That Pizza Joint

- 349 Central Ave, Lawrence, NY 11559

Welcome to the Five Towns, where the local dining scene constantly surprises and delights. Today, we're putting the spotlight on a true local gem that has been quietly earning rave reviews for its exceptional and unique take on a classic favorite: That Pizza Joint in Lawrence, NY. This is not your average neighborhood slice shop; it's a dedicated pizza restaurant and Kosher destination that brings an elevated, artisan approach to every pie, making it a must-try for residents and visitors throughout Long Island.

That Pizza Joint has quickly established itself as a standout, combining the best traditions of gourmet pizza-making with a commitment to quality and community. Identifying as a women-owned business, this establishment adds a distinct, welcoming flavor to the local business landscape. The atmosphere is consistently described as casual, making it a perfect, laid-back spot for any meal, whether you're grabbing a quick bite during the day or settling in for a satisfying family dinner.

What truly sets this place apart is its culinary identity. The menu leans heavily into specialty pizzas, offering both New Haven Style Pizza and Focaccia Pizza, styles that are beloved by purists and offer a delightful contrast to the more common New York-style slices found elsewhere. They have successfully blended comfort food favorites with gourmet standards, ensuring every item is crafted with attention to detail—a detail that customers have noted is evident in the 'perfect char' of their crusts.

Whether you are a devoted pizza enthusiast or simply looking for your next great meal in the Five Towns, That Pizza Joint offers a fresh, high-quality, and reliable dining experience that consistently delivers on taste and satisfaction.

The local New York area, particularly the bustling Five Towns community, is known for its high standards when it comes to Kosher dining, and That Pizza Joint proudly meets these expectations. It operates as a dedicated Kosher restaurant, providing delicious dairy food options that cater to the community's needs without compromising on flavor or creativity. This commitment ensures that a wide array of local patrons can enjoy their exceptional pizza and other comfort food offerings.

Location and Accessibility

Situated right in the heart of Lawrence, New York, That Pizza Joint is conveniently located for those living and working in the Five Towns area and beyond. Its location on a main thoroughfare makes it easy to reach, whether you are driving by for a quick pickup or stopping for a sit-down meal.

The restaurant's address is 349 Central Ave, Lawrence, NY 11559, USA. Central Avenue serves as a key artery connecting the various communities of the Five Towns, ensuring excellent visibility and accessibility. For customers who prefer to pay using modern convenience, the restaurant accepts all major credit cards.

Services Offered

That Pizza Joint understands that modern dining requires flexibility. To accommodate the busy schedules and preferences of the Long Island community, they offer several convenient service options, ensuring you can enjoy their delicious food wherever you are.

• Dine-in: The establishment provides a casual atmosphere perfect for a relaxed meal. It’s an ideal spot for a quick lunch break or a comfortable dinner with friends and family. The restaurant is also noted as being good for kids, making it a great family dining option.

• Takeout: For those who prefer to eat at home or on the go, easy and fast takeout service is a core offering, allowing you to quickly grab your order and head out.

• Delivery: To reach a wider audience and provide maximum convenience, That Pizza Joint offers delivery services. This means you can enjoy their hot, fresh pizzas delivered right to your door.

• Lunch and Dinner Service: The restaurant is popular for both lunch and dinner, catering to both daytime crowds seeking a quick, quality meal and evening diners looking for satisfying comfort food.

• Quick Bite Offerings: Their menu is perfectly suited for those looking for a fast, delicious "quick bite" that doesn't sacrifice flavor or quality.

Features / Highlights

What makes That Pizza Joint stand out in the competitive New York pizza market? It’s a combination of unique culinary choices, excellent food quality, and a commitment to customer experience.

• Specialty Pizza Styles: They are masters of distinct pizza styles, prominently featuring both New Haven Style Pizza and Focaccia Pizza. This provides a desirable alternative to the standard New York slice.

• The Perfect Crust: A recurring theme in customer feedback is the quality of the crust. One reviewer exclaimed, "A perfect char as another reviewer here mentioned is 100% true. Crunchy and delicious." This attention to a beautifully charred and textured crust elevates their pies above the competition.

• Signature Pies: The menu includes highly-rated specialty items like the "Flip Side Pie," which features the mozzarella topped with sauce and Parmesan, and the "Vaadka Pie" made with homemade vodka sauce, fresh, and regular mozzarella. Other popular options include the "Mozzarella Tomato Pie" and the "Pesto Pie."

• Gourmet Comfort Food: Beyond pizza, the menu offers unique comfort food, most notably the "Georgian Cheese Boat (Khachapuri)," a freshly baked bread filled with a mixture of white cheeses, providing a taste of international comfort.

• Women-Owned Business: Proudly identifying as a women-owned business, That Pizza Joint is an important part of supporting local, diverse entrepreneurship in the Lawrence community.

• Kosher Dairy Certification: As a dedicated Kosher restaurant (dairy), it serves the local religious community with high standards of quality and compliance.

• High-Quality Ingredients: Customer reviews often praise the flavor and quality of the ingredients, noting that you can "legit taste the quality" in their dishes.

Contact Information

Whether you're looking to place a pickup order or inquire about delivery, getting in touch with the friendly team at That Pizza Joint is simple.

Address: 349 Central Ave, Lawrence, NY 11559, USA

Phone: (516) 395-1289

What is Worth Choosing

For anyone in the Lawrence and Five Towns area, or for those traveling through Long Island looking for truly great pizza, That Pizza Joint offers a compelling choice. Their dedication to craft and quality shines through, especially in their unique pizza styles.

You should choose That Pizza Joint if you value:

• A Superior Crust: If you appreciate a pizza crust with a perfect char, crunch, and flavor—a characteristic frequently highlighted by loyal patrons—their New Haven and Focaccia styles are unmatched locally.

• Creative & Specialty Pies: Move beyond the standard cheese and pepperoni. Their specialty pies, such as the famous "Flip Side Pie" and the creamy "Vaadka Pie" (made with homemade vodka sauce), offer a fresh, exciting flavor profile that customers say "can't even compare to any pizza in the 5t."

• Reliable Kosher Dining: As a trusted Kosher restaurant, you can rely on them for high-quality, delicious dairy comfort food that meets the community's standards.

• Supporting a Local, Women-Owned Business: Choosing That Pizza Joint means supporting local entrepreneurs and a business deeply rooted in the Lawrence community.

• Variety in Comfort: Beyond pizza, the availability of satisfying comfort food like their house-made Georgian Cheese Boat (Khachapuri) ensures there is something unique and delicious for everyone at the table.

Next time you're craving a memorable slice of pizza, skip the ordinary and head to That Pizza Joint. Experience the quality, taste the difference, and discover why this spot is becoming the talk of the Five Towns. It's truly a destination for gourmet, Kosher-friendly pizza lovers throughout New York.

That Pizza Joint

349 Central Ave, Lawrence, NY 11559, USA