Catfish Annie's

- 116 Commack Rd, Commack, NY 11725

For Long Island residents and New York visitors craving truly fresh and flavorful seafood in a comfortable setting, **Catfish Annie's** in Commack, NY, presents a compelling dining solution. Established in 1981, this family-owned operation uniquely combines the freshness of a dedicated **seafood market** with the warmth of a casual, full-service **seafood restaurant**. This integrated approach ensures that every dish served is crafted from the highest quality ingredients, often sourced directly from their own market.

Catfish Annie's prides itself on delivering "delicious dishes with the freshest of ingredients," and their reputation is built on classic preparations of fish and shellfish. Diners can enjoy everything from simple, perfectly cooked fish like their signature broiled catfish—which one patron praised as being "cooked to perfection"—to comforting Italian-inspired seafood plates such as *Mussels Marinara*.

The atmosphere is intentionally **Casual** and **Cozy**, making it an excellent choice for a wide range of occasions, whether it’s a quick **Lunch**, a family **Dinner**, or a meal for **Solo dining**. By focusing on great food, generous portions, and a welcoming environment, Catfish Annie's has cemented its position as a beloved local establishment serving the New York region. It's a place where the local specialty is celebrated, and patrons return not just for the cooked meals but also for the promise of a "no smell" fresh seafood market experience.

Catfish Annie's is conveniently located at **116 Commack Rd, Commack, NY 11725, USA**. This address places it in a busy area of Suffolk County, accessible to residents of Commack and the surrounding Long Island communities. The location within a strip mall, as noted by reviewers, makes it visible and easy to access.

The restaurant is highly committed to accessibility and ease of visit, featuring several accommodations:

• **Parking:** Patrons have access to both a **Free parking lot** and **Free street parking**, which simplifies arrival and departure—a significant benefit in the bustling New York suburbs.
• **Wheelchair Accessibility:** Accessibility is a priority, with a **Wheelchair accessible entrance**, **Wheelchair accessible parking lot**, and **Wheelchair accessible seating** available, ensuring a comfortable experience for all guests.
• **Restrooms:** A readily available **Restroom** facility is provided for customer convenience.

Catfish Annie's offers a comprehensive array of services to cater to both individual diners and larger events, highlighting its role as a full-service community spot.

• **Dine-in Experience:** Full-service **Dine-in** is available with **Seating** and **Table service** in a casual and cozy setting. They also offer **Counter service** for quick ordering.
• **Reservation and Planning:** The restaurant **Accepts reservations**, a useful feature for **Groups** and for planning special occasions during busy dinner hours.
• **Takeout and Onsite Services:** Offers **Takeout** for those preferring to eat at home, alongside other **Onsite services**, likely referring to their adjacent fish market operations.
• **Catering:** Provides **Catering** services, allowing customers to bring their expertly prepared seafood to large events and parties.
• **Dining Times:** Open for both **Lunch** and **Dinner**, and is **Popular for Lunch, Dinner, and Solo dining**. The kitchen opens in the mid-morning/late lunch hours throughout the week.
• **Family-Friendly:** Considered **Good for kids**, and offers essential amenities like **High chairs** and a dedicated **Kids' menu**.
• **Payment Methods:** Accepts various forms of payment, including **Credit cards** and **Debit cards**.

The major draws to Catfish Annie's are rooted in the quality of its fresh offerings, the variety of its menu, and the comforting, local atmosphere.

**Freshness and Local Focus:**

• **Seafood Market Connection:** The strongest highlight is the connection to a full-service **fresh seafood market**, ensuring the restaurant’s ingredients are consistently of the highest quality—a feature highly valued by customers who note the lack of "smell" and the fresh appearance of the products.
• **Local Specialty:** The restaurant **Serves local specialty**, demonstrating a commitment to regional favorites and unique dishes that resonate with the Long Island dining tradition.

**Menu Variety and Offerings:**

• **Signature Seafood:** Focuses on classic seafood preparations, including expertly **Broiled Catfish**, the popular *Mussels Marinara*, and traditional *Fried Calamari* appetizers.
• **Comfort and Health:** The menu successfully balances **Comfort food** like the *Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana* and *Hamburger* with **Healthy options** like broiled fish, appealing to diverse dietary preferences.
• **Beverage Selection:** Offers both **Beer** and **Wine**, complementing the seafood menu and enhancing the casual dining experience. *Coffee* is also available.
• **Soup Selection:** Features classic starters, including two distinct regional chowders: **Manhattan Clam Chowder Soup** and a rich **Seafood Bisque Soup**.
• **Quick Options:** The menu is suited for a **Quick bite**, with readily available **Sandwiches** such as the *Crab Cake Sandwich* and *Fried Scallops Sandwich*.

**Atmosphere and Crowd:**

• The environment is defined as **Casual** and **Cozy**, fostering a relaxed and family-friendly dining experience that attracts a mix of **Locals**, **Groups**, and even **Tourists** visiting the area.

Catfish Annie's makes it easy for the New York community to reach out for reservations, takeout orders, or inquiries about the seafood market's daily catches.

**Address:** 116 Commack Rd, Commack, NY 11725, USA

**Phone:** (631) 499-5131

**Mobile Phone:** +1 631-499-5131

The restaurant operates on a schedule that closes on Mondays and Tuesdays and opens from mid-morning on the remaining days, with later closing times on Fridays and Saturdays to accommodate the weekend dinner rush. It is recommended to call ahead, especially for larger groups or during high-demand hours, to secure seating or check the availability of specific market items.

For residents and visitors in the New York region, Catfish Annie's stands out as the choice destination for seafood for several compelling reasons that speak directly to quality and community value.

**It is worth choosing Catfish Annie's because:**

• **Unbeatable Freshness Guaranteed:** The most significant advantage is the dual operation as a **fresh seafood market and restaurant**. Patrons can literally purchase seafood from the market that is destined for their dinner plates, a guarantee of freshness that few other restaurants can match. This commitment to quality is the foundation of their delicious menu.
• **The Perfect Balance of Menu Options:** The menu offers a satisfying middle ground between healthy, quality seafood (like broiled Salmon or Lemon Sole) and comforting, familiar dishes (*Fish Cakes*, *Mussels Marinara*). This versatility, coupled with its offering of both **Beer** and **Wine**, ensures there is something to satisfy every craving and occasion.
• **Exceptional Customer Convenience and Service:** The restaurant excels in providing accessibility and ease of service. The availability of **Free parking**, comprehensive **Wheelchair accessibility**, and the option to **Accept reservations** all contribute to a smooth, stress-free dining experience—a rarity in high-traffic areas of New York.
• **A True Local Institution:** Since 1981, Catfish Annie's has been a family-owned business deeply rooted in the Commack community. When you dine here, you are supporting a Long Island staple that prides itself on friendly service and local flavor, including their celebrated *Serves local specialty* highlight.

Whether you are stocking up on fresh fish for home or sitting down for a perfectly cooked dinner, Catfish Annie's provides the genuine, fresh, and friendly seafood experience that Long Island is known for.

Catfish Annie's

116 Commack Rd, Commack, NY 11725, USA