Amaya’s Deli

- 786 New Lots Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11208

Introduction / Overview

In a borough like Brooklyn, where the local deli is the true cornerstone of the community food scene, Amaya’s Deli stands out as a genuine neighborhood favorite in East New York. Far more than just a place to grab a quick snack, Amaya’s offers a sprawling and creative menu that covers every craving, from the earliest morning rush to a late-day comfort food fix. It's the kind of establishment that truly embodies the New York spirit: fast, friendly, and bursting with flavor. The local reputation for delivering "delicious food" across a wide variety of cuisines speaks to its commitment to quality and diversity.

Amaya’s Deli has skillfully woven together the classic New York deli experience with an exciting range of options, including Halal platters, creative “Exotic Sandwiches,” and a dedicated breakfast menu featuring rave-worthy Belgian waffles. This comprehensive approach means it serves as a one-stop-shop for a complete breakfast, a quick lunch, or a satisfying dinner, cementing its role as an essential part of the East New York culinary landscape. The focus here is on providing a meal that "feels like your neighborhood favorite," offering bold, comforting bites that are tailored to the local taste.

The menu is an adventure in itself. Where else can you start your day with a "Bacon Egg & Cheese Waffle" and end it with a savory plate of "Halal Chicken & Lamb Over Rice"? This flexibility is key to its popularity among Brooklynites who appreciate variety and convenience. Even when a minor hiccup occurs, such as a burnt sandwich, the overall feedback is overwhelmingly positive—a testament to the high standard of their regular offerings and their dedicated service. As one satisfied customer put it, the morning chef’s skill with the Belgian waffles is a definite "10/10" highlight.

Furthermore, Amaya’s commitment to community accessibility is notable. The acceptance of SNAP/EBT benefits for eligible items, which is crucial in New York City, ensures that high-quality, freshly prepared meals are available to a wider segment of the neighborhood. This feature elevates Amaya's status from a simple business to a vital neighborhood resource, providing both convenience and essential services to the East New York and surrounding Brooklyn areas.

***

Location and Accessibility

Amaya’s Deli is located at a prominent and convenient spot in Brooklyn, making it highly accessible for local residents and those commuting through the East New York area. The specific address is 786 New Lots Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11208, USA. New Lots Avenue is a main thoroughfare in the neighborhood, ensuring visibility and easy access.

For New Yorkers relying on public transit, the location is well-served by the public bus network that runs along New Lots Avenue. Additionally, the deli is situated in proximity to the subway stations serving the New Lots Avenue area, allowing for quick stops for those coming to or from work. The establishment's business hours are designed for convenience, operating daily from 8:00 AM to 8:00 PM for both pickup and delivery, ensuring that a fresh meal is available for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, seven days a week.

***

Services Offered

Amaya’s Deli is structured around maximum efficiency and customer convenience, reflecting the demands of the New York lifestyle. The primary services offered are:

• Delivery: Fast and reliable delivery service is available, bringing the expansive menu directly to your door, perfect for residents and businesses in the area.
• Takeout: Offering quick and efficient service for customers who prefer to pick up their orders in person.
• Breakfast Service: A full menu dedicated to morning meals, including a variety of unique waffles, omelettes, and classic New York-style breakfast sandwiches.
• Lunch and Dinner Service: A broad range of options for midday and evening meals, including signature sandwiches, paninis, burritos, and Halal platters.
• Online Ordering: Customers can easily place orders through the deli’s dedicated website or third-party delivery platforms for maximum ordering convenience.

***

Features / Highlights

What makes Amaya’s Deli a standout destination for New York foodies is the combination of its diverse, creative menu and its focus on local needs. The highlights include:

• SNAP/EBT Payment Acceptance: A critical feature for community accessibility, allowing customers to use their benefits for eligible food purchases.
• The Chopped Cheese Innovation: Taking the legendary New York staple and offering it in creative formats, such as the Chopped Cheese Quesadilla (with crispy chicken cutlet and hashbrown) and as an option for a Halal-style platter (Chopped Cheese Over Tice/Fries).
• Signature Waffle Menu: Praised by customers as "10/10," the dedicated waffle menu offers sweet and savory combinations like the Chicken & Waffles and Bacon Egg & Cheese Waffles.
• Halal and Gyro Offerings: Catering to a strong local demand with a variety of Over Rice and Gyro options, including Halal Chicken, Lamb, and Fresh Steak.
• Unique "Exotic Sandwiches" and Paninis: The menu encourages exploration with creatively named items like The Heart Attack, The King Party, and the Money Sign panini, promising bold, unconventional flavor combinations.
• Extensive Side Dish Variety: Offering numerous ways to complete a meal, from classic Mozzarella Sticks and Onion Rings to various fries, including Sweet Potato, Curly, and Tater Tots.
• All-Day Operational Hours: Consistent hours (8:00 AM - 8:00 PM) every day of the week ensure reliability for the busy New Yorker’s schedule.

***

Contact Information

Connecting with Amaya’s Deli to place an order or inquire about their offerings is simple and direct. For Brooklyn residents looking for the best in East New York, here is the essential information:

Address: 786 New Lots Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11208, USA

Phone: (929) 554-2163 (Mobile Phone: +1 929-554-2163)

***

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing a single dish at Amaya's Deli is a delightful challenge, as the menu is rich with local classics and inventive creations. However, a true New York deli experience demands starting with their signature and highly innovative offerings. The Chopped Cheese options are an absolute must-try, demonstrating how Amaya's elevates a simple staple. The Chopped Cheese Quesadilla is a particular standout, combining the savory, melted goodness of the chopped cheese with a crispy chicken cutlet and hashbrowns—a triple-threat of comfort and flavor that exemplifies creative deli cuisine.

For breakfast aficionados, the Belgian Waffles are the stars. With a customer rating of "10/10" for the morning chef's execution, the Chicken & Waffles and the Bacon Egg & Cheese Waffles are essential picks, turning a classic breakfast base into a hearty, all-in-one meal. For a simple but highly satisfying morning grab, the classic Egg & Cheese breakfast sandwich at just $3.50 offers a fantastic value proposition that caters to the everyday New York hustle.

At lunchtime or dinnertime, the Halal Chicken & Lamb Over Tice (or Fries) is a robust, flavorful, and filling choice, competing with some of the best street carts in the city but with the quality assurance of a local deli. For the adventurous eater, the mysterious Exotic Sandwiches—such as The Heart Attack or The East Ny—are worth a selection. While their contents are part of the fun of discovery, their unique names promise a hefty, memorable sandwich experience designed to please a Brooklyn palate.

Finally, the acceptance of SNAP/EBT makes this deli a necessary and responsible choice for many families in the area, providing access to a wide variety of fresh and hot food options that support the entire community.

Amaya’s Deli

786 New Lots Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11208, USA