Brooklyn Square Pizza Seaford NY: Long Island's Best Brooklyn-Style Pizza and Italian Catering

Brooklyn Square Pizza Introduce

For residents of New York, especially those on Long Island looking for that authentic taste of a true Brooklyn-style pie without the bridge traffic, Brooklyn Square Pizza in Seaford is a must-visit destination. This establishment brings a classic, much-loved style of pizza and a full Italian menu right to the heart of Nassau County. It’s more than just a pizzeria; it’s a family-friendly restaurant, an American and Italian kitchen, and a dedicated caterer, all rolled into one.

Known widely for its signature square slices and crispy, fluffy crusts, Brooklyn Square Pizza prides itself on using fresh ingredients and time-honored family recipes. From a quick slice during a busy lunch break to a full, comforting Italian dinner, the menu offers a diverse range of options that appeal to every craving, including specialty pizzas, heroes, entrées, and fresh salads. The casual and welcoming atmosphere makes it an ideal spot for solo diners, groups, and local families alike.

The focus here is not just on volume but on quality and flavor, with many patrons raving about the distinct, tangy tomato sauce and the perfect bake of their Sicilian-style pies, which some fans compare favorably to the best squares available in New York City's boroughs. Whether you are craving the classic cheese, the popular Buffalo Chicken, or the rich Alla Vodka slice, this Seaford spot is committed to delivering a consistently excellent New York pizza experience.

Location and Accessibility

Brooklyn Square Pizza is conveniently situated on the highly trafficked 3620 Merrick Rd in Seaford, NY 11783, USA, making it a central and easily accessible location for the local Long Island community. The restaurant is located in Nassau County, an area served by the establishment’s extensive delivery and catering services. This prime Merrick Road spot ensures it’s a natural stop for residents in Seaford and surrounding towns, including Wantagh, Massapequa, Bellmore, and North Bellamere.

Accessibility is a key priority for the business, ensuring a comfortable experience for all patrons. The location provides both a Free parking lot and Free street parking, eliminating the stress of finding a spot, especially during peak dining hours. Furthermore, the premises are designed for inclusivity, featuring Wheelchair accessible parking lot and Wheelchair accessible seating, so everyone can enjoy a meal with ease. The dining area has a casual, comfortable ambiance that encourages guests to relax, whether they are dining in or simply waiting for their takeout order.

Services Offered

Brooklyn Square Pizza is a full-service Italian and American eatery offering a wide array of options to meet any dining need, from individual meals to large-scale events.

Dine-in Service: Enjoy a meal in the casual, family-friendly dining room with seating available, perfect for groups or a solo dining experience. Reservations are accepted for planning convenience.
Takeout (Carryout) & Curbside Pickup: Place your order by phone or online and pick it up hot and fresh. Curbside pickup offers a convenient, quick, and no-contact option.
Delivery & No-Contact Delivery: Full delivery service is provided throughout the local area, including a no-contact option for maximum safety and convenience.
Catering Services: The restaurant offers comprehensive full-service catering across Long Island for parties, corporate events, and family gatherings, featuring pasta trays, salads, specialty pizzas, and Italian classics with generous, shareable portions.
Family Special Dinner: A specific dinner package designed for families looking for a complete, budget-friendly meal, often including an entrée, pasta, and salad.
Quick Bite & Lunch Special: Ideal for local workers or quick stops, offering individual slices, rolls, heroes, and a dedicated Lunch Special option.
Payment Flexibility: Accepts modern payment methods, including Debit Cards and NFC Mobile Payments, in addition to traditional forms.
Late-Night Food: Caters to those late-night cravings, offering a quick bite after the sun goes down.

Features / Highlights

The restaurant’s reputation is built on specific features that differentiate its offering from a typical local pizza shop. These highlights stem from its commitment to authentic flavors, variety, and customer experience.

