Bay Coffee Shop: A Brooklyn Favorite for Breakfast, Lunch, and Authentic Mexican Cuisine

Bay Coffee Shop Introduce

In a city as dynamic as New York, finding a local gem that consistently delivers great food and a welcoming atmosphere is a treasure. For Brooklyn residents, the Bay Coffee Shop, located right on 86th Street, has established itself as that kind of reliable neighborhood fixture. More than just a place for a quick caffeine fix, this spot serves as a full-service restaurant and diner, specializing in a vast selection of classic American and Greek dishes, alongside a surprisingly extensive and authentic Mexican menu.

Known for being a comfortable and casual spot favored by locals, Bay Coffee Shop is a go-to choice for all dining occasions: whether you're starting your day with a hearty breakfast, grabbing a quick lunch, or settling in for a satisfying dinner. With a commitment to offering a diverse menu, from a classic omelette to genuine Mexican platillos, Bay Coffee Shop ensures there is a comfort food option for virtually every palate in the Bath Beach neighborhood.

---

Location and Accessibility on 86th Street

The Bay Coffee Shop is conveniently situated at 1950 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11214, placing it in the heart of the bustling Bath Beach/Bensonhurst area of Brooklyn. Its location on a major commercial thoroughfare makes it highly accessible for both local foot traffic and those traveling via public transit.

For New Yorkers relying on the MTA, the location is a prime benefit. The coffee shop is located extremely close to the Bay Pkwy station. This station is served by the D train (6 Avenue Express) and the N train (Broadway Local) subway lines. MTA accessibility information indicates that this subway stop is just about a one-minute walk from the area of the coffee shop, providing excellent transit convenience.

In addition to the subway, the area is well-served by several bus lines, with stops such as 86 St/Bay Pkwy and Bay Pkwy/86 St also located just a minute's walk away. Bus lines serving this major intersection include the B1, B6, B82, and B82-SBS. For those driving, paid street parking is available in the vicinity, which is a key consideration in this busy section of Brooklyn. The casual and cozy atmosphere, coupled with its ease of access for locals, solidifies Bay Coffee Shop as a true neighborhood hub.

---

Services Offered

Bay Coffee Shop is not a one-note operation; it’s a full-fledged dining establishment that blends the fast service of a coffee shop with the expansive offerings of a classic diner, with a strong focus on Mexican cuisine. Its services and dining options cater to a wide range of needs throughout the day.

Dine-in Service: Offering a casual and cozy atmosphere with table service for an enjoyable meal experience.
Takeout & Delivery: Customers can enjoy the extensive menu from the comfort of their home or office via takeout and delivery options.
Catering: While not explicitly detailed in the provided data, many full-service diners offer catering, and the extensive menu suggests the potential for event services.
Daily Dining Options: The establishment is a popular spot for Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, and Dinner, with options available for a quick bite or a full, multi-course meal.
Family-Friendly: Recognized as being good for kids, making it a welcoming environment for families in the neighborhood.

---

Features and Highlights

What truly sets Bay Coffee Shop apart is the sheer variety of its menu, which stretches far beyond typical coffee shop fare. The highlights include a dedicated focus on quality beverages and an extensive food menu that encompasses breakfast staples, American diner classics, Greek specialties, and authentic Mexican dishes.

Great Coffee and Tea Selection: The foundation of any great coffee shop, Bay Coffee Shop is noted specifically for its great coffee and a great tea selection.
All-Day Breakfast & Diner Staples: The menu offers a massive selection of Omelettes (like the Ranch Omelette or a classic Bacon Omelette), French Toast, Pancakes, and various Breakfast Specials (including Romanian Steak with Eggs).
Extensive Mexican Menu: A defining feature is the deep dive into Mexican cuisine, which includes, but is not limited to: Tacos (Pollo, Bistec, Camaron, Barbacoa, etc.), Sopas (Sopa De Mariscos, Sopa De Pollo), Burritos, Fajitas, Quesadillas, Enchiladas (Verdes, Rojas, De Mole), and a variety of Platillos (Camarones A La Mexicana, Mole Poblano, Mojarra Frita).
Classic Diner and Comfort Food: Beyond breakfast and Mexican options, the menu covers a wide range of Comfort Food and American standards, such as Unbeatable Burgers, Triple Decker Clubs, Cold Platters, and various types of Sandwiches.
Greek Specialties: The menu also features popular Greek items, including Chicken Souvlaki and Beef and Chicken Gyros.
Payment Flexibility and Amenities: The shop accepts a variety of payment methods, including major Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments. It provides an on-site Restroom for customer convenience and allows Dogs outside for patrons with pets.

