Seafood Story Brooklyn: Fresh, Mediterranean-Inspired Seafood in Sunset Park, NY

Seafood Story Introduce

Introduction / Overview

New York City's dining scene is a mosaic of global flavors, and for Brooklyn residents seeking an authentic, fresh, and deeply flavorful seafood experience, Seafood Story stands out as a true neighborhood gem. Located in the heart of Sunset Park, this restaurant is not your typical coastal crab shack; it offers a distinctive and welcoming approach to marine cuisine, heavily inspired by Mediterranean and possibly Egyptian culinary traditions, as noted by local reviewers. Patrons consistently praise the commitment to using incredibly fresh ingredients, with many commenting that they can "really taste the quality in every bite."

Seafood Story provides a comprehensive menu that spans from expertly prepared whole fish dishes to rich seafood pastas and unique appetizers. It has quickly become a highly recommended spot for those who appreciate authentic flavor and a cozy dining atmosphere. The restaurant’s interior is celebrated for its "beautiful ocean-inspired decor" and "boat-themed" design, which successfully creates the welcoming sensation of "dining by the sea"—a pleasant escape from the bustling streets of New York. The experience is enhanced by staff that are consistently described as "super kind and welcoming," ensuring excellent service for every table.

Whether you're craving a robust fish dish like oven-baked Red Snapper, a comforting bowl of Creamy Salmon Pasta, or one of their innovative seafood sandwiches, Seafood Story is positioned as a local favorite that provides great value for fresh, authentic seafood dishes in Brooklyn. It caters to a wide audience, offering options for every meal of the day, including Brunch, Lunch, and Dinner, alongside a specific Kids' Menu, cementing its status as a family-friendly establishment.

Location and Accessibility

Seafood Story is conveniently situated at 5717 5th Ave in the vibrant Sunset Park neighborhood of Brooklyn, NY 11220, USA. This highly trafficked section of 5th Avenue makes it easily reachable for New Yorkers utilizing public transportation or those living in the surrounding areas. The restaurant's presence in this dynamic area adds a unique and high-quality seafood option to the neighborhood’s diverse culinary offerings.

For all community members, the restaurant prioritizes accessibility. It proudly features a wheelchair accessible entrance, restroom, and even a wheelchair accessible parking lot—critical amenities that contribute to a welcoming environment for every patron. The central location in Brooklyn ensures that whether you're a local resident, a college student, or a visitor exploring the borough, accessing this seafood haven is hassle-free.

Services Offered

Seafood Story offers a wide array of services designed for maximum convenience and dining flexibility for the New York community:

Dine-in: Enjoy a full meal with table service and a cozy, ocean-themed ambiance.
Takeout: Quick and easy pickup options for those on the go.
Delivery & No-contact delivery: Full menu availability through delivery platforms, offering convenient service directly to homes and offices throughout the service area.
Reservations: The establishment accepts reservations, making it simple for patrons to plan ahead for dining, especially during peak dinner hours.
Catering: Available for events, offering a seamless way to bring their fresh seafood and unique flavors to your special occasion or corporate gathering.
Meal Service: Serving Brunch, Lunch, and Dinner, covering all major meal times.
Payment Methods: Accepts Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments for modern, secure transactions.

Features / Highlights

Seafood Story distinguishes itself with several key features and unique offerings that make it a standout choice for seafood lovers in New York:

Authentic Cuisine Focus: The menu offers Mediterranean-inspired seafood with clear influences from Egyptian cuisine (such as the mention of Sayadiyah Rice and Molokhia with Shrimp), providing flavors that are rare and authentic to find in this part of Brooklyn.
Fresh, Quality Seafood: Customer reviews consistently highlight the incredible freshness and high quality of the seafood, which is the foundation of their culinary "story."
Variety of Whole Fish Preparations: Offering Branzino, Red Snapper, Sea Bream Fish, and White Perch, customers can choose various cooking methods, including grilling, oven-baking with herbs, or the distinctive Singari style (mixed bell peppers, tomatoes, and spices).
Signature Dish: The "Soft Volcano (Salmon Special)"—a salmon fillet filled with a creamy shrimp blend and baked with a rich, velvety sauce—is noted as a must-try dish by many patrons.
Unique Sides: Offering authentic side dishes that go beyond the typical French fries, such as Sayadiyah Rice (a classic Egyptian rice dish often served with fish), Babaghanoush, Molokhia with Shrimp, and Garlic Eggplant.
Ambiance and Decor: The cozy, clean atmosphere and "ocean-inspired decor," including a painted floor that gives the sensation of "walking on water," create a memorable and immersive dining experience.
Family and Inclusive Environment: Features a dedicated Kids' Menu and is noted as a welcoming space for all patrons, including being family-friendly, LGBTQ+ friendly, and a transgender safespace.
Seafood Pasta Selection: An impressive array of pasta options, including Shrimp Scampi, Frutti di Mare, and the fan-favorite Creamy Salmon Pasta.