Signature Brooklyn Square (Sicilian) Pizza: The namesake specialty, known for its thick, yet airy and crispy crust, generously topped with a rich, tangy tomato sauce. This is a must-try for any pizza enthusiast.
Extensive Specialty Slice Selection: Offers an incredible variety of by-the-slice options, including popular choices like Buffalo Chicken, Chicken Bacon Ranch, Alla Vodka, and Eggplant & Ricotta, ensuring there is always something new to try.
Full Italian & American Menu: Beyond pizza, the menu includes a complete range of Italian favorites such as Baked Ziti, Lasagna, Linguine Pescatore, and classic Entrées like Chicken Francese, Chicken Marsala, and Eggplant Parmigiana.
Family and Vegetarian Options: The menu features numerous fresh salads, including the Pecan Salad and Spinach Salad, as well as dedicated vegetarian choices like the Veggie Wrap and Sautéed Spinach/Broccoli, alongside a dedicated Kids’ Only menu.
Freshly Prepared Appetizers and Sides: Popular starters include Wings (Buffalo or BBQ), Baked Clams, Calamari, and the highly-rated Garlic Knots and Rolls (like the Sausage Roll or Chicken Roll).
Dog-Friendly Outdoor Area: Allows patrons with pets to dine comfortably, with a policy of Dogs allowed outside.
Family-Friendly Environment: Known for being good for kids, providing high chairs, and having a welcoming environment for large groups and families.

Contact Information

For placing an order, making a reservation, or inquiring about catering, the restaurant is easily reachable through the following information:

Address: 3620 Merrick Rd, Seaford, NY 11783, USA

Phone: (516) 804-8004

What is Worth Choosing

Brooklyn Square Pizza has earned its reputation in the Seaford community and across Long Island by offering high-quality food that is both comforting and authentic. What truly sets this local business apart is its specialty pizza—particularly the Brooklyn Square (Sicilian) Pizza and the Grandma Pizza. Patrons consistently highlight the crispy, perfectly baked crust and the distinctive sauce as the foundation of their superior product. Unlike many pizzerias, this location is noted for making its square slice better than even some highly-regarded competitors.

Beyond the pizza, the establishment excels as a full-spectrum Italian kitchen. The extensive menu, featuring everything from Heroes like the Chicken Cutlet Hero to full Entrées and Pasta dishes like the Rigatoni Pollo Caprese or Penne Alla Vodka, ensures a complete dining experience. The availability of a generous Family Special Dinner makes it a practical choice for feeding a hungry New York family without compromise. When considering where to spend your dining dollar on Long Island, the combination of high-quality, authentic flavors, generous portions, excellent accessibility (including ample free parking), and comprehensive services like catering and various delivery options makes Brooklyn Square Pizza a clear and highly recommended choice for your next Italian meal or pizza fix. The staff are known for being professional and accommodating, completing the friendly, casual vibe that keeps locals coming back.

Brooklyn Square Pizza Vibe

Appetizers & Side Orders
Wings (10 pcs) $18.00
Buffalo or BBQ.
Mozzarella Sticks (6 pcs) $10.00
Crispy sticks filled with melted mozzarella cheese.
Chicken Fingers (5 pcs) $12.00
Tender and juicy chicken strips, perfect for dipping.
Calamari $19.00
Fried.
Broccoli Rabe $14.00
Sautéed.
Calamari Arrabbiata (Spicy Tomato Sauce) $21.00
Tender calamari in a spicy tomato sauce. Spicy.
Spinach $12.00
Sautéed.
Broccoli $12.00
Sautéed.
Meatballs (4 pcs) $9.00
Four per order.
Baked Clams (8 pcs) $17.00
Freshly baked clams served in a set of 8 pieces.
Fresh Mozzarella $16.00
Sliced fresh tomatoes with fresh mozzarella and lettuce on the bottom.
Zucchini Sticks $11.00
Crisp and flavorful zucchini strips, perfect for snacking.
Garlic Bread $5.00
Buttery bread infused with garlic.
Garlic Bread with Cheese $7.00
Freshly baked bread infused with garlic and melted cheese.
French Fries $8.00
Crispy, golden sticks served hot.

Mains
Lunch Special $13.00
One piece of chicken entree-chicken Parmesan, chicken marsala, chicken francese, eggplant Parmesan, or sausage and peppers. Choice of pasta or salad.

