The Brooklyn Sweet Spot: A Black-Owned Bakery in Fort Greene, NY

The Brooklyn Sweet Spot Introduce

In the vibrant and bustling neighborhood of Fort Greene, a hidden gem has been capturing the hearts—and satisfying the sweet cravings—of locals and visitors alike. The Brooklyn Sweet Spot, a Black-owned and women-owned bakery on Myrtle Avenue, is not just a place to get dessert; it's a destination for a truly memorable treat. This charming bakery has cultivated a reputation for its exceptional baked goods, from classic cakes and cupcakes to some of the most raved-about banana pudding in the city. It’s a place that feels deeply personal, like a taste of home-style baking made with love and care.

The atmosphere at The Brooklyn Sweet Spot is focused on the delightful experience of quick, delicious satisfaction. It is perfectly designed for a quick visit, whether you're grabbing a single cupcake for yourself or picking up a full order for an event. The bakery's main focus is on the quality of its products and the convenience of its service. When you step inside, you are met with a tantalizing display of desserts, each one looking more decadent than the last. The staff, known for their kindness and wonderful demeanor, add to the positive experience, making every interaction feel personal and welcoming.

What makes The Brooklyn Sweet Spot a true standout is its dedication to crafting extraordinary desserts. While the cupcakes and cake slices are undeniably delicious, it's the legendary banana pudding that has earned a devoted following. Customers who have tried it describe it as a transformative experience, hailing it as the "literal BEST" they have ever had. This kind of passionate praise is a testament to the quality and care that goes into every single item on the menu. Beyond the classics, the bakery also offers a variety of other treats, including pies, brownies, and a selection of fresh fruit smoothies, ensuring that there's a perfect treat for every craving.

The Brooklyn Sweet Spot is located at 366 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205. Its position on Myrtle Avenue makes it a convenient stop for anyone in the Fort Greene and surrounding Brooklyn neighborhoods. The area is easily accessible for a quick visit, and the bakery's business model is built for efficiency and convenience. While there is paid street parking available, its central location makes it an easy spot to get to on foot or by public transportation, which is often the preferred mode of travel in this part of New York.

The focus on in-store pickup and takeout ensures that the process is streamlined and quick. It’s designed to get you your treats with minimal fuss, which is perfect for busy New Yorkers on the go. The bakery also offers delivery, providing an excellent service for those who want to enjoy their sweet treats from the comfort of their home or office.

The Brooklyn Sweet Spot offers several key services to provide a seamless customer experience.

Takeout and In-store Pickup: Customers can easily order their favorite desserts for a quick pickup at the store, perfect for a fast-paced lifestyle.
Delivery: For ultimate convenience, the bakery provides delivery service, bringing their delicious products directly to you.
Quick Visit Model: The bakery is designed for a quick and efficient visit, making it an ideal stop for a sudden sweet craving or a planned pickup.
Accepts Various Payments: The bakery accepts all major credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making transactions quick and easy.

The highlights and features of The Brooklyn Sweet Spot are what make it a true local treasure.

Legendary Banana Pudding: The banana pudding has earned a reputation for being one of the best in the city, with a loyal following of devoted fans.
Variety of Cupcakes and Cake Slices: The bakery offers a wide and decadent selection of cupcakes in unique flavors like "Sexy Lady Cake" and "Strawberry Banana Pudding Cupcake," along with classic cake slices like "Bomb Carrot Cake" and "Classic Red Velvet Cake."
Black-Owned and Women-Owned: As a business that identifies as Black-owned and women-owned, it is an important part of the local community and a source of pride for many.
Fresh Fruit Smoothies: In addition to the baked goods, the bakery offers a selection of refreshing and healthy smoothies, such as Strawberry Mango and Pink Dragon Fruit, providing a fresh alternative.
Home-style Comfort Desserts: The menu is filled with classic comfort desserts like Southern Bayou Bread Pudding and Sweet Potato Pie, offering a nostalgic and satisfying experience.

For more information or to place an order, you can contact The Brooklyn Sweet Spot at:

Address: 366 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, USA

Phone: (347) 916-0494

What makes The Brooklyn Sweet Spot worth choosing is its ability to deliver an unparalleled dessert experience with a focus on quality and community. In a city saturated with bakeries, this one stands out not only for its delicious products but also for its commitment to being a Black-owned and women-owned business. The legendary banana pudding alone is a reason to visit, but the entire menu is a testament to the skill and passion of its creators.

