Sweets By SHAY.: Your Destination for Handcrafted Desserts in Brooklyn, NY

Sweets By SHAY. Introduce

In the heart of Brooklyn's vibrant community, Sweets By SHAY. stands out as a dedicated bakery that brings a touch of artistry and passion to every dessert they create. This Black and women-owned business has built a reputation for crafting beautiful, from-scratch treats that are as delightful to the eyes as they are to the palate. From custom cakes to a variety of chocolate-covered delights, Sweets By SHAY. is the go-to spot for special occasions, gifts, or a personal indulgence in the New York region.

The ethos of this bakery is simple: everything is made with care and a commitment to deliciousness. This is a place where you can find handcrafted desserts that feel personal and unique. Whether you’re celebrating a milestone with a grand cake or simply want to brighten someone's day with a box of chocolate-covered strawberries, the quality and attention to detail are evident. Customers consistently praise the taste and beautiful presentation, making it a reliable choice for those who value both flavor and aesthetics in their desserts.

As a local business, Sweets By SHAY. adds a special flavor to the neighborhood. The fact that it is an LGBTQ+ friendly establishment further contributes to the inclusive and welcoming spirit of Brooklyn. This introduction provides a glimpse into what makes this bakery so special. As we explore further, we will detail its location, the services it offers, and the standout features that make it a compelling choice for any dessert lover in New York.

---

Location and Accessibility

Sweets By SHAY. is located at 146 Jefferson Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216. This address places the bakery in a residential and accessible part of Brooklyn, making it convenient for local customers to visit for a quick pickup or to place an order.

While the bakery may operate by appointment, which is noted in its planning information, it is well-suited for a quick visit for those who have pre-ordered their treats. The emphasis on custom orders and appointments allows the team to dedicate their full attention to each creation, ensuring the highest quality.

The bakery offers several convenient service options to meet the needs of its clientele. Customers can utilize curbside pickup for a seamless, on-the-go experience. Additionally, takeout is available for those who prefer to pick up their orders in person. A key service is delivery, which ensures that their beautiful cakes and treats can reach customers' homes and event venues without hassle, perfect for celebrations or last-minute surprises. For payments, the bakery accepts NFC mobile payments, providing a modern and efficient transaction method.

---

Services Offered

Bakery: At its core, Sweets By SHAY. is a full-service bakery specializing in a range of handcrafted desserts. Their menu includes both elaborate custom cakes and a variety of smaller treats, all made from scratch.
Custom Cakes: A major offering is their custom cakes, which include impressive creations like the Dramatic Drip Cakes, Rockin' Rosette Cake, and Marvelous Marble Cake. These are perfect for birthdays, weddings, or any significant celebration where a beautifully designed cake is needed.
Variety of Treats: The menu extends beyond cakes to include a wide selection of treats. These are ideal for party favors, dessert tables, or as a simple sweet gift. Options include Chocolate Covered Strawberries, Glitter Strawberries, Cake Pops, Chocolate Covered Oreo, and more.
Delivery and Pickup: The bakery provides convenient service options to make getting your treats as easy as possible. Customers can opt for curbside pickup or takeout, or have their order delivered directly to them, which is perfect for larger orders or for those who can't make it to the location.

---

Features and Highlights

Black and Women-Owned Business: Sweets By SHAY. proudly identifies as a Black and women-owned business. Supporting this bakery means you are not only getting a high-quality product but also contributing to the success of a local, minority-owned enterprise in the community.
Made From Scratch: The food is described by customers as "made from scratch," which speaks to the quality and care put into every item. This commitment to fresh, homemade ingredients is a significant factor in the delicious taste of their desserts.
Beautiful and Delicious Decorations: While some feedback on the safety of certain decorative items has been noted, customers consistently praise the beauty and taste of the decorations. The high level of artistry and attention to detail in their designs, as mentioned by a reviewer, is a key highlight that sets them apart from other bakeries.
Wide Variety of Offerings: The bakery's menu is diverse, offering not just cakes but also an array of smaller, handheld treats. This variety makes it a versatile choice for any event, whether you need a centerpiece cake or a selection of smaller desserts.
LGBTQ+ Friendly: The business proudly identifies as LGBTQ+ friendly, creating a welcoming and inclusive environment for all customers. This focus on community and acceptance is an important feature of the business's identity.

---

Contact Information

To place an order or inquire about a custom creation, you can contact Sweets By SHAY. directly.

Address: 146 Jefferson Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216
Phone: (929) 269-5087

---

What is worth choosing

When you choose Sweets By SHAY., you are choosing a bakery that is deeply committed to both flavor and aesthetics. What is truly worth choosing here is the promise of a dessert that is not only delicious but also a work of art. The handcrafted nature of their products, from the "made from scratch" taste to the beautiful decorations, is the main reason to give them a try.

The desserts, particularly the chocolate-covered strawberries and the custom cakes, are highly praised for their taste and presentation. For a special occasion, the beautifully designed cakes, such as the Dramatic Drip Cakes, offer a spectacular centerpiece. For a more casual treat or a gift, the chocolate-covered strawberries are a fan favorite, consistently described as delicious and beautiful.

It is important for customers to be mindful of the business's operational style, which includes the requirement for appointments and the potential for specific service hours, as noted in a review. However, the consistent praise for the quality of their key products—the cakes and chocolate-covered treats—shows that when you work with them, the result is a truly satisfying and delicious dessert. You're supporting a local, Black and women-owned business that pours its heart into every creation, and that is a choice that feels good on all levels.

