Bagel & Bialys

- 1152 Willis Ave, Albertson, NY 11507

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers, a bagel is more than just a breakfast item; it's a way of life, a benchmark of local cuisine quality. When we talk about an authentic New York bagel shop, we’re looking for that perfect balance: a crispy, thin crust giving way to a dense, chewy interior, and a delicious aroma that fills the air. Bagel & Bialys in Albertson, NY, situated right on Long Island, is one of those essential local spots that truly lives up to the demanding expectations of the region. This establishment isn't just known for its bagels, but as the name suggests, it celebrates the lesser-known, yet equally traditional, bialy—a distinction that serious New York bread enthusiasts appreciate.

As a cornerstone of the Albertson community, Bagel & Bialys operates with a clear commitment to freshness and quality. Customer feedback frequently highlights the “fresh, soft, and tasty” nature of their bagels, noting that the aroma alone is a stand-out feature—a true sign of baking excellence. They offer a comprehensive menu that covers everything you need for the perfect start to your day, from a wide selection of bagels and homemade cream cheeses to full breakfast sandwiches and gourmet deli salads. Whether you're commuting through Nassau County or simply looking for the best breakfast in the area, this shop is dedicated to providing a quick, satisfying, and authentically New York experience.

The business has successfully blended traditional baking methods—with customers often observing the bagels coming straight out of the oven—with modern convenience, offering various services to suit the busy Long Island lifestyle. For those craving that genuine local taste without the chain store compromise, Bagel & Bialys in Albertson is clearly positioned as the preferred choice.

Location and Accessibility

Bagel & Bialys is conveniently located at 1152 Willis Ave, Albertson, NY 11507, USA. Willis Avenue is a major thoroughfare in Nassau County, making the location highly accessible for drivers across Long Island. This is particularly advantageous for customers who, as one reviewer noted, find it "absolutely worth coming off of the Long Island expressway" for a fresh stop during their commute between Queens and Suffolk County.

The shop understands the importance of ease and convenience for New York customers. Accessibility features ensure that everyone can enjoy their offerings:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Furthermore, parking is straightforward, a rarity in parts of New York, with options that include:

• Free parking lot
• Free street parking

This ease of access, combined with its centralized location in Albertson, makes it an ideal spot for a quick visit—a key factor for busy professionals and families on Long Island.

Services Offered

Bagel & Bialys has adapted its service model to meet the diverse needs of the modern New York customer, focusing on speed and convenience for breakfast and lunch fare:

• Delivery: For those days when you can't make it to the shop, customers in the local delivery radius can have their favorites brought right to their home or office.
• In-store pickup: Ideal for placing an order ahead of time and grabbing it quickly, minimizing wait time.
• Takeout: The traditional way to enjoy fresh bagels on the go, perfect for commuters.
• Breakfast offerings: Serving a full menu tailored for the most important meal of the day, including omelettes, breakfast sandwiches (like Bacon, Egg and Cheese), and a variety of specialty coffee drinks.
• Multiple Payment Methods: Accepting Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments ensures a fast and seamless checkout experience.

Features / Highlights

This Albertson bagel shop differentiates itself through a few crucial, New York-specific features:

• Dual Bread Specialty (Bagel & Bialy): Not all New York shops offer a true bialy, a flat, chewy baked roll with a depression (not a hole) traditionally filled with onions or poppy seeds. Bagel & Bialys provides both the classic bagel and the authentic bialy, offering patrons a choice between these two distinct Jewish-Polish culinary staples.
• Obsession-Worthy Freshness: Customers rave about the palpable freshness, noting that the bagels have a “crispy crunch on the outside and are soft and chewy on the inside” and often see them being pulled “straight out of the oven.” This commitment to made-on-premises quality is a hallmark of a top-tier New York bagel shop.
• Gourmet Cream Cheese Variety: The shop features an extensive array of homemade cream cheese options, from classic Plain CC and Vegetable Cream Cheese to unique flavors like Blueberry, Jalapeño, and premium Lox Spread, including several low-fat options.
• Full Deli Selection: Beyond breakfast, the shop offers an impressive range of Lox and Fish By the Pound (including Handcut Nova, Sturgeon, and Sable), various Bulk Deli Salads (like Whitefish Salad and Baked Salmon Salad), and Specialty Sandwiches and Wraps for a complete lunch experience.
• Exceptional Beverage Menu: Catering to all morning needs, they offer everything from a Coffee Box perfect for the office, various sizes of hot and iced coffee, to fresh offerings like Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice and several Smoothies (e.g., Strawberry Blueberry, Orange Mango).

Contact Information

Bagel & Bialys is ready to take your order for your next bagel fix or catering request. They are typically open early (5:00 AM) to serve the morning rush on Long Island, closing mid-afternoon (3:00 PM).

Address: 1152 Willis Ave, Albertson, NY 11507, USA

Phone: (516) 621-9520

Mobile Phone: +1 516-621-9520

What is worth choosing

If you live in or commute through the Long Island area of New York, Bagel & Bialys should be your primary destination for several compelling reasons. The core value proposition here is uncompromising quality and authenticity. In a state saturated with bagel shops, this location stands out by delivering bagels that meet the high-bar standards of the New York palate—chewy, fresh, and perfectly seasoned. Reviewers specifically call out the well-done seasoning on the everything bagel, highlighting the flavor profiles of the seeds and spices.

The true differentiator is the presence of the bialy. For those who appreciate the history and variety of New York's Jewish bakeries, finding a shop that masters both the boiled-then-baked bagel and the oven-only bialy is rare and highly prized. It offers a softer, more bread-like alternative that is often best enjoyed simply buttered, complementing the more robust texture of the classic bagel.

Beyond the bread, the menu offers a complete New York deli experience. From the decadent Belly Lox Sandwich and premium Handcut Nova to the impressive 13 different homemade cream cheeses, Bagel & Bialys provides the breadth of options necessary for a personalized and satisfying meal. The commitment to being a quick, convenient stop with free parking and multiple service options simply makes the whole experience seamless. Choosing Bagel & Bialys means choosing a superior, authentic New York bagel and a high-quality deli experience right here on Long Island, one that truly rivals any shop in the five boroughs.

Bagel & Bialys

1152 Willis Ave, Albertson, NY 11507, USA