Rancherita Restaurant

- 1400 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302

For New York residents searching for truly authentic and deeply satisfying Mexican cuisine, Rancherita Restaurant, located on Staten Island's Forest Avenue, stands out as a genuine culinary destination. This establishment proudly operates exclusively as a Mexican restaurant, dedicating itself to serving traditional, homestyle recipes that transport diners south of the border with every bite. The foundational principle of Rancherita is to offer food that is described by patrons as "authentic, delicious, and satisfying," making it a beloved local spot.

Rancherita offers an expansive menu that covers every meal of the day—from Breakfast and Brunch to Dinner—and extends into large-scale Catering. This flexibility makes it an excellent choice for a wide array of dining needs, whether you are stopping in for a quick weekday Lunch or planning a family-style Dinner. The commitment to traditional preparation is evident in the rich offerings, which include classic Plates, hearty Sopas, and a dedicated section for the trending Birria dishes. The restaurant operates seven days a week, generally from 10:00 AM to 11:00 PM, providing reliable service throughout the day and into the evening for the Staten Island community.

While the focus is squarely on the quality and flavor of the food—a key highlight for many customers—the atmosphere is noted for being relaxed, with good music playing at a comfortable volume. Patrons appreciate the excellent service provided by the staff, who are committed to a positive experience. However, new visitors should be aware of past feedback regarding the interior comfort, specifically concerns about a lack of proper cooling during warmer months. While the staff is excellent, investing in basic ambient improvements, such as fans and updated decor, would significantly enhance the overall dine-in experience and potentially attract more first-time customers, as suggested by community reviews. Nonetheless, for those who value authenticity over ambiance, the food alone is the primary reason to visit and return.

Rancherita Restaurant is centrally located on a major thoroughfare of Staten Island, ensuring ease of access for local New Yorkers. The precise location facilitates straightforward navigation whether driving or utilizing local transit options:

• The restaurant’s address is 1400 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302.
• It is situated to be easily reachable by residents in the surrounding Staten Island neighborhoods.
• While specific parking details are not provided, its Forest Avenue location suggests accessibility via common city transportation routes.
• The dining format is built around both indoor and off-premise convenience, offering both Dine-in and comprehensive off-site Service options.

The service structure at Rancherita is designed to cater to the diverse dining preferences of the New York market, ensuring that customers can enjoy their authentic Mexican meal conveniently and on their own terms:

• Full Dining Availability: Open for all main meals, including Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, and Dinner.
• Table Service: The primary Dine-in experience is enhanced by attentive Table service, though Counter service is also available for quick needs.
• Off-Premise Options: Provides easy Takeout for customers on the run.
• Delivery Services: Full Delivery is available, including a No-contact delivery option for safety and convenience.
• Event Catering: Offers Catering services, making it an excellent choice for feeding large groups with authentic Mexican dishes for parties or events.
• Seating and Desserts: Dedicated Seating is provided for comfortable dining, and a selection of Desserts rounds out the menu for a complete meal.

Rancherita Restaurant's menu is its crowning feature, offering a substantial range of authentic dishes that showcase the richness of Mexican culinary traditions. The highlights include:

• Authentic Birria Selection: A dedicated Birria section offers trending specialties like Burrito De Birria, Quesabirria, Tortabirria, and the hearty Birria 32 Oz, appealing to those seeking this savory, slow-cooked meat dish.
• Traditional Main Platters (Platos): Extensive range of main courses, including Molcajete ($35.00), Grilled Steak ($35.00), Azteca Steak ($32.00), and Enchiladas in various preparations (Verdes, Rojas O Mole, and Suizas), demonstrating traditional cooking expertise.
• Hearty Soup Offerings (Sopas): Features traditional Mexican soups like Pozole, Pozole Con 2 Tostadads, and special Seafood soups such as Sopa De Mariscos ($22.00) and Sopa De Camaron ($20.00).
• Diverse Taco Menu: Offers Small Tacos with a wide variety of fillings, including classic options like Steak, Chicken, and Marinated Pork, alongside more unique choices like Beef Tongue, Bullhead, Salted Beef, and Shrimp ($4.00).
• Seafood Specialties: Goes beyond typical Mexican fare with dedicated seafood dishes, including Grilled Fish, Fried Mojarra, Shrimp In Garlic Sauce, and the impressive Sopa De Mariscos and Paella, catering to marine cuisine enthusiasts.
• Fajitas and Alambres: Offers sizzling skillet dishes like Res (Steak), Pollo (Chicken), Camaron (Shrimp), and Mixtas (Mixed) Fajitas, which are perfect for sharing.
• Authentic Sides and Starters: The menu features traditional appetizers like Chips Con Salsa, Guacamole, Arroz Y Frijoles, and specialty sandwiches like As Poblanas (Cubana, Hawaiian, etc.), offering a full and customizable meal experience.

For reservations, takeout orders, or inquiries about catering services, please contact Rancherita Restaurant using the details below:

Address: 1400 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302

Phone: (718) 682-1247

Mobile Phone: +1 718-682-1247

Rancherita Restaurant is worth choosing for New Yorkers in the Staten Island area who seek an authentic, uncompromising taste of Mexico without needing to cross the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge. The single, most compelling reason to visit Rancherita is the exceptional quality and authenticity of its food. Customer reviews consistently highlight the dishes as "authentic, delicious, satisfying," and the "main attraction" of the restaurant.

For those familiar with Mexican cuisine, the extensive menu offers genuine depth, moving beyond standard taco-and-burrito fare to include regional specialties such as Birria in multiple formats, traditional Plates like the Molcajete, and a strong offering of fresh Mexican Seafood, including Paella and various shrimp preparations. This wide range, combined with affordable pricing across various options—from $3.50 Small Tacos to large $35.00 Platters—makes it an excellent value proposition.

The restaurant is a perfect fit for an authentic, family-style meal, available throughout the day from Breakfast to Dinner. While the ambiance may be understated and has room for improvement in terms of cooling and decor, the food quality and the commitment to excellent, friendly service ensure a satisfying experience. For New Yorkers prioritizing a real taste of Mexico, generous portions, and a broad menu that includes rare and trending items like Quesabirria, Rancherita Restaurant provides a delicious and reliable local choice.

Rancherita Restaurant

1400 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302, USA