---

Contact Information

For inquiries, to place an order for pickup, or for delivery information, you can reach the Bay Coffee Shop at the following:

Address: 1950 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11214, USA

Phone: (718) 975-3906

---

What is Worth Choosing

If you are a New Yorker looking for variety, convenience, and a casual setting, Bay Coffee Shop offers a compelling reason to visit. The sheer breadth of the menu means you can return multiple times and try something completely new. The combination of classic American diner ambiance, reliable breakfast fare, and the unexpected depth of the authentic Mexican and Greek selections makes it a unique find in the neighborhood.

The coffee shop is particularly worth choosing for:

Authentic Mexican Dishes: For those craving real Mexican fare, the selection of **Enchiladas Verdes**, **Huaraches**, or a hearty **Sopa De Mariscos** is highly recommended and often praised by customers. One customer specifically noted the enchiladas verdes as "great," served with rice and beans.
Breakfast Power: With over thirty different omelette options, including the specialty **New Bay Omelette** or the **Farmers Omelette**, alongside deluxe pancakes and waffles, this is a strong destination to start your day.
Unbeatable Accessibility: The location is a huge draw. Being virtually adjacent to the **Bay Pkwy subway station (D, N trains)** and major bus routes makes it an ideal stop for commuters and anyone using public transportation in Brooklyn.

While some customer reviews mention occasional service issues, particularly related to order accuracy during peak times, the overall feedback points to a vast and satisfying menu, a great value, and the appeal of the food itself. The Bay Coffee Shop remains a beloved spot for locals seeking a cozy, neighborhood place to grab comfort food, great coffee, and a taste of diverse culinary traditions—all conveniently under one roof on 86th Street.

Bay Coffee Shop Coffee

New Bay's Omelettes
Plain Omelette $8.50
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling.
Cheese Omelette $10.00
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling with cheese.
Pizza Omelette $10.00
Mozzarella and marinara sauce.
Mozzarella, Tomato, Sausage And Mushroom Omelette $12.50
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling with mozzarella, tomato, sausage and mushroom.
Spanish Omelette $10.00
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling.
Western Omelette $10.50
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling.
Bacon Omelette $10.00
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling with bacon.
Ham Omelette $10.00
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling with ham.
Sausage Omelette $10.00
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling with sausage.
Bacon, Tomato And Onion Omelette $11.00
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling with bacon, tomato and onion.
Ham, Tomato And Onion Omelette $11.00
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling with bacon, tomato and onion.
Sausage, Tomato And Onion Omelette $11.00
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling with bacon, tomato and onion.
Broccoli Omelette $10.00
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling with broccoli.
Spinach Omelette $10.00
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling with spinach.
Onion Omelette $9.00
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling with onion.
Pepper Omelette $9.00
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling with pepper.
Mushroom Omelette $10.00
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling with mushroom.
Feta Cheese Omelette $10.50
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling with feta cheese.
Greek Omelette $10.50
Feta, tomato and onion.
Nova Scotia Lox And Onion Omelette $13.00
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling.
Pastrami Omelette $10.00
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling with pastrami.
Corned Beef Omelette $11.00
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling with corned beef.
Turkey Omelette $10.00
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling with turkey.
Chorizo Omelette $10.00
Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling with chorizo.
Mexican Omelette $11.00
Served with choice of onion, tomato, jatapeno or peppers.
Vegetarian Omelette $12.50
Broccoli, onion and tomato.
Farmers Omelette $13.00
Mushrooms, onions, tomato, peppers and American cheese.
Popeye Omelette $13.00
Egg white, spinach and turkey.
California Omelette $13.00
Broccoli, mushroom, tomato and cheddar cheese.
Italian Omelette $12.00
Mozzarella cheese, sausage, tomato and basil.
D'Light Omelette $14.00
Egg white and choice of avocado, cilantro, jalapeho or peppers.
New Bay Omelette $13.00
Corned beef, onion, tomato and Swiss cheese.
Ranch Omelette $14.00
Chicken, corn, cilantro and mozzarella cheese.
Mediterranean Omelette $13.50
Gyro, tomato, onion and oregano.
Huevos A La Mexicana $12.00
Eggs.
Huevos Rancheros $10.00
Eggs.
Huevos Rancheros With Grilled Chicken $14.00
Eggs.
Huevos Rancheros With Steak $14.00
Eggs.
Huevos Rancheros With Mexican Sausage $14.00
Eggs.
Huevos Rancheros With Bacon $12.00
Eggs.
Huevos Rancheros With Ham $12.00
Eggs.
Huevos Rancheros With Sausage $12.00
Eggs.

