Schultzy's Restaurant

- 265 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709

For Long Island residents and visitors exploring the North Shore, Schultzy's Restaurant in Bayville, NY, is not just another seafood spot—it's a deep-rooted local institution built on genuine experience. The restaurant is the realization of a lifelong dream for owner Jim Schultzy, a man whose connection to the water began as a 13-year-old clammer in Oyster Bay. This authentic "bay-to-table" philosophy ensures that the seafood served is among the freshest available in the New York region, a quality immediately noticeable in every dish.

Schultzy's perfectly balances a sophisticated, seafood-centric menu with an inviting, accessible environment. The atmosphere is described as both Casual and Cozy, making it a comfortable destination for everyone from Groups of friends to Locals and Tourists. The high standard of service is frequently highlighted in customer reviews, with staff noted for being attentive, professional, and friendly. One patron lauded the staff for welcoming them in even before opening hours, a clear sign of the restaurant's commitment to outstanding hospitality.

The menu is a celebration of both classic and creative American seafood cuisine. Starters feature locally sourced delicacies like the Schultzy's Baked Stuffed Clams and Fresh North Shore Fire Roasted Oysters, reflecting the owner's origins in the shellfish industry. The Lunch and Dinner menus offer substantial main courses, from the classic and highly-praised Lobster Roll ($38.00) to upscale entrées like the Classic Lobster Baked ($52.00) and Schultzy's Surf N Turf ($62.00). Non-seafood enthusiasts are also well-catered for with options such as the NY Prime Strip Steak ($49.00) and The Classic Cheeseburger ($18.00).

Beyond the food, Schultzy's is also known for its full Bar onsite, featuring a Great beer selection and Great cocktails. This emphasis on quality beverages, combined with a lively social atmosphere—sometimes featuring the charisma of owner Jim Schultzy himself—makes it a great spot for Solo dining or a fun night out. It is a genuine Long Island gem where excellent food, a warm welcome, and a true coastal vibe come together seamlessly. The commitment to fresh, flavorful food being served quickly also earns them a highlight for Fast service.

Schultzy's Restaurant is conveniently located on Bayville Avenue in the village of Bayville, Long Island. This positioning makes it a central and easy-to-reach destination for residents across Nassau County and for those taking a scenic drive through the North Shore.

The full address is:265 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709

The restaurant has prioritized accessibility for all guests:

• Parking: Guests benefit from hassle-free parking with a Free parking lot and Free street parking readily available.
• Mobility Access: Comprehensive accommodations include a Wheelchair accessible entrance, Wheelchair accessible parking lot, Wheelchair accessible restroom, and Wheelchair accessible seating, ensuring comfort for every diner.
• Pets: While pets are not permitted inside, Dogs allowed outside means you can bring your furry friend along if you choose to dine in the open air.

Schultzy's provides a complete and flexible range of services to accommodate all styles of dining, from quick meals to large organized events.

• Dine-in and Seating: Offers comfortable indoor Seating with Table service and a Bar onsite, providing a Cozy and Casual dining environment.
• Reservations: The restaurant Accepts reservations, which is particularly beneficial for planning Dinner, especially on weekends or for large Groups.
• Takeout Options: Patrons can easily place orders for Takeout for an excellent meal at home.
• Comprehensive Dining Hours: Offers a full day of dining with dedicated services for Brunch, Lunch, and Dinner, as well as Dessert.
• Catering: The business also provides Catering services, specializing in bringing their fresh seafood and raw bar expertise to private parties and events.
• Full Bar Service: Serves a complete selection of beverages, including Alcohol, Beer, Cocktails, Hard liquor, and Wine, in addition to Coffee.
• Family-Friendly Amenities: The presence of a Kids' menu and High chairs makes it a welcoming choice for families with young children.
• Payment Methods: Accepts modern payment options including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Schultzy's Restaurant stands out in the competitive Long Island dining scene due to its unique identity and commitment to quality:

• Owner’s Baymen Heritage: The restaurant is owned by Jim Schultzy, a longtime Oyster Bay clammer, ensuring a genuine "bay-to-table" experience and ultra-Fresh North Shore Littleneck Clams and Oysters.
• Acclaimed Signature Dishes: Highly praised for its classic, delicious **Lobster Roll** ($38.00) and the rich **Shrimp And Lobster Bisque** ($15.00), which are must-try items.
• Exceptional Bar Program: Features a full Bar onsite with a Great beer selection and Great cocktails, providing a complete and enjoyable dining or social experience.
• Cozy, Welcoming Atmosphere: The ambiance is described as Casual and Cozy, attracting a lively crowd of Groups, Locals, and Tourists, with staff known for providing exceptional, friendly service.
• Serves Local Specialty: Focuses on utilizing local Long Island seafood, ensuring the freshest ingredients and supporting the local shellfishing community.
• Diverse Menu Offering: Provides a wide range of options, including Comfort food, Small plates like Grilled Octopus and Tuna Tartare, and Healthy options like a variety of fresh Salads and Sides.
• Popular for All Occasions: Highly Popular for Lunch, Dinner, and especially well-suited for Solo dining at the bar.

To make a reservation for Dinner, inquire about the nightly specials (such as Paella Monday or Mussel Night Tuesday), or arrange catering services, please use the contact details provided below:

Address: 265 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709
Phone: (516) 588-6240
Mobile Phone: +1 516-588-6240

Given the restaurant's popularity and the Cozy nature of the dining room, calling ahead to secure a reservation is strongly advised, especially if dining during peak hours.

For diners in the New York region, Schultzy's Restaurant is worth choosing because it delivers a rare, authentic, and high-quality seafood experience directly from the heart of Long Island's shellfishing community. You are not just getting a meal; you are tasting the direct passion and expertise of a dedicated local bayman, owner Jim Schultzy.

The ultimate reason to visit is the **freshness of the food and the consistency of the execution**. Customers consistently praise the food as being "incredible," "fresh, flavorful and always hot," highlighting the top-notch quality control. If you visit, you must try the **Lobster Roll** for a taste of Long Island done right, or dive into a lavish Entrée like the **Schultzy's Surf N Turf** ($62.00) or the **Classic Lobster Baked** ($52.00) for a truly decadent dinner experience. Even their desserts are "completely off the charts," rounding out a flawless culinary journey.

Furthermore, the atmosphere is magnetic. The combination of a **Cozy setting** and a staff known for being attentive and courteous creates a dining experience that feels like coming home. Whether you are a local seeking your new favorite spot, a tourist looking for a genuine taste of Long Island, or simply someone who appreciates a great cocktail and a plate of ultra-fresh seafood, Schultzy's offers a truly top-notch experience that earns its stellar reputation.

Schultzy's Restaurant

265 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709, USA