Salads
Pecan Salad $16.00
Mesclun greens and fresh baby arugula topped with goat cheese, honey-roasted pecans, and cranberries in our homemade balsamic dressing. Add grilled chicken, and chicken cutlet for an additional charge.
Caesar Salad $14.00
Romaine lettuce and croutons sprinkled with grated cheese in our creamy Caesar dressing. Add grilled chicken, and chicken cutlet for an additional charge.
The Square Salad $16.00
Romaine lettuce with dried cranberries, sliced almonds, cherry tomatoes, shredded mozzarella in our homemade balsamic dressing. Add grilled chicken, and chicken cutlet for an additional charge.
Spinach Salad $17.00
Baby spinach topped with gorgonzola cheese and candied walnuts in a raspberry vinaigrette. Add grilled chicken, chicken cutlet for an additional charge.
House Salad $13.00
Iceberg lettuce tossed with onions, sliced plum tomatoes and green olives in our house vinaigrette. Add grilled chicken, chicken cutlet for an additional charge.
Tomato Mozzarella $12.00
Tomato steak fresh mozzarella balsamic and fresh basil. Add grilled chicken, chicken cutlet for an additional charge.
Taco Shell Salad $15.00

Soup
Minestrone, Pasta Fagioli or Lentil Soup $9.00
Chicken or Tortellini in Brodo Soup $9.00
Broth-based soup available with either chicken or tortellini.

Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza $32.00
Spicy chicken and buffalo sauce on a bed of melted mozzarella cheese.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza $32.00
Tender chicken, crispy bacon, and creamy ranch sauce on a flavorful pizza.
White Pizza $26.00
Margherita Pizza $29.00
Fresh tomatoes and mozzarella on a classic Italian-style crust.
Grandma Pizza $27.00
Classic-style pizza with a rich flavor profile.
Chicken Marsala Pizza $35.00
Tender chicken, Marsala sauce, and melted mozzarella on a crispy crust.
BBQ Chicken Pizza $32.00
Tender chicken, smothered in BBQ sauce, on top of a crispy crust.
Brooklyn Square (Sicilian) Pizza $25.00
Thick, crispy crust topped with rich flavors.
Round Pizza $21.00
Classic-style pizza made with a round crust.
Gluten Free Pizza $16.00
Made with a gluten-free crust, perfect for those with dietary restrictions.
Grandpa Pizza $30.00
Classic cheese pizza with a blend of flavors.
Alla Vodka Pizza $33.00
Chicken Broccoli Pizza $28.00
Sautéed.
Eggplant & Ricotta Pizza $32.00
Eggplant and ricotta combine in a flavorful pizza.
Spinach Artichoke (12") Pizza $35.00
Sautéed.

By the Slice
Specialty Slice $7.00
Choose from over 20 different specialty pizza slices including options like chicken bacon ranch, broccoli, margarita, and ala vodka. Availability may be limited at times.
Slice $5.00
Square Slice $5.00
Thin crust slice of pizza.

Rolls
Garlic Knots Roll $8.00
Soft, buttery knots infused with garlic.
Pin Wheel Roll $7.00
Buffalo Chicken Roll $10.00
Spicy chicken wrapped in a roll.
Cheese Calzone Roll $10.00
Rolled dough filled with melted cheese.
Rice Ball $10.00
Chicken Roll $11.00
Tender chicken wrapped in a roll.
Sausage Roll $13.00
Savory sausage wrapped in a flaky pastry.
Eggplant Roll $10.00
Meat Lover Roll $10.00
Pepperoni sausage and meatballs.
Ham Calzone Roll $11.00
Ham and melted goodness wrapped in a crispy roll.
Meat Ball Calzone Roll $11.00
Tender meatballs wrapped in a crispy roll.
Sausage Calzone Roll $11.00
Sausage wrapped in a crispy roll.

Wraps
Chicken Caesar Wrap $15.00
Tender chicken, crisp lettuce, and tangy Caesar dressing wrapped in a soft tortilla.
Grilled Chicken Wrap $11.00
Lettuce, tomato, and honey mustard.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap $15.00
Spicy chicken wrapped in a flavorful tortilla.
Chicken Cutlet Wrap $11.00
Lettuce, tomato, mozzarella and ranch.
Veggie Wrap $13.00
Fresh vegetables wrapped in a flavorful package.

Heroes
Meatball Hero $12.00
Make it parmigiana for an additional charge. Add garlic bread for an additional charge.
Chicken Cutlet Hero $12.00
Lettuce, tomato, mozzarella and ranch. Make it parmigiana for an additional charge. Add garlic bread for an additional charge.
Potato & Egg Hero $11.00
Make it parmigiana for an additional charge. Add garlic bread for an additional charge.
Veal Cutlet Hero $13.00
Make it parmigiana for an additional charge. Add garlic bread for an additional charge.
Sausage & Peppers Hero $12.00
White or red sauce. Make it parmigiana for an additional charge. Add garlic bread for an additional charge.
Eggplant Hero $11.00
Make it parmigiana for an additional charge. Add garlic bread for an additional charge.
Shrimp Hero $15.00
Make it parmigiana for an additional charge. Add garlic bread for an additional charge.

