The Firehouse Family Restaurant & Bar

- 42 Plauderville Ave, Garfield, NJ 07026

The Firehouse Family Restaurant & Bar is a true local cornerstone in Garfield, New Jersey, celebrated by residents across Bergen County as the go-to spot for a blend of comforting Italian-American cuisine and a classic, welcoming pub atmosphere. This family restaurant, bar, and pizzeria has firmly established itself as more than just a place to eat—it's a community hub where friendly service meets consistently fantastic food. If you are a New Jersey local searching for a reliable, family-friendly venue with an extensive menu and an atmosphere adorned with firemen memorabilia, The Firehouse is an absolute must-visit.

The restaurant’s reputation is built on a few standout items, most notably their incredible Thin Crust Pizza and their highly-praised Firehouse Mussels in a rich Tomato Basil sauce. Customers consistently rave about the pizza's perfect balance of crispy crust, quality cheese, and flavorful sauce. Beyond the famous pizza, the menu offers a generous selection of appetizers, entrées, and sandwiches, ensuring there’s a satisfying option for every taste and craving. It’s the kind of place where you can grab a quick bite during lunch, enjoy a cozy dinner with the family, or meet up with friends for late-night drinks and comfort food.

The atmosphere at The Firehouse is distinctly welcoming. It strikes a perfect balance between a traditional pub and a comfortable family dining room, complete with a bar at the center and a cozy, historic, and trendy ambiance. The staff are known for their efficiency and genuine friendliness, with service that often makes first-time visitors feel like long-time regulars. This combination of great food, great value, and a great vibe is what keeps the tables full and the community coming back for more.

The diverse menu is a testament to its commitment to being a true family restaurant. From the "Off The Grill" selections like the Open Sliced Steak Platter to Italian specialties such as Penne Vodka and various chicken and seafood pasta options, the food is all about quality comfort and generous portions. The lunch and dinner options cater to solo diners, couples, and large groups, with offerings that span from healthy salads to indulgent desserts like Nasto's Tartufo.

The beverage selection also merits a mention, with a great beer and cocktail selection perfect for pairing with a specialty pizza like the Drunken Grandma Pie or one of their popular subs. The bar area provides a casual setting to catch a game and enjoy Happy Hour drinks and food.

Location and Accessibility

The Firehouse Family Restaurant & Bar is conveniently situated in the heart of Garfield, making it a highly accessible spot for residents across Bergen County and beyond. Its location helps cement its role as a neighborhood favorite, providing a dependable and delicious local dining option.

The physical address is:

42 Plauderville Ave, Garfield, NJ 07026, USA

Accessibility is a priority at The Firehouse, ensuring a comfortable experience for all patrons. The facility is fully equipped with Wheelchair Accessible Entrance, Parking Lot, Restroom, and Seating, making it a welcoming choice for everyone in the community. Parking is also convenient, with Free Parking Lot and Free Street Parking available.

Services Offered

The Firehouse is designed to meet various dining needs, whether you're planning a meal out or enjoying a night in.

• Dine-in: Enjoy the cozy, historic, and casual atmosphere.
• Takeout: Convenient options for picking up your favorite dishes.
• Delivery: Bringing the full menu right to your door.
• Outdoor Seating: A comfortable option for enjoying a meal outside.
• Catering: Available for larger events and gatherings.
• Reservations: The restaurant accepts reservations for easy planning, though walk-ins are welcome.
• Bar Service: A full bar with a great selection of beer, cocktails, wine, and hard liquor.
• Table Service: Full service provided for a relaxed dining experience.

Features / Highlights

The Firehouse is celebrated for a variety of features that contribute to its consistent popularity among New Jersey locals.

• Thin Crust Pizza: Consistently praised as a standout in the region for its crispy, perfectly-cooked crust and flavorful toppings.
• Delectable Mussels: The Firehouse Mussels (in Tomato Basil or Sam Adams Steamers) are a famous signature dish that locals often recommend.
• Exceptional Service: Known for Fast Service and friendly, professional staff—with one review mentioning a server's remarkable memory and genuine attention to detail.
• Appetizer Variety: An impressive list of starters including Buffalo Wings, Chicken Quesadillas, Gravy & Mozzarella Fries, and Spicy Garlic Fries.
• Pub Atmosphere: A Cozy and Casual setting with a well-stocked Bar Onsite, perfect for watching Sports.
• Wide Menu Range: Offers everything from Comfort Food and Quick Bites to Italian Entrées (like Chicken Francese and Shrimp Scampi) and delicious Firehouse Subs.
• Family and Group Friendly: Popular for Lunch and Dinner, welcoming to Families with a Kids' Menu and high chairs, and great for Groups and Solo Dining.
• Dietary Options: Provides Vegetarian Options and Healthy Options alongside traditional offerings.

Contact Information

For reservations, inquiries, or placing a takeout order, please use the following contact details:

Address: 42 Plauderville Ave, Garfield, NJ 07026, USA

Phone: (973) 478-2226

What is Worth Choosing

When visiting The Firehouse Family Restaurant & Bar, New Jersey users should prioritize experiencing the dishes that have made this spot a local institution. The Thin Crust Pizza is non-negotiable for any first-time visitor; it is consistently cited as one of the best local pizzas. Pairing an Original Thin Crust with a bowl of the highly-acclaimed Firehouse Mussels will give you a perfect sense of the quality Italian-American cooking the restaurant is known for.

For pasta lovers, the Penne Vodka is a top choice, offering a rich and creamy tomato-based sauce. The menu also features hearty steak and chop selections, like the Open Sliced Steak Platter, which is a fan favorite for its generous portion and garlic butter topping.

Don't overlook the impressive variety of appetizers and sides. The Gravy & Mozzarella Fries offer a true comfort food experience, and the substantial, fresh Caesar Salad is another highly recommended side that consistently receives praise in reviews. Finally, be sure to save room for the famous Nasto's Tartufo for dessert.

Ultimately, what makes The Firehouse Family Restaurant & Bar worth choosing is the complete dining experience: a warm, pub-like ambiance, a stellar reputation for their signature thin crust pizza and mussels, and staff that provide the kind of genuinely welcoming, efficient service that turns first-time customers into loyal regulars. For authentic, high-quality Italian-American comfort food in a fun, friendly Bergen County setting, The Firehouse is a true gem.

The Firehouse Family Restaurant & Bar

42 Plauderville Ave, Garfield, NJ 07026, USA