Tony's Brick Oven

- 1140 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10305

For decades, New Yorkers have debated where to find the absolute best slice, and in Staten Island, one name consistently enters the conversation: Tony's Brick Oven. Located right on Bay Street, this long-running establishment is more than just a pizzeria; it’s a neighborhood staple and a destination for authentic Italian-American cuisine. Tony's Brick Oven stands out for its commitment to old-school Italian recipes and style, priding itself on using fresh, high-quality ingredients, including dough made in-house daily, sauce crafted from hand-crushed tomatoes, and fresh mozzarella. This dedication to tradition ensures that every bite, from a classic round cheese pie to a hearty Italian entrée, delivers that true, comforting New York flavor locals cherish.

Tony's Brick Oven is classified as a Pizza Restaurant, Italian Restaurant, and Delivery Restaurant, making it a versatile choice for any dining occasion. Whether you're a local seeking a quick slice, a family looking for a cozy sit-down dinner, or a group needing catering, Tony’s delivers a consistently superb experience. The atmosphere is casual, cozy, and quiet, providing a welcoming environment perfect for lunch, dinner, solo dining, or gathering with family and friends.

Tony’s Brick Oven is conveniently situated at 1140 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10305, USA, placing it in the heart of a vibrant Staten Island community, particularly in the Rosebank area. Its position on Bay Street makes it a highly accessible spot for local residents and those traveling from other parts of the borough.

For patrons planning to visit, the restaurant has taken care to ensure accessibility. They offer a wheelchair accessible entrance, wheelchair accessible restroom, and wheelchair accessible seating, demonstrating a commitment to serving all members of the New York community. Parking is also stress-free, with options including a free parking lot, free street parking, and on-site parking, a significant amenity in the city. Its location is a genuine asset for those who prefer the convenience of dining in a well-equipped, local spot without the hassle of navigating difficult city parking.

Tony's Brick Oven provides a comprehensive suite of service options tailored for the modern New York lifestyle:

• Dine-in: Enjoy a cozy and casual atmosphere for lunch or dinner with table service.
• Takeout: Perfect for picking up a freshly made pizza or dinner to enjoy at home.
• Delivery: Convenient service bringing your favorite Italian meals directly to your door.
• No-contact delivery: A safe and preferred option for many customers, ensuring minimum interaction.
• Catering: Available for events, parties, and gatherings, offering a wide selection of their extensive menu.
• Reservations: The restaurant accepts reservations, making it easy to plan for groups or special occasions.
• Full Lunch and Dinner Service: Serving a full menu throughout the day for both main meals.
• Dessert Service: Providing sweet conclusions to your meal.

Tony's Brick Oven has built a reputation on standout qualities that keep customers coming back, often for decades:

• Authentic Brick Oven Pizza: The namesake and core of the business, serving old-world style pizza cooked to perfection in a brick oven. Popular brick oven options include the classic Margherita and specialty pies like Quattro Stagioni - 4 Seasons, Vodka Sauce, and Clam Pizza.
• Signature Vodka Sauce: A fan favorite, highly praised by regulars for its richness, it is available on both pasta orders and as a topping for their famous brick oven pies.
• Extensive Menu Variety: Beyond exceptional pizza (Round, Sicilian, Brick Oven, Pan, and Stuffed varieties, plus pizza by the slice), the menu offers a full Italian dining experience with an incredible selection of appetizers (like Stuffed Garlic Knots and Fried Calamari), heroes (hot and cold), wraps, paninis, calzones, baked dinners (e.g., Baked Ziti Sicilian Style, Baked Lasagna), and entrees (such as Chicken Parmigiana, Veal Parmigiana, and Shrimp Scampi).
• Diverse Offerings: Catering to various dietary preferences and tastes, the menu includes traditional comfort food, vegetarian options, healthy choices, and small plates.
• Beverage Selection: The restaurant offers a selection of Alcohol, Wine, and Coffee to complement your meal.
• Fast Service: Known for their efficiency, they consistently provide fast service whether you are dining in or opting for takeout/delivery.
• Family-Friendly Environment: Tony's is considered good for kids and families, offering high chairs and a dedicated Kids' menu.

To place an order, make a reservation, or inquire about catering, you can contact Tony's Brick Oven using the following details:

Address: 1140 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10305, USA

Phone: (718) 816-6516

Mobile Phone: +1 718-816-6516

For those new to Tony's Brick Oven, or even long-time New Yorkers looking for a local gem, the range of dishes can be overwhelming. Tony’s is highly regarded for several menu items that exemplify their commitment to quality and classic preparation.

First and foremost, you must sample the pizza. The Round Cheese pie embodies the "Classic New York style pizza" that customers have enjoyed for over 25 years. Beyond the classic, the Brick Oven Pizza section offers masterpieces like the Margherita, a simple yet perfect showcase of their fresh mozzarella and hand-crushed tomato sauce. For a unique experience, the Vodka Sauce Pizza or a pasta dish with their famous Ala Vodka Sauce is a must-try—it’s frequently cited by regulars as excellent. The Sicilian Pie, known for its generous size and satisfying thickness, is another standout that receives high praise.

Beyond the pizzas, the full Italian menu offers exceptional comfort food. The reviews specifically call out the Baked Ziti (especially the Sicilian Style), Chicken Marsala, and the Veal Parmigiana for their quality and portion size. Appetizers like the Stuffed Garlic Knots and the Fried Calamari are the perfect way to start your meal. With reasonable prices and professional service that makes both locals and visitors (even those 'visiting here from Texas') feel welcomed and appreciated, Tony's Brick Oven delivers an exceptional value proposition.

Tony's Brick Oven is truly a hidden gem bringing "old fashioned Brooklyn Italian style pizza" and a comprehensive menu of consistently great food to the heart of Staten Island. It's a professional operation where the people "mean business" and the food speaks for itself—often devoured "right away as soon as food arrives."

Tony's Brick Oven

1140 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10305, USA