Stephanie's Italian Restaurant Introduce
For decades, **Stephanie's Italian Restaurant** has been a beloved staple of the dining landscape in Caldwell, New Jersey, offering a taste of the old country right on Bloomfield Avenue. More than just a local eatery, Stephanie's is a full-service **Italian restaurant** and a cherished gathering place where authentic cuisine meets a warm, welcoming atmosphere. It is renowned across Essex County for delivering hearty portions of traditional and expertly crafted Italian fare, making it a highly **Popular for Lunch** and a perfect destination for a satisfying **Dinner**.
The restaurant strikes a perfect balance in ambiance, managing to be both **Casual** and **Cozy**, with a definite leaning toward the **Romantic** feel that makes it an excellent choice for a date night or a special celebration. The commitment to quality is evident not only in the food but also in the service, which is frequently highlighted by patrons for its **Fast service** and attentive staff. Whether you are looking for classic **Comfort food** to enjoy solo or a lovely setting for **Groups** and a **Family-friendly** meal, Stephanie's Italian Restaurant provides a genuine, memorable New Jersey Italian dining experience.
Stephanie's Italian Restaurant is conveniently situated at **283 Bloomfield Ave, Caldwell, NJ 07006, USA**. This address places the restaurant squarely in a high-visibility, accessible part of Caldwell, making it easy to find for both locals and those traveling from nearby towns. Its location on Bloomfield Avenue—a central artery in the area—ensures that it remains a focal point for fine, authentic dining in the community.
The restaurant has taken comprehensive measures to ensure broad accessibility for all patrons. Parking is made easy with options for both a **Free parking lot** and **Free street parking** available, a significant benefit in a busy commercial area. Furthermore, Stephanie's is equipped with full accommodations for guests with mobility needs, offering a **Wheelchair accessible entrance**, **Wheelchair accessible parking lot**, **Wheelchair accessible restroom**, and **Wheelchair accessible seating**. This commitment to comfort and ease of access ensures that all guests can enjoy the authentic Italian experience without hassle.
Stephanie's Italian Restaurant provides a wide array of services designed to meet diverse customer needs, from a quick meal to a large celebration:
- **Dining Options:** The venue offers flexible **Dine-in** options, with **Seating** available for both lunch and dinner, including classic **Table service**.
- **Reservations:** Due to its popularity, **Dinner reservations are recommended**, and the restaurant **Accepts reservations** to help plan your visit.
- **Carry-out Convenience:** For those who prefer to eat at home, **Takeout** and **Delivery** services are available, alongside a **No-contact delivery** option.
- **Special Occasions:** The restaurant offers comprehensive **Catering** services, making it an excellent choice for hosting private events and parties.
- **Beverage Service:** The menu includes offerings of **Coffee** and a selection of **Alcohol** and **Wine**, but a major highlight is its celebrated **BYOB policy** which allows guests to bring their preferred wine or beverages to complement their meal.
- **Family Amenities:** To accommodate younger diners, **High chairs** are provided, underscoring its family-friendly environment.
- **On-site Comforts:** Guests can benefit from practical amenities, including a clean **Restroom** and available **Wi-Fi**.
The menu at Stephanie's Italian Restaurant is a deep exploration of authentic Italian cooking, with several standout features that set it apart in the North Jersey dining scene:
- **Signature Pasta Dishes:** The menu features an extensive selection of pasta, including notable house specialties. These include the signature **LINGUINI STEPHANIE** (pasta with spinach and shrimp in a fresh tomato sauce), the rich **LOBSTER RAVIOLI** topped with vodka sauce, and the unique **FIOCCHI** (pasta pouches filled with pear and cheese in a white wine and shallots sauce).
- **Expansive Entree Selection:** The Dinner Entrees offer a wide range of options beyond just pasta, featuring classic Italian-American favorites and regional specialties. Highlights include **CHICKEN FRANCESE**, **CHICKEN SALTIMBOCCA** (topped with prosciutto and provolone), various parmigiana selections (Chicken, Shrimp, Eggplant), and substantial cuts like the **VEAL CHOP MILENESE W/SHAVED PARM**.