New Bay's Breakfast Special
Romanian Steak With 2 Eggs $26.00
Served with potatoes and toast. Substitute bagel, bialy, English muffin or pita for an additional charge. Tomato instead of potato for an additional charge.
1 Egg Any Style Breakfast $4.00
Served with potatoes and toast. Substitute bagel, bialy, English muffin or pita for an additional charge. Tomato instead of potato for an additional charge.
1 Egg Any Style With Meat Breakfast $6.00
Choice of bacon, ham, or sausage. Served with potatoes and toast. Substitute bagel, bialy, English muffin or pita for an additional charge. Tomato instead of potato for an additional charge.
2 Eggs Any Style Breakfast $6.00
Served with potatoes and toast. Substitute bagel, bialy, English muffin or pita for an additional charge. Tomato instead of potato for an additional charge.
2 Eggs Any Style With Meat Breakfast $9.00
Choice of bacon, ham, or sausage. Served with potatoes and toast. Substitute bagel, bialy, English muffin or pita for an additional charge. Tomato instead of potato for an additional charge.
2 Eggs Any Style With Corned Beef Hash Breakfast $10.50
Choice of bacon, ham, or sausage. Served with potatoes and toast. Substitute bagel, bialy, English muffin or pita for an additional charge. Tomato instead of potato for an additional charge.
2 Eggs Any Style With Beef Sausage Breakfast $11.50
Choice of bacon, ham, or sausage. Served with potatoes and toast. Substitute bagel, bialy, English muffin or pita for an additional charge. Tomato instead of potato for an additional charge.
2 Eggs Any Style With Chorizo Breakfast $12.00
Choice of bacon, ham, or sausage. Served with potatoes and toast. Substitute bagel, bialy, English muffin or pita for an additional charge. Tomato instead of potato for an additional charge.
2 Eggs Any Style With Turkey Breakfast $10.50
Choice of bacon, ham, or sausage. Served with potatoes and toast. Substitute bagel, bialy, English muffin or pita for an additional charge. Tomato instead of potato for an additional charge.
2 Eggs Any Style With Turkey Bacon Breakfast $10.50
Choice of bacon, ham, or sausage. Served with potatoes and toast. Substitute bagel, bialy, English muffin or pita for an additional charge. Tomato instead of potato for an additional charge.
2 Eggs Any Style With Turkey Sausage Breakfast $10.50
Choice of bacon, ham, or sausage. Served with potatoes and toast. Substitute bagel, bialy, English muffin or pita for an additional charge. Tomato instead of potato for an additional charge.
Pancakes Breakfast $7.50
Thin flat cake.
Old Fashion French Toast Breakfast $7.50
Pan fried bread.
Pancakes With Meat Breakfast $9.50
Thin flat cake with bacon, ham or sausage.
Old Fashion French Toast With Meat Breakfast $9.50
Pan fried bread with bacon, ham or sausage.
Pancakes Deluxe Breakfast $11.50
Served with bacon, ham and sausage.
French Toast Deluxe Breakfast $11.50
Served with bacon, ham and sausage.
Super Deluxe Breakfast $12.50
Served with bacon, ham, sausage and 2 eggs any style.
Pancakes Monte Cristo Style Breakfast $12.50
Served with turkey, ham and melted Swiss cheese.
French Toast Monte Cristo Style Breakfast $12.50
Served with turkey, ham melted Swiss cheese.
Pancakes With 1 Fruit Breakfast $9.00
Thin flat cake with 1 fruit.
Pancakes With Banana, Strawberry And Blueberry Breakfast $12.50
Thin flat cake with banana, strawberry and blueberry.

Bagel Center
Toasted Bagel With Butter And Jelly $3.00
Boiled and baked round bread roll with butter and jelly.
Toasted Bagel With Cream Cheese $3.00
Boiled and baked round bread roll with cream cheese.
Toasted Bagel With Nova Scotia Lox And Cream Cheese $9.00
Boiled and baked round bread roll with nova scotia lox and cream cheese.
Toasted Bagel With Lox, Cream Cheese, Onion, Lettuce And Tomato $11.00
Boiled and baked round bread roll with lox, cream cheese, onion, lettuce and tomato.

Muffins and Bagels
Toasted Bagel With Butter And Jelly $3.00
Bread made from the yeast with butter and jelly.
Toasted Bialy With Butter And Jelly $3.00
Toasted Bagel With Cream Cheese $3.00
Bread made from the yeast with cream cheese.
Toasted Bialy With Cream Cheese $3.00
Toasted Bagel With Cream Cheese And Lox $9.00
Bread made from the yeast with cream cheese and lox.
Toasted Bialy With Cream Cheese And Lox $9.00
Toasted Bagel With Nova Scotia Lox $11.00
Served with cream cheese, sliced onion, lettuce and tomato.
Toasted Bialy With Nova Scotia Lox $11.00
Served with comes cheese, sliced onion, lettuce and tomato.
Golden Brown Toast $1.50
Toasted English Muffin $1.75
Yeast leavened bread.
Homemade Muffin $2.50
Choice of com, bran or blueberry.
Homemade Muffin With Butter And Jelly $2.75

