The Original Pizza of Avenue L, INC

- 9514 Avenue L, Brooklyn, NY 11236

For those in search of an authentic taste of Brooklyn, look no further than The Original Pizza of Avenue L, INC. This is not just another pizza shop; it’s an iconic establishment that has become a cherished part of the neighborhood’s fabric. Stepping inside, you'll find an old-school pizzeria with a casual, historic feel, complete with ample seating. The focus here is on classic New York-style pizza, made with a dedication to tradition that has kept customers coming back for generations. Beyond the pizza, The Original Pizza of Avenue L offers a full menu of Italian and American comfort foods, making it a true one-stop destination for a satisfying meal. It’s a place where you can feel the history and community in every bite.

The atmosphere at The Original Pizza of Avenue L is perfect for a variety of occasions. Whether you're a college student grabbing a quick slice, a family looking for a casual dinner, or a group of friends meeting up, the space is welcoming and accommodating. The restaurant is family-friendly and even offers high chairs for the little ones. The staff and ownership are dedicated to their customers and community, staying true to the classic pizza experience that has made them famous. While some newer pizza shops may come and go, this place has endured by staying true to its roots, offering a dependable and delicious slice that many consider to be a perfect example of what Brooklyn pizza should be.

Location and Accessibility

The Original Pizza of Avenue L, INC is conveniently located at 9514 Avenue L, Brooklyn, NY 11236. The address places it in a prime spot within the Canarsie neighborhood, easily accessible to local residents and visitors alike. The restaurant is situated in a way that makes it a visible landmark, and its longstanding presence in the community means it's a well-known spot. The establishment is committed to accessibility, featuring a wheelchair-accessible entrance and seating, ensuring that everyone can comfortably enjoy a meal.

For those driving, the restaurant provides options for both free and paid street parking, which is a great convenience in a busy borough like Brooklyn. This makes it a feasible destination for groups or families who are traveling by car. For those relying on public transport, Avenue L is well-served by local buses, making it a simple journey from many surrounding areas. The combination of easy street access, thoughtful accessibility features, and a central location makes The Original Pizza of Avenue L a highly convenient dining option. It’s the kind of place you can quickly pop into for a slice or settle in for a full meal.

Services Offered

• Dine-in, Takeout, and Delivery: The Original Pizza of Avenue L provides multiple ways to enjoy their food. Customers can dine in and take advantage of the generous seating, or they can opt for convenient takeout and delivery services.
• Extensive Menu: In addition to a wide range of round and Sicilian pies, the menu includes specialty slices, sides like garlic knots and wings, pasta dishes, salads, and more. This variety caters to all tastes and cravings.
• Catering: For larger events, the restaurant offers catering options, making it a great choice for parties, office lunches, or family gatherings.
• Multiple Payment Options: The restaurant accepts a variety of modern payment methods, including NFC mobile payments in addition to traditional credit and debit cards. They also accept Zelle for an added convenience.
• Family and Group Friendly: The atmosphere is great for kids and families, with a dedicated kids' menu and high chairs available. It's also a popular spot for groups looking for a casual and affordable place to eat.
• Late-Night Food: The Original Pizza of Avenue L is open until late, providing a great option for late-night cravings.

Features / Highlights

• Iconic Brooklyn Pizza: This pizzeria is celebrated for its authentic, old-school New York-style pizza. Many locals consider it to be a true representation of the classic Brooklyn slice.
• Diverse Pizza Selection: The menu offers a wide array of options, including classic Cheese and Sicilian pies, as well as creative and delicious choices like the Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Penne Alla Vodka Pizza, and Chicken Caesar Salad Pizza.
• Historic and True to its Roots: The restaurant is described as an "old school pizza shop" that has stayed true to its customers and community for many years, giving it a unique, historic charm.
• Generous Seating: Unlike some smaller slice shops, this location has "a lot of seating," making it a comfortable place to sit and enjoy your meal, whether you're alone or with a group.
• Comprehensive Menu Beyond Pizza: The offerings extend beyond just pizza to include pasta dishes like Penne Alla Vodka, salads, and a variety of sides and specialty items, such as rolls, calzones, and wings.
• Community and Staff: The staff are noted for being "so nice" and for their commitment to the local community, which contributes to the friendly and welcoming atmosphere.

Contact Information

Address: 9514 Avenue L, Brooklyn, NY 11236, USA

Phone: (718) 531-3559

What is worth choosing

For a true New York pizza experience, The Original Pizza of Avenue L is a must-visit. What makes it worth choosing is its ability to deliver on the classic, authentic taste that many associate with Brooklyn pizza. The consistent quality of their pies and slices is a significant draw for long-time customers who "never miss" coming here. While one negative review exists regarding the taste, it's juxtaposed with overwhelming praise from long-standing patrons who grew up on the pizza and consider it "iconic." This loyalty speaks volumes about the overall quality and community connection.

Beyond the pizza itself, the sheer variety of the menu is a major reason to choose The Original Pizza of Avenue L. You can get a simple cheese slice, a specialty slice, or an entire pie with a variety of toppings. The presence of options like Buffalo Chicken Wings, garlic knots, and Italian pasta dishes means there's something for everyone, making it a great place for families or groups with diverse preferences. The convenience of their service—including delivery, takeout, and a welcoming dine-in area with plenty of seating—makes it an effortless choice for any time of day. In a city saturated with pizza, this spot stands out for its delicious, classic offerings, deep community roots, and all-around dependable service.

The Original Pizza of Avenue L, INC

9514 Avenue L, Brooklyn, NY 11236, USA