- **Fresh Seafood and Veal:** Seafood lovers are well-catered for with dishes such as **SHRIMP STEPHANIE** (shrimp sautéed with artichokes hearts, sun-dried tomatoes, and shiitake mushrooms), **ZUPPO DI PESCE MARCHIARO OVER PASTA**, and the fresh **FLOUNDER OREGANATA**. Veal is treated with respect, notably in the large **Veal Chop Parmigiana**.
- **Salad Variety:** The menu offers sophisticated, fresh salads, including **FENNEL SALAD**, **ARUGALA & TOMATO SALAD**, and **STRINGBEAN SALAD**, which serve as a great counterpoint to the rich entrees and are perfect for a lighter **Healthy option**.
- **Exceptional Desserts and Coffee:** Patrons consistently rave about the menu's offering, specifically mentioning **Great dessert** options, with Tiramisu often being a crowd favorite, paired perfectly with their **Great coffee**.
- **Generous Portions and Value:** Customer reviews frequently point out that the **portions are large** and the ability to order appetizers **family style** adds tremendous value for groups.
Connecting with Stephanie's Italian Restaurant for reservations, takeout, or catering is simple. The essential contact details are:
- **Address:** 283 Bloomfield Ave, Caldwell, NJ 07006, USA
- **Primary Phone:** (973) 226-2142
- **Mobile Phone (for service/ordering):** +1 973-226-2142
- **Hours:** They are typically open Tuesday through Saturday, serving lunch and dinner. Tuesdays through Fridays from 11:00 am to 9:00 pm, and Saturdays from 11:00 am to 10:00 pm. The restaurant is closed on Sundays and Mondays. Customers should always call ahead to confirm holiday or seasonal hours.
For residents of New Jersey, choosing Stephanie's Italian Restaurant is about opting for a truly authentic and high-quality local dining experience. The primary reason it is so highly recommended is the potent combination of **authentic Italian food** prepared with care and the restaurant’s unique features. The celebrated **BYOB policy** is a massive draw, allowing diners to bring their personal favorite bottles of wine to enjoy with their meal, significantly enhancing a date night or group dinner while keeping the experience more affordable.
Beyond the flexibility of the BYOB policy, the culinary offerings speak for themselves. The **large portions** ensure no one leaves hungry, and the diverse menu—from house-named signature pasta dishes like the **LINGUINI STEPHANIE** to the impressive **Veal Chop Parmigiana**—guarantees a delicious choice for every palate. The fact that the restaurant can deliver on multiple vibes, being described as perfect for **date night, family night, or a night with your friends**, underscores its versatility and consistent appeal. The service, while occasionally noted as being a little rushed when busy, is overall **attentive** and **great**, with a consistently **welcoming hostess** that makes every visitor feel at home. When you want a meal that offers genuine Italian flavor, a cozy environment, and the value of a BYOB spot in Essex County, Stephanie's Italian Restaurant is the definitive choice.