The bakery's model of being a quick-visit, takeout-friendly spot is perfectly suited to the New York lifestyle, making it an easy and rewarding choice for a sweet treat. The friendly and welcoming staff add to the overall positive experience, making every visit a pleasant one. For anyone in Brooklyn with a sweet tooth, a craving for a taste of home, or a desire to support a local, women-owned business, The Brooklyn Sweet Spot is an absolute must-visit. It's a true neighborhood gem that proves that some of the best things in life are indeed sweet.

The Brooklyn Sweet Spot Menu

Cupcake Flavors
Sexy Lady Cake $6.00
Red velvet. Velvety red cake with a hint of cocoa under a cloud of white chocolate cream cheese frosting.
Chocolate Seduction Cupcake $6.50
Super rich, super intense, delicious chocolate cake glazed with truffle cream and topped with chocolate cream cheese mousse.
All American Cupcake $6.50
When you cant decide. Why not choose the best of all 3 worlds?! Moist chocolate cake, vanilla cake and red velvet cake topped with our signature buttercream dipped in chocolate ganache swirled all into 1 awesome cupcake
Strawberry Banana Pudding Cupcake $6.50
Vanilla cake with fresh strawberry and banana folded in, with a banana custard filling.
Tuxedo Cupcake $6.50
Chocolate cake dipped in our rich chocolate truffle glaze topped with sweet vanilla buttercream.
Strawberry Shortcake Cupcake $6.50

FRESH COLD FRUIT SMOOTHIES
STRAWBERRY SMOOTHIE $8.00
STRAWBERRY MANGO $8.00
TROPICAL FRUIT SMOOTHIE $8.00
BERRY BLAST SMOOTHIE $8.00
WATERMELON MINT SMOOTHIE $8.00
DESIGN YOUR OWN SMOOTHIE $9.00
PINK DRAGON FRUIT $10.00

Cake Slices
Slice Of Bomb Carrot Cake $8.00
Fresh organic carrots, brown sugar, and too many secret ingredients to mention here. Frosted with our signature caramel cream cheese frosting and plenty of nuts.
Slice Of "Church" Cake $8.00
Delicious vanilla cake sandwiched between layers of chocolate buttercream and our signature chocolate truffle glaze.
Slice Of Pineapple Coconut Cake $8.00
Sweet, juicy, fresh pineapple and creamy coconut! Take your taste buds on a mini vacay, as this moist delicious cake melts in your mouth.
Classic Red Velvet Cake $8.00
A southern favorite. It's not just vanilla cake with red food coloring or chocolate cake with red food coloring. It's a marriage of buttermilk, vanilla flavors, cocoa flavors and so much more.
Luscious Lemon $8.00
A little tart, a little sweet, a lotta delicious

Bread Puddings and Pies
Watermelon Mint $6.00
Made with sweet,juicy watermelon and refreshing mint leaves. Something to keep you cool and refreshed throughout your day.
Peach Colada $6.00
Enjoy a taste of summer with our peach Colada. Made with cream of coconut and fresh peaches.
Lime Mint Mojito $6.00
This refreshing mocktail, stems from simple, yet essentials ingredients. A little lime, a little sugar, a little mint and a lot of love.
Strawberry Lemonade $6.00
Just two simple ingredients can make your taste buds come alive.
Sweet Potato Pie (3") $4.00
Sized just right for a personal indulgence, this creamy, dreamy, sweet potato pie sits in the flakiest crust. Loaded with all the warm spices to take you to your grandma's kitchen.
Caramel Apple Pie $4.50
Indulge in our luscious 6" caramel apple pie, where tender, cinnamon-kissed apples nestle in a flaky, buttery crust, all drizzled with rich, golden caramel that oozes into every bite. Perfectly portioned for a personal treat, this little pie delivers big, mouthwatering flavor that will leave you craving another!
Southern Bayou Bread Pudding $7.50
Ease your fork into the rich, melt-in-your-mouth goodness of our Louisiana bread pudding, where the warmth of cinnamon, vanilla, and a buttery custard soak into every bite of tender, golden-baked bread. Topped with a velvety rich Jamaican rum sauce that drapes each bite, this Southern classic is pure comfort and indulgence on a plate!
Sweet Potato Bread Pudding $7.50
Experience the soul-warming flavors of our Southern sweet potato bread pudding, where velvety sweet potatoes, cinnamon, and nutmeg blend into a rich, custardy delight. Drizzled with a silky Jamaican rum sauce that adds just what you need to make everything a little bit better, every bite is a decadent taste of Southern comfort with a Caribbean twist!
Apple Bread Pudding $7.50
Indulge in our Southern apple bread pudding, where tender, spiced apples are baked into a rich, buttery custard, creating a heavenly blend of warmth and sweetness in every bite. Finished with a luscious Jamaican rum sauce that seeps into every golden-baked layer, this comforting dessert is pure Southern soul with a touch of island bliss!

