Caterina Pizza

- 3035 Fulton St #1FL, Brooklyn, NY 11208

In a city where pizza is a way of life, finding a place that truly stands out from the crowd is a monumental task. Caterina Pizza, located at 3035 Fulton St #1FL, Brooklyn, NY 11208, has earned its reputation as a true local gem. This establishment is more than just a pizza joint; it’s an Italian restaurant that has been serving the East New York community for decades, creating a loyal following of customers who appreciate its consistent quality and classic flavors. The shop's legacy is so strong that one customer has been coming for almost 30 years, since they were in elementary school. This article will provide a comprehensive guide to Caterina Pizza, detailing its extensive menu, convenient services, and what makes it a must-try for anyone in the Brooklyn area.

Caterina Pizza is a quintessential New York experience, a place where a slice of pizza is not just food but a piece of culture. The restaurant is celebrated for its crispy crust, perfect cheese, and a taste that has made it a favorite among locals. One review even proclaims it the "Best pizza in Brooklyn around East New York," a high compliment in a city with no shortage of pizza options. The establishment's success is rooted in its ability to offer a classic, comforting experience without pretension. It’s the kind of place you can grab a quick bite, have a relaxed meal, or get food for a large group.

The atmosphere at Caterina Pizza is casual and cozy, making it a great spot for a quick lunch or a casual dinner. The space, though small, is always kept clean, creating a welcoming environment. While some customers have noted minor changes in ingredients over the years, the overall consensus is that the food remains "great" and consistently delicious. This is a place that thrives on its strong community ties and a menu that delivers on its promise of traditional, satisfying Italian-American fare. The addition of healthy options, such as the highly recommended Greek salad with grilled chicken, shows a commitment to catering to a wide range of tastes and dietary needs.

As a pizza and Italian restaurant, Caterina Pizza offers a full dining experience, from quick slices to full-course meals. The menu is a testament to its versatility, featuring everything from classic pies and pasta dishes to a variety of baked items and hot sandwiches. This broad selection ensures that whether you're craving a simple slice of cheese or a full plate of baked ziti, Caterina Pizza has you covered.

Location and Accessibility

Caterina Pizza is located at 3035 Fulton St #1FL, Brooklyn, NY 11208, USA. This prominent location on Fulton Street makes it a highly accessible spot for both local residents and visitors to the East New York neighborhood. The restaurant is well-integrated into the community, serving as a familiar landmark and a go-to destination for a satisfying meal.

While specific accessibility features beyond what is publicly available are not fully detailed, the restaurant is a local, neighborhood spot that is easy to find and reach. It is a place that caters to a diverse crowd, including families, groups, and even tourists seeking an authentic taste of Brooklyn. The availability of parking is not specified, but its location on a main street likely provides street parking options. The fact that the restaurant is on the first floor also adds to its general accessibility.

Services Offered

Caterina Pizza offers a wide range of services designed for the convenience of its customers, accommodating various dining preferences and situations.

• Delivery and No-Contact Delivery: The restaurant provides reliable delivery service, including a no-contact option, which is perfect for those who want to enjoy their meal at home. This service is essential for a delivery restaurant in a busy city.
• Takeout: For customers who prefer to pick up their food, the takeout service is fast and efficient. It allows for a quick stop to grab a slice or a full pie on the go.
• Dine-in: Caterina Pizza offers a casual dine-in experience with seating available. It is a cozy and comfortable space to sit and enjoy a meal, whether you're on a solo outing or with a small group.
• Catering: For larger events or gatherings, the restaurant provides catering services. This is ideal for office lunches, parties, or any event that requires a reliable source of delicious, classic Italian food.
• Counter Service: The counter service is perfect for a quick bite or for ordering from the extensive menu, which includes slices, rolls, and calzones.

Features / Highlights

Caterina Pizza is known for several key features that make it a favorite among its patrons.

• Authentic Italian and Pizza Menu: The menu is extensive and includes a wide variety of pizza styles, from classic slices to specialty pies like Buffalo Pizza and Ziti Pizza. Beyond pizza, the menu features classic Italian dishes such as baked ziti, lasagna, and a variety of hot sandwiches and heroes.
• Family-Friendly Atmosphere: With a casual and cozy vibe, Caterina Pizza is good for kids and families. Its delicious food and comfortable setting make it a perfect spot for a family outing.
• Late-Night Food and Quick Bites: The restaurant offers late-night food options, making it a great spot for a meal after hours. It is also perfect for a quick bite, with single slices and small plates like mozzarella sticks and garlic knots readily available.
• High-Quality Ingredients: Customers consistently praise the quality of the food. Reviews mention the pizza as being "tasty, cheesy, and crispy," and a customer "obsessed" with the Greek salad with grilled chicken, highlighting the quality of the ingredients used.
• Accepts Reservations: For groups or special occasions, the restaurant accepts reservations, which adds a level of convenience and planning for customers.

Contact Information

For more information or to place an order, you can contact Caterina Pizza directly.

Address: 3035 Fulton St #1FL, Brooklyn, NY 11208, USA

Phone: (718) 277-2571

Mobile Phone: +1 718-277-2571

What is worth choosing

With countless pizza places in New York City, what makes Caterina Pizza the right choice? It comes down to its authenticity, value, and community-focused approach. For anyone in East New York, this is a trusted and reliable spot that delivers a high-quality, delicious product every time. The fact that a customer has been a regular for almost 30 years speaks volumes about its consistency and quality.

For pizza lovers, the simple slice is a great place to start. A plain slice, pepperoni slice, or chicken slice are all excellent choices that showcase the restaurant’s mastery of the basics. The specialty pies, like the Ziti Pizza or Lasagna Style, offer a fun and delicious twist on classic Italian dishes.

Beyond pizza, the menu is filled with worthy choices. The baked ziti, for example, is a classic comfort food that is available with various toppings. The hot sandwiches, like the Chicken Cutlet Hero, are also a great choice for a filling and satisfying meal. The newly discovered Greek salad with grilled chicken, with its "red wine vinaigrette," is a great option for a lighter but equally delicious meal.

Caterina Pizza offers great value for your money. With a large pie starting at $14.00 and a slice at just $2.75, it’s an affordable option for individuals and families. The fact that it is a family-friendly and good-for-kids spot further enhances its appeal. Choosing Caterina Pizza is not just about getting a meal; it's about supporting a local institution that has been a cornerstone of the community for decades, providing delicious food and a welcoming atmosphere.

Caterina Pizza

3035 Fulton St #1FL, Brooklyn, NY 11208, USA