Ship Wreck Tavern

- 10 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709

Introduction / Overview

For New York locals and visitors exploring the beauty of Long Island, Ship Wreck Tavern in Bayville offers a dining and nightlife experience that is as unique as its nautical name suggests. Functioning as a high-quality bar and grill, a welcoming local bar, and a dedicated seafood restaurant, this establishment, located right on Bayville Avenue, is a triple threat on the North Shore. It's a fantastic spot to escape the city bustle and enjoy a distinctly maritime atmosphere while overlooking the scenic Long Island Sound.

The atmosphere at Ship Wreck Tavern is best described as Casual, Cozy, and Trendy. It effortlessly attracts a diverse crowd, including large groups, solo diners, and, notably, a steady stream of tourists, all drawn to its picturesque location and vibrant setting. The reputation for delivering fast service ensures that even during peak hours, your dining experience remains efficient and pleasant. Beyond the food, the Tavern is a haven for cocktail and beer aficionados, boasting a Great Beer Selection and an impressive array of Great Cocktails, making it a premier spot for happy hour drinks and evening revelry.

The menu is designed to appeal to a wide range of tastes, expertly blending quintessential American Comfort Food with fresh, expertly prepared Seafood dishes. While you can find satisfying land fare like the Prime Dry Age Sirloin Steak and the signature Shipwreck Burger, the restaurant truly shines with its ocean-inspired selections. Starters like the Louisiana Style Fried Popcorn Shrimp and the rich Traditional Lobster Bisque set the stage for entrees that celebrate the bounty of the sea. The Tavern provides a full-service experience, catering to lunch, dinner, and brunch, with ample seating options available.

Location and Accessibility

Ship Wreck Tavern is ideally located at 10 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709, USA, placing it directly in a prime waterfront community on Long Island. This location in Nassau County is a major draw, especially for those seeking dining with a view and easy access to the Long Island Sound shorefront.

Accessibility is a priority for the establishment, ensuring a comfortable visit for all patrons. The tavern is fully Wheelchair Accessible, providing a seamless experience from arrival to seating. This includes:

• Wheelchair Accessible Entrance
• Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot (availability may vary)
• Wheelchair Accessible Restroom
• Wheelchair Accessible Seating

For visitors driving to the location, convenient Free Street Parking is available nearby, which is a welcome feature for a desirable waterfront location in the New York metropolitan area. Its strategic position makes it a perfect stop for Long Island day-trippers and local residents alike, blending a vacation feel with neighborhood accessibility.

Services Offered

• Dine-in: Full-service dining for Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert, with comfortable seating and table service.
• Outdoor Seating: Highly popular option, often featuring the renowned tiki bar and stunning water views, perfect for enjoying a Long Island summer evening.
• Takeout: Convenient service for those who wish to enjoy the menu at home or at a nearby beach.
• Reservations: The restaurant accepts reservations, highly recommended for securing a table during peak dining hours or for large groups.
• Bar Onsite: A fully stocked bar offering a wide variety of Alcohol, Beer, Cocktails, Hard liquor, and Wine.
• Happy Hour: Features special Happy Hour Drinks for guests looking to unwind after a long day.
• Family-Friendly Amenities: Good for kids with a dedicated Kids' menu and High Chairs available, accommodating families.
• Payment Options: Accepts major Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments.

Features / Highlights

• Signature Seafood Dishes: A core focus on fresh catches, including Maryland Jumbo Crab Cake, Atlantic Salmon, and the classic Traditional Fish And Chips.
• Unique Themed Ambiance: The maritime theme is a major draw, providing a fun and memorable dining backdrop that is particularly appealing to tourists and groups.
• Outdoor Tiki Bar Experience: The outdoor area, complete with a tiki bar, is a significant highlight, offering a lively and tropical-inspired atmosphere with refreshing cocktails.
• Robust Bar Offerings: Known for its extensive beverage menu, featuring a Great Beer Selection (including local and international brews) and expertly crafted Cocktails.
• Comfort and Steakhouse Classics: The menu successfully balances seafood with comforting land entrees such as Hanger Steak, Prime Dry Age Sirloin Steak, and the hearty Macaroni And Cheese.
• Diverse Appetizers and Soups: Starters like Crispy Coconut Shrimp and Jumbo Buffalo Chicken Wings are popular, as are the traditional soups: New England Style Clam Chowder and Traditional Lobster Bisque.
• Late-Night Food Service: Offers Food at Bar, catering to patrons who arrive later or prefer a casual dining experience at the bar.

What is Worth Choosing

When selecting a local New York dining spot that seamlessly blends a bar, grill, and seafood restaurant, Ship Wreck Tavern is a compelling choice, particularly for its unique coastal appeal. For those visiting or living on Long Island, the main reason to choose the Tavern is the complete experience: authentic comfort food and fresh seafood served in a highly atmospheric setting, often with stunning views. The Outdoor Seating is a highlight not to be missed, offering a picturesque backdrop to your meal or drinks.

On the menu, focusing on the highly rated bar and seafood selections is advisable. The Crispy Coconut Shrimp are a standout starter often praised by customers, and for a satisfying main, the Tilapia Oreganata or Traditional Fish And Chips are excellent choices that showcase the restaurant's seafood expertise. Land lovers will appreciate the quality of the Prime Dry Age Sirloin Steak or the inventive The Shipwreck Burger.

Beyond the food, the bar is a significant feature. The reputation for Great Cocktails and a Great Beer Selection makes it the perfect venue for socializing. Taking advantage of the Happy Hour Drinks is a great way to sample their offerings. The Tavern is also an ideal choice for a family outing due to its Casual atmosphere and specific amenities like the Kids' menu and High Chairs.

While some past customer feedback noted concerns about pricing transparency for seasonal items, it is important to choose from the clearly listed menu items, which offer competitive value for high-quality food in a prime waterfront location. The undeniable combination of prompt Fast Service, a friendly environment for Groups and Tourists, and a comprehensive menu ranging from seafood to steak, confirms Ship Wreck Tavern as a worthwhile and unique Long Island dining destination for any New Yorker.

Contact Information

Address: 10 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709, USA

Phone: (516) 628-2628

Mobile Phone: +1 516-628-2628

Ship Wreck Tavern

10 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709, USA