Brownies
Salted Caramel Brownie $4.00
Fudge Brownies $4.00
You know what they say, a brownie a day keeps the brownies away. Not too cakey and not too dense and heavy on the chocolatey goodness.
Cheesecake Brownies $5.00

Banana Pudding
Banana Pudding $7.00
You remember this. Fresh, ripe bananas, old fashioned vanilla wafers, creamy vanilla custard all layered together to create this down home southern dessert.

Cookies
3 Chocolate Chip Cookies $3.50
Sugar, butter, eggs, chocolate chips, our secret ingredient and love. You can't go wrong.
Butter Crunch Chocolate Chip Cookie $4.00
This is a cookie game changer. The toffee pieces allow the cookie to spread nice and thin for a good Crunch but not too thin.
3 Coconut Pecan Cookies $3.50
Soft and chewy coconut cookies with shredded coconut, chopped pecans, and tons of yum.
3 White Chocolate Macadamia Cookies $3.50
Soft baked with extra chewy centers. Packed with white chocolate and walnuts.
3 Oatmeal Cookies $3.50
Oats, raisins, sugar, spice and everything nice gives you that iconic cookie. Oatmeal raisin. Full of spice and just the right amount of chew.
3 Funfetti Cookies $3.50
Our Funfetti Cookie is pure happiness in every bite—a soft, buttery sugar cookie bursting with colorful sprinkles that melt into sweet pockets of joy as it bakes. With its crisp edges, chewy center, and a nostalgic vanilla flavor, this festive treat is like a celebration you can taste, no occasion needed!

The Brooklyn Sweet Spot Details

From the business
Identifies as Black-owned
Identifies as women-owned

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
Takeout

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Paid street parking

The Brooklyn Sweet Spot Photos

The Brooklyn Sweet Spot Location

The Brooklyn Sweet Spot

New York Kings County Fort Greene Myrtle Avenue

366 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, USA

The Brooklyn Sweet Spot Reviews

An average rating of ★4.7 from 257 user reviews.

banana puddingcarrot cakefrostingbirthdayred velvet cupcakesstrawberrybrowniecheesecakebread puddingapple pie

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Thank you for the literal BEST banana pudding I have ever had in my entire life. I came in today after seeing the sign outside that ya’ll had banana pudding and thank God I did. I am healed. The sweet woman at the front was absolutely wonderful as well. The whole experience was superb and I will be back here over and over. I am in love. It’s so good. Thank you ♥️♥️
August 13 · Katie W
I ordered 3 cupcakes (red velvet, strawberry banana and strawberry shortcake) which totaled $18 which is very expensive if you ask me but two of the three did taste good. I didn’t like the strawberry shortcake one. I don’t think any of them are worth $6 though considering the size.Also, I asked for a receipt and they don’t print receipts or allow you to type your number in since it’s behind glass, so they ask you to say your phone number out loud in front of other customers… I never even got the text receipt after that
March 12 · Aliyah Brathwaite
The desserts are on point in here. I honestly wanted to buy everything, but I decided to buy a slice of cake and a cookie this time around. I have to go back to try the cupcakes. I would recommend the apple crumble cookie. So delicious, and not overly sweet. The strawberry cake taste homemade (which I appreciate when cakes tastes like this) and was also yummy.
June 17 · Ayana Austin-Depay
Absolutely love Brooklyn Sweet Spota and the owner Kym! We order her cakes for all our special occasions (weddings, birthdays, baby showers) and guests always rave about how amazing her desserts are. The carrot cake and red velvet are our favorites - moist, soft, flavorful 10/10 every time! They also make beautiful cake designs and are easy to work with when you have a custom design.
June 09 · Keira Duarte Vinson
First, let me say, I have been a baker myself professionally for the past 9 years, and the texture, freshness, and flavors are on point 100%The banana pudding, red velvet cupcakes, and carrot cake slices are divine. Soft, fluffy, and the textures are spot on!Baybeee, the cinnamon rolls are to die for!!!! It's tastes like a brioche dough base, which shows they take their time to prepare the desserts with care.Loved it! Will be back when I'm in Brooklyn again. Thank you for doing things the right way!
October 07 · Chantel P