Montalbano's

- 1140 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10305

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers who appreciate the genuine taste of Italian tradition and the quintessential local deli experience, Montalbano's stands out as a true neighborhood gem. Located in the heart of Staten Island, Montalbano's is much more than just a deli; it's a family-owned and operated institution specializing in authentic Italian food specialties, gourmet sandwiches, and full-service catering. This establishment seamlessly blends the convenience of a modern delivery restaurant with the charm and expertise of an old-school Italian market, offering a culinary haven where quality and tradition are paramount. The commitment to using the highest quality ingredients—including premium Boar's Head cold cuts, fine imported meats and cheeses, and house-made delicacies like fresh mozzarella—is evident in every bite. Whether you're a long-time Staten Islander or just passing through, Montalbano's promises a dining experience that is both satisfying and deeply rooted in the rich Italian-American culture of New York City.

Montalbano's offers a diverse menu that caters to every craving, from quick lunch stops to elaborate family dinners and event catering. Their comprehensive offerings include a remarkable selection of hot and cold sandwiches, freshly prepared daily lunch specials, and a tempting array of hot soups and fresh salads. The deli's atmosphere is frequently described by local patrons as friendly, warm, and reminiscent of a classic, community-focused Italian shop where customers are treated with kindness. It's a place where the love for food and family shines through, making it a reliable and beloved choice for authentic Italian fare in the NYC region.

Location and Accessibility

Montalbano's is conveniently situated at 1140 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10305, USA, placing it within easy reach for residents and visitors on the island. The location on Bay Street ensures visibility and accessibility in a bustling part of the borough. As a destination, Staten Island is connected to the rest of New York City, and this specific address is well-known within the local community. The accessibility of Montalbano's is enhanced by several practical considerations for patrons:

• The establishment features a Wheelchair accessible entrance, ensuring comfortable access for all members of the community.
• Parking is made easier with the availability of both a Free parking lot and Free street parking, a significant convenience in a busy metropolitan area like New York.
• For those on the go, the focus is clearly on a Quick visit experience, perfect for grabbing a freshly made lunch or prepared dinner.

This combination of a central location and thoughtful accessibility features makes Montalbano's an easy and appealing stop for daily needs or special event planning.

Services Offered

Montalbano's provides a wide array of services designed to meet the diverse needs of their New York clientele, from individual meals to large-scale events:

• Full-Service Deli: Offering premium Boar's Head cold cuts, imported Italian meats, and fine cheeses, perfect for slicing fresh to order.
• Delivery Restaurant Service: Meals and specialty items can be conveniently delivered, bringing the authentic Italian taste right to your door.
• Takeout and In-store Pickup: Fast and efficient service options for customers who prefer to order ahead or grab their food on the go.
• Onsite Services: The traditional deli experience, allowing customers to shop for ingredients and order prepared foods in person.
• Comprehensive Catering: Offering both hot and cold buffet options, custom menu creation, specialized holiday menus, and platters for any occasion, including giant 3-6 foot heroes and cold cut platters.
• Full Event Planning: Beyond just food, the business offers complete event services including staffing (waiters, bartenders, chefs), party rentals (tables, tents, linens), and more, allowing customers to truly be a guest at their own party.
• Payment Flexibility: Accepting Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments, and notably, SNAP/EBT, helping to serve a broad range of the local community.

Features / Highlights

What sets Montalbano's apart are the features that celebrate its Italian heritage and commitment to quality:

• Signature Specialty Sandwiches: The menu features a vast selection of specialty sandwiches, often named with a local New York flavor, such as "The Staten Islander" (Fried Chicken Cutlet, Swiss, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Honey Mustard) and "The Godfather," showcasing creative and generous combinations of Italian ingredients.
• Authentic Italian Entrees: Daily specials and catering menus include classic homemade Italian dishes like Chicken Parmigiana, Eggplant Rollatini, Lasagna, Veal Parmigiana, Meatballs, and Penne Alla Vodka, all prepared with an authentic, homemade style.
• Freshly Prepared Salads and Soups: Offering a selection of fresh salads, including the popular "The Pauley Salad" and "My Big Fat Greek" Salad, alongside comforting hot soups like Lentil, Minestrone, and Pasta and Beans, perfect for a complete lunch.
• Commitment to Quality Meats: The use of high-quality ingredients like Boar's Head cold cuts and imported Italian provisions is a cornerstone of their product offering.
• Family-Owned and Operated Charm: Customers consistently praise the "old-school style" and "kindness" from the ownership and staff, creating a loyal, neighborhood-focused clientele.
• Daily Lunch Specials: Featuring rotating daily items that offer a full, satisfying meal often including an entree, a side (like rice or broccoli), a drink, and a choice of a rice ball or potato croquet at a value price point.

Contact Information

For inquiries, placing an order, or booking catering services, Montalbano's can be reached at their primary location:

Address: 1140 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10305, USA

Phone: (718) 448-8077

Mobile Phone: +1 718-448-8077

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Montalbano's is choosing a piece of Staten Island's authentic Italian-American heritage. What truly sets this establishment apart and makes it an excellent choice for any New Yorker is the combination of impeccable, traditional Italian quality and the scope of services offered. They are a dual-threat: an exceptional Italian restaurant for ready-to-eat meals and a premier catering and food specialties provider. You are not simply buying a sandwich; you are investing in a product crafted from the finest imported ingredients, often using cherished family recipes.

For a quick, satisfying lunch, the extensive list of specialty sandwiches, like "The Goodfella" or "The Monte Special," are generous, flavorful, and a significant step up from standard fare. For family life, Montalbano’s solves the daily dinner dilemma with prepared meals like Chicken Cutlets and Lasagna, allowing New Yorkers to bring home a delicious, homemade-quality dinner without the cooking hassle. As one customer noted, "why cook after work, eh?!"

Furthermore, for those planning family events, communions, graduations, or holiday gatherings, their full-service catering and event planning capabilities are second to none. They offer customizable packages, professional staffing, and a vast menu of authentic entrees and platters. The ability to pay with SNAP/EBT further solidifies their role as a truly community-focused resource. In an era where authenticity can be hard to find, Montalbano's delivers on its promise of delicious food, honest service, and a warm, old-school Italian vibe, making it a must-visit destination for anyone seeking the best Italian food in New York's Staten Island.

Montalbano's

1140 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10305, USA