Butterworths Bagel Bakery

- 50 Bi State Plaza, Old Tappan, NJ 07675

For residents across Bergen County, the quest for the perfect New Jersey bagel often leads to one reliable location: Butterworths Bagel Bakery in Old Tappan. This local bagel shop has cemented its status as a community cornerstone, offering more than just morning fuel—it provides a tradition of quality, fresh ingredients, and genuine neighborhood hospitality. Whether you’re a lifelong New Jersey resident or new to the area, a visit to Butterworths is an essential local experience that celebrates the Garden State's love affair with the authentic, kettle-boiled, and baked-fresh bagel.

Stepping inside, you're immediately greeted by the aroma of freshly baked goods and brewing coffee, a sign that the day is starting right. Butterworths is well-regarded for its consistency and dedication to the craft, producing bagels that are famously not too chewy, always fresh, and hailed by many as among the best in the county. But this bakery is about much more than just a great bagel; its extensive menu, warm service, and deep commitment to the Old Tappan community ensure that it remains a beloved spot from the first crack of dawn until mid-afternoon.

From the classic plain bagel with a schmear of their delicious cream cheese to the fully loaded Jersey breakfast sandwich featuring Taylor Ham, Egg, and Cheese, Butterworths Bagel Bakery covers all the bases for breakfast, brunch, and lunch. They've built a reputation for reliable, fast service, making them the perfect stop for locals dashing out for a busy day or those looking to sit and enjoy a moment of morning calm. This is a family-owned place that operates with pride, making every customer feel like part of the family.

Location and Accessibility

Conveniently situated in the Bi State Plaza, Butterworths Bagel Bakery is easily accessible for anyone in the Old Tappan area and surrounding Bergen County towns. Its location makes it a quick and practical stop for commuters and local families alike. The address is:

50 Bi State Plaza, Old Tappan, NJ 07675, USA

The bakery understands the needs of its diverse customer base, offering a variety of conveniences to ensure a smooth and pleasant visit. Accessibility features are a key priority, making it easy for everyone to enjoy their offerings. Furthermore, the availability of ample, free parking is a huge benefit in a busy shopping center, allowing patrons to quickly grab their order without hassle.

For those who prefer to stay in or are just passing through, Butterworths has embraced modern convenience. The availability of multiple service options—from in-store pickup to curbside service—reflects their commitment to accommodating every lifestyle. Whether you are rushing through your morning routine or planning a group meal, their location and service model are designed to put the customer first. This attention to detail is part of what makes them a staple in the North Jersey area.

Services Offered

Butterworths Bagel Bakery offers an incredibly diverse and comprehensive menu, covering everything from a simple cup of coffee to full catering platters. Their offerings go far beyond the expected, establishing them as a full-service deli and bakery. Key categories on their menu include:

• Classic Bagel Selection: Featuring a variety of freshly baked bagels available individually or by the Baker's Dozen.
• Bagels with Spreads: Options range from classic Plain Cream Cheese and Flavored Cream Cheese to premium spreads like Lox Cream Cheese and Fresh Nova and Cream Cheese.
• Signature Breakfast Sandwiches: A highly popular selection including the NJ-favorite Taylor Ham, Egg and Cheese, Bacon, Egg and Cheese, Sausage Egg & Cheese, and the hearty Steak, Egg and Cheese Sandwich. Specialized items like the "BOBO" are also available.
• Omelettes and Platters: Serving substantial breakfast meals like the Big Breakfast Platter, Western Omelettes, Spinach Omelettes, and Meat and Cheese Omelettes, all served with Hash Browns.
• Specialty Breakfast Items: Including the Protein Wrap and Breakfast Burrito for a quick, filling start to the day.
• Classic and Signature Sandwiches: Their all-day menu includes deli favorites like the Tuna Sandwich, Turkey Club Sandwich, Chicken Cutlet Sandwich, and hot options like the Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich, Italian Bomber Sandwich, and Hot Roast Beef Special Sandwich.
• Fresh Salads: Offering a light option with choices like the Garden Salad, Chef Salad, and Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad, as well as by-the-pound deli salads such as Tuna Salad, Chicken Salad, and Egg Salad.
• Sweet Desserts: A well-stocked case of fresh baked goods including Black & White Cookies, Plain Crumb Cake, Cinnamon Rolls, and various Pound Cakes and Croissants.
• Beverages: A full coffee bar with hot and iced options, plus a selection of other drinks including smoothies (Strawberry, Strawberry and Banana), Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice, Naked Juice, and classic bottled beverages like Snapple and Gatorade.
• Catering/Group Options: Family-style offerings like the Butterworth Bagel Platter and Baker's Dozen Value Packs are perfect for feeding a crowd.

This vast selection ensures that whether you’re craving a savory lunch or a sweet treat, or need to cater a meeting, Butterworths has high-quality options made fresh daily.

Features / Highlights

The reputation of Butterworths Bagel Bakery is built upon several core features that resonate deeply with the local New Jersey clientele. These are the elements that keep customers coming back week after week:

• Authentic, Freshly Made Bagels: Known for a quality that rivals the best in the state, with customers praising them for being fresh daily and having the perfect texture.
• Community Support: The bakery is an active supporter and contributor to local causes, including Old Tappan Social Services, demonstrating a deep commitment to the well-being of the community.
• Extensive Menu Variety: Beyond standard bagels, the shop offers a full deli menu with signature sandwiches, homemade salads by the pound (like Chicken Salad noted as one of the best in the area), and made-to-order omelettes and wraps.
• Customer-Centric Service: Described by regulars as having a friendly, professional staff that provides quick service, creating a welcoming and reliable 'go-to' atmosphere.
• Convenient Service Options: Offering Curbside pickup, Delivery, In-store pickup, and Takeout, they maximize convenience for their busy customers.
• Accessibility and Parking: Equipped with a Wheelchair accessible entrance and parking lot, plus a free parking lot for easy access.
• Inclusive Environment: Known to be an LGBTQ+ friendly and Transgender safe space, fostering a welcoming environment for all community members.

Contact Information

For easy planning, here is the essential contact information for Butterworths Bagel Bakery:

Address: 50 Bi State Plaza, Old Tappan, NJ 07675, USA

Phone: (201) 666-8111

What Is Worth Choosing

In a region saturated with bagel shops, what makes Butterworths Bagel Bakery the worthiest choice for New Jersey locals? It boils down to a perfect blend of high-quality products and genuine community spirit. The foundation is their bagel—fresh, handmade, and consistently excellent, living up to the high standards of a true New Jersey bagel. But the real value is in the expansive menu that extends throughout the day.

If you are looking for a true local flavor, the Taylor Ham, Egg and Cheese Sandwich is a must-try, a quintessential Jersey breakfast executed to perfection. For a full meal, their Signature Sandwiches, like the Hot Roast Beef Special or the Philly Cheese Steak, offer hearty, satisfying options that transition perfectly from breakfast to lunch. Customers also highly recommend their various deli salads, with the Chicken Salad frequently mentioned as being top-notch in the area.

Ultimately, choosing Butterworths means supporting a reliable, family-owned business that gives back to its community—evidenced by their contributions to local initiatives like Old Tappan Social Services. It’s a place where the staff remembers your regular order and the quality of the food never wavers. It’s a reliable staple, a welcoming environment, and simply put, the best spot to secure an authentic, top-tier bagel and a delicious meal in the Old Tappan area. For a quick visit, a morning routine, or a group order, Butterworths Bagel Bakery provides the superior local choice.

Butterworths Bagel Bakery

50 Bi State Plaza, Old Tappan, NJ 07675, USA