Pretty Toni's Cafe: The Ultimate Soul Food and Sandwich Destination in Valley Stream, NY

Pretty Toni's Cafe Introduce

For New Yorkers in search of a dining experience that combines comfort, flavor, and a uniquely welcoming atmosphere,

Pretty Toni's Cafe

in Valley Stream stands out as a true local gem. More than just a simple sandwich shop, this establishment is a versatile culinary destination, operating as a soulful restaurant, a cozy cafe, and a lively bar all in one. It is a place where every item, from a quick lunch sandwich to a full hot plate dinner, is prepared with a distinctive touch that keeps the locals coming back.

Located conveniently in Nassau County,

Pretty Toni's Cafe

caters perfectly to the demands of the New York metropolitan area, offering a blend of fast service and high-quality, memorable dishes. This article provides a comprehensive and engaging look at what makes this establishment a vital part of the local dining scene. We will detail its strategic location, the extensive range of services and menu options—including its famous soul food items—and the critical contact information. Our goal is to serve as an informative guide for users in the New York region looking for their next great dining spot, emphasizing facts and a professional, inviting tone. The highly positive customer reviews confirm its reputation as a

very lovely place

with

amazing, friendly people

---

Location and Accessibility

Pretty Toni's Cafe

is situated at

759 W Merrick Rd, Valley Stream, NY 11580, USA

. This location places it conveniently on a major thoroughfare in Valley Stream, making it easily reachable for residents of Long Island and those commuting through the area. For New Yorkers, accessibility is a non-negotiable feature, and Pretty Toni's excels in providing a hassle-free visit.

One of the most valuable amenities for any establishment in the New York vicinity is parking.

Pretty Toni's Cafe

offers the dual convenience of a

Free parking lot

as well as

Free street parking

, significantly easing the stress of dining out. This makes it an ideal spot for family outings, business lunches, or a quick dinner pickup.

Furthermore, the restaurant demonstrates a strong commitment to serving all members of the community through its comprehensive accessibility features. These include a

Wheelchair accessible entrance

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Wheelchair accessible restroom

, and

Wheelchair accessible seating

. This level of detailed accommodation ensures a comfortable and welcoming environment for everyone. The atmosphere is described as

Casual, Cozy, and Trendy

, drawing a crowd of

Locals, Groups, and Families

---

Services Offered

Pretty Toni's Cafe

provides a versatile array of service options designed to meet various dining preferences, from a spontaneous visit to a planned event. The options available cater directly to the needs of the dynamic New York customer.

The full range of services includes:

Dine-in:
Enjoy the cozy and casual atmosphere with full
Table service
available for
Brunch, Lunch, and Dinner
.
Takeout:
A quick and convenient option for grabbing meals on the go, perfect for the commuter or the busy local.
Delivery:
Have the delicious soul food and sandwiches brought directly to your home or office.
Reservations:
The establishment
Accepts reservations
, with
Brunch reservations recommended
, making it easy to plan group gatherings or weekend meals.
Catering:
Offering full
Catering
services, allowing customers to bring the acclaimed soul food and comfort dishes to their events.
Full Bar Service:
Featuring a
Bar onsite
with an extensive list of
Alcohol, Beer, Cocktails, Hard liquor, and Wine
.
Family-Friendly Amenities:
The cafe is
Good for kids
and provides
High chairs
and a dedicated
Kids' menu
.
Payments:
Accepting major forms of payment including
Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments
.

With amenities like

Restroom

access and

Wi-Fi

, the cafe is also well-suited for solo diners or those seeking a comfortable, trendy spot for a quick break.

---

Features / Highlights

The core highlights of

Pretty Toni's Cafe

lie in its unique menu blend, which focuses on elevated comfort food, and its exceptional service qualities. The venue is celebrated for delivering a high-quality experience across various dining categories.

Key menu and service highlights include:

Signature Soul Food Plates:
The menu features highly popular dishes such as the
Red Velvet Waffle & Chicken Plate ($25.00)
and the
Belgian Waffle & Chicken Plate ($23.00)
, with customer reviews confirming the quality and unique flavor of the former. Other hot plates include
Salmon Plate ($33.00), New York Strip Steak Plate ($42.00)
, and the signature
SOUL BOWL ($23.00)
.
Sandwich and Lunch Focus:
Despite its diverse menu, the cafe operates successfully as a
Sandwich shop
, notably featuring the
Whiting Sandwich Combo ($20.00)
in its lunch specials, appealing directly to the quick-bite crowd.
Exceptional Beverages and Cocktails:
Recognized for offering
Great cocktails
, the menu features inventive drinks like the
JAMAICAN RUM PUNCH ($15.00)
,
SOUR SOP MARGARITA ($16.00)
, and specialized wines like
BLACK GIRL MAGIC RED BLEND ($14.00)
, appealing to those seeking high-quality alcoholic offerings. They also offer
Flavored Iced Tea Or Flavored Lemonade ($5.50)
.
Highly-Rated Service:
Patrons consistently highlight the
Fast service
and the
Amazing, friendly people
working there, making the dining experience pleasant and efficient.
Dessert and Sides:
The cafe is known for
Great dessert
, and the side orders are comforting and traditional, including favorites like
Mac & Cheese ($6.00), Candied Yams ($5.00), Sweet Plantains ($5.00)
, and
Vegetarian Greens ($5.00)
.
Local Specialty:
The establishment
Serves local specialty
and offers
Comfort food
and
Small plates
, making it a great destination for a quick, flavorful meal or a full, relaxing dinner.

