Riesterer's Bakery

- 282 Hempstead Ave, West Hempstead, NY 11552

Introduction / Overview

For New York residents, particularly those on Long Island, the name Riesterer's Bakery is synonymous with baking history and tradition. Established in 1931, Riesterer's proudly holds the title of Long Island's oldest bakery, a remarkable tenure that spans over 94 years. This longevity is evident in the quality of their superb products and the “affinal interactions” they maintain with every patron, suggesting a deep-rooted connection to the community they serve from their expansive West Hempstead storefront.

Riesterer's is much more than a bakery; it is a true institution that acts as a symbolic centerpiece for countless celebrations across the New York region. While their cakes for all occasions—and even "no occasion"—appear to be the mainstay, the sheer scale of their offerings is described as "mind-boggling." From famous ring cakes and decorative layer cakes to an incredible "assortment and quantity of off-shelf" cookies, the store is a vibrant testament to decades of baking excellence.

Crucially, Riesterer's has expertly adapted to modern dietary requirements without sacrificing tradition. They are Kosher certified by the Vaad of Queens, offering both pareve (non-dairy) and dairy items, with a Mashgiach on the premises. This focus on providing diverse and inclusive options, including specialized items like dairy-free and sugar-free selections, ensures that everyone in the family, regardless of dietary need, can find a delicious treat to enjoy. This blend of history, vast selection, and community commitment is why Riesterer's remains a highly regarded destination in Nassau County.

Location and Accessibility

Riesterer’s Bakery is centrally and conveniently located at 282 Hempstead Ave, West Hempstead, NY 11552, USA. Positioned directly on Hempstead Avenue, it is a prominent fixture on Long Island, making it easily accessible from various points in Nassau County and nearby Queens.

As a bustling local business, the bakery’s location facilitates easy access for both quick pickup and longer consultations for custom orders. While the store offers some seating, reflecting changes in consumer preference, the primary focus is on providing high-quality baked goods to take home and enjoy. The bakery’s operating hours cater well to the local community's needs, running from 6:00 AM to 6:00 PM Monday through Saturday, and a shorter day on Sunday, allowing customers to pick up treats early in the morning or just after the workday.

For those wishing to connect with the bakery’s extensive history, the location features a notable "Nostalgia Wall" with photos from each decade, a clear beacon of the tradition they uphold. Although aspects of the store fixtures may evoke a sense of the past, the core product remains fresh and delicious, drawing generations of loyal New York customers back to this historic West Hempstead address.

Services Offered

Riesterer's Bakery provides a wide range of services, leveraging their nearly century-long expertise to serve the diverse needs of the New York metropolitan area.

• Custom Cake Creation: Specializing in custom cakes designed to be the "crowning jewel" or "symbolic centerpiece" for all celebrations, including birthdays, weddings, and holidays.
• Kosher Certified Products: Offering a large selection of items that are Kosher certified by the Vaad of Queens, including both pareve (non-dairy) and dairy baked goods, with a Mashgiach on premises.
• Dietary Specialty Options: Providing a "creative and diverse" range of options, including dairy-free, sugar-free, and noted gluten-free selections like loaf cakes and cupcakes, catering to various dietary restrictions.
• Nationwide Shipping: Offering the convenience of shipping their famous ring cakes, loaf cakes, and traditional rainbow cookies across New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Pennsylvania, and beyond.
• Extensive Assortment of Everyday Baked Goods: Maintaining a massive daily supply of cookies (including their famous Rainbow Cookies), Danish, muffins, and ring cakes in numerous flavors.
• Holiday and Shabbat Specials: Carrying a large selection of specialized baked items specifically prepared for Shabbat and major Jewish holidays.
• Celebratory Stationary and Complements: Offering a fair selection of complementary celebratory stationary and items alongside the baked goods displays.
• Customer Service and Consultation: Providing helpful and friendly employees who assist with selections and custom order requests via phone or in-store consultation.

Features / Highlights

Riesterer's Bakery stands out in the New York market due to its profound history, quality commitment, and exceptional variety.

• Long Island’s Oldest Bakery: With over 94 years in business ("Baking Memories since 1931"), the bakery offers a tradition and expertise that is unparalleled on Long Island.
• Kosher Certification: The full Kosher certification (Pareve and Dairy) and presence of a Mashgiach make it a highly reliable and essential resource for the religious community in the region.
• Famous Ring Cakes and Rainbow Cookies: Signature items like their ring cakes (available in flavors such as Cinnamon Crumb, Marble, and Blueberry) and traditional almond-flavor Rainbow Cookies are famous and available for in-store purchase and shipping.
• Dietary Flexibility: The commitment to diverse options, including parve icings, fillings, dairy-free whipped cream, and specialized sugar-free and gluten-free products, ensures a wide market appeal.
• Volume and Variety: The sheer "assortment and quantity" of treats, including hundreds of varieties of baked goods and custom cake flavor combinations (e.g., Napoleon Cake, Black Forest, Cannoli filling), offers unlimited choice.
• Deep Community Connection: The visible history (Nostalgia Wall) and "affinal interactions" with patrons highlight the bakery's deep, generational connection to the local West Hempstead community.
• Award-Winning Products: The bakery has received "various awards for our superb products," testifying to the consistent quality maintained over decades.

Contact Information

For creating a custom cake, placing an order for shipment, or inquiring about their daily specials, New York customers can contact Riesterer's Bakery using the information below.

• Address: 282 Hempstead Ave, West Hempstead, NY 11552, USA
• Phone: (516) 481-7636
• Mobile Phone: +1 516-481-7636
• Email: info@Rbakery.com

What is Worth Choosing

Riesterer's Bakery is an absolutely essential choice for anyone in the New York region seeking a bakery that combines rich history with modern versatility. Choosing Riesterer's means entrusting your most important celebrations to Long Island's oldest bakery—a team of professionals who have been "Baking Memories since 1931." This long-standing tradition ensures an unmatched level of expertise, particularly in creating spectacular custom cakes designed to "live up to your expectations and add to the success of your celebration."

More significantly for the diverse New York audience, the bakery's robust Kosher certification and wide array of options—including pareve, dairy-free, and sugar-free items—make it a crucial resource for families with specific dietary needs, ensuring no one is excluded from the enjoyment. Whether you are buying their famous Rainbow Cookies for a trip down memory lane, picking up a unique holiday item like the "apple sugar challah thing" that families rave about, or planning the perfect custom centerpiece, Riesterer's offers a reliable, high-quality, and creative selection that is unparalleled in the Nassau County area.

Riesterer's Bakery

282 Hempstead Ave, West Hempstead, NY 11552, USA