The Original Crab Shanty

- 361 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464

For generations of New Yorkers, the mention of City Island instantly conjures up images of fresh seafood, nautical charm, and a relaxing escape right in the Bronx. Anchored firmly in this maritime community is The Original Crab Shanty, a beloved seafood institution that has been serving up generous portions and creating cherished dining memories since 1977. More than just a restaurant, it's a vibrant culinary gem and a historic fixture that remains a staple for locals and a destination for seafood enthusiasts from across the New York metropolitan area. City Island itself is a unique, charming environment, often referred to as 'a little New England in New York City,' and The Original Crab Shanty perfectly embodies that authentic, welcoming spirit.

The building that houses The Original Crab Shanty has a rich history, dating back to the turn of the century when it served as a silent movie theater. Later, in the early 1900s, it was converted into the City Island Post Office, a significant local landmark. When the property was transformed into a restaurant in 1977, the owners were determined to stand out, focusing on offering exceptional value: larger portions, reasonable prices, and impeccable service. This commitment quickly made them famous, particularly for their inventive menu items like the "Feast for Two," a combination platter that was unique in the local dining scene and a huge hit with customers. This dedication to quality and value is a tradition that continues to this day, making The Original Crab Shanty a trusted choice for a satisfying meal.

Today, the restaurant is celebrated for its striking visual appeal and cozy, historic atmosphere. Patrons are drawn to the friendly, attentive service and the overall calming, welcoming vibe—ideal for a family gathering or a casual outing after a sleepy weekend on the island or a visit to nearby Orchard Beach. The ambiance is notably casual, sometimes described as a fun, ship-like feel, making it approachable for everyone, from locals to tourists. They’ve even expanded their seating options to include a side patio, allowing diners to enjoy their meal while taking in the charm of City Island's main street.

The Original Crab Shanty is conveniently situated at the heart of the island’s main thoroughfare, making it an easy drive from various points in the Tri-State area. Its physical address is:

361 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464, USA

For those traveling by car from Westchester, Connecticut, or New Jersey, you can take I-95 or the Hutchinson River Parkway to the Orchard Beach/City Island exit and follow the signs. From Queens or Brooklyn, the Throgs Neck or Whitestone Bridges lead to I-95 North, with the same City Island exit. Once you cross the City Island bridge and pass two traffic lights, you will spot the restaurant’s parking lot on your right-hand side.

The restaurant prioritizes comfort and convenience for all patrons, offering a range of accessibility and parking options.

• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot (including valet service)
• Wheelchair accessible restroom and seating
• Valet parking is available, and there is also a free parking lot.
• Free street parking can often be found nearby, especially later in the evening.

The Original Crab Shanty maintains a casual dress code, ensuring that all guests feel relaxed and welcome. While reservations are accepted on weekdays, the restaurant operates on a first-come, first-served basis on busy weekends due to the dining room's limited size, reflecting its popularity.

The Original Crab Shanty provides a comprehensive set of services to accommodate every dining preference, from quick bites to large celebrations.

• Dining Options: Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Dessert, and Catering services are all available.
• Seating: Indoor table service is offered, alongside seasonal outdoor seating on the patio, perfect for enjoying City Island's pleasant weather.
• Order Fulfillment: Guests can choose from Dine-in, Takeout, No-contact delivery, and standard Delivery services.
• Beverage Program: A full bar is available onsite, featuring a great selection of Beer, Cocktails, Hard Liquor, and an extensive Wine list. Happy Hour drinks and food specials are also featured.
• Private Events: The restaurant has a private dining room available for booking large parties and functions.
• Atmosphere: The venue is consistently praised for its cozy, casual, and historic atmosphere, which appeals to groups, locals, and tourists alike.
• Payment: Accepts all major Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC mobile payments for a seamless transaction.

The long-standing success of The Original Crab Shanty is built on several key features that consistently delight its patrons, transforming a simple meal into a memorable experience.

• The Famous Garlic Bread: A true legend in the Bronx dining scene. The whole-clove garlic bread is irresistible and widely recognized as one of the restaurant's signature items—many loyal customers insist it's the best around.
• Generous Portions and Value: The restaurant has a decades-old reputation for offering colossal portions, ensuring excellent value for money. Combination platters like the Lobster and Shrimp special are often highlighted by customers as an 'insane' value.
• Snow Crab Legs: This is the most popular dish on the menu. The colossal snow crab legs can be ordered in various styles, including the popular Garlic, Marinara, or traditional Baltimore Style.
• Extensive Seafood Menu: The menu features a vast array of fresh seafood, serving crab 17 different ways. Options include succulent lobster specials, whole fish like trout and flounder, large scallops, stuffed clams, oysters, and various seafood pasta dishes.
• Non-Seafood Options: While seafood is the star, the menu is not limited, offering full steak, chicken, and pasta selections for all diners. This includes specialties like NY Shell Steak, Prime Rib, BBQ Baby Back Ribs, and classic Italian-American fare like Chicken and Veal Parmigiana.
• Dessert and Coffee: Customers frequently compliment the 'Great Coffee' and 'Great Dessert' selection, providing a perfect end to a rich seafood meal.
• Family-Friendly Amenities: The restaurant is noted for being good for kids, offering high chairs and a dedicated Kids' Menu, making it an ideal choice for family dining. They also welcome dogs in their outdoor seating areas.
• Fast Service: Despite the typically bustling crowd, particularly during popular dining hours, patrons often praise the service for being attentive and the food for coming out 'hot and fast.'

To plan your visit, inquire about catering, or book a reservation (recommended for weekdays and large parties):

Address: 361 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464, USA

Phone: (718) 885-1810

If you are visiting The Original Crab Shanty for the first time, you are in for a treat that captures the essence of City Island dining. The reason this place has maintained its status as a local favorite for decades is simple: consistency, quality, and exceptional value. You simply must begin your meal with a basket of their famous complimentary garlic bread, a recipe they are widely credited with originating, which has achieved legendary status among long-time customers.

For the main course, the top recommendation is undoubtedly the colossal Snow Crab Legs. Whether you opt for the classic broiled style or have them tossed in their house-made marinara or garlic sauce, it's the centerpiece dish that draws visitors from far and wide. The daily and luncheon specials, often featuring generous combos like a crab cluster, a lobster tail, and fried shrimp with a choice of sides, are especially worth choosing for the immense value they offer. These combos exemplify the restaurant’s commitment to providing a “Feast” rather than just a meal.

Beyond the crab, the New England clam chowder is a beloved appetizer, and the variety of Feasts for Two, such as the “Banquet for Crab Lovers” or the "Italian Feast" over fresh pasta, are perfect for sharing, staying true to the spirit of generous family dining that The Original Crab Shanty has cultivated for nearly fifty years. For a memorable and authentic New York seafood experience that feels a world away from the city's hustle, this Bronx gem is the ultimate destination.

The Original Crab Shanty

361 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464, USA