Stephanie's Italian Restaurant Vibe
Dinner - Pasta
- FETTUCINI CALABRESE $27.99
Pasta with jumbo shrimp, shiitake mushrooms, sun dried tomatoes in a light creamy pesto sauce
- PENNE BARESI $23.99
Penne pasta with broccoli rabe and sausage in a light garlic and oil
- CAPPELINI VENTIMIGLIA $22.99
Pasta with a light marinara sauce made with artichoke hearts, prosciutto and sliced olives
- FUSSILI BOLOGNESE $24.99
Home made spiral pasta with meat sauce and a touch of cream
- FUSSILI BARESI $24.99
Home made spiral pasta with broccoli rabe and sausage in a light garlic and oil
- CHEESE RAVIOLI $20.99
Cheese filled pasta in marinara sauce
- RIGATONI SICILIANO $22.99
Pasta with eggplant , mozzarella and tomato sauce
- CAPPELINI PRIMAVERA $22.99
Pasta with carrots, broccoli, zucchini and peas with light pink cream sauce
- PASTA MARINARA $18.99
Pasta in our homemade marinara sauce
- TORTELINI BOLOGNESE $24.99
Cheese filled tortellini in a creamy meat sauce
- LINGUINI STEPHANIE $27.99
Pasta with spinach and shrimp in a fresh tomato sauce
- BAKED PENNE $20.99
Pasta in our marinara sauce baked with mozzarella
- GNOCCHI ROMANO $22.99
Potato Dumplings with prosciutto, peas, mushrooms in a light pink cream sauce
- FIOCCHI $24.99
Pasta pouches filled with pear and cheese in a white wine and shallots sauce
- RIGATONI VODKA $22.99
Rigatoni with herbs in a light pink vodka sauce
- PENNE VODKA $22.99
Penne with herbs in a light pink vodka sauce
- CAVATELLI SORRENTINO $23.99
Pasta with fresh mozzarella in a fresh tomato sauce
- LOBSTER RAVIOLI $24.99
Lobster filled pasta topped with vodka sauce
- FETTUCINI ALFREDO $24.99
Pasta in a creamy alfredo sauce
- SPAGHETTI CARBONARA CON GAMBERI $27.99
Pasta with peas, pancetta, shrimp, onions in a creamy Alfredo sauce
- LASAGNA W/ MEATBALLS $24.99
Homemade with cheese, ricotta and a marinara sauce W 2 Meatballs
- CAPPELLINI POMODORO $22.99
Pasta with fresh tomato, onion and basil
Dinner - Salads
- STRINGBEAN SALAD $14.99
String beans tossed with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, red onions and black olives in a balsamic vinaigrette dressing
- MESCALIN SALAD $13.99
Baby greens tossed with carrots, red onions, tomatoes and our homemade dressing
- Spinach Salad $14.99
Spinach tossed with tomatoes, black olives and our homemade creamy Gorgonzola dressing
- FENNEL SALAD $14.99
Fennel tossed with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, red onions, arugula and black olives in a white balsamic vinaigrette
- ARUGALA & TOMATO SALAD $13.99
Arugula tossed with tomatoes and our homemade dressing
- TRI COLOR SALAD $14.99
Arugula, endive and radicchio tossed with tomatoes and our home made dressing
- TOMATO & ONION SALAD $14.99
Tomatoes and red onions tossed with black olives and fresh mozzarella with a white balsamic vinaigrette dressing
- CAESAR SALAD $14.99
Romaine lettuce tossed with croutons, grated cheese and our homemade creamy Caesar dressing
NEW YEARS EVE MENU
- CHICKEN MILANESE W SHAVED PARM $25.99
Breaded chicken cutlet with arugula, radicchio, endive, diced tomatoes and shaved parmigiana cheese
- BLACKENED SALMON $27.99
Served over broccoli rabe
.
- CHICKEN CALABRESE $25.99
Chicken scaloppini topped with asparagus, roasted red peppers, and provolone cheese in a light lemon vermouth sauce
- CHICKEN MILANESE W SHAVED PARM $25.99
Breaded chicken cutlet with arugula, radicchio, endive, diced tomatoes and shaved parmigiana cheese
- CHICKEN PICCATTA $26.99
Chicken scaloppini in a lemon, wine and butter sauce with capers
- CHICKEN SORRENTINO $27.99
Chicken scaloppini topped with prosciutto, eggplant, sliced tomato, provolone cheese in a light brown sauce
- CHICKEN GIAMBOTTA $25.99
Chicken sautéed with peppers, onions, mushrooms, sausage, and potatoes in a light demi glaze sauce
- SALMON GRILLED $27.99
Grilled salmon served on a bed of broccoli rabe
- CHICKEN TRE FUNGHI $27.99
chicken scaloppini with assorted mushrooms in a marsala wine demi glaze with a touch of cream
- CHICKEN MARSALA $26.99
Chicken scaloppini with mushrooms in a marsala sauce
Dinner - Entrees
- CHICKEN SORRENTINO $27.99
Chicken scaloppini topped with prosciutto, eggplant, sliced tomato, provolone cheese in a light brown sauce
- SCALLOPS TRE FUNGHI $35.99
Scallops sautéed with three mushrooms in light marsala cream sauce
- CHICKEN SALTIMBOCCA $27.99
Chicken scaloppini topped with prosciutto and provolone, served over a bed of spinach in a demi glaze sauce