---

Contact Information

To plan your visit, make a reservation, or place an order for delivery or takeout, here is the essential contact information for

Pretty Toni's Cafe

in Valley Stream, NY:

Address:

759 W Merrick Rd, Valley Stream, NY 11580, USA

Phone:

(516) 285-8664

Mobile Phone:

+1 516-285-8664

---

What is Worth Choosing

For the New York local,

Pretty Toni's Cafe

is an absolute must-try for several compelling reasons that extend beyond a standard sandwich shop experience. It truly excels in blending casual convenience with gourmet, soulful flavors.

The Unique Menu Experience:

The decision to visit is largely driven by the opportunity to indulge in dishes that are hard to find executed this well, such as the widely praised

Red Velvet Waffle & Chicken Plate

. This dish, noted for its balance of sweet waffles and savory chicken, is an experience in itself, positioning the cafe as a premier brunch or dinner spot. The entire menu, from the fried appetizers like

FRIED MACARONI & CHEESE ($12.00)

and

Pan Seared Crab Cakes ($18.00)

to the traditional sides, promises high-quality, authentic soul food.

Perfect for Any Occasion:

Whether you need a

Quick bite

during lunch—perhaps the

Whiting Sandwich Combo

—or a full

Dinner

with friends, this place is versatile. The

Great cocktails

and

Bar onsite

make it a great spot for an evening gathering, while the family-friendly amenities ensure groups with children are well taken care of. Being popular for

Solo dining

also speaks to the comfortable and friendly vibe.

Hassle-Free Logistics:

In the Tri-State area, the rare combination of

Fast service

and

Free parking lot

access makes

Pretty Toni's Cafe

a practical winner. New Yorkers value their time, and the quick, efficient, and friendly staff—praised for being

amazing

and

courteous

—ensure that a visit here is enjoyable from start to finish.

Ultimately, you choose

Pretty Toni's Cafe

not just for a sandwich, but for a full-spectrum dining experience that delivers on taste, comfort, service, and convenience, making it a highly recommended destination in Valley Stream.

Pretty Toni's Cafe Vibe

Starters
Deep Fried Chicken Strips $12.00
Plain, Buffalo,
Whiting Strips $12.00
Deep fried with tarter & hot sauce.
Catfish Strips $12.00
Deep fried with tarter & hot sauce.
Wingettes $12.00
Fried, Buffalo, jerked
Grilled Shrimp Skewer $13.00
Plain, BBQ, jerked
Pan Seared Crab Cakes $18.00
Served with spicy mango drizzle.
FRIED MACARONI & CHEESE $12.00
10 pc Fried Macaroni and Cheese Wedges drizzled with Ranch Dressing
BROCOLLI & CHEESE SOUP 10 OZ $10.00
CREAMY BROCOLLI AND CHESE SOUP

Hot Plates
Red Velvet Waffle & Chicken Plate $25.00
Belgian waffle drizzled with cream cheese icing and deep fried half chicken.
Belgian Waffle & Chicken Plate $23.00
Belgian waffle and deep fried half chicken. No side orders on waffle meals.
Deep Fried Half Chicken Plate $23.00
Choose any 2 side orders.
Catfish Plate $23.00
Deep fried, grilled or blackened. Choose any 2 side orders. Add fried or grilled shrimp, smothered with gravy & onions, spicy mango or sweet chili drizzle for an additional charge.
Shrimp Plate $29.00
1 dozen x-large fried, grilled, jerked or blackened. Choose any 2 side orders. Add smothered with gravy & onions, spicy mango or sweet chili drizzle for an additional charge.
Salmon Plate $33.00
Grilled, BBQ, blackened, jerked. Choose any 2 side orders. Add spicy mango or sweet chili drizzle for an additional charge.
Fried Whiting Plate $23.00
Whiting filets. Choose any 2 side orders. Add fried shrimp for an additional charge.
New York Strip Steak Plate $42.00
10 oz. grilled, blackened or jerked. Choose any 2 side orders.
SOUL BOWL $23.00
MAC & CHEESE, YAMS, VEG. GREENS, PLANTAINS FIXED PLATE. NO SUBSTITUTIONS OR CHANGES

Salads
KALE Caesar Salad $12.00
KALE with Caesar dressing, croutons and Parmesan cheese. Add grilled or fried chicken cutlet, grilled or fried shrimp, deep fried or Buffalo chicken strips for an additional charge.

