Bagel Boys

- 598 Central Ave, Cedarhurst, NY 11516

Welcome to Bagel Boys on Central Avenue, a cornerstone of the Cedarhurst dining scene in the heart of Long Island's Five Towns area. More than just a typical bagel shop, Bagel Boys has established itself as a reliable destination for high-quality, freshly baked goods and a diverse menu of breakfast and lunch options. Serving the greater New York region, this establishment is celebrated for combining the classic New York bagel tradition with a commitment to excellent service and strict kosher standards. It’s a place where locals and visitors alike can start their day right or grab a satisfying midday meal, all within a friendly, fast-paced environment.

The core identity of Bagel Boys centers around its specialty: truly fresh bagels. New Yorkers know the difference between a good bagel and a great one, and Bagel Boys aims for the latter, baking a full line of bagels, bialys, twists, minis, sticks, and flats fresh daily on the premises. Beyond the bread, the shop functions as a full-service Kosher dairy restaurant and café, offering an extensive menu that caters to a wide variety of tastes and dietary needs. The commitment to maintaining a Dairy and Kosher kitchen, supervised by the Vaad Hakashrus, makes it a vital resource for the local community, ensuring trust and peace of mind for those observing Jewish dietary laws, including Cholov Yisroel, Pas Yisroel, and Yoshon products.

What truly sets Bagel Boys apart is the sheer variety available, particularly in their famous salads and sandwiches. A review highlights the surprisingly large selection of house-made spreads and fillings. For instance, customers looking for a simple tuna salad sandwich can often choose between original, regular, veggie, balsamic, spicy, honey mustard, or low-fat veggie options. This level of customization and attention to fresh ingredients, including using crisp lettuce stalks instead of romaine for enhanced freshness, underscores a focus on quality that keeps customers returning. The menu extends well beyond bagels, encompassing egg dishes, specialty paninis, wraps, chopped salads, and various sweet treats, solidifying its position as an all-day food provider.

Location and Accessibility

Bagel Boys is strategically located on Central Avenue in Cedarhurst, New York, placing it in a busy commercial hub easily accessible to residents of the Five Towns area and beyond. Cedarhurst is well-known for its vibrant Jewish community and excellent local businesses, making Bagel Boys a central figure for daily food needs.

The official address is:

Bagel Boys

598 Central Ave, Cedarhurst, NY 11516, USA

The location offers several key accessibility features designed to accommodate all patrons:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance: Ensuring easy access for all customers.
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot: Dedicated spots for convenient access.
• Wheelchair accessible seating: Comfortable dining options inside the establishment.

For those traveling by car, parking options include both paid parking lot and paid street parking in the surrounding area. This central location in Nassau County makes it an easy stop for a quick bite whether you are running errands, commuting, or meeting friends for breakfast.

Services Offered

Bagel Boys is committed to offering flexible service options to meet the needs of its bustling New York clientele, whether you're in a hurry or planning a large event. The establishment operates not only as a typical bagel shop and restaurant but also as a dedicated Catering food and drink supplier, making it a great choice for corporate breakfasts, community events, or family gatherings.

Available customer services include:

• Delivery: Conveniently get your fresh bagels, sandwiches, and salads brought directly to your home or office.
• In-store pickup: Order ahead and quickly grab your meal at the counter.
• Takeout: Perfect for customers who want to enjoy their food on the go.
• Dine-in: Space is available for patrons who wish to enjoy their meal inside the restaurant.
• Catering: Specialized service for larger orders, offering an array of platters and full meals for any event.

In terms of payment, the store offers a variety of modern and convenient options for a quick transaction:

• Credit cards
• Debit cards
• NFC mobile payments (like Apple Pay or Google Pay)

Features / Highlights

Bagel Boys distinguishes itself from other local eateries through several key features, blending community values with quality cuisine.

• Certified Kosher Dairy & Parve Menu: The entire menu is under the strict supervision of the Vaad Hakashrus, ensuring all food meets high Jewish dietary standards (Dairy, Parve, Cholov Yisroel, Pas Yisroel, Yoshon).
• Fresh, On-Premises Baking: A vast selection of bagels, bialys, twists, rolls, and more are baked fresh daily, offering that authentic, perfect New York texture and flavor.
• Extensive Salad and Sandwich Options: Patrons enjoy a non-cheap, generous approach to portions and an impressive variety of sandwich fillings and specialty salads, going beyond standard offerings with options like six different types of tuna salad.
• Full Breakfast & Lunch Menu: Serving as a primary Breakfast restaurant and Lunch restaurant, the shop offers more than just bagels, including coffee, egg dishes, specialty paninis, wraps, and house-made sweets.
• Great Staff Presence: The store often has a lot of staff on hand, which helps keep the service moving efficiently, minimizing wait times for many customers—a crucial factor for New Yorkers on a quick visit.
• Quick Visit Focus: The dining option is listed for a "Quick visit," underscoring the store's dedication to providing prompt and efficient service for those with a busy schedule.
• Quality of Produce: A commitment to using fresh ingredients, such as lettuce stalks for extra freshness in salads and sandwiches, points to a dedication to food quality that enhances the customer experience.

Contact Information

For direct inquiries, ordering ahead, or catering questions, you can reach Bagel Boys at the following contact points:

Address:

598 Central Ave, Cedarhurst, NY 11516, USA

Phone:

(516) 374-7644

What is Worth Choosing at Bagel Boys

When considering where to find your next great New York meal, Bagel Boys offers a compelling package, particularly for those in the Five Towns area. The main appeal lies in the rare combination of an expansive menu, guaranteed kosher certification, and fresh, baked-in-house products. For those seeking reliable dietary compliance, the oversight from the Vaad Hakashrus is a significant, value-added benefit that few standard bagel shops can offer. This means patrons can be confident in the integrity of everything from their classic plain bagel to their specialty wraps and salads.

Furthermore, the positive customer feedback consistently highlights two aspects: great food and generous portions. When you're paying for a sandwich or a salad, the promise of not being "cheap on the portions" is a major draw. The ability to customize your choice from a wide array of quality fillings—such as the six different tuna salad varieties—ensures that every visit can be a new culinary adventure, tailored exactly to your preference. While some customer experiences suggest occasional challenges with order accuracy or staff communication, the commitment to fresh, plentiful, and high-quality food, backed by ample staff to move the line, generally makes Bagel Boys a preferred destination.

Ultimately, whether you are stopping by for a quick cup of hot coffee and an egg sandwich to power your morning, or you need a large catering order of fresh salads and baked goods for a business lunch, Bagel Boys is a fixture in Cedarhurst that delivers consistent quality and convenience. It is a local favorite that embodies the spirit of New York's robust and specialized food culture, making it well worth a visit on Central Avenue.

Bagel Boys

598 Central Ave, Cedarhurst, NY 11516, USA