takeout: If you’re on a tight schedule, their efficient takeout service ensures that you can quickly grab your order and get on with your day without any delay.
Dine-in: The cozy interior with comfortable seating invites you to take a break and relax. It's an ideal setting for a quiet moment alone or a focused study session.
These services highlight Poetica Coffee's commitment to providing a seamless and enjoyable experience for all of its patrons, no matter their preference.
What truly sets Poetica Coffee apart are the specific features and highlights that create its unique identity. These are the elements that locals love and that keep them coming back day after day.
Great Coffee and Tea Selection: The quality of the beverages is a top priority. Customers consistently praise the coffee, with options ranging from a classic Drip Coffee and Americano to more specialized drinks like a Cortado and Flat White. The tea selection is equally impressive, offering classics like Organic Earl Grey and Jasmine Green, as well as unique options like Matcha and Iced Chai Latte. This variety ensures there is a perfect drink for every palate.
Atmosphere and Crowd: The atmosphere is described as casual, cozy, and trendy, striking the perfect balance between a comfortable neighborhood spot and a stylish cafe. It's a place where you can feel relaxed and inspired. The primary crowd consists of locals, which contributes to a friendly and community-oriented vibe.
Accessibility: The wheelchair-accessible entrance makes the shop a welcoming space for all. This thoughtful feature reflects a commitment to inclusivity and makes it a convenient spot for a wide range of customers.
Offerings: Besides a wide array of drinks, Poetica also offers quick bites like pastries and sandwiches, perfect for a light breakfast or a mid-day snack. The menu includes Chocoloate Croissant, Prosciutto Sandwich, and the unique Turkey Pomegranate Sandwich, providing delicious options to complement your drink.
Customer Service: Reviewers frequently highlight the "superb customer service." Baristas like Hernán are noted for being "nice to talk to" and genuinely friendly, going beyond a simple welcome to create a personal connection with customers. This level of service transforms a simple coffee run into a pleasant, memorable experience.
These highlights are a testament to why Poetica Coffee is considered more than just a place to get coffee—it's a community hub.
For any inquiries or to simply learn more about the shop, you can contact them through the following details: Address: 251 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA. Phone: (212) 244-2681 or +1 212-244-2681. These contact points make it simple to get in touch with the shop for any reason, whether it's to confirm business hours or to place a large order.
In a city as saturated with coffee shops as New York, choosing one can be overwhelming. So, what makes Poetica Coffee the right choice? The answer lies in its perfect blend of quality, comfort, and genuine hospitality. The coffee and tea are consistently excellent, with a variety that caters to every taste. The baristas are not just skilled at making drinks; they are also friendly and engaging, fostering a sense of community that is often missing in a big city. This personal touch is what turns first-time visitors into regulars.
The atmosphere is a major draw as well. It’s cozy and casual, making it an ideal place for solo dining, a quiet work session, or a relaxing catch-up with a friend. The outdoor seating is a significant plus, offering a breath of fresh air and a prime spot for people-watching. While the pastries may not be for everyone's personal preference, the wide range of beverage options ensures there is always something to love. From a classic Iced Latte to a unique Matcha Lemonade, their menu is crafted to delight. Additionally, for those who love their coffee so much they want to brew it at home, they also offer coffee beans for purchase, including their "Prose" blend.
Ultimately, Poetica Coffee is a place where you can find both superb beverages and a welcoming home away from home. Its dedication to quality products and excellent customer service makes it a standout choice and a true neighborhood treasure worth visiting again and again.
Poetica Coffee Menu
Pastry
- Chocoloate Croissant $3.81
A flaky French pastry.
- Croissant Plain $3.81
A flaky French pastry.
- Pierogi $5.50
All Natural Homemade Pierogies. With Potato, Chicken or Egg and Scallion.
- Prosciutto Sandwich $9.00
Arugula and prosciutto with cheese inside a butter croissant.
- Turkey Pomegranate Sandwich $9.00
Massaged Baby Spinach with mozzarella cheese turkey and pomegranate sauce in a butter croissant.
Drinks
- Americano
- Iced Green Tea
- Iced Chai Latte
Iced tea is a form of cold tea. though usually served in a glass with ice, it can refer to any tea that has been chilled or cooled. It may be sweetened with sugar, syrup.
- Iced Cappuccino
- Iced Matcha
- Iced Latte
- Matcha Lemonade $5.75
20 oz.
- Matcha Tea $4.00
- Matcha Latte
- Flat White $3.50
- Organic Chamomile $3.50
FLAVOR PROFILE - The buttery body and apple-like aroma can be enhanced with a touch of honey for a soothing beverage that can be enjoyed throughout the day. CAFFEINE FREE - Our Croatian Chamomile blossoms are a great caffeine-free herbal alternative to our teas
- Jasmine Green $3.50
Our Jasmine Green is a blend of spring-harvested green tea from Hubei, China scented with fresh jasmine flower grown in Fujian, China. This aromatic blend seamlessly combines the two flavors for a blend greater than the sum of its parts
- Organic Earl Grey $3.50
Summer harvested black tea from Yunnan, China and essential oil of the bergamot orange. When grown at an elevation of 1600-1800 meters, the da yeh cultivar produces a caramel sweet, malty black tea that pairs perfectly with the perfumed citrus aroma of first pressed oil from the bergamot fruit.
- Organic English Breakfast Tea $3.50
Harvested in October 2018, our English Breakfast was blended with intention of being great with a bit of milk and sugar, as well as on its own. The slow growth of several Yunnan cultivars at roughly 1850 masl develops sweet malty flavors, accented with notes of caramelized sugar, baking spices, and cocoa.
- Drip Coffee
This coffee is pure joy! Another hot seller! Its med-dark strength offers dark chocolate, rich caramel and hazelnut-like, natural flavors. We all need some hazelnut in our lives! It carries a Bonnie and Clyde dynamic when paired with milk! Those who enjoy a full bodied/strong coffee and are not shy to hit it with some leche, you will want this over and over again. Forza can be your ride or die!
- Hot Chocolate
- Mocha
- Latte
- Cortado
- Macchiato
- Espresso
- Iced Matcha Lemonade $5.00
16 oz.
- Iced Black Tea
20 oz.
- Iced Americano
Iced Americano is made by pouring cold water, over ice followed by shots of espresso. Served with manual pour-over, the coffee drains directly onto the cold water and ice, so it chills during brewing.
- Cold Brew
The cold brew process of leaching flavor from the beans produces a chemical profile different from conventional brewing methods.
- Arnold Palmer
The Arnold Palmer is a name commonly used for a non-alcoholic beverage that combines iced tea and lemonade.
- Whole Milk $6.00
Local farm milk.
- Oat Milk In Carton $6.00
- Almond Milk In Carton $6.00
Coffee Beans
- Prose $19.00
12 oz. Full bodied strong with dark chocolate, caramel and hazelnut.
- Coffee Beans $75.00
5 lb. Full bodied strong dark chocolate, caramel and hazelnut.
Poetica Coffee Details
Service options
- Outdoor seating
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Highlights
- Great coffee
- Great tea selection
Popular for
- Breakfast
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Offerings
- Coffee
- Quick bite
Dining options
- Breakfast
- Dessert
- Seating
- Table service
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cozy
- Trendy
Crowd
- Locals
Planning
- Accepts reservations
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Paid street parking
Poetica Coffee Photos










