Prime 374 - Seafood & Steak

- 374 Morsetown Rd, West Milford, NJ 07480

If you're a New Jersey resident seeking an exceptional dining experience that harmoniously blends the richness of prime steaks with the freshness of quality seafood, look no further than Prime 374 - Seafood & Steak. Located conveniently in West Milford, this establishment has positioned itself as a premier destination for those who appreciate fine dining, excellent service, and a diverse, meticulously crafted menu. Whether you are planning a romantic dinner, a celebratory group gathering, or just looking for a quality meal in a welcoming atmosphere, Prime 374 offers a compelling choice for locals and visitors alike. It's more than just a restaurant; it’s a culinary hub delivering an upscale yet cozy experience right here in our community.

The restaurant provides a range of dining options, from satisfying brunch selections to lavish dinner entrées. They are well-known for their commitment to using quality ingredients, evident in their extensive menu that covers everything from hearty comfort food to sophisticated culinary creations. Local patrons often highlight the seamless transition between a classic steakhouse feel and an excellent seafood eatery. The atmosphere is consistently described as casual yet cozy, making it an ideal spot for a relaxed meal or a more formal gathering. Furthermore, the commitment to great service, as noted by numerous guests, ensures a truly enjoyable and memorable meal every time you visit.

Location and Accessibility

Prime 374 - Seafood & Steak is situated at 374 Morsetown Rd, West Milford, NJ 07480, USA, making it a central and accessible spot for those in the West Milford area and surrounding communities in Northern New Jersey. The location on Morsetown Road is easy to find, and the restaurant takes great care to ensure that accessibility is a priority for all patrons.

The restaurant provides comprehensive accessibility features, reflecting a commitment to accommodating every guest. These features include:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot
• Wheelchair accessible restroom
• Wheelchair accessible seating

Parking is also exceptionally convenient, eliminating the usual hassle often associated with dining out. Guests can take advantage of the following parking amenities:

• Free parking lot
• Free street parking
• On-site parking

These details ensure that visiting Prime 374 is a stress-free experience from the moment you arrive, allowing you to focus entirely on the exceptional food and service that awaits inside.

Services Offered

Prime 374 is a full-service restaurant offering a broad spectrum of dining services to meet various needs and preferences within the New Jersey community.

• Dine-in: Enjoy the full, cozy, and casual atmosphere with table service. Dinner reservations are recommended, and the restaurant accepts reservations to help with planning.
• Takeout: For those busy nights or cozy meals at home, the full menu is available for convenient takeout.
• Curbside pickup: A fast and easy option to grab your meal without needing to enter the establishment.
• Brunch: Offering a delightful selection of brunch items, including Avocado Omelet, Skirt Steak & Eggs, and Eggs Benedict, perfect for a weekend outing.
• Dinner: The main offering, featuring their signature Prime Steaks and diverse Seafood Entrées, alongside a robust menu of pastas, salads, and appetizers.
• Catering: Services available for larger events and gatherings, bringing the quality of Prime 374 to your special occasions.
• Dessert: A selection of great desserts, such as Cheesecake, Chocolate Lava Cake, and Tartufo, to complete your meal.
• Table service: Professional and attentive service throughout your dining experience.
• Bar onsite: A fully stocked bar offering a great selection of beers, cocktails, and wines.
• Kids' Menu & High Chairs: The restaurant is family-friendly, offering specialized menu options and high chairs for younger guests.

Features / Highlights

The unique selling points of Prime 374 that make it stand out among New Jersey’s dining options include both the quality of its offerings and the excellence of its operational standards.

• Exceptional Culinary Focus: Specializing in both prime cuts of steak—like the Porterhouse Steak For Two 44 Oz. and Grilled Ribeye USDA Prime—and a wide variety of fresh seafood, ensuring options for every palate. Seafood offerings include Blue Point Oysters, Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail, and Drunken Salmon.
• Fast and Professional Service: A key highlight is the commitment to fast service without compromising quality, ensuring a smooth and enjoyable dining process.
• Diverse and High-Quality Beverages: The restaurant boasts a great beer selection, a notable wine list, and expertly crafted cocktails, perfect for pairing with your meal or enjoying at the bar.
• Appetizer Variety: The appetizer selection is expansive and high-end, featuring items like Cold Seafood Cocktail For Two, Grilled Octopus, and Fried Calamari.
• Dessert Excellence: Known for having great desserts, providing a perfect conclusion to any meal.
• Ambiance: The atmosphere is noted as being casual and cozy, creating a relaxing and inviting environment suitable for various occasions, from solo dining to group dinners.
• Accommodations for Groups and Tourists: A popular spot for groups and recognized as a destination for tourists passing through or staying in the area.
• Pet-Friendly Outdoor Area: Dogs are allowed outside, making it a great option for pet owners during warmer months.
• Flexible Payments: The restaurant conveniently accepts major credit cards and debit cards.

Contact Information

For making reservations, placing a takeout order, or any general inquiries, the restaurant can be reached through the following contact details:

Address: 374 Morsetown Rd, West Milford, NJ 07480, USA

Phone: (973) 728-9613 or +1 973-728-9613

It is highly recommended to call ahead for dinner, as reservations are accepted and often recommended to secure your seating, especially on weekends or for larger parties.

What is worth choosing

Choosing Prime 374 - Seafood & Steak is an excellent decision for several reasons that resonate deeply with the New Jersey dining scene. Firstly, the fusion of a top-tier steakhouse with a comprehensive seafood selection is a rare and valuable offering, providing incredible versatility and quality under one roof. Whether your craving is for a perfectly cooked Filet Mignon, a massive Dry Aged Porterhouse, or fresh Seafood Linguine and Blue Point Oysters, this restaurant delivers. This depth of menu allows the establishment to cater to diverse tastes and large groups with varying preferences.

Secondly, the dedication to a high-quality overall experience sets it apart. The combination of great food, great drinks (including a carefully curated wine and cocktail list), and great desserts ensures that every stage of your meal is satisfying. Customer feedback consistently praises the staff for being very nice, welcoming, and attentive, indicating a genuine commitment to customer comfort and satisfaction. The recognition for "fast service" further enhances the dining value, ensuring a pleasant and timely meal.

Finally, the combination of convenient location in West Milford, extensive accessibility features, and hassle-free parking makes it an incredibly practical choice. The environment is both sophisticated enough for a fine dining experience, as noted by some calling it one of West Milford's best fine dining spots, yet casual and cozy enough to be comfortable for regular visits. For New Jersey locals seeking reliability, quality, and variety in their dining choices, Prime 374 stands out as a superior establishment well worth the visit, whether you're celebrating a milestone or simply enjoying a weeknight dinner.

Prime 374 - Seafood & Steak

374 Morsetown Rd, West Milford, NJ 07480, USA