Entrées
Chicken Francese $26.00
Lightly battered chicken breast in a smooth lemon-butter white wine sauce. Accompanied by your chosen side from various pasta options or a house salad. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional...
Chicken Marsala $26.00
Sautéed chicken paired with a sweet marsala wine and mushroom sauce. Accompanied by a side of your choice: spaghetti primavera, rigatoni bolognese, baked ziti among others, or a house salad. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substi...
Chicken Verde $25.00
Battered chicken breast topped with broccoli and mozzarella in a cherry plum tomato sauce. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana $25.00
A delectable chicken cutlet, cooked to a golden crisp, lavished with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella. Choose a flavourful side from a selection of pasta dishes or a fresh house salad. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitu...
Eggplant Parmigiana $25.00
Thinly sliced eggplant layered with mozzarella served with a chosen side pasta or house salad. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.
Shrimp Parmigiana $30.00
Shrimp parmigiana paired with a variety of side choices ranging from linguine pescatore, baked ziti to fettuccine alfredo, and house salad. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.
Chicken Fiorentina $21.00
Breaded on a bed of spinach topped with sautéed onions and mushroom in a marsala wine sauce. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.
Chicken Cacciatore $25.00
Sautéed with white wine, fresh tomato, mushroom, onions, and peppers in a light marinara sauce. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.
Chicken Pizzaiola $25.00
Buttered chicken sautéed with garlic and olives in a plum tomato sauce. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.
Shrimp Monachino $30.00
Breaded shrimp topped with mushroom and melted mozzarella in a brown marsala wine sauce. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.
Chicken Milanese $26.00
A delectable golden brown breaded chicken cutlet served with the side of your choice. Options include a variety of pasta dishes with rich, flavorful sauces or a crisp house salad. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicke...
Sausage & Peppers $26.00
White or red sauce. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.
Chicken Contarina $25.00
Sautéed sausage, potato, and zucchini with brown wine sauce. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.
Chicken Scarpariello $25.00
Pieces of chicken sautéed with garlic, olives, sweet peppers, onions, and mushroom in a lemon wine sauce. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.
Grilled Salmon $27.00
Salmon filet grilled and served over a bed of spinach. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.

Pasta
Rigatoni Pollo Caprese Pasta $23.00
Sautéed pieces of chicken with fresh tomato basil sauce and fresh mozzarella in a garlic wine sauce.
Rigatoni Bolognese Pasta $19.00
Tube-shaped pasta.
Baked Ziti Pasta $18.00
Smooth tube shaped pasta.
Ravioli Marinara Pasta $17.00
Stuffed pasta.
Penne Alla Vodka Pasta $19.00
Narrow tube-shaped pasta.
Spaghetti Pomodoro Pasta $15.00
Long thing pasta.
Linguine with Garlic & Oil Pasta $17.00
Ribbon pasta.
Linguine white Clam Sauce Pasta $20.00
Ribbon pasta.
Rigatoni with Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pasta $24.00
Tube-shaped pasta.
Penne with Broccoli Pasta $18.00
Narrow tube-shaped pasta.
Lasagna Pasta $20.00
Layered dish with wide flat pasta.
Manicotti Pasta $18.00
Large tube-shaped pasta.
Spaghetti Meatballs Pasta $18.00
Tender meatballs served with spaghetti in a rich pasta dish.
Fettuccine Alfredo Pasta $19.00
Fettuccine pasta tossed in a classic Alfredo cheese sauce.
Spaghetti Rustica Pasta $23.00
Sautéed scrambled sausage and broccoli rabe in a garlic white wine sauce.
Linguine Alla Brooklyn Pasta $25.00
Sautéed shrimp, plum tomatoes, mushroom and Brooklyn sauce.
Spaghetti Primavera Pasta $21.00
Sautéed fresh vegetables in a light cream sauce.
Rigatoni Fiorentina Pasta $22.00
Fresh chicken, spinach, and mozzarella tossed on a pink sauce.
Penne Bocconcini Pasta $23.00
Sun-dried tomatoes, diced plum tomatoes with fresh mozzarella in a creamy pink sauce.
Linguine Pescatore Pasta $29.00
Calamari, shrimp, mussels, and clams in a rich plum tomato sauce.
Linguine Red Clam Sauce Pasta $20.00
Ribbon pasta.