- CHICKEN GIAMBOTTA $25.99
Chicken sautéed with peppers, onions, mushrooms, sausage, and potatoes in a light demi glaze sauce
- CHICKEN CALABRESE $25.99
Chicken scaloppini topped with asparagus, roasted red peppers, and provolone cheese in a light lemon vermouth sauce
- CHICKEN MARSALA $26.99
Chicken scaloppini with mushrooms in a marsala sauce
- Shrimp Parmigiana $27.99
Breaded shrimp in a light tomato sauce, topped with melted mozzarella
- CHICKEN SAVOY $27.99
Chicken scaloppini with garlic, wine and balsamic vinegar
- SALMON OREGANTA $29.99
Salmon topped with bread crumbs and seasonings in a lemon, wine and butter sauce served over a bed of spinach W/2 Shrimp
- Eggplant Parmigiana $24.99
Breaded eggplant in a light tomato sauce, topped with melted mozzarella
- VEAL CHOP MILENESE W/SHAVED PARM $36.99
Breaded Veal Chop topped with arugula, radicchio, endive, diced tomatoes and shaved parmigiana cheese
- SHRIMP STEPHANIE $27.99
Shrimp sautéed with artichokes hearts, sun dried tomatoes and shiitake mushrooms in a lemon wine sauce
- FLOUNDER OREGANATA $28.99
Flounder topped with bread crumbs and seasonings in a lemon, wine and butter sauce served over a bed of spinach W /2 Shrimp
- Veal Chop Parmigiana $36.99
Breaded veal chop in a light tomato sauce, topped with melted mozzarella
- CHICKEN PAILLARD $25.99
Grilled chicken topped with sautéed sweet peppers and mushrooms
- BLACKENED SALMON $27.99
Served over broccoli rabe
- CHICKEN TRE FUNGHI $27.99
chicken scaloppini with assorted mushrooms in a marsala wine demi glaze with a touch of cream
- SHRIMP FRANCES $28.99
Egg dipped shrimp in a lemon, wine, butter sauce over a bed of spinach
- FLOUNDER FRANCES $27.99
Egg dipped flounder in a lemon, wine and butter sauce over a bed of spinach
- Chicken Parmigiana $25.99
Breaded chicken cutlet in a light tomato sauce, topped with melted mozzarella
- CHICKEN & SHRIMP FRANCES $27.99
Egg dipped shrimp and chicken in a lemon, wine and butter sauce over a bed of spinach
- CHICKEN FRANCESE $26.99
Egg dipped chicken in a lemon, wine and butter sauce over a bed of spinach
- EGGPLANT ROLLATINI $24.99
Sliced eggplant filled with ricotta cheese in a light tomato sauce, topped with mozzarella
- ZUPPO DI PESCE MARCHIARO OVER PASTA $38.99
Clams, mussels, shrimp, scallops, calamari and flounder served in a light marinara sauce over pasta
- SALMON GRILLED $27.99
Grilled salmon served on a bed of broccoli rabe
- CHICKEN PICCATTA $26.99
Chicken scaloppini in a lemon, wine and butter sauce with capers
- CHICKEN MILANESE W SHAVED PARM $25.99
Breaded chicken cutlet with arugula, radicchio, endive, diced tomatoes and shaved parmigiana cheese
- Calamari Marinara Over Cappellini $27.99
Calamari sautéed with onions, herbs and wine in a light tomato sauce over capellini
Stephanie's Italian Restaurant Details
Service options
- Outdoor seating
- No-contact delivery
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Highlights
- Fast service
- Great coffee
- Great dessert
- Serves local specialty
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Wheelchair accessible seating
Offerings
- Alcohol
- Coffee
- Comfort food
- Healthy options
- Wine
Dining options
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Catering
- Dessert
- Seating
- Table service
Amenities
- Restroom
- Wi-Fi
- Wi-Fi
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cozy
- Romantic
Crowd
- Family-friendly
- Groups
Planning
- Dinner reservations recommended
- Accepts reservations
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- Credit cards
Children
- High chairs
Parking
- Free parking lot
- Free street parking
- Parking
Stephanie's Italian Restaurant Photos










Stephanie's Italian Restaurant Location
Stephanie's Italian Restaurant
283 Bloomfield Ave, Caldwell, NJ 07006, USA
Stephanie's Italian Restaurant Reviews
pricesfood and servicediningappetizerchicken parmBYOBscallopsvodka saucevealparking
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1I have not been to Stephanie's since about 2008. This Friday night I went with my buddies. All around, great food, great service , great desserts. Byob.The Italian food was true authentic Italian food. We had lots of appetizers, and all were delicious. You can order the appetizers' family style, so we did. There was not one thing bad about this restaurant. We had 9 people.This restaurant is perfect for date night, family night , or a night with your friends. FABULOUS!