Sweets By SHAY. Food & drink

Cakes
Dramatic Drip Cakes $100.00
This cake is PERFECT for any event. If you are looking for something more elegant and simple this is your go-to! Jazz it up with a customer topper or even with some roses for extra effect. Choose your base color and your drip color.
Rockin' Rosette Cake $120.00
This cake SCREAMMMSS classy and elegant. Perfect for any loved one. Choose between your rosette color and add toppers or even some infusers to spice it up!
Marvelous Marble Cake $150.00
This cake is perfect for our marble LOVERS! Choose any colors to be marbled! Top if off with a custom topper or even some infused berries ! This cake comes with EDIBLE 24K gold to give it that elegance! With this cake you'll definitely feel like A BOSS !
Red Velvet Cheesecake $65.00
THIS CAKE ONLY COMES IN A 7IN ROUND! 2 Decadent red velvet layers with our creamy cheesecake layer in between! This cake has a cream cheese frosting and some cake crumbs to top it off! this cake can also be topped with nuts if requested.
Strawberry Shortcake Cheesecake $65.00
THIS CAKE ONLY COMES IN A 7IN ROUND! Enjoy every sweet bite of 2 layers of our infamous soft vanilla sponge cake and a sweet creamy cheesecake layer, DONT FORGET OUR STRAWBERRY FILLING ,(with real strawberries) that literally tops it all off ! Coated with our nostalgic strawberry shortcake crunch.

Treats
Chocolate Covered Strawberries $45.00
includes 12 berries. choose between milk or white chocolate. Add infusions or an edible inscription
Glitter Strawberries $50.00
12 BERRIES . CHOICE OF GLITTER/ ADD INFUSIONS OR AN EDIBLE INSCIPRITON
Cake Pops $40.00
12 in total. your choice of sweet cake and our original vanilla buttercream coated in a colored white chocolate. PERFECT ADDITION FOR ANY TREAT TABLE.
Chocolate Covered Oreo $40.00
includes 12 oreos. Dipped in your choice of milk or white chocolate.
chocolate covered Marshmallow $40.00
Includes 12 XL JUMBO marshmallows. Dipped in your choice of milk or white chocolate. add colors or some edible gold
Dipped Pretzel Sticks $40.00
include 12 large pretzel STICKS . your choice of milk or white chocolate. colored chocolate is optional.
Cupcakes $45.00
Includes 12 cupcakes. your choice of one of our decadent flavors and pair it with a bomb buttercream or a fancy filling. add edible images or infusers to give it a pop! always a CLASSIC crowd pleaser for ALL AGES!
Chocolate covered Apples $50.00
Includes 12 WHOLE granny smith apples. coated in a thin crunchy layer ,of your choice of chocolate, which gives off a nice shine. switch it up and add some color or even a bling stick.

Sweets By SHAY. Details

From the business
Identifies as Black-owned
Identifies as women-owned

Service options
Curbside pickup
Delivery
Takeout

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Amenities
Restroom

Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly

Planning
Appointment required
Quick visit

Payments
NFC mobile payments

Sweets By SHAY. Photos

Sweets By SHAY. Location

Sweets By SHAY.

New York Kings County Bedford-Stuyvesant Jefferson Avenue

146 Jefferson Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216, USA

Sweets By SHAY. Reviews

An average rating of ★4.7 from 18 user reviews.

banana puddingmother’s daycupcakes

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

The cakes, besides being very small, were not good. While the flavor and design weren’t bad, the decoration on the cakes was dangerous, as it was inedible and shaped like spheres that could easily choke someone. Regarding service, even though we didn’t stay, they were refusing to serve us at 4 PM, despite it clearly stating on Maps that they close at 6 PM.
November 19 · Julio Jiménez
Everything is Delicious & made from scratch, I LOVE IT ... I Ordered a banana Pudding Jar & Chocolate covered strawberries for my mom for for mother’s day & I can say SweetsbyShay Never goes wrong with these desserts! Me & My Mothered Loved EVERYTHING ❤️ & This isn’t my first time ordering from here. I give sweets by shay a five star rating For taste & decoration ❤️ Everything was beautiful & Delicious
May 12 · Sheena Beena
Sweets By SHAY cakes, cupcakes and edible arrangement designs are very creative and designed the way you like. Each time I ordered I was impressed with not only how beautiful the cakes and arrangements were but they were also very delicious. The Jell-O shots were a big hit. All cakes are made from scratch and with love. This is my new cake spot, great customer service and the price is right.
May 11 · Monique Lovander
My mother bought a cake for my twin brother 4th birthday. First of all the cake was late and we were told that the oven was not working. She rush the cake and gave it to us the next day. The box that has the cake inside smells like weed and when my dad went to get the cake from her car there was a dog next to the cake. And like I said the car smelled like weed. This is a children’s cake and I am so disappointed, the fact that this place have all 5 stars is shocking. We were then told that we will be getting cupcakes for the lateness of the cake, but then she said they were no more cupcakes and brought Rice crispy‘s. And to sum this up my brothers names are not even on the cake so this was completely rushed. The quality of the cake we got compared to every else is just bad very bad.
April 15 · Krystal Barrie
I absolutely loveddd my banana pudding ! I couldn’t put it down I will definitely be placing another order my grandmother and mother loved them it was like the cherry on top for Mother’s Day ! Thank you sooo much she replied in a timely manner, kept me posted with my order, and she’s so nice !!!
May 11 · Chardonnay Gittens