Kids Only
Chicken Fingers (3) & Fries $10.00
Tender chicken strips served with crispy fries.
Mozzarella Sticks (4) & Fries $10.00
Crispy mozzarella sticks served with a side of fries.
Spaghetti & Meatball $12.00
Tender meatballs served with spaghetti.
Penne with Butter $10.00
Tender penne pasta in a rich butter sauce.

Family Special Dinner
Family Special Dinner $56.00
One choice of entree. Chicken Parmesan, chicken marsala, chicken francese, eggplant Parmesan, or sausage and peppers. One choice of pasta and house salad or Caesar salad.

Appetizers & Side Orders
Wings (10 pcs) $18.00
Buffalo or BBQ.
Mozzarella Sticks (6 pcs) $10.00
Crispy sticks filled with melted mozzarella cheese.
Calamari $19.00
Fried.
Calamari Arrabbiata (Spicy Tomato Sauce) $21.00
Tender squid rings in a spicy tomato sauce. Spicy.
Spinach (Sautéed) $12.00
Sautéed.
Broccoli (Sautéed) $12.00
Sautéed.
Chicken Fingers (5 pcs) $12.00
Tender and juicy chicken strips, perfect for dipping.
Meatballs (4 pcs) $9.00
Four per order.
Baked Clams (6 pcs) $17.00
Freshly baked clams, served in a set of six.
Broccoli Rabe $14.00
Sautéed.
Fresh Mozzarella $16.00
Sliced fresh tomatoes with fresh mozzarella and lettuce on the bottom.

Soup
Minestrone, Pasta Fagioli or Lentil Soup $9.00
Chicken or Tortellini in Brodo Soup $9.00
Broth-based soup with a choice of tortellini or chicken.

Pizza
Brooklyn Square (Sicilian) Pizza $25.00
Round Pizza $21.00
Classic-style pizza made with a round crust.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza $32.00
Spicy chicken, buffalo-style, on a bed of melted mozzarella cheese.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza $32.00
Tender chicken, crispy bacon, and creamy ranch come together in a delicious combination.
BBQ Chicken Pizza $32.00
Tender chicken, smothered in BBQ sauce, on top of a crispy crust.
White Pizza $26.00
Margherita Pizza $29.00
Classic Neapolitan-style pizza topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.
Grandma Pizza $27.00
Classic-style pizza with a rich flavor profile.
Grandpa Pizza $30.00
Classic cheese pizza with a blend of flavors.
Alla Vodka Pizza $33.00
Chicken Marsala Pizza $35.00
Tender chicken, Marsala sauce, and melted mozzarella on a crispy crust.
Eggplant and Ricotta Pizza $32.00
Eggplant and ricotta combine in a flavorful pizza.
Broccoli Pizza $23.00
Sauteed.
Spinach Artichoke Pizza $35.00
Sauteed.

By the Slice
Specialty Slice $7.00
A variety of pizza slices to select from. Options include buffalo chicken, white, broccoli, spinach, chicken bacon ranch, BBQ chicken, Sicilian, eggplant and ricotta, chicken marsala, round, grandma, grandpa, ala vodka, and margherita.
Slice $5.00

Rolls
Pin Wheel Roll $7.00
Soft and flavorful roll.
Rice Ball $10.00
Chicken Roll $11.00
Side of sauce included.
Sausage Roll $13.00
Side of sauce included.

Paninis
Chef Ramsey Panini $17.00
Chicken Cutlet, fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil, roasted peppers.
Alton Brown Panini $17.00
Chicken, cutlet, sautéed spinach, peppers, fresh mozzarella.
Donatella Panini $17.00
Fresh Mozzarella, tomato, basil. Vegetarian.

Wraps
Chicken Caesar Wrap $15.00
Tender chicken, crisp lettuce, and tangy Caesar dressing wrapped in a soft tortilla.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap $15.00
Spicy chicken wrapped in a flavorful tortilla.
Chicken Cutlet Wrap $12.00
Lettuce, tomato, mozzarella and ranch.
Grilled Chicken Wrap $12.00
Lettuce, tomato, and honey mustard.

