Baviello Italian Deli

- 216 Old Tappan Rd #16, Old Tappan, NJ 07675

In New Jersey, the title of 'deli' carries significant weight, especially in Bergen County, where quality, authenticity, and a true Italian influence are non-negotiable standards. Baviello Italian Deli in Old Tappan stands as a testament to these values, offering a local, friendly, and high-quality experience that elevates the classic deli visit. It’s a place where the fresh scent of imported meats, daily-made mozzarella, and warm, crusty bread signals that you are about to enjoy an authentic meal that is a step above the ordinary.

Baviello is more than just a counter service; it is a full-fledged Italian specialty shop and a vital part of the Old Tappan community. While some seek 'over-stuffed' quantity, Baviello has built its reputation on the quality of its ingredients and the dedication to true Italian deli fare. Customers consistently highlight the freshness of the bread and the superior taste of their meats and homemade items, recognizing that this focus on quality justifies their pricing and sets them apart from the competition.

From specialty sandwiches named after Italian cultural icons to classic breakfast selections and savory hot heroes, Baviello Italian Deli serves as a reliable culinary hub for locals. The shop is also highly regarded for its robust catering service, making it a go-to choice for feeding meetings, parties, and family gatherings across North Jersey. Under the friendly guidance of the owner, Carol, Baviello delivers pleasant service and top-notch food, ensuring a satisfying experience for every patron who walks through the door.

Location and Accessibility

Baviello Italian Deli is conveniently situated in a central location within Old Tappan, making it easily accessible for residents and those working or traveling through the area. Finding the perfect deli is always easier when accessibility is a priority, and Baviello’s location ensures just that. The full address is:

216 Old Tappan Rd #16, Old Tappan, NJ 07675, USA

Its positioning allows for quick visits, perfect for grabbing a sandwich or a catering order on the way to or from work. Baviello has adopted several service options to maximize customer convenience. Patrons can easily run in for In-store shopping or utilize modern options like Curbside pickup, Delivery, In-store pickup, and Takeout. For those driving, the location includes a Wheelchair accessible parking lot, ensuring ease of access for all community members.

It is important to note their operating hours for planning a visit: Monday through Friday, they are open from 7:00 AM to 5:00 PM, and on Saturday, from 9:00 AM to 3:00 PM. They are closed on Sundays, particularly during the summer months, a detail helpful for local planning.

Services Offered

Baviello Italian Deli provides a comprehensive menu that extends far beyond a simple sandwich counter, offering a full range of Italian-American deli staples, specialized offerings, and daily homemade items. Their core services and menu categories include:

• Custom Sandwiches and Wraps: Customers can create their perfect meal using a wide array of premium Boar’s Head meats (including Roasted Turkey, Imported Prosciutto, and Hot & Sweet Soppressata), cheeses, and fresh breads (Round Roll, Club Roll, White, Rye, Whole Wheat, Terranova, and Gluten-Free options). All sandwiches can be made into a variety of Wraps (Plain, Whole Wheat, Sundried Tomato, Spinach).
• Specialty Sandwiches: The menu features famously named creations like the 'Godfather,' 'Scarface,' 'Soprano,' 'Italian Stallion,' and the 'Bronx Tale,' each built with a carefully curated combination of Italian cold cuts and fresh toppings.
• Hot Heroes: Offering satisfying, warm options such as Balboa, Traditional Philly Cheesesteak, Eggplant Parmigiana, Chicken Parmigiana, Meatball Parmigiana, and Sausage & Peppers.
• Paninis: Pressed-to-perfection sandwiches with Italian-themed names like the 'Arthur Avenue,' 'Brooklyn Bridge,' and 'Little Italy.'
• Homemade Sides and Salads: Featuring freshly made options like Tri-Color Pasta, Cucumber & Tomato Salad, Antipasto Salad, and the highly-regarded Fresh Mozzarella, which is made daily. They also offer classic deli salads by the pound, including Potato, Macaroni, and Tuna or Chicken Salad.
• Hot Daily Specialties and Soups: Including sautéed Italian Spinach, Broccoli Rabe, Grilled Portobello Mushroom, and the popular homemade Turkey Chili, as well as classic soups like Chicken Noodle and Pasta Fagioli.
• Breakfast Selections: Serving a dedicated morning menu with options such as Egg on a Roll, Hobo, Bobo, and Sobo on a Roll, available as sandwiches, wraps, or heroes.
• Catering: A full-service catering division that has been approved for local school district lunch deliveries, specializing in Italian-style platters and large orders for events and meetings.
• Take-Home Items: Offering fresh and frozen Italian items for convenience, including Homemade Marinara Sauce, Vodka Sauce, Meatballs, Fried Eggplant, Assorted Ravioli, Manicotti, and Stuffed Shells.

Features / Highlights

Baviello Italian Deli distinguishes itself in the highly competitive North Jersey market through several key features that appeal to the local palate:

• Commitment to Quality: The deli’s reputation is built on using quality ingredients, with customers noting the higher caliber of meats and daily-made food, which sets their offerings a "step above the others."
• Daily Fresh Mozzarella: A major highlight is their Fresh Mozzarella, which they make daily, ensuring the utmost freshness and authentic Italian flavor in their signature sandwiches.
• Proprietary Specialty Sandwiches: The uniquely named 'Godfather,' 'Scarface,' and 'Soprano' sandwiches draw devoted customers looking for specific, expertly crafted Italian combinations.
• Homemade Deli Sides and Chili: The availability of homemade take-home items like Marinara Sauce, Meatballs, and particularly Carol's homemade Turkey Chili are major draws for local families.
• Full Catering Services: Baviello is a recognized and approved caterer in the local community, reliable for both corporate and private events.
• Exceptional Customer Service: The owner, Carol, and staff are consistently described as very friendly and pleasant, fostering a warm and welcoming neighborhood atmosphere.
• Customer Loyalty Program: The availability of a punch card for a free sandwich after purchasing ten incentivizes repeat visits and rewards their loyal clientele.

Contact Information

To place an order for pick-up, delivery, or catering, please use the following information:

Address: 216 Old Tappan Rd #16, Old Tappan, NJ 07675, USA

Phone: (201) 666-6750

What Is Worth Choosing

For New Jersey residents seeking a deli experience where ingredient quality takes precedence, Baviello Italian Deli is the clear choice. While some may prioritize sheer size, Baviello focuses on delivering authentic, superior taste—a dedication that is deeply valued by those who appreciate true Italian provisions. The core reason to choose Baviello is their commitment to freshness, especially their daily-made mozzarella and fresh bread, which truly distinguish their sandwiches.

A must-try for any first-time visitor is one of their Specialty Sandwiches. The Godfather (featuring imported mortadella, hot ham cappy, smoked mozzarella, and sun-dried tomato) or the Scarface (with salami, hot ham cappy, prosciutto, imported sharp provolone, and hot peppers) offer complex, authentic Italian flavor profiles that showcase the best of their cold cuts. For something lighter but equally satisfying, the Carol's homemade Turkey Chili is a highly recommended comfort food that has earned local fame.

Moreover, Baviello serves as an ideal solution for any meal need, from a quick and easy Egg on a Roll breakfast to the convenience of stocking your fridge with Take Home items like their homemade sauces and meatballs. In a town where quality and community matter, Baviello Italian Deli provides not just a meal, but a taste of genuine North Jersey Italian-American tradition, delivered with a smile and a commitment to excellence.

Baviello Italian Deli

216 Old Tappan Rd #16, Old Tappan, NJ 07675, USA