City Island Pizza Company

- 273 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464

For New Yorkers seeking a culinary escape that feels like a trip to the shore without leaving the five boroughs, City Island is the quintessential destination. Nestled in this charming nautical town—often affectionately called "the Nantucket of the Bronx"—is the City Island Pizza Company. This restaurant is far more than just a pizzeria; it’s a modern, vibrant Italian-American eatery that has quickly become one of the area's newest and brightest dining spots. It flawlessly combines traditional Italian preparations with high-quality, locally sourced ingredients, resulting in dishes that are both authentic to their heritage and perfectly suited to the New York setting.

City Island Pizza Company offers a cozy, trendy atmosphere with a nautical meets mid-century aesthetic, making it an ideal setting for everything from a casual weeknight dinner to a special date night. The ethos of the business is built on warm and gracious hospitality, quality ingredients, and a strong sense of community. The restaurant takes pride in being a locally-owned establishment that is both Latino-owned and women-owned, contributing to the diverse and dynamic culinary landscape of the Bronx. It's a place where patrons—whether they are lifelong locals, family groups, or day-tripping visitors—can gather for impeccable Italian cuisine and a truly welcoming experience. Whether you’re stopping by for a hearty lunch, a full dinner, or the newly popular weekend brunch, the energetic and friendly vibe promises a wonderful time.

The menu goes well beyond traditional pizza, offering a full range of Italian-American classics and inventive specialties. Customers rave about the generous portions, fresh ingredients, and signature items like the rice balls and decadent desserts. With seating options both inside and, presumably seasonally, outside, you can enjoy the atmosphere of City Island Avenue while savoring gourmet pizza or soul-soothing pasta.

City Island Pizza Company is centrally located on City Island's main thoroughfare, making it an accessible spot for New Yorkers traveling from all parts of the city and beyond.

The full address is:

273 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464, USA

The restaurant ensures comfort and ease of access for all guests with comprehensive accessibility features:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible restroom
• Wheelchair accessible seating
• Free street parking is available, which is a notable convenience in New York City.
• The interior features gender-neutral restrooms, promoting an inclusive environment.
• The venue accepts reservations, allowing guests to plan ahead, especially for larger groups.

City Island Pizza Company provides a versatile range of services to accommodate every patron’s needs, whether they are dining in or enjoying a meal at home.

• Dining Experiences: Offers Table Service for Brunch (available on weekends), Lunch, and Dinner.
• Off-Premise Options: Provides Delivery, No-contact delivery, Takeout, and Curbside pickup, serving the City Island and greater NY community.
• Events and Groups: Welcomes groups of 7 to 60 guests for family-style lunch, dinner, or reception-style events, with fully customizable menus. Comprehensive Catering services are also available.
• Atmosphere & Amenities: Offers a Bar onsite with Alcohol, Beer, Cocktails, and a curated Wine list, including a selection of natural wines. Wi-Fi access is available for guests.
• Payment: Accepts Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments (e.g., Apple Pay, Google Pay).
• Family Services: The restaurant is recognized as Family-friendly, offering a dedicated Kids' menu and High chairs.

The restaurant's appeal stems from its commitment to quality, a diverse menu, and a vibrant dining experience, offering numerous highlights that set it apart.

• The Red Hot Chili Pepper Pie: One of the signature and most-loved menu items. This large pie is loaded with flavor, featuring high-quality San Marzano tomatoes, mozzarella, N'Duja (spicy Calabrian sausage), and hot Italian sausage, with a perfect kick of chili pepper spice.
• The Signature Rice Balls: A must-try appetizer, described by customers as amazing. These creamy risotto balls are panko-crusted and typically feature dried sausage and fresh mozzarella.
• Acclaimed Brunch: A new, highly anticipated addition to City Island dining. Brunch is noted for generous portions and delicious dishes like the savory Steak and Eggs and the "ridiculously delicious" Avocado Toast on housemade focaccia, often topped with poached eggs and whole burrata.
• Gourmet Italian Classics: The menu features classic dishes prepared with care, such as the Short Rib Pappardelle with braised short rib ragu, the rich Carbonara, and the soul-soothing Chicken Parmigiana or Eggplant Parmigiana.
• Unique Starters: Beyond the rice balls, popular small plates include Crispy Brussel Sprouts, Polenta Fries (parmesan-crusted and served with marinara), and Fried Mini Pizzas with burrata.
• Housemade Quality: Many items are made in-house, including the Housemade Rosemary Potato Chips, Focaccia, and Meatballs (a blend of pork, beef, and veal).
• Diverse Ownership: The business proudly identifies as both Latino-owned and women-owned, reflecting a commitment to diversity and local entrepreneurship.
• Cozy, Trendy Vibe: The atmosphere is carefully curated to be casual, cozy, and trendy, making it a great date spot that is both stylish and comfortable for locals.

To place an order, make a reservation, or inquire about events, please use the following contact details:

Address: 273 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464, USA

Phone: (718) 210-1970

If you are visiting City Island Pizza Company, the menu offers numerous standout choices, but a few dishes consistently earn the highest praise from New York diners.

The first and foremost choice for any visitor should be one of their signature pizzas. The Red Hot Chili Pepper Pie is a top highlight, a perfectly balanced gourmet pizza that delivers a complex flavor profile with its combination of N'Duja and spicy sausage. For a more classic experience that showcases the quality of their ingredients, the Margherita is an excellent choice, built on D.O.P San Marzano tomatoes and fresh mozzarella. If you're dining alone or looking for a quick bite, the smaller Bar Size Margarita Pie is a fan favorite.

Beyond the pizza, the Rice Balls are consistently called a "must have" appetizer, praised for their creamy texture and flavorful filling. For a hearty entrée, the Short Rib Pappardelle is often recommended, as the slow-braised short rib ragu offers a deeply savory, soul-satisfying experience. Finally, if you are visiting on a weekend, you owe it to yourself to experience their popular Brunch. Dishes like the Avocado Toast with burrata and poached eggs are reported to be "ridiculously delicious" and a truly filling, gourmet start to your weekend. Whether you are craving the comfort of perfect Italian-American cooking or a sophisticated, new take on New York pizza, City Island Pizza Company offers a destination-worthy meal.

City Island Pizza Company

273 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464, USA