Heroes
Meatball Hero $13.00
Make it parmigiana for an additional charge. Add garlic bread for an additional charge.
Chicken Cutlet Hero $14.00
Lettuce, tomato, mozzarella and ranch. Make it parmigiana for an additional charge. Add garlic bread for an additional charge.
Veal Cutlet Hero $14.00
Make it parmigiana for an additional charge. Add garlic bread for an additional charge.
Sausage & Peppers Hero $14.00
White or red sauce. Make it parmigiana for an additional charge. Add garlic bread for an additional charge.
Potato & Egg Hero $12.00
Make it parmigiana for an additional charge. Add garlic bread for an additional charge.
Eggplant Hero $12.00
Make it parmigiana for an additional charge. Add garlic bread for an additional charge.
Shrimp Hero $15.00
Make it parmigiana for an additional charge. Add garlic bread for an additional charge.

Entrées
Chicken Fiorentina $21.00
Breaded on a bed of spinach topped with sautéed onions and mushroom in a marsala wine sauce. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana $25.00
Chicken cutlet blanketed in marinara and mozzarella, with a choice of distinctive pasta sides. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.
Eggplant Parmigiana $25.00
Eggplant layered with mozzarella, served with a side choice of various pasta dishes or a house salad. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.
Chicken Francese $26.00
Sautéed chicken breast in a lemon butter and white wine sauce. Choose a side from a broad array, including house salad, varieties of linguine, rigatoni, spaghetti, penne, and more. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chick...
Shrimp Parmigiana $30.00
Shrimp parmigiana served with a choice of side, options include pasta varieties and house salad. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.
Sausage & Peppers $26.00
White or red sauce. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.
Chicken Verde $25.00
Battered chicken breast topped with broccoli and mozzarella in a cherry plum tomato sauce. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.
Chicken Scarpariello $25.00
Pieces of chicken sautéed with garlic, olives, sweet peppers, onions, and mushroom in a lemon wine sauce. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.
Chicken Milanese $26.00
Breaded chicken served with a choice from a variety of pasta dishes or house salad. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.
Chicken Marsala $26.00
Enjoy a hearty dish of succulent chicken sautéed with lush mushrooms and aromatic marsala wine. Complement your main course with a side of your choice, from a range of flavorful pasta options. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Subs...
Chicken Contarina $25.00
Sautéed sausage, potato, and zucchini with brown wine sauce. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.
Chicken Cacciatore $25.00
Sautéed with white wine, fresh tomato, mushroom, onions, and peppers in a light marinara sauce. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.
Chicken Pizzaiola $25.00
Buttered chicken sautéed with garlic and olives in a plum tomato sauce. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.
Shrimp Monachino $30.00
Breaded shrimp topped with mushroom and melted mozzarella in a brown marsala wine sauce. All entrées are served with pasta or house salad. Substitute chicken for veal for an additional charge.

Pasta
Ravioli Marinara Pasta $17.00
Delicious pasta pockets filled with savory ingredients, topped with a rich marinara sauce.
Penne Alla Vodka Pasta $19.00
Narrow tube-shaped pasta.
Linguine with Garlic & Oil Pasta $17.00
Ribbon pasta.
Linguine with Clam Sauce Pasta $21.00
Ribbon pasta.
Penne with Broccoli Pasta $18.00
Narrow tube-shaped pasta.
Lasagna Pasta $20.00
Layered dish with wide flat pasta.
Baked Ziti Pasta $18.00
Smooth tube-shaped pasta.
Manicotti Pasta $18.00
Large tube-shaped pasta.
Spaghetti Meatballs Pasta $18.00
Tender meatballs served with spaghetti.
Fettuccine Alfredo Pasta $19.00
Fettuccine pasta tossed in a classic Alfredo cheese sauce.
Rigatoni Pollo Caprese Pasta $23.00
Sautéed pieces of chicken with fresh tomato basil sauce and fresh mozzarella in a garlic wine sauce.
Linguine Alla Brooklyn Pasta $25.00
Sautéed shrimp, plum tomatoes, mushroom, and Brooklyn sauce.
Spaghetti Primavera Pasta $21.00
Sautéed fresh vegetables in a light cream sauce.
Rigatoni Fiorentina Pasta $22.00
Fresh chicken, spinach, and mozzarella tossed on a pink sauce.
Penne Bocconcini Pasta $23.00
Sun-dried tomatoes, diced plum tomatoes with fresh mozzarella in a creamy pink sauce.
Rigatoni Bolognese Pasta $19.00
Tube-shaped pasta.
Spaghetti Pomodoro Pasta $15.00
Long thing pasta.
Rigatoni with Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pasta $24.00
Tube-shaped pasta.
Spaghetti Rustica Pasta $23.00
Sautéed scrambled sausage and broccoli rabe in a garlic white wine sauce.
Linguine Pescatore Pasta $29.00
Calamari, shrimp, mussels, and clams in a rich plum tomato sauce.

