Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe

- 1899 Victory Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10314

Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe has been a beloved, time-honored institution on Staten Island, New York, since 1970, establishing itself as a premier destination for high-quality, traditional Italian-American baked goods. Rooted in the techniques and traditions perfected by Alfonso Campitiello—whose experience includes working with regional chefs in Italy and serving as a pastry chef at The Plaza Hotel and The Hampshire House in Manhattan—this bakery is more than just a shop; it’s a living piece of New York City's rich culinary history.

The shoppe operates as a comprehensive bakery, cake shop, and pastry shop, with a dedicated specialization in custom wedding cakes. For locals across New York, Alfonso's is the reliable source for everything from a simple morning coffee and quick pastry to elaborate, multi-tiered celebration cakes for life’s most significant milestones. The extensive menu is a testament to its long-standing tradition, featuring classic Italian-American pastries and an enormous variety of layer cakes, cheesecakes, and cookies. The atmosphere is centered on a quick, efficient visit, allowing customers to easily pick up their pre-ordered items or select treats from the beautifully displayed showcases.

While the bakery maintains its decades-old reputation for spectacular custom cakes and classic items like cannolis, the business—now run by Alfonso's son, Anthony Campitiello—is focused on preserving its legacy while also embracing modern cake trends and maintaining a high volume of daily-fresh products. It stands out in the New York market for its blend of old-world quality and commitment to meeting the contemporary demands of a bustling urban clientele.

Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe is conveniently located at 1899 Victory Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10314. This central location in the heart of Staten Island makes it highly accessible for residents across the borough, particularly those in the Castleton Corners and surrounding neighborhoods. Victory Boulevard is a major thoroughfare, ensuring visibility and ease of travel.

A significant point of accessibility for all New Yorkers is the physical store’s layout. The establishment is equipped with a wheelchair accessible entrance, ensuring that all members of the community can easily visit and enjoy their vast selection of sweet treats. As the shop is designed primarily for takeout, customers typically spend a brief amount of time there, making it an ideal destination for a quick stop to pick up a dessert tray, a birthday cake, or a box of pastries. The focus on a 'Quick visit' is a key advantage for busy locals who value efficiency.

Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe provides a flexible array of services to meet the needs of their New York customers, from individual purchases to large-scale catering for events:

• Delivery: For customers who cannot make it to the store, delivery service is available, providing a convenient way to get cakes, cookies, and pastries right to their door across the local area.
• In-store Pickup: This essential service allows patrons who pre-order custom cakes, large cookie trays, or pastry platters to quickly and efficiently collect their items.
• Takeout: The primary mode of service, enabling customers to stop in, select individual pastries like the popular Cannoli or Napoleon, and quickly be on their way.
• Custom Cake Design: Specializing as a Wedding Bakery, Alfonso's takes custom orders for all occasions—including weddings, anniversaries, birthdays, and graduations—working with customers on bespoke designs, flavors, and fillings.
• Daily Offerings: Freshly brewed coffee is offered alongside the pastries, making it a perfect spot for a quick morning or afternoon pick-me-up.
• Payment Options: The shoppe accepts modern payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, such as Apple Pay and Google Pay, ensuring a fast and hassle-free transaction.

The unique selling proposition of Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe lies in its combination of classic Italian-American baking with an extraordinary range of specialty products and custom capabilities.

• Signature Italian Pastries: They are highly celebrated for their authentic, generously-filled Italian items, including the traditional Cannoli, the multi-layered Napoleon, Sfogliatelle, and Cream Puffs. The specialty Cannoli Lobster Tail and French Cream Lobster Tail are iconic treats not found everywhere.
• Extensive Cake Selection: The menu features a vast range of celebration cakes, from classic New York-style Cream Cheesecake and Strawberry Shortcake to decadent options like Chocolate Mousse Cake, Tiramisu Cake, and the very popular Rainbow Cookie Cheesecake.
• Wedding Bakery Expertise: The bakery is a trusted vendor for wedding and special event cakes across the New York metropolitan area, known for creating beautiful, multi-tiered cakes with a high degree of personalization in both design and flavor. Their ability to deliver a show-stopping cake that also tastes exceptional is a major highlight.
• Rainbow Cookie Creations: Alfonso’s showcases a distinct love for the classic Rainbow Cookie, incorporating it into other treats like the Rainbow Cookie Cheesecake, Rainbow Cookie Mousse Cake, and the unique Rainbow Cookie Donut, making them a go-to spot for this tri-colored favorite.
• Mini Pastry Trays: The availability of pre-arranged 2, 3, and 4 dozen Mini Pastry Trays is a perfect feature for New Yorkers hosting gatherings, providing a beautiful and varied dessert spread with zero effort.

For placing custom orders, inquiring about product availability, or obtaining any current information, patrons in New York can utilize the following contact details:

• Address: 1899 Victory Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10314, USA
• Phone: (718) 273-8802
• Mobile Phone (Local Reference): +1 718-273-8802

Customers are encouraged to call ahead, especially when ordering custom cakes or large trays for holidays and events, to ensure all details are confirmed by the professional staff.

Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe is absolutely worth choosing for any New Yorker looking for an authentic, high-quality bakery experience, particularly those on Staten Island. The primary value lies in its established legacy of tradition and the unparalleled breadth of its offerings. Few single locations can provide a classic Napoleon, a complex Rainbow Cookie Mousse Cake, and a custom-designed, multi-layer wedding cake—all with the same high standards. For those planning a significant event, Alfonso's reputation as a dedicated wedding bakery, complete with a wide selection of cake flavors, mousses, and fillings (such as Cannoli Cream, Hazelnut Mousse, and French Cream), makes it an essential choice.

Moreover, the sheer convenience factor is a strong draw for busy NYC users. The availability of delivery, in-store pickup, and a quick-visit atmosphere—supported by modern payment methods—ensures that getting a high-quality dessert is never a cumbersome task. Whether you're rushing to a family dinner and need a last-minute Tiramisu Cake or planning a large corporate event requiring dozens of mini pastries, Alfonso's is set up for efficiency. The commitment to maintaining classic Italian recipes, refined over decades and initially learned in Europe and prestigious Manhattan establishments, means every bite carries a sense of history and quality that mass-market bakeries cannot replicate.

The shop’s focus on specialty items like the lobster tails and unique rainbow cookie mash-ups gives customers a reason to visit specifically for those items, knowing they are getting a truly special product. Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe is, therefore, the ideal choice when a standard, everyday dessert simply won't do and a touch of New York tradition and culinary artistry is desired.

Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe

1899 Victory Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10314, USA