Cinnamon Girl

- 583 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225

Cinnamon Girl is a cherished neighborhood coffee shop and bakery that has become a staple for locals along Flatbush Avenue in Brooklyn, New York. More than just a place to grab a quick coffee, this cozy and trendy spot offers an impressive array of freshly baked goods, savory meals, and a curated selection of beverages, establishing itself as a premier destination for breakfast, dessert, and quick bites. The establishment stands out for its commitment to inclusive offerings, with a significant portion of its menu dedicated to high-quality vegan and gluten-free pastries, ensuring there is a delectable option for nearly every New Yorker.

The atmosphere, often described as having the welcoming vibes of a small-town general store, makes it a comfortable yet stylish spot to begin your day or enjoy an afternoon treat. New Yorkers appreciate the quality ingredients, with baked goods made in-house and coffee sourced from reputable roasters like La Colombe. Whether you're a local resident, a student, or a visitor passing through, Cinnamon Girl provides a unique culinary experience that blends New York sophistication with comforting, homemade flavors. The store's hours, typically running from 8:00 AM to 8:00 PM daily, offer ample opportunity to enjoy their diverse offerings.

Location and Accessibility

Cinnamon Girl is conveniently located at 583 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225, USA, placing it firmly in a bustling, central part of the borough, particularly near the Prospect-Lefferts Gardens area. Its proximity to Prospect Park makes it a popular stop for people heading out for a run or a leisurely stroll, or simply for those engaging in the daily Flatbush Avenue people-watching scene.

Accessibility is designed primarily for a quick, efficient experience. While the venue offers dine-in service, seating is limited, typically featuring two indoor high-top tables (without chairs) and a few tables for outdoor seating. This setup favors the New York "grab and go" mentality, prioritizing fast service. For patrons arriving by car, there is paid street parking available nearby. The quick-service model ensures that while the space may be small, your wait time for excellent coffee or a quick bite is kept efficiently minimal, which is essential for a busy city life.

Services Offered

Cinnamon Girl provides a surprising depth of services for a coffee shop and bakery, covering not only essential dining needs but also offering unique community provisions.

• Takeout and Dine-In: Offering both options, patrons can choose to enjoy their goods on-site at the limited seating or grab their order for enjoyment elsewhere. The shop primarily functions as a takeout haven.
• Full Beverage Program: The menu includes excellent Coffee, Cold Brew, and boasts a Great tea selection. For refreshing options, freshly squeezed juices like Orange and Grapefruit are available, along with their Seasonal Ginger-Maple Drink and the signature house blend coffee.
• Bakery Specialties and Catering: The core service is the expansive bakery menu, featuring daily fresh-baked items like Bagels, Croissants, Cookies, and Cakes. They also offer special-order items, with customers reporting excellent Vegan Birthday Cakes, highlighting their ability to cater to celebratory needs.
• Diverse Culinary Options: Beyond the sweet treats, the shop provides hearty savory items, including Quiche (like Tomato Basil Goat Cheese and Spinach Goat Cheese), various Sandwiches (such as Nova on 7 Grain and Tuna Melt), and culturally inspired items like flaky patties.
• Dietary Inclusivity: A defining service is the wide range of Vegetarian options, with nearly half of the baked goods being Vegan. This includes items like Vegan Hand Pies, Vegan Cinnamon Rolls, Vegan Muffins & Scones, catering thoughtfully to various health and ethical diets.
• Provision Sales: Uniquely, Cinnamon Girl acts much like a specialized grocer, selling local provisions and a small, fantastic selection of fresh produce, dry products, sauces, wine, and Beer, turning a coffee run into a quick grocery stop.

Features / Highlights

The appeal of Cinnamon Girl extends far beyond its baked goods, residing in the overall experience and the commitment to quality service—despite some occasional operational challenges.

• Superior Quality Offerings: The coffee is noted for being Great coffee, with drip coffee often highlighted as an unbeatable value. The shop also excels in desserts, earning praise for Great dessert quality, particularly the vegan options and rich cakes.
• Unique Savory Selection: The inclusion of savory baked goods, like jerk salmon patties and lentil hand pies, elevates the menu beyond typical coffee shop fare, offering full meal options for a Quick bite.
• Atmosphere and Vibe: The atmosphere is consistently described as Casual, Cozy, and Trendy, with a welcoming environment that draws a loyal local customer base. The decor, reminiscent of a small-town general store, contributes to its unique charm in the city.
• Efficiency Focus: The operation emphasizes Fast service for coffee and quick orders, a necessity given the limited seating. This speed ensures that even when busy, customers are served efficiently.
• Payment Flexibility: Catering to modern New York convenience, the shop accepts all standard forms of payment, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
• Vegan and Gluten-Free Excellence: This is a major highlight, as the shop doesn't just offer an afterthought vegan item but provides an impressive array of high-quality, delicious vegan and gluten-free options that delight even non-vegan palates.

Contact Information

For New Yorkers looking to visit Cinnamon Girl, the primary point of contact is the physical location.

Address: 583 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225, USA

As a neighborhood cafe prioritizing on-site service and local interaction, a public-facing phone number is not consistently available across directories. Therefore, planning a visit is best done by checking the general operating hours (typically 8:00 AM to 8:00 PM daily) and visiting the location directly.

What is Worth Choosing

Cinnamon Girl is worth choosing primarily for its exceptional baked goods and its robust, flavorful coffee program. For anyone in Brooklyn, particularly those near Prospect-Lefferts Gardens, the quality of the pastries alone warrants a visit. The highly celebrated Vegan Cinnamon Rolls are repeatedly mentioned as a must-try signature dish—soft, gooey, and generously spiced—even by non-vegans. Similarly, the custom cake service, especially for vegan birthday cakes, has received rave reviews for taste and quality. The savory items, such as the flaky quiches and unique ethnic patties, provide excellent, hearty meal options for breakfast or lunch.

While the shop offers Fast service, it is important for New Yorkers to manage expectations regarding long lines and item availability during peak times, as reported by some customers. The recommendation is to use the glass display case to check item stock, as signage for sold-out items can be inconsistent. However, the quality of the food—from the highly affordable $1 drip coffee to the gourmet Nova on 7 Grain Sandwich ($13.00)—makes the occasional wait worthwhile. The general store aspect, selling local provisions, is an added convenience that elevates the entire experience, transforming a simple coffee shop visit into a chance to support local businesses and stock up on unique household goods. For a quality, quick-service bakery and coffee shop that genuinely caters to all dietary needs in a cozy Brooklyn setting, Cinnamon Girl is an excellent local choice.

Cinnamon Girl

583 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225, USA