LUNCH SPECIALS
Whiting Sandwich Combo $20.00
Fried Whiting Sandwich on White or Wheat Bread, French Fries, Homemade Iced Tea Hot sauce, Ketchup, and Tarter sauce on the side Please put in notes choice of bread

Side Orders
Sweet Plantains $5.00
Vegetarian Greens $5.00
French Fries $5.00
Sweet Potato Fries $6.00
Candied Yams $5.00
Cajun Fries $6.00
Mac & Cheese $6.00
Cajun Fries $5.00

Beverages
Soft Drink $4.50
Flavored Iced Tea Or Flavored Lemonade $5.50
Lemonade Or Iced Tea $4.50
Poland Spring $3.00

ALCOHOL BEVERAGES
SNOOP DOG HARD CHARDONNAY $13.00
BLACK GIRL MAGIC RED BLEND $14.00
SNOOP DOG CALI RED $13.00
BLACK GIRL MAGIC MIMOSA $14.00
MARY J BLIGE SUN GODDESS SAUVIGNON BLANC $14.00
BLACK GIRL MAGIC SANGRIA $14.00
CHOOSE RED OR ROSE'
BLACK GIRL MAGIC FLAVORED MIMOSA $15.00
CHOOSE ONE: POMEGRANATE, GUAVA, OR PINEAPPLE

ALCOHOL COCKTAILS
JAMAICAN RUM PUNCH $15.00
WHISKEY LAVENDER LEMONADE $15.00
UNCLE NEAREST WHISKEY, LEMONADE, LAVENDER
D'USSE SIDE CAR $16.00
D'USSE COGNAC, ORANGE LIQUEUR, SOUR MIX
APPLETON ESTATE SPICED ICED TEA $15.00
APPLETON ESTATE RUM, ICED TEA, CINNAMON PINCH
PINEAPPLE UPSIDE DOWN $15.00
JAMIE FOX BROWN SUGAR BOURBON, PINEAPPLE JUICE
WHISKEY SOUR $15.00
UNCLE NEAREST WHISKEY, ORANGE LIQUEUR, SOUR MIX
SOUR SOP MARGARITA $16.00
HORNITOS PLATA TEQUILA, ORANGE LIQUEUR, SOUR SOP NECTAR
CIROC MARTINI $15.00
CIROC VODKA CHOOSE 1 JUICE: PINEAPPLE, GUAVA OR POMEGRANATE

Pretty Toni's Cafe Details

Service options
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great cocktails
Great dessert
Serves local specialty

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Hard liquor
Quick bite
Small plates
Wine

Dining options
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Bar onsite
Restroom
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd
Family-friendly
Groups
Locals

Planning
Brunch reservations recommended
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
Parking

Pretty Toni's Cafe Photos

Pretty Toni's Cafe Location

Pretty Toni's Cafe

New York Nassau County Valley Stream West Merrick Road

759 W Merrick Rd, Valley Stream, NY 11580, USA

Pretty Toni's Cafe Reviews

An average rating of ★4.1 from 259 user reviews.

brunchcatfishmusicred velvetchicken and wafflescornbreadfood and servicepartycollard greensintimate

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Very lovely place. Amazing, friendly people. Food was great. More people should go here. I'm glad I didn't overlook this place. Got there right as they opened.
September 06 · Desiree Reyes
Very nice chill environment to enjoy brunch, soul food style. I had the red velvet chicken and waffles and loved it. The chicken is a little salty but that's tradition! Waffles are a very sweet and they balance off the chicken well with the right drink. I would try again!
August 23 · Anthony Whyte
This was my 1st time dining here. This place is small, but it's so cute, cozy, & quaint! I love the fact that it's a small restaurant. Sometimes, you just want that 'at home' feel, and you will definitely get that here. Everything was awesome! From the atmosphere, to the music, to the food, (that cornbread!!) and to Gary. Gary was very warm and attentive and greeted everyone with a smile. Kudos to Pretty Toni's Cafe!! You have my stamp of approval, and I will definitely be back!
November 18 · Big Steph
The food was delicious, and freshly cooked and hot on my plate. I was a little hunggry upon my arrival so the cornbread and water was right on time. Pleasant atmosphere, wonderful music and immense service was much appreciated. Thank you Craig. I had the red velvet waffle with chicken topped with snoop dogs Chardonnay. It was as truly a wonderful brunch with Pretty Toni’s cafe., and the price was right. Not sure when I will go back but I surely will go back.
July 20 · Sharon Johnson
Wonderful, quiet restaurant!! I stopped by here for brunch while getting some errands done and the food was great for lunch :) Host was very accomodating and extremely kind!!! Everything tasted great
December 27 · Jenny Zhang