Kids Only
Chicken Fingers (3 pcs) & Fries $10.00
Mozzarella Sticks (4 pcs) & Fries $10.00
Crispy mozzarella sticks served with a side of fries.
Spaghetti & Meatball $12.00
Tender meatballs served with spaghetti.
Penne with Butter $10.00
Tender penne pasta in a rich butter sauce.

Family Special Dinner
Family Special Dinner $56.00
One choice of entree. Chicken Parmesan, chicken marsala, chicken francese, eggplant Parmesan, or sausage and peppers. One choice of pasta and house salad or Caesar salad.

Brooklyn Square Pizza Details

Service options
Curbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Late-night food
Quick bite

Dining options
Catering
Dessert
Seating

Atmosphere
Casual

Crowd
Family-friendly
Groups

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking

Pets
Dogs allowed outside

Brooklyn Square Pizza Photos

Brooklyn Square Pizza Location

Brooklyn Square Pizza

New York Nassau County Seaford Merrick Road

3620 Merrick Rd, Seaford, NY 11783, USA

Brooklyn Square Pizza Reviews

An average rating of ★4.4 from 205 user reviews.

buffalo chickencrustslicespricedl&b spumoni gardenssicilian slicesesamevodkacutletgarlic knots

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

The food here is very good. The square slice is awesome nice sauce nice crunch baked to perfection with plenty of cheese. The chicken roll is awesome. Their other specialty slices is good. This place makes the Sicilian slice better than the Brooklyn location. The staff are nice and professional. Highly recommended 👌. Plenty of Parking. They have a good special if you buy 2 slices you get a free can of soda.
September 17 · BK Man
Ordered a bunch of slices to be headed up at home at closing time on a weekday.The pizza was good, especially with the sesame seeded crusts.All were a tad sweet as if the sesame seeds were applied with a little honey.I happen to like a hot honey pepperoni slice with sesame seed crust.But others like the vodka slice were a bit odd since they on the sweeter and less salty side.Crust and cheese were tasty.The best of the slices were a sausage, cooked onion and peppers Sicilian and the Buffalo chicken.I will be back to get a whole pie of the sausage pepper onion.
February 13 · John H.
Ordered a Sicilian upside down for pickup. Visions of L&B Spumoni Gardens danced in my head as I looked forward to my first pie from this place.Parking was a breeze off the street in the adjacent lot next to the 7th Precinct. Walked in was greeted by a pleasant enough counter person. Place looked kinda clean, smelled pretty good. Grabbed my $28.- pie; which was quite weighty and I thought was reasonably priced, adjusted for inflation, and headed out to the lot. Drove home and opened the warm box at my kitchen table.What an ultimate let down when I opened it up.The box contents reeked of Parmesan dumped atop a seeming gallon of acrid sauce drowning a mere and slight hint of barely there mozzarella, all framed by a dark brown border of over cooked crust. Not so bad, you might say? When I went go grab a slice it flopped over lifelessly as the sauce and parm dust flowed off into the box. Still I remained undeterred and feeling adventurous, I took a bite. Horrible. Back into the box it went and after a shot trip to the garbage cans my brief but unforgettable experience with Brooklyn Square came to an unceremonious end.In summary, not the new favorite place we were hoping for.
February 10 · Scott Gordon
Where Brooklyn at!! I love upside-down pizza & Brooklyn Square makes a really good one! Slices are small but flavor is big
November 04 · MIKEY LAP
Excellent authentic N.Y. style pizza with sesame crust! The garlic knots are delicious and not too doughy!
June 14 · June Stoyer