From the Griddle
Short Stack Pancakes $6.00
Thin flat cake.
Golden Brown Pancakes $8.00
Thin flat cake.
Golden Brown Pancakes With Bacon $10.00
Thin flat cake with bacon.
Golden Brown Pancakes With Ham $10.00
Thin flat cake with ham.
Golden Brown Pancakes With 2 Eggs $12.00
Thin flat cake with 2 eggs.
Blueberry Pancakes $10.00
Thin flat cake with blueberry.
Strawberry Pancakes $10.00
Thin flat cake with strawberry.
Silver Dollar Pancake $9.00
Thin flat cake.
French Toast $7.50
Pan fried bread. Served with butter and syrup.
French Toast With Strawberry Preserves $10.00
Pan-fried bread with strawberry preserves. Served with butter and syrup.
French Toast With Blueberry Preserves $10.00
Pan-fried bread with blueberry preserves. Served with butter and syrup.
French Toast With 2 Eggs $11.00
Pan-fried bread with 2 eggs. Served with butter and syrup.

New Bay's Waffles
Waffle $7.50
Thick cake made from leavened batter or dough.
Waffle With Strawberry $10.00
Thick cake made from leavened batter or dough with strawberry.
Waffle With Banana $10.00
Thick cake made from leavened batter or dough with banana.
Waffle With Bacon $9.50
Thick cake made from leavened batter or dough with bacon.
Waffle With Sausage $9.50
Thick cake made from leavened batter or dough with sausage.
Waffle With Ice Cream $9.00
Thick cake made from leavened batter or dough with ice cream.
Waffle With Banana, Strawberry And Blueberry $12.50
Thick cake made from leavened batter or dough with banana, strawberry, and blueberry.
Waffle Super Deluxe $14.00
Served with bacon, ham, sausage and 2 eggs any style.

Soup
Soup

Sopas
Sopa De Pollo $9.00
Chicken.
Sopa De Pancita $15.00
Sopa De Camaron $16.00
Shrimp.
Sopa De Mariscos $18.00
Seafood.
Sopa De Lentejas $9.00

Salads
Caesar Salad $8.00
Crisp hearts of romaine lettuce with our special Caesar dressing, croutons and Parmesan cheese.
Chicken Caesar Salad $14.00
Our specially seasoned Caesar salad with strips of grilled chicken breast placed gently on top of crisp romaine lettuce with croutons and Parmesan cheese.
Greek Salad $11.50
Greek Salad With Chicken $14.50
Mixed Green Salad $7.00
Fresh salad with a variety of green vegetables typically served on a bed of lettuce.
Mixed Green Salad With Grilled Chicken $10.00
Fresh salad with a variety of green vegetables typically with grilled chicken. Served on a bed of lettuce.
Chicken Salad $11.00
Salad with poultry.

Tacos
Pollo Taco $3.00
Chicken.
Bistec Taco $4.00
Beef steak.
Chorizo Taco $4.00
Mexican sausage.
Carnitas Taco $3.00
Fried Pork.
Lengua De Vaca Taco $5.00
Cow tongue.
Camaron Taco $5.00
Shrimp.
Barbacoa Taco $5.00
Lamb.
Vegetariano Taco $3.00
Rice, beans and sour cream. Vegetarian.

Tortas
Pollo Asada Torta $10.00
Grilled chicken.
Milanesa Pollo Torta $10.00
Chicken cutlet.
Carne Asada Torta $11.00
Beef steak.
Milanesa De Res Torta $11.00
Breaded beef.
Chorizo Torta $10.00
Mexican sausage.
Jamon Torta $10.00
Ham.
Huevo Con Chorizo Torta $11.00
Egg with Mexican sausage.
Norteña Torta $12.00
Onion, jalapeño, cheese, avocado, chorizo, beef and beans.
Cubana Torta $14.00
Grilled chicken, breaded beef, egg, ham, bacon, cheese, avocado, lettuce, tomato, beans, mayonnaise and jalapeño.

Nachos
Pollo Nacho $12.00
Chicken.
Chorizo Nacho $1.00
Mexican sausage.
Bistec Nacho $13.00
Beef steak.
Carnitas Nacho $12.00
Fried pork.
Lengua De Vaca Nacho $14.00
Cow tongue.
Camaron Nacho $16.00
Shrimp.

Burritos
Vegetariano Burrito $10.00
Vegetarian.
Pollo Burrito $12.00
Chicken.
Chorizo Burrito $12.00
Mexican sausage.
Carnitas Burrito $12.00
Fried pork.
Bistec Burrito $12.00
Beef steak.
Camaron Burrito $14.00
Shrimp.
Lengua De Vaca Burrito $14.00
Cow tongue.

Fajitas
Fajitas De Res $16.00
Cooked strips of meat wrapped in a tortilla.
Fajitas De Pollo $15.00
Cooked strips of meat wrapped in a tortilla.
Fajitas De Camaron $18.00
Cooked strips of meat wrapped in a tortilla.
Fajitas De Mixtas $18.00
Cooked strips of meat wrapped in a tortilla.