Contact Information

For New Yorkers planning a visit, reserving a table, or inquiring about catering, the contact information for Seafood Story is provided below:

Address: 5717 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220, USA
Phone: (718) 799-7110

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Seafood Story over other New York seafood restaurants is about prioritizing a unique combination of fresh quality, authentic flavor, and a welcoming, attentive dining experience. For the discerning Brooklyn diner, what makes this restaurant truly worth choosing is the ability to step away from the commonplace and into a culinary narrative focused on the Mediterranean Sea.

The emphasis on whole, fresh fish is a major factor. The ability to select your desired fish—be it Branzino or Red Snapper—and specify its preparation (grilled with a bran coating, Singari, or oven-baked) ensures a custom-tailored dish that highlights the fish's natural flavors. This level of customization and commitment to traditional cooking methods sets it apart from more generalized seafood establishments.

Beyond the main courses, the specialty appetizers and sides are compelling reasons to visit. Items like the Mussels Royale, Cheesy Mussels, or the often-praised Sayadiyah Rice offer rich, deep flavors that reflect the restaurant's culinary heritage. The presentation, such as the rice served in the shape of a fish, as noted by a reviewer, adds a thoughtful touch that enhances the "story" concept.

Finally, the value and atmosphere are undeniable draws. Customers repeatedly mention the "decently priced" menu for such high-quality, fresh seafood. When coupled with the "cozy and clean" environment and the genuinely "kind and welcoming" staff, Seafood Story transforms a simple meal into an excellent, memorable local dining experience—a true hidden jewel in the dynamic food landscape of Sunset Park. It is highly recommended for anyone in the New York area craving a truly fresh, flavorful, and unique seafood meal.

Seafood Story Menu

FISH DISHES
Branzino / Sea Bass $28.00
Whole fish, with a distinctive Mediterranean flavor, tender texture, and rich aroma. Cooking methods: Grilled with a bran coating for a rich flavor. Singari with mixed bell peppers, tomatoes, and spices. Oven-baked with lemon and herbs. Oven-cooked over a bed of potatoes, onions, and tomatoes.
Sea Bream Fish $32.00
Whole sea bream, firm yet tender, with a naturally sweet and clean marine flavor. Cooking methods: Grilled with a bran coating for a rustic flavor. Oven-baked with herbs and spices. Oven-cooked over a bed of potatoes, onions, and tomatoes.
Red Snapper $32.00
Whole red snapper with a strong flavor and a crisp texture, rich, vibrant color. Cooking methods: Fried with a strong flavor and a crisp texture. Oven-baked with herbs and spices.
White Perch $18.00
Whole fish, perfect for absorbing Mediterranean spices with a clean, light flavor. Cooking methods: Grilled with a bran coating for a rich flavor. Fried with a strong flavor and a crisp texture.
Fish & Chips $19.00
Golden fried cod fish fillet served with crispy seasoned fries, your choice of sauce and coleslaw - a classic with a bold Latin flavor. Choice of sauce: Tartar - Garlic - Mango - Spicy Aioli -Sweet Chili Sauce
The Soft Volcano (Salmon Special) $35.00
A tender salmon fillet, carefully opened and filled with a creamy shrimp blend. Baked to perfection with a rich, velvety sauce that flows like lava - soft, bold, unforgettable.

