Cookie Jar

- 181 New Dorp Ln, Staten Island, NY 10306

For residents and visitors in the New York City borough of Staten Island, the search for the perfect local spot often leads to a delightful find that merges the cozy atmosphere of a cafe with the sweet indulgence of a high-quality bakery. Cookie Jar, located right in the heart of Staten Island, has established itself as a premier destination for those seeking exceptional coffee, handcrafted cookies, and a wide array of decadent desserts and beverages. More than just a simple coffee shop, Cookie Jar is a multi-faceted establishment that operates as a dedicated cookie shop, a comprehensive bakery, and a welcoming cafe, making it an essential stop for any New Yorker with a craving for quality treats and a well-made cup of coffee.

The establishment's reputation in the New York community is built on a commitment to serving fresh, high-quality products. While they are renowned for their cookies, their coffee program and extensive menu of shakes and ice cream contribute to a truly well-rounded experience. Whether you’re beginning your day with a hot cup of coffee and a quick breakfast item or winding down with a rich dessert, Cookie Jar on New Dorp Lane is a friendly, professional, and accessible option for the local New York clientele.

The location of this popular Staten Island spot is incredibly convenient for local residents and commuters alike. Situated at 181 New Dorp Ln, Staten Island, NY 10306, the Cookie Jar’s New Dorp location places it in a highly trafficked and easily identifiable area of the borough. New Dorp Lane is a significant thoroughfare, ensuring that access via personal vehicle or public transportation is straightforward for anyone in the New York region looking for a quick and satisfying visit.

Accessibility is a key priority for a local New York business, and Cookie Jar meets essential needs by offering a wheelchair accessible entrance. This commitment to inclusivity ensures that all members of the New York community can easily enjoy their offerings. The amenity of a well-maintained restroom is also available on-site for the comfort of patrons. For those in a hurry, the establishment is structured for a quick visit, making it ideal for the fast-paced New York lifestyle, whether you’re grabbing a morning espresso or a platter of cookies for an evening gathering.

Cookie Jar offers a variety of services designed to accommodate modern customer preferences in New York:

• In-store pickup: Conveniently place your order and retrieve it quickly from the New Dorp Lane location.
• Onsite services: Enjoy a brief respite and your selection inside the cafe.
• Takeout: Perfect for New Yorkers on the go who want to grab their favorite cookies, coffee, or treats to enjoy elsewhere.
• Payment Flexibility: Major payment methods are accepted, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making transactions quick and easy.

The menu at Cookie Jar is impressively extensive, catering to a wide range of tastes and covering everything from morning drinks to late-day desserts. The core offering, of course, revolves around high-quality coffee and baked goods. The variety ensures that every visit, whether for breakfast or an afternoon indulgence, offers something new and exciting to try.

Features and highlights of the Cookie Jar experience include:

• Extensive Beverage Menu: The coffee offerings go beyond the basics, including essentials like Cappuccino, Espresso, Coffee, and Tea, alongside specialty creations such as the flavorful Extreme Toffee Coffee. Iced options like Iced Coffee and Iced Latte are perfect for warmer New York days, and the indulgent Crema Di Café is a unique treat.
• Creative Shake Selection: The shake menu is a standout feature, with imaginative flavors like Toasted Marshmallow, the decadent Red Velvet Cake Shake, a refreshing Frozen Cappuccino, and even the unique Avocado Shake and Lavender Shake. Classic options such as Vanilla Shake and Chocolate Shake are also available.
• Hard Scoop Ice Cream: Offering classic and unique ice cream flavors like Vanilla, Chocolate, Lavender, Coconut Almond Joy, and Bourbon Pecan, providing the perfect accompaniment to their baked goods. Lighter options like Lemon Sorbet are also offered.
• Full Dessert Menu: Beyond cookies, the selection includes a wide range of classic American desserts such as The Classic Sundae, Salted Caramel Brownie, Strawberry Shortcake, Key Lime Pie, Apple Crumb Pie, and the exotic Cherries Jubilee. The availability of an Espresso-Shot and items like Surely Pistachio further diversify the offerings.
• Dining Options: The cafe caters to both Breakfast needs with coffee and quick bites, as well as being a premier destination for Dessert throughout the day.
• Reputation for Cookies: Customers frequently praise the establishment for having "great cookies in Staten Island," with many using the shop for platters before holiday meals, cementing its place as a trusted local bakery in New York.

Whether you're a long-time Staten Island resident or just visiting the New York area, knowing how to reach this local gem is essential. Cookie Jar's contact information is straightforward and reliable:

• Address: 181 New Dorp Ln, Staten Island, NY 10306
• Phone: (718) 979-4500 (Also listed as Mobile Phone: +1 718-979-4500)

What makes Cookie Jar worth choosing for local New Yorkers is its dual identity as a professional cafe and a gourmet bakery. For the morning rush, it provides the essential jolt of an expertly made Coffee or Espresso, coupled with a convenient breakfast option. For those special occasions or simply a mid-week treat, the expansive selection of specialty cookies, custom cakes, rich shakes, and sundaes makes it a true dessert haven. The ability to easily pick up a platter of high-quality cookies for a New York gathering or holiday meal, as noted by enthusiastic local customers, is a significant draw. While reviews acknowledge the high quality and variety of their baked goods, the management's attention to product freshness and service remains crucial for maintaining the highest standards expected by the discerning New York customer base. Ultimately, Cookie Jar provides a unique, accessible, and delicious local option on Staten Island, successfully merging the warmth of a community bakery with the professionalism of a modern coffee shop.

Cookie Jar

181 New Dorp Ln, Staten Island, NY 10306, USA