Flautas
Pollo Flautas $13.00
Chicken.
Queso Flautas $13.00
Cheese.
Carne Bistec Flautas $14.00
Beef.
Carnitas Flautas $13.00
Fried pork.

Sincronizada
Sincronizada $9.00
Jamon, queso, guacamole, jalapeños and sour cream salad.

Sopes
Pollo Sope $12.00
Chicken.
Bistec Sope $13.00
Beef steak.
Chorizo Sope $13.00
Mexican sausage.
Carnitas Sope $12.00
Fried pork.
Lengua De Vaca Sope $16.00
Cow tongue.

Cemitas
Pollo Asado Cemita $10.00
Grilled chicken.
Milanesa Pollo Cemita $10.00
Breaded chicken.
Milanesa De Res Cemita $10.00
Breaded beef.
Bistec Cemita $10.00
Beef.
Norteña Cemita $12.00
Chorizo Cemita $11.00
Mexican sausage.
Cubana Cemita $12.00

Quesadillas
Hongos Con Queso Quesadilla $13.00
Mushrooms and cheese.
Bistec Quesadilla $13.00
Beef steak.
Pollo Quesadilla $13.00
Chicken.
Chorizo Quesadilla $13.00
Mexican sausage.
Camaron Quesadilla $16.00
Shrimp.
Lengua De Vaca Quesadilla $16.00
Cow tongue.
Barbacoa Quesadilla $16.00
Lamb.

Enchiladas
Enchiladas Verdes $13.00
Enchiladas Rojas $13.00
Enchiladas De Mole $16.00
Enchiladas Suizas $14.00

Huaraches
Carne Bistec Huarache $12.00
Beef.
Chorizo Huarache $12.00
Mexican sausage.
Pollo Huarache $11.00
Chicken.
Carnitas Huarache $11.00
Fried pork.
Barbacoa Huarache $15.00
Lengua De Vaca Huarache $15.00
Camaron Huarache $15.00

Platillos
Camarones A La Mexicana $18.00
Camarones A La Diabla $18.00
Camarones Al Mojo De Ajo $18.00
Mojarra Frita $19.00
Filete De Pescado $16.00
Salmon Al Gusto $20.00
Ray-finned fish.
Mole Poblano $16.00
Chuletas Al Gusto $16.00

Especiales del Dia
Chilaquiles Verdes $12.00
Fried tortillas with salsa and cheese.
Chilaquiles Rojos $12.00
Fried tortillas with salsa and cheese.
Bistec A La Mexicana $15.00
Thinly cut beef.
Bistec Encebollado $15.00
Thinly cut beef.
Pollo A La Mexicana $14.00
Chicken.
Pollo Asado $14.00
Chicken.
T-Bone Steak $25.00
Jalapenos, cebolla y nopales.
Lengua Al Gusto $18.00
Carnitas Al Gusto $16.00
Mexican pork dish.
Barbacoa $18.00
Slow cooked over an open flame.
Barbacoa With Cebolla, Jalapeño Y Nopales $20.00
Pollo En Salsa Verde $16.00
Costillas Al Gusto $16.00

Tasty Sandwiches
1 Fried Egg Sandwich $4.00
Pan-cooked eggs.
1 Fried Egg Sandwich With Bacon $5.50
Pan-cooked eggs with bacon.
1 Fried Egg Sandwich With Ham $5.50
Pan-cooked eggs with ham.
2 Fried Eggs Sandwich $5.50
Pan-cooked eggs.
2 Fried Eggs Sandwich With Bacon $6.50
Pan-cooked eggs with bacon.
2 Fried Eggs Sandwich With Ham $6.50
Pan-cooked eggs with ham.
Western Egg And Ham Sandwich $7.00
Ham and egg sandwich with pepper and onion.
Potato And Egg Sandwich $5.50
Bacon, Egg And Cheese Sandwich $7.50
Fried Filet Of Sole On A Roll $10.00
Ham, Bacon, Cheese With Lettuce And Tomato On A Roll $8.50
Grilled American Cheese Sandwich $5.00
Hot sandwich filled with cheese that has been pan cooked or grilled.
Grilled American Cheese Sandwich With Bacon $7.00
Hot sandwich filled with cheese and bacon that has been pan cooked or grilled.
Grilled American Cheese Sandwich With Ham $7.00
Hot sandwich filled with cheese and ham that has been pan cooked or grilled.
Grilled American Cheese Sandwich With Tomato $5.50
Hot sandwich filled with cheese and tomato that has been pan cooked or grilled.
Grilled Swiss Cheese Sandwich $5.00
Hot sandwich filled with cheese that has been pan cooked or grilled.
Grilled Swiss Cheese Sandwich With Bacon $7.00
Hot sandwich filled with cheese and bacon that has been pan cooked or grilled.
Grilled Swiss Cheese Sandwich With Ham $7.00
Hot sandwich filled with cheese and ham that has been pan cooked or grilled.
Grilled Swiss Cheese Sandwich With Tomato $6.00
Hot sandwich filled with cheese and tomato that has been pan cooked or grilled.
Grilled Cheddar Cheese Sandwich $5.00
Hot sandwich filled with cheese that has been pan cooked or grilled.
Grilled Cheddar Cheese Sandwich With Bacon $7.00
Hot sandwich filled with cheese that has been pan cooked or grilled.
Grilled Cheddar Cheese Sandwich With Ham $7.00
Hot sandwich filled with cheese and ham that has been pan cooked or grilled.
Grilled Cheddar Cheese Sandwich With Tomato $6.00
Hot sandwich filled with cheese and tomato that has been pan cooked or grilled.
Fresh Tuna Salad Sandwich $7.00
Chilled creamy mild fish sandwich.
Fresh Chicken Salad Sandwich $6.00
Chilled creamy mild chicken sandwich.
Fresh Egg Salad Sandwich $5.00
Chilled creamy mild egg sandwich.
Lettuce And Tomato Sandwich $4.00