SEAFOOD SPECIALS
Seafood Boil
A delicious combination of seafood, includes ½ lb shrimp, ½ lb calamari, 6 mussels, 6 clams, corn, and potatoes-all marinated in rich bold spices. *Add Crab/lobster
Whole Crab or Lobster Tail
Fresh whole crab, oven-roasted and served open-style. Finished with your choice of garlic butter, cajun, or lemon-herb sauce. Served with roasted corn and baby potatoes.

APPETIZERS
Clams $15.00
Cooked with garlic, lemon and fresh herbs - the true taste of the sea in every bite.
Cheesy Mussels $15.00
Mussels baked with a rich mozzarella cheese blend stretchy, and full of sea flavor.
Crispy Fish Sticks $12.00
A tender fish cut - deep-fried to golden perfection. Crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside.
Shrimp Whisper $12.00
Lightly breaded, fried open shrimp - crispy.
Golden Circles $12.00
Golden-fried calamari rings served with a zesty dip.
Mozzarella Sticks $12.00
Crispy mozzarella sticks, golden-fried and served with warm marinara sauce.
Popcorn Shrimp $12.00
Crispy shrimp, golden-fried and perfect for dipping - a fun, flavorful seafood favorite.
Mussels Royale $18.00
Fresh mussels delicately filled with minced shrimp, butter, and fresh herbs, then oven-baked to perfection.

SIDES
Signature Rice $6.00
Spiced rice infused with caramelized onions and aromatic herbs.
Sayadiyah Rice $12.00
Golden spiced rice hiding crispy fish - a coastal secret in every bite.
Garden Salad $5.00
A crisp mix of lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, tossed in a zesty lemon vinaigrette.
Garlic Eggplant $6.00
A flavorful chapter from our Story - tender eggplant glazed in rich garlic and vinegar.
Babaghanoush $7.00
A smoky tale from our Story - creamy roasted eggplant blended with tahini, garlic, and lemon.
Mousaka $7.00
A classic tale of sliced eggplant and rich tomato sauce, from the heart of our Story.
Mixed Seafood Salad $7.00
A wonderful mix of shrimp, calamari, krab, corn, bell peppers, shredded carrots, dill, and pasta, with our special dressing.
Tahini $5.00
A smooth side from our Story - creamy sesame blend with a hint of lemon and garlic.
Seasoned Fries $6.00
A crispy bite from our Story - golden fries tossed in our special house seasoning.
Potato Salad $6.00
Potato cubes tossed with fresh herbs and garlic touch to your plate.

SALADS
Mixed Seafood Salad $16.00
A wonderful mix of shrimp, calamari, krab, corn, bell peppers, shredded carrots, dill, and pasta, with our special dressing.
Seafood Avocado Salad $16.00
A rich mix of shrimp, calamari, krab, lettuce, herbs, cherry tomatoes, cucumber cubes, with our signature avocado sauce.
Ensalada de Mariscos $16.00
A mixture of seafood, krab bell peppers, red and green onions, lettuce, olive oil, garlic, lemon, and parsley with an authentic Latin touch.
Tuna Salad $16.00
Tuna, lettuce, cherry tomatoes, olives, with a lemon dressing made from olive oil, salt, pepper, thyme, and lemon.

SOUPS
Seafood Cream Soup $9.00
A rich and velvety cream-based soup infused with the essence of the sea. Made with tender shrimp, calamari, mussels, krab, all simmered in a silky broth flavored with garlic, herbs.
Sea Soul Soup $9.00
A vibrant red broth, like the beating heart of the sea - rich with shrimp, calamari, mussels, and Cod.
Ocean Broth $7.00
A clear seafood broth infused with herbs, garlic, and vegetables - pure ocean essence in every spoonful.
Molokhia with Shrimp $7.00
A comforting Middle Eastern soup of molokhia leaves, garlic, and shrimp broth finished with tender shrimp and rich tradition.

