Come Prima

- 903 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10021

In the heart of New York City’s bustling Upper East Side, Come Prima stands out as a beacon of authentic Italian dining. This elegant restaurant, located on the iconic Madison Avenue, offers a sophisticated and cozy atmosphere that feels like a true escape from the urban frenzy. From the moment you step inside, you are transported to a place where classic Italian hospitality and culinary excellence are paramount. The ambiance is designed to be both romantic and upscale, yet also welcoming and comfortable, making it a perfect destination for a special date night, a celebratory dinner, or even a solo meal. The menu is a tribute to traditional Italian flavors, featuring dishes that are prepared with care and an emphasis on high-quality ingredients. Come Prima is well-known for its impressive culinary standards and is a popular choice for both locals and tourists seeking a memorable dining experience. The restaurant’s commitment to authentic flavors and impeccable service is evident in every detail, from the carefully curated wine list to the beautifully presented dishes. This dedication to providing a genuine taste of Italy in the heart of NYC is what makes Come Prima a standout choice among the city's many dining options.

The culinary journey at Come Prima begins with its varied and tempting menu, which offers a wide selection of traditional Italian dishes. The menu includes classic “Antipasti Caldi” and “Antipasti Freddi” to start, featuring items like the creamy mozzarella di bufala and the perfectly prepared filetto di manzo in carpaccio. The pasta selection is a true highlight, with options that are both comforting and refined. They also offer gluten-free and wholewheat pasta, which is a great option for those with dietary preferences. The “Secondi” menu presents a range of expertly prepared meat and fish dishes, such as the costolette d’agnello in crosta di pistacchio and the tagliata di manzo con rucola e parmigiano. The restaurant is also celebrated for its desserts, which are a must-try. Reviewers rave about the great desserts, noting that a bottle of Vermentino or another wine from their exceptional list complements the meal beautifully. The “dolci” menu includes classic Italian delights like tiramisu, panna cotta, and cannoli, all designed to be the perfect indulgent end to your dining experience. The bar on-site also offers a wide selection of beverages, including a great wine list, beer, cocktails, and hard liquor, ensuring there is a perfect pairing for every dish and a drink for every taste.

Come Prima is conveniently located at 903 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10021. Its prime location in the heart of the Upper East Side makes it easily accessible for anyone in the city. Situated between 72nd and 73rd Streets, the restaurant is a short walk from several subway stations, including the 6 line at 77th Street and the Q line at 72nd Street. This makes it a great choice for a night out, as it is well-connected to the rest of Manhattan and beyond. For those arriving by car, there is paid street parking available in the vicinity, which is a key consideration for this busy neighborhood. The restaurant is also mindful of accessibility for all guests, offering a wheelchair accessible entrance and a wheelchair accessible restroom. This commitment to convenience and inclusivity ensures that everyone can enjoy the refined atmosphere and exquisite food that Come Prima has to offer. The prestigious Madison Avenue location also places it in close proximity to some of New York's most famous landmarks, including Central Park and a number of renowned museums, making it a perfect spot for a meal after a day of sightseeing or a visit to a gallery. The neighborhood itself exudes an air of classic New York elegance, which perfectly complements the restaurant's upscale and romantic ambiance.

Come Prima provides a variety of services and features that enhance the dining experience for its guests. The restaurant is popular for both lunch and dinner, making it a versatile option for any time of day. They offer both takeout and dine-in options, providing flexibility for those who want to enjoy their delicious food at home or in the elegant setting of the restaurant.

• Takeout and Dine-in: Customers can choose to enjoy their meal in the restaurant’s cozy and upscale atmosphere or order to go for a taste of Italy at home.
• Accepts Reservations: Given its popularity, dinner reservations are highly recommended, and the restaurant accepts them to ensure guests can plan their visit in advance.
• Great Desserts: The dessert menu is a standout feature, with options like tiramisu and panna cotta that receive high praise.
• Great Wine List: The restaurant offers a curated and extensive wine list, providing the perfect pairing for any dish on the menu.
• Full Bar Service: A bar onsite offers a complete range of beverages, including alcohol, beer, cocktails, hard liquor, and a great selection of wine.
• Accessibility: The restaurant provides a wheelchair accessible entrance and restroom, ensuring it is a welcoming space for all guests.
• Dining Options: Come Prima is a popular spot for lunch, dinner, and dessert, and also offers table service for a more traditional dining experience.
• Atmosphere: The ambiance is described as cozy, romantic, trendy, and upscale, creating a multi-faceted setting suitable for various occasions.
• Payment Flexibility: The restaurant accepts both credit cards and debit cards for easy and convenient payment.

For your convenience, here is the contact information for Come Prima:

Address: 903 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10021

Phone: (212) 517-7700

Choosing Come Prima is a fantastic decision for anyone seeking an authentic and memorable Italian dining experience in New York City. What makes this restaurant truly worth choosing is its unwavering commitment to quality and tradition. The food is consistently described as "optimal," with dishes like the tender octopus and the flavorful pastas earning high praise. The restaurant successfully strikes a balance between being a trendy and upscale spot while maintaining a cozy and romantic atmosphere, which is a difficult feat to achieve in a bustling city like New York. The warm and attentive service contributes significantly to the overall positive experience, making you feel like a welcomed guest rather than just another customer. The highlights, such as the great dessert and impressive wine list, further elevate the dining experience, ensuring that every part of your meal is exceptional. The fact that it is a popular destination for tourists also speaks to its reputation for providing a truly classic New York dining experience. While some may note a need for a decor refresh, the quality of the food and the heart put into every dish more than compensates. Come Prima is a reliable and rewarding choice for a beautiful evening out, a celebratory meal, or simply to indulge in some of the city's finest Italian cuisine. It's a place where you can taste the "flavor and heart" of Italy right on Madison Avenue.

Come Prima

903 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10021, USA