Cold Platters
Homemade Fresh Chicken Salad Platter $10.00
Poultry.
Tuna Fish Salad Platter $10.00
Cold salad with shredded tuna.
Individual Tuna Platter $10.00
Egg Salad Platter $10.00

Triple Decker Clubs
Turkey And Bacon Triple Decker Club $12.00
Ham And Swiss Cheese Triple Decker Club $10.00
Roast Beef And Bacon Triple Decker Club $12.00
Tuna And Sliced Eggs Triple Decker Club $12.00
Chicken Salad And Bacon Triple Decker Club $12.00
Grilled Chicken And Bacon Triple Decker Club $12.00

Broiled Seafood
Shrimps On Rice In Lemon Butter Sauce $18.00
Jumbo Shrimp Scampi In Butter Sauce $18.00
Jumbo Shrimp Scampi In Garlic Sauce $18.00
Filet Of Sole In Lemon With Wine Sauce $18.00
Norwegian Salmon Filet With Lemon $18.00
Norwegian Salmon Filet With Garlic $18.00
Norwegian Salmon Filet With Olive Oil $18.00
Broiled.

Fried Seafood
Jumbo Shrimp With Tartar Sauce $18.00
Filet Of Sole With Tartar Sauce $18.00

On Garlic Bread
BBQ Grilled Chicken On Garlic Bread $10.50
Buttery bread that is topped with garlic.
Broiled Filet Of Sole On Garlic Bread $12.00
Buttery bread that is topped with garlic.
Philly Cheese Steak On Garlic Bread $12.00
Buttery bread that is topped with garlic.
Grilled Roast Beef On Garlic Bread $12.00
Buttery bread that is topped with garlic.
Mozzarella Cheese And Onion On Garlic Bread $10.00
Buttery bread that is topped with garlic.

Our New Gourmet Wraps
Tuna, Lettuce, And Tomato Wrap $9.00
A rolled-filled tortilla or flatbread with tuna, lettuce and tomato.
Grilled Chicken Mixed Salad Wrap $9.00
A rolled-filled tortilla or flatbread with grilled chicken mixed salad.
Grilled Chicken Greek Salad Wrap $9.00
A rolled-filled tortilla or flatbread with grilled chicken Greek salad.
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap $9.00
A rolled-filled tortilla or flatbread with grilled chicken Caesar salad.
Turkey BLT Wrap $10.00
A rolled-filled tortilla or flatbread with turkey.

Greek Specialties
Chicken Souvlaki $9.00
Chunks of marinated chicken breast served in warm pita bread with tzatziki sauce, lettuce, tomato and onions.
Chicken Souvlaki Platter $12.00
Chunks of marinated chicken breast served in warm pita bread with french fries, small Greek salad and tzatziki sauce.
Beef Gyro $9.00
Served in warm pita bread with tzatziki sauce, lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Chicken Gyro $9.00
Served in warm pita bread with tzatziki sauce, lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Gyro Platter $13.00
Beef or chicken. Served in warm pita bread with french fries, small Greek salad and tzatziki sauce.