SHRIMP DISHES
Butterfly Shrimp $12.00
Succulent butterfly shrimp kissed with lemon-garlic butter, grilled to golden perfection with our signature creamy sauce.
Grilled Shrimp $12.00
Succulent shrimp, expertly grilled and glazed with a sweet-savory blend of soy sauce and rich pomegranate molasses.
Fried Shrimp $12.00
Golden whole shrimp, fried to perfection for an irresistible crunch. Served with our exclusive mango sauce.
Shrimp Vegetables $24.00
With sliced tomatoes, onions, and bell peppers in a rich tomato sauce - choose your spice level.
Tempura Shrimp $12.00
Golden tempura shrimp, served with our signature mango sauce. Every bite tells a story of crisp perfection and tropical sweetness.
Dynamite Shrimp $12.00
Crispy golden shrimp coated in our seasoned breadcrumb blend, then tossed in a bold, spicy dynamite sauce - made for flavor lovers who like it hot.
Creamy Spinach Shrimp $27.00
Shrimp sautéed with garlic in a rich, creamy sauce, blended with fresh spinach. A savory and comforting dish with bold, balanced flavors.
Pineapple Shrimp $32.00
Shrimp sautéed with pineapple, red bell pepper, garlic, onion, and a hint of curry - sweet, spicy, and full of tropical herb flavor.

SEAFOOD PASTA
Shrimp Scampi $22.00
Succulent shrimp sautéed in garlic-infused butter, finished with fresh lemon juice- bold, zesty, and unforgettable served over a bed of linguine.
Seafood Pesto Pasta $24.00
A savory blend of shrimp, calamari, and mussels sautéed to perfection, tossed with linguine in a creamy basil pesto sauce. Finished with grated parmesan - a fragrant, flavorful seafood delight.
Frutti di Mare $25.00
An authentic Italian seafood pasta featuring a flavorful medley of shrimp, calamari, mussels, and clams, simmered in a light garlic-tomato sauce. Served over perfectly cooked linguine - a rustic, coastal classic from the heart of the Mediterranean.
Creamy Salmon Pasta $24.00
Tender chunks of salmon gently tossed in a velvety garlic cream sauce with shallots, lemon zest, and a hint of fresh herbs. Finished with parmesan and served with your choice of linguine or penne.
Shrimp Tuscan Pasta $24.00
Succulent shrimp simmered in a creamy garlic-parmesan sauce with sun-dried tomatoes and fresh spinach. Served over your choice of fettuccine or penne - a rich and comforting taste of Tuscany.
Spicy Shrimp Arrabbiata $25.00
Juicy shrimp sautéed with garlic and chili flakes in a bold Arrabbiata sauce made from crushed tomatoes and fresh herbs. Served over linguine for a fiery, flavor-packed Italian experience.

CALAMARI DISHES
Tajine - Seafood Story Style $18.00
Tender calamari slow-cooked in a rich tomato-based sauce, blended with colorful bell peppers, sweet onions, aromatic herbs, and a mix of our secret spices. Served bubbling hot - a bold Mediterranean twist in every bite.
Tajine in White Cream Sauce $22.00
Calamari cooked in a creamy white sauce made from fresh cooking cream and colorful bell peppers, topped with mozzarella cheese for a rich, golden finish. Just pure creamy indulgence.
Fried Calamari Rings $19.00
Crispy golden rings of calamari, lightly breaded and fried to perfection. Served with a side of our signature mango dipping sauce or zesty garlic aioli.
Calamari Fajita $24.00
Grilled calamari strips marinated in lime, garlic, and Seafood Story spices, sautéed with bell peppers and onions over high flame. A smoky, zesty twist on the classic fajita - straight from the sea.
Magic Stuffed Calamari $27.00
Whole calamari, scored and stuffed with a magical mix of garlic, parsley, and chili, then grilled in butter for a rich, juicy bite with bold Mediterranean flavor.

