The Square on Annadale

- 833 Annadale Rd, Staten Island, NY 10312

The Square on Annadale Pizzeria & Restaurant is a staple dining destination nestled in the Annadale neighborhood of Staten Island, New York. As its name suggests, this establishment is renowned for its signature square pizzas, distinguishing itself in a borough known for its competitive and high-quality pizza scene. It operates as both a classic New York-style Pizza restaurant and a reliable Delivery Restaurant, offering a wide array of Italian-American Comfort food staples beyond the pies.

The menu is designed to satisfy the diverse cravings of New York locals, featuring a comprehensive selection of pizzas, including specialized options like the thick-crust Sicilian Slice, the rustic Grandma Slice, and unique creations such as the Vodka Slice and the highly praised Triple Sauce Slice. Beyond pizza, the restaurant serves a full range of Italian-American appetizers, calzones, heroes, and entrees, all utilizing fresh ingredients and focusing on the satisfying, traditional flavors that define this cuisine.

The atmosphere at The Square on Annadale is described as Casual and Cozy, making it an inviting place for a relaxed meal. It caters well to various demographics, being popular for Lunch, Dinner, Solo dining, and especially welcoming to Groups and Good for kids. The staff is often praised for being very welcoming and friendly, which contributes significantly to the overall positive dining experience for many loyal customers. The venue also offers Beer and Wine to complement its hearty food options.

While the food quality, particularly the pizza, is often described as "BANGING" and "amazing," and service is noted as consistent and good, it is important to acknowledge the occasional lapses in service that have been reported. Some customers have described instances of unhelpful delivery/customer service, especially during busy times, and there have been reports of incorrect or substandard items. The restaurant's popularity and high volume likely contribute to occasional service delays, with reviews noting that service can be "slow during the weekends," though the food is "always hot and fresh" upon arrival.

Location and Accessibility

The Square on Annadale is conveniently located at 833 Annadale Rd, Staten Island, NY 10312, USA. Situated in the Eltingville/Annadale area, it is easily reachable for local residents and accessible to Tourists and visitors to the area. Its location on a main road simplifies finding the spot for both driving and local transit.

The restaurant has made significant efforts to ensure it is fully accessible to all members of the community:

• The facility includes a Wheelchair accessible entrance, making entry into the dining and takeout area easy.
• Dedicated Wheelchair accessible seating is provided within the restaurant.
• A Wheelchair accessible restroom is available for guests' comfort and convenience.

Services Offered

The restaurant offers a flexible service model to suit any dining preference, whether you're staying in or dining out:

• Dine-in: Features dedicated Seating and Table service for a relaxed experience, perfect for Lunch or Dinner.
• Takeout: A traditional and efficient service option for those who want to pick up their order to enjoy at home or on the go.
• Delivery: Offered as a primary service. Despite occasional reports of delays, the service is generally reliable for getting hot and fresh pizza to local homes.
• Reservations: The restaurant Accepts reservations, which is highly recommended, particularly for Groups or during peak weekend hours, given its popularity.
• Catering: Provides Catering services for larger events and parties, with customers praising the quality and portions for group orders.
• Payment Convenience: Accepts Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for fast and modern transactions.

Features / Highlights

The reputation of The Square on Annadale is built on several customer-centric features and menu strengths:

• Signature Square Pizza: The 'Square Pie' is a core highlight, celebrated by many customers for its unique taste, crisp crust, and overall quality, often compared favorably to other local spots.
• Specialty Pizza Selection: Offers a dynamic and extensive menu of unique pizzas, including the highly-rated Vodka Pizza and Grandma Pizza, alongside classic options.
• Full Italian-American Menu: Goes beyond basic pizza to offer an extensive list of Comfort food options, including pasta dishes, heroes, and specialty appetizers like Italian Egg Rolls and Grandma's Meatballs.
• Beverage Options: Provides a selection of Beer and Wine, allowing for a complete dining experience that pairs well with their Italian offerings.
• Dessert Available: Completes the meal with various Dessert options.
• Family-Friendly Environment: The restaurant is Good for kids and provides High chairs, making it an easy choice for families.
• High-Quality Ingredients: Many reviews stress that the food, including the pizza and other menu items, is consistently made with fresh ingredients.

What is Worth Choosing

For New York locals, particularly those on Staten Island, The Square on Annadale is worth choosing when the craving for authentic, high-quality square pizza and Italian-American Comfort food strikes. The key draw is the exceptional quality and variety of their pizzas, which stand out even in a pizza-rich environment. Customers traveling from as far as New Jersey specifically for this pizza attest to its unique appeal.

The restaurant is an excellent option for versatile dining: you can enjoy a leisurely, Cozy dine-in experience with Table service for Dinner, or rely on their Delivery service for a convenient meal at home. For office Lunch or family events, their Catering service and array of large-format items are highly praised. While service can occasionally be a point of friction, the overwhelming positive feedback regarding the freshness and deliciousness of the food—particularly the pizza—secures its reputation as a top-tier local pizza restaurant that offers genuine New York flavor and comfort.

The Square on Annadale

833 Annadale Rd, Staten Island, NY 10312, USA