Carving Board
Grilled Chicken Carving Board $9.00
Corned Beef Carving Board $9.00
Pastrami Carving Board $9.00
Beef Carving Board $9.00
Meatloaf Carving Board $10.00
Roast Vermont Turkey Carving Board $9.00
All White Meat Roast Vermont Turkey Carving Board $9.00

Unbeatable Burgers
Jumbo Beef Burger $6.00
The best you ever tasted.
Jumbo Beef Burger Deluxe $9.00
The best you ever tasted.
Cheeseburger $8.00
Covered with melted cheese.
Cheeseburger Deluxe $11.00
Covered with melted cheese.
Cheddar Burger $8.00
Tangy cheddar cheese melted on top.
Cheddar Burger Deluxe $11.00
Tangy cheddar cheese melted on top.
Bacon Burger $9.00
Strips of crispy bacon.
Bacon Burger Deluxe $12.00
Strips of crispy bacon.
Bacon Cheese Burger $9.50
Melted American cheese and bacon.
Bacon Cheese Burger Deluxe $13.00
Melted American cheese and bacon.
Pizza Burger $8.00
Mozzarella and pizza sauce.
Pizza Burger Deluxe $12.00
Mozzarella and pizza sauce.
Mushroom Burger $8.00
Topped with loads of mushroom.
Mushroom Burger Deluxe $11.50
Topped with loads of mushroom.
California Burger $8.50
Served with lettuce, tomato, onion and mayonnaise on hard roll.
California Burger Deluxe $12.50
Served with lettuce, tomato, onion and mayonnaise on hard roll.
Turkey Burger $8.50
Ground turkey patty served on a bun.
Turkey Burger Deluxe $12.50
Ground turkey patty served on a bun.
Vegetable Burger $7.50
Meatless burger.
Vegetable Burger Deluxe $10.50
Meatless burger.
Twin Burger Platter Deluxe $16.00
2 juicy burgers.
Twin Cheese Burger Platter Deluxe $18.00
Topped with melted American cheese.

New Bay Wraps
Caesar Salad With Chicken Wrap $11.00
A rolled-filled tortilla or flatbread and Caesar salad with chicken.
Caesar Salad With Shrimp Wrap $11.00
A rolled-filled tortilla or flatbread and Caesar salad with shrimp.
Greek Salad With Chicken Wrap $12.00
A rolled-filled tortilla or flatbread and Greek salad with chicken.
Greek Salad With Shrimp Wrap $12.00
A rolled-filled tortilla or flatbread and Greek salad with shrimp.
House Salad With Chicken Wrap $10.00
A rolled-filled tortilla or flatbread and basic vegetable salad with chicken wrap.
House Salad With Shrimp Wrap $10.00
A rolled-filled tortilla or flatbread and basic vegetable salad with shrimp wrap.
Meat Vegetable Wrap $10.00
A rolled-filled tortilla or flatbread and meat vegetable.
Chicken Salad Wrap $10.00
A rolled-filled tortilla or flatbread and chicken salad.

Sandwiches
Chicken Cutlet Milanese Sandwich
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Sandwich

Hot Open Sandwiches
Hot Open Sliced Turkey Sandwich $11.50
White meat. Served with brown gravy and cranberry sauce.
Hot Open Roast Sirloin Of Beef Sandwich $11.50

Specialty Sandwiches
Grilled Reuben Sandwich $12.00
Corned beef or pastrami and sauerkraut, grilled on rye bread, topped with melted Swiss cheese. Served with potato.
Grilled Cheese Deluxe $9.00
Served with French fries, lettuce and tomato.
Fries Fillet Of Sole Deluxe Sandwich $13.00
Served with French fries on the toasted bun with tartar sauce, lettuce and tomato.
Open Slices Steak Sandwich $16.00
Broiled with our chef's magic hands, placed on bun with French fries, onion rings, lettuce and tomato.
Happy Waitress Sandwich $10.00
Open faced grilled cheese with strips of bacon, tomato and French fries.
Tuna Salad Melted Sandwich $10.00
Open grilled cheese on rye with tuna salad. Served with French fries.
Chicken Salad Melted Sandwich $10.00
Open grilled cheese on rye with chicken salad. Served with French fries.
Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich $12.00
Thin sliced steak on a roll sauteed onions, peppers, and melted cheese. Served with French fries.

Grilled Chicken Deluxe Sandwiches
Grilled Chicken Deluxe Sandwich $10.00
Grilled Chicken With Melted Cheese Deluxe Sandwich $11.00
Grilled Chicken Oriental Deluxe Sandwich $10.00
Onions and peppers.
Grilled Chicken Italian Deluxe Sandwich $11.50
Mozzarella, roasted pepper and grilled tomatoes.
Grilled Chicken Deluxe Sandwich $11.50
Cheddar cheese and mushroom.

For the Weight Conscious
Tuna Fish Salad $9.00
Served with lettuce, tomato and fresh fruit.
Grilled Chicken $9.00
Served on bed of lettuce with cottage cheese, lettuce and tomatoes.

Meat and Chicken Gyro
Gyro Sandwich $8.00
Beef or chicken. Cooked on a spit and wrapped in a pita.
Gyro Deluxe $11.00
Beef or chicken. Served with salad and french fries on pita.
Sliced Steak On Garlic Bread $15.00
Served with french fries, lettuce, tomato, onion rings and cup of soup.
Buffalo Wings $9.00
Served with choice of hot or blue sauce and french fries.
Chicken Fingers $9.00
Served with choice of hot or blue sauce and French fries.