SEAFOOD SANDWICHES
Seafood Burger $16.00
A juicy seafood patty made from shrimp and fish, grilled to perfection and served on a toasted bun with our signature sauce, fresh lettuce, and tangy pickles. A bold twist on a classic favorite.
Fried Fish Sandwich $14.00
Crispy fried fish fillet served in a soft hero with lettuce, pickles, and classic tartar sauce. Simple, satisfying, and full of flavor from the sea.
Fried Calamari Sandwich $14.00
Crispy golden calamari piled into a soft hero, topped with lettuce, pickled onions, and our zesty house-made sauce. A crunchy, savory bite from the sea - bold and unforgettable.
Grilled Fish Sandwich $14.00
Tender grilled fish fillet served in a soft hero with fresh lettuce, pickles, and lemon-garlic sauce. Light, flavorful, and straight from the sea - a healthier twist on a classic.
Fried Shrimp Sandwich $14.00
Crispy fried shrimp served in a soft hero with fresh lettuce, pickles, and classic tartar sauce. A crunchy seafood favorite - simple, bold, and satisfying.
Dynamite Shrimp Sandwich $14.00
Crispy golden shrimp tossed in our spicy dynamite sauce, layered in a soft bun with shredded lettuce and a touch of pickled onions. A bold explosion of flavor - creamy, spicy, and irresistibly crunchy.
Mixed Seafood Fajita Sandwich $15.00
Shrimp, calamari & fish sautéed with peppers and onions in bold fajita spices - served in a soft roll with tartar or spicy mayo. A smoky, juicy fusion of land and sea.
Garlic Shrimp sandwich $14.00
Juicy grilled shrimp sautéed with garlic and olive oil, served in a soft hero roll with fresh lettuce and a hint of lemon. A bold, aromatic sandwich bursting with flavor - simple, clean, and unforgettable.

DRINKS
Lemon Mint Breeze $7.00
Fresh lemon juice blended with mint - crisp, cool, and unforgettable.
Iced Hibiscus Bliss $5.00
Chilled hibiscus tea - floral, refreshing, and beautifully balanced.
Crimson Sunset $7.00
Sweet, tangy, and deeply refreshing - a true taste of the Middle East.
Iced Coffee $4.00
Chilled coffee - refreshing and energizing
Hot Coffee $4.00
Because some stories are best told over hot coffee.
Tea $3.00
Classic Black Tea or Black Tea with Mint or Green Tea
Soda / water $2.00

KIDS MENU
Little Sailor Pasta $10.00
Pasta tossed in a light tomato or butter sauce with shrimp - choose your favorite!
Fish sticks $10.00
Crispy fish sticks served with golden fries.
Popcorn Shrimp at Sea $10.00
Crispy shrimp bites served with our signature mango dipping sauce and golden fries - a magical ocean breeze in every bite!

Seafood Story Details

Service options
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom

Dining options
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Restroom
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Crowd
Family-friendly
LGBTQ+ friendly
Transgender safespace

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Kids' menu

Seafood Story Photos

Seafood Story Location

Seafood Story

New York Kings County Sunset Park 5th Avenue

5717 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220, USA

Seafood Story Reviews

An average rating of ★4.7 from 62 user reviews.

riceseasonedgrilledhibiscus drinkdecorseafood soupwalkingfried fish

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Beautiful little seafood spot with delicious fare. Butterfly shrimp was grilled perfectly with just the right amount of char, smoky flavor. The pasta was incredible and the rice came out in the shape of a fish.. peak ambiance!Highly recommend this place for decently priced, fresh seafood dishes :)
September 25 · Ahmed Hussain
I had the pleasure of visiting this new seafood spot and I was seriously impressed!The food was incredibly fresh and full of flavor you can really taste the quality in every bite.The atmosphere is cozy and clean, with beautiful ocean-inspired decor that makes you feel like you’re dining by the sea.The staff were super kind and welcoming, and the service was quick and friendly.Definitely a place I’ll be coming back to highly recommended for anyone who loves good seafood and great vibes! 🐟💙
June 21 · Hoda Magdy
Definitely one of the best seafood restaurants I've tried in Brooklyn!! Super cute and thoughtful interior design, GREAT food (tastes homemade) and PERFECT flavor, not too salty not too sweet. Will come back many times!
July 12 · Kim Yuan Xu
DELICIOUS FOOD!!! I was walking around the area and notice this nice gentleman named Aldo in front of the restaurant inviting people to come in, he got me with the lunch special a great portion for what’s included — fried fish, a beautiful masterpiece of rice and a good portion of salad on the side as well as a good freshing Hibiscus water! Great prices! Had to come back again and have my partner try some as well! Amazing and friendly service!
September 06 · Zaida Garcia
One of the best seafood restaurants I’ve ever visited — the food very delicious and the sauces were full of flavor. The staff were welcoming and the atmosphere felt fresh and authentic. Highly recommended for seafood lovers!”
June 22 · Im Mo