Poetica Coffee Location
Poetica Coffee Reviews
baristalattepastriesbackyardmatchacold brewcappuccinopierogigrape vinesback garden
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1This coffee shop is such a cozy spot. Hernán offers superb customer service and always recommends new things. My go to is a chai latte and on a warm day, a dirty chai. Either or always a yummy experience!!
August 27 · arbaI had a great study session here, i enjoyed the outdoor seating. The baristas were nice to talk to, and not just in a short friendly "welcome" way, in a real, they really wanted to know me way. Try the matcha, i recommend it, however the pastries were just not really for me, personal preference
September 23 · Antony JuelaMy iced vanilla latte was on point. It was really clean and it smelled like amazing coffee.
August 11 · Zoe DukasPoetica is my favorite coffee shop. I go out of my way to go there just because I know it’ll be worth it. Consistently good coffee and friendly staff. Hernán always serves with a smile on his face, a neighborhood true gem.
May 21 · Zac HartSuch a charming sister coffee shop to Park Slope’s own Poetica on 7th Avenue and 5th Street. ❤️ Wonderful coffee and breakfast treats. They make their own croissants!The newly renovated shop is so inviting and has the prewar feel. I am thrilled they kept the tin ceiling and medallions 😍I sat and worked at 8:45. Not too busy, but a constant stream of customers getting to go.And they have a back garden as well. 👍
December 20 · Heidi Faucette
More restaurants near me

30 Lafayette Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217, USA

106 DeKalb Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

707 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11217, USA

108 DeKalb Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

711 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11217, USA

114 DeKalb Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

719 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11217, USA

116 DeKalb Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

721 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11217, USA

118 DeKalb Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217, USA

725 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11217, USA

120 DeKalb Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Dining Insights Posts