On the Side
French Fries $4.00
French Fries With Cheese And Gravy $6.00
Curly Fries $5.00
Onion Rings $5.00
Home Fries $4.00
Baked Potato $4.00
Mashed Potato $4.00
Potato Salad $4.00
Coleslaw $4.00
Feta Cheese $4.00
Mozzarella Sticks $8.00
6 pieces.
Side Of Spaghetti With Marinara Sauce $9.00

Lunch Plate Specials
Baked Meatloaf Lunch Plate $12.50
Loaf made from seasoned and baked ground meat.
Hot Open Roast Beef Lunch Plate $12.50
Sliced beef that has been cooked over dry heat.
Hot Open Turkey Lunch Plate $12.50
Pasta Penne Lunch Plate $12.00
Narrow tube shaped pasta.
Penne With Grilled Chicken Lunch Plate $15.00
Narrow tube shaped pasta with grilled chicken.
Penne With Shrimp Lunch Plate $18.00
Narrow tube shaped pasta with shrimp.
Penne With Beef Lunch Plate $16.00
Narrow tube shaped pasta with beef.
Penne With Salmon Lunch Plate $18.00
Narrow tube shaped pasta with salmon.

Dinner Plate Specials
Roumanian Steak Dinner Plate $25.00
Pork Chops Dinner Plate $14.00
Thick cut of meat from a pig typically cut from the spine.
Chopped Steak With Fried Onions Dinner Plate $15.00
Ground sirloin patty with fried onions.
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Dinner Plate $14.00
Served with spaghetti.
Grilled Chicken Over Rice Dinner Plate $14.00
Served with broccoli.
Broiled Filet Of Sole Dinner Plate $18.00
Cooked in an oven.
Broiled Filet Of Salmon Dinner Plate $18.00
Cooked in an oven.

Desserts
Ice Cream
Milk Shake $5.00
Thick Shake $4.00
Jell-O $2.50
Homemade Cake $3.00

Beverages
Coffee
To Go Coffee
Tea
To Go Tea
Decaffeinated Tea
To Go Decaffeinated Tea
Herbal Tea
To Go Herbal Tea
Hot Chocolate $3.50
Juice $5.00
Orange, tomato, apple, pineapple, grapefruit or cranberry.
Juice To Go
Orange, tomato, apple, pineapple, grapefruit or cranberry.
Iced Coffee $4.00
Chocolate Milk $5.00
Canned Soda $2.00
Bottled Soda $3.00
Snapple Drink $2.00
Spring Water $1.00
Seltzer With Lemon $2.00
Milk Shake
Shake
Mango, strawberry, banana, papaya or blackberry.
Aguas Frescas

Bay Coffee Shop Details

Service options
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Great coffee
Great tea selection

Popular for
Breakfast
Lunch
Solo dining

Offerings
Coffee
Comfort food
Quick bite

Dining options
Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dessert
Table service

Amenities
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy

Crowd
Locals

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Parking
Paid street parking

Pets
Dogs allowed outside

Bay Coffee Shop Photos

Bay Coffee Shop Location

Bay Coffee Shop

New York Kings County Bath Beach 86th Street

1950 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11214, USA

Bay Coffee Shop Reviews

An average rating of ★4.2 from 147 user reviews.

dinereggfood servicebacondeliverytax

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

I’ve come here many times. At first it was ok,But most of the time we get a waitress that doesn’t speak any English and we’re left waiting for nearly half an hour for something to eat- and the place is nearly empty.When the food comes, it’s not exactly what we asked for, because they do not understand us when we place the order details.Also, we ordered turkey burgers deluxe, and as you can see in the pictures, it’s a shameful pancake thin turkey burger.We were left frustrated and dissatisfied.
September 06 · B. Saszare
Food was great. The service was friendly and the menu has lots variety of food. I ordered enchilada verdes, served with rice and beans.
June 19 · Esmeralda C
Ordered beef burrito with fries and mushroom quesadilla. Portions are big. Drinks: mango milk shake( very tasty) and orange juice. The service is good and the waitress was attentive.A bit on the pricey side though.
January 09 · Mieriem Abdullaieva
20240408::overcharged. got a burger(frozen)$7.50 and an egg salid sandwich(lack luster) $5, pricing according to menu should have come out to $12.50. was charged $15.40 with tax. not going to bore u with 8.875% out of $15.40, or before tax $14.15. so why was i charged $2.90 more? what i know is im not eating here again. btw i tip'd $3 on top of this. they are going to need tipif anyone reads this. other comments also states overcharging the check.
April 12 · OH yeah
classic diner with a huge menu. good selection of mexican food as well to appeal to the local population.they can be very busy on the weekends. the few mexican dishes that I tried were a bit bland for me. I would recommend sticking with the classic American diner food.however it could just be that I didn't order the right dishes
April 14 · Nisa