Buttermilk Bakeshop

- 264 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215

Buttermilk Bakeshop is a standout bakery and cake shop that has captured the hearts of locals in Brooklyn, New York. Situated in the charming neighborhood of Park Slope, this women-owned business is a go-to destination for anyone in search of delicious, high-quality, and artistically crafted baked goods. From custom cakes that are truly works of art to a wide array of delectable treats, Buttermilk Bakeshop prides itself on using top-notch ingredients and crafting everything fresh daily in their open kitchen. The bakery is more than just a place to get dessert; it's a creative hub where personal visions are transformed into stunning and tasty realities. Whether you're planning a major event like a wedding or simply looking for a sweet escape, Buttermilk Bakeshop offers a welcoming and delightful experience. Their reputation for exceptional customer service, efficient communication, and a talent for bringing personalized ideas to life has made them a trusted favorite among New Yorkers.

The bakery's commitment to quality is evident in every bite. Their cakes are consistently praised for being not only visually beautiful but also incredibly delicious. They have a knack for creating unique flavor combinations that leave a lasting impression on guests. Beyond their custom creations, the bakeshop offers a variety of ready-to-order items that cater to different tastes and occasions. From their signature pies to cupcakes and cookies, there's something to satisfy every craving. Buttermilk Bakeshop also understands the importance of accommodating dietary needs, with a selection of gluten-free and vegan options that don't compromise on flavor or artistry. This dedication to inclusivity and quality is what sets them apart as a true gem in the Brooklyn food scene.

Buttermilk Bakeshop is an ideal spot for a quick visit, whether you're grabbing a coffee and a croissant on the way to work or picking up a treat for later. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, making it a pleasant place to stop and enjoy a moment of indulgence. It's a place where you can rely on consistent quality and a friendly, professional staff that is always ready to help you find the perfect confection. The bakery’s success is built on a foundation of creativity, customer satisfaction, and a genuine love for baking, all of which are on full display for anyone who walks through their doors.

The bakery is conveniently located at 264 5th Ave in Brooklyn, NY 11215. This prime spot in the Park Slope neighborhood makes it easily accessible for locals and visitors alike. When it comes to parking, the area offers both free and paid street parking options, which is a great convenience for customers who are picking up large orders like custom cakes. For those who prefer to stay in, Buttermilk Bakeshop offers delivery through various services like Grubhub, Uber Eats, DoorDash, and Seamless, making it simple to get your favorite treats brought right to your door. They also provide in-store pickup for a seamless and quick experience. The bakeshop's location is a hub of activity, surrounded by other local businesses, and it’s a great destination for anyone exploring the vibrant Park Slope neighborhood.

The team at Buttermilk Bakeshop is dedicated to making the custom cake process as smooth and enjoyable as possible. They encourage customers to book as soon as their event date is finalized, as they are often fully booked weeks in advance. The process is straightforward: you can get a quote by choosing from their vast catalog of designs or by uploading your own inspiration photos. Their team is known for being responsive and helpful, working with customers to ensure their vision aligns with their budget. Once an order is confirmed and paid for, the team reviews all the details and will contact you with any questions. They even accommodate changes to flavors, colors, and inscriptions up to a few days before the event, offering flexibility and peace of mind.

Services Offered

• Custom cakes for all occasions, including birthdays and weddings, with a wide variety of designs available.
• Ready-to-order cakes, such as the 6" Classic Birthday Cake, 6" Double Chocolate Cake, and 6" Rainbow Cake, which require a minimum of 48 hours' notice for pre-order.
• A diverse selection of cookies, including classic Chocolate Chunk, Salted Nutella, and V/GF Chocolate Chunk cookies.
• Freshly baked cupcakes in flavors like Vanilla, Chocolate, and Strawberry Shortcake.
• Pies, including the signature Buttermilk Pie and Nutella Pecan Pie, available whole or by the slice.
• A range of bars and brownies, such as the "Brookie" (half brownie, half cookie) and Tangy Lemon Bar.
• Unique dessert options like Cake in a Jar, with flavors like Banana Pudding, Chocolate, and Vanilla.
• Gift boxes featuring assorted macarons, chocolate-covered Oreos, and other sweets.
• Coffee to complement your baked goods.
• Onsite services, including parties and classes where guests can learn decorating techniques.
• In-store shopping, delivery, and in-store pickup for convenient service.

Features and Highlights

• Women-Owned Business: A proud women-owned establishment that contributes to the local community.
• Customization and Artistry: The bakery excels at creating custom cakes that are not only delicious but also visually stunning works of art. Customers can provide their own images or ideas from sources like Pinterest, and the team works with them to create a unique and personalized cake.
• Accommodates Dietary Needs: They offer a thoughtful selection of gluten-free and vegan options, ensuring that more people can enjoy their treats without compromising on taste or quality.
• Exceptional Customer Service: Known for their quick, friendly, and reliable customer service. They are praised for their seamless communication and for making the custom ordering process a breeze.
• High-Quality Ingredients: All products are crafted fresh daily in their open kitchen using top-notch ingredients, which contributes to the superior taste of their baked goods.
• Variety of Offerings: Beyond cakes, they provide a wide range of desserts, including cookies, cupcakes, pies, and even "Brookies." They also offer tasting kits for those planning a special event.
• Specialty Cake Flavors: The bakery is celebrated for unique flavors such as the classic Birthday cake (vanilla with raspberry jam), Wedding cake slice (almond cake with lemon curd and raspberry jam), and Cookies and Milk (vanilla and chocolate cake with cookie pieces).

Contact Information

Address: 264 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA

Phone: (347) 987-3941

What is worth choosing

For those in Brooklyn and beyond, Buttermilk Bakeshop is a must-visit for any celebration or sweet craving. What makes this bakery truly stand out is its seamless combination of artistic vision and exceptional flavor. They have mastered the art of creating custom cakes that not only look incredible but also taste fantastic, a quality often hard to find. The team's ability to take a simple idea, like an image from an invitation or a Pinterest board, and turn it into a magnificent, edible centerpiece is what keeps customers coming back. The personalized, hassle-free experience is a key reason for their glowing reviews, with many customers noting how easy and stress-free the ordering process is, even when working within a budget.

Buttermilk Bakeshop is also worth choosing for its reliability and consistency. As one customer noted, they are "super reliable" and "never disappoint," which is crucial when planning a special event. The bakery’s dedication to quality ingredients ensures that every item, from a simple chocolate chip cookie to a multi-tiered wedding cake, is made with care and tastes fresh. Their wide range of products means you can get everything you need for a party in one place, from the main cake to matching custom cookies or cupcakes. The availability of gluten-free and vegan options also makes them a considerate choice for hosts and guests with dietary restrictions. Ultimately, Buttermilk Bakeshop is more than just a place to buy a dessert; it’s a partner in making your celebrations unforgettable, offering beautiful, delicious, and perfectly crafted creations that are a highlight of any event.

Buttermilk Bakeshop

264 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA