Bill's Supper Club

- 57 E 54th St, New York, NY 10022

Bill's Supper Club is more than just a restaurant; it’s a living piece of New York City history, reborn for the modern era. Located in a beautiful 19th-century townhouse in Midtown, this establishment captures the timeless elegance of a classic New York dining experience with a contemporary twist. Once a legendary speakeasy known as Bill's Gay Nineties, the restaurant has been thoughtfully reimagined to evoke the sophisticated, club-like atmosphere of the late fifties and early sixties, reminiscent of iconic social clubs like 21 and The Stork Club. It’s a place where you can feel the nostalgia while enjoying a dining experience that is entirely relevant and fresh. With its rich history—including stories of legends like Marilyn Monroe and James Cagney singing at the piano—Bill's Supper Club offers a truly unique and memorable atmosphere.

The menu at Bill's Supper Club is a celebration of classic American fare, balancing sophistication with comforting, familiar dishes. While the ambiance is elevated, the food is grounded in quality and tradition. Patrons can indulge in a range of expertly crafted dishes, from hearty sandwiches and salads to prime steaks and chops. Whether you're in the mood for a light bite or a full-course meal, the diverse menu has something for every palate. The kitchen excels at perfecting classics, as noted by a customer review praising the "absolutely delicious" crab cake and "unreal delicious" side of bacon. The focus on high-quality ingredients and meticulous preparation ensures that every dish is both satisfying and memorable.

The restaurant's interior is as much a part of the experience as the food. The space spans two distinct floors, each offering a different vibe. As one customer review notes, the first floor serves as a lively bar area, perfect for socializing and enjoying a drink, while the second floor provides a quieter, more intimate dining experience. This dual-level setup makes it a great choice for both casual gatherings and more formal dinners. The décor, with its nod to a bygone era and features like a working fireplace, creates a cozy and warm atmosphere that encourages guests to relax and stay a while. The presence of live music adds to the supper club ambiance, offering a layer of entertainment that enhances the overall experience.

Beyond the food and atmosphere, the service at Bill's Supper Club is a key highlight. Customers consistently praise the friendly and attentive staff, from the bartenders to the management. The personalized service and welcoming vibe make guests feel special, whether they are a regular or a first-time visitor. The restaurant is LGBTQ+ friendly and a transgender safe space, fostering an inclusive environment for everyone. This dedication to hospitality and community sets Bill’s Supper Club apart as not just a place to eat, but a place to feel welcomed and appreciated.

Bill’s Supper Club is perfect for a variety of occasions. It's a popular spot for both lunch and dinner, making it a versatile choice for a business meeting, a celebratory meal, or a solo dining experience. The counter service option and ability to make reservations cater to both spontaneous visits and planned events. The restaurant's appeal to "locals" and "groups" further highlights its role as a central and beloved part of the Midtown community.

Location and Accessibility

Located at 57 E 54th St, New York, NY 10022, USA, Bill's Supper Club is situated in a prime Midtown location. The address is conveniently placed between Madison and Park Avenues, making it easily accessible for professionals working in the area, tourists staying in nearby hotels, and residents of the surrounding neighborhoods. The location is well-served by public transportation, with the E and M subway lines at Lexington Avenue/53rd Street just a short walk away. For those traveling by car, there is paid street parking available, which, while typical for the area, is a useful option. The restaurant also offers wheelchair-accessible seating, demonstrating a commitment to welcoming all guests.

Services Offered

• Outdoor seating: For a pleasant dining experience during warmer weather, Bill's Supper Club offers outdoor seating.
• Takeout: Customers can enjoy the restaurant's delicious food from the comfort of their home or office with convenient takeout service.
• Dine-in: The full dine-in experience, complete with table service, is available on both the bar and dining floors.
• Catering: The restaurant offers catering services, making it a great choice for corporate events or private parties.
• Counter service: For a quicker option, counter service is available.
• Reservations: Reservations are accepted and recommended, especially for dinner, ensuring a seamless dining experience.

Features and Highlights

• Iconic Ambiance: The restaurant is housed in a historic 19th-century townhouse, featuring a cozy and trendy atmosphere with a fireplace and stylish decor.
• Live Music: The presence of live music, particularly jazz, adds to the quintessential supper club experience, creating a special and vibrant atmosphere.
• Exceptional Drinks: The bar offers a "great cocktails" and a "great wine list," with customer favorites including well-balanced espresso martinis. A full bar is available with beer, wine, and hard liquor.
• Diverse Menu Offerings: The menu includes a variety of comfort food, organic dishes, and options for different dietary needs, including vegan and vegetarian choices.
• Late-Night Food: For those looking for a bite after hours, late-night food is offered.
• Amenities: The restaurant provides a bar onsite, gender-neutral restrooms, and Wi-Fi for guests.

Contact Information

Bill's Supper Club is located at 57 E 54th St, New York, NY 10022, USA. For reservations or general inquiries, you can call them at (212) 590-2455 or +1 212-590-2455.

What is Worth Choosing

Bill's Supper Club is a destination worth choosing for a New Yorker who appreciates a dining experience rich with history and modern sophistication. The food is a major draw, particularly the prime meat dishes. The "20oz Bone In Ny Strip" and "2 Double Bone Lamb Chops" from the in-house aged chops section are perfect for a special occasion. For something more casual, the "Bill's 1890' Burger & Fries" is a highly-rated, satisfying classic. The "Jumbo Lump Crab Cake" is also a customer favorite, described as "meaty and flavorful," and is a perfect small plate to start your meal.

The restaurant's beverage program is another highlight. The "great cocktails" and "great wine list" provide the perfect pairing for any meal. The Espresso Martini is noted as being "well-balanced and not overly sweet." Beyond the food and drinks, the atmosphere is what truly makes Bill's Supper Club stand out. The combination of a cozy setting, live music, and a warm, attentive staff creates a truly exceptional dining experience. It's a place where you can celebrate, socialize, or simply enjoy a fantastic meal in an environment that feels both historic and exclusive. The fact that the manager personally greets customers underscores the high level of hospitality that makes this a great choice for anyone looking for a memorable night out in New York City.

Bill's Supper Club

57 E 54th St, New York, NY 10022, USA