March 28 · David G.we enjoyed our meal and the service was attentive. the hostess was welcoming and the restaurant is quaint.the food is very good and portions are large.the 4 stars because i requested to swap spaghetti for penne but the chef must have refused. and the courses were rushed, dinner served while still enjoying the appetizer. the restaurant was not busythe desserts were fantastic
February 23 · D MagnusWe dined outside which is decorated beautifully. Staff is wonderful. The food is fabulous.. we shared the arugula salad special, I had the lobster raviolis, my friend had scallop and crab stuffing special, I finished with the berries w/ cream.. make reservations! BYOB..
July 03 · Chrystia WorochDelicious. I had the flounder and my wife had salmon. Good service and atmosphere.
July 26 · Tom CraneOverall, the food was very good BUT staff were unfriendly. Also, my pasta in the white wine clam sauce was undercooked and some strands were just hard and brittle. Clams were not fresh. Not sure if I’ll go back.
August 07 · Gin B
More restaurants near me
Belgiovine's Italian Deli4.0 (370 reviews)714 Bloomfield Ave, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA
Toast Montclair4.0 (1711 reviews)700 Bloomfield Ave, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA
The Splendid Rooftop3.0 (422 reviews)690 Bloomfield Ave, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA
Allegory Restaurant and Bar3.0 (103 reviews)690 Bloomfield Ave, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA
Sayola Restaurant4.0 (300 reviews)38 Valley Rd, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA
Let's Yo! Montclair4.0 (627 reviews)31 Valley Rd, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA
Beyond Pita4.0 (476 reviews)82 Church St A, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA
Laboratorio Kitchen4.0 (608 reviews)615 Bloomfield Ave, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA
Charm Thai Cuisine4.0 (352 reviews)600 Bloomfield Ave, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA
La Rocca Osteria4.0 (320 reviews)21 Midland Ave, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA
Antika Grill4.0 (814 reviews)578 Bloomfield Ave, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA
Lu Nello4.0 (673 reviews)182 Stevens Ave, Cedar Grove, NJ 07009, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Mamoun's Falafel4.0 (1852 reviews)
P.J. Finnegan's4.0 (394 reviews)
Za Late Night Pizzeria3.0 (205 reviews)
Empanada Mama LES4.0 (2938 reviews)
Jumong Karaoke3.0 (18 reviews)
NBB Coffee, Protein and Smoothie Co5.0 (83 reviews)Top restaurants Searches
Trending Dining Insights Posts
The Growing Popularity of Acai Bowls and Smoothie Cafes
Discovering Brunch Restaurants That Highlight Local Ingredients in Creative Dishes | Dine Droop
How Ice Cream Shops Are Partnering With Local Farmers to Source Fresh Ingredients
How Wine Bars Are Hosting Tastings to Introduce New Varieties
Discovering American Restaurants That Incorporate Seasonal Local Ingredients
How Wine Bars Are Becoming Popular for Casual and Professional Meetings
