Coral Bay Cafe

- 722 Rockaway St, Staten Island, NY 10307

Nestled in the quaint Tottenville neighborhood at the southern tip of Staten Island, Coral Bay Cafe offers New York diners a distinctive experience that blends authentic Italian cuisine with a robust focus on fresh, high-quality seafood. This establishment is not just another neighborhood eatery; it is a beloved local destination, frequently highlighted for its unique waterside location and its commitment to an exceptional dining experience. Diners seeking classic Italian comfort food alongside exquisite seafood specialties will find a generous and varied menu here.

The culinary philosophy at Coral Bay Cafe revolves around creating memorable meals, specializing in traditional Italian preparations while showcasing the freshest ingredients, especially in their extensive seafood offerings. From carefully crafted cold appetizers like Frutta Di Mare and Scungilli Salad to a dedicated pasta selection featuring items like Black Tagliatelle with jumbo lump crabmeat and Lobster Ravioli, the menu demonstrates a deep appreciation for both land and sea. Dinners are a celebration of aquatic delights, including Alaskan King Crab Legs, Shrimp Scampi, and the house specialty, Coral Bay Shrimp.

Beyond the plate, the cafe is renowned for its inviting ambiance. It is described as having a blend of casual, cozy, romantic, and trendy elements, making it suitable for almost any occasion—from a family dinner to a first date. Key highlights consistently praised by local patrons include the notably fast service, great dessert selections, excellent cocktails, and, critically, its stunning location which provides a rare waterfront dining experience in New York City.

Coral Bay Cafe is perfectly situated at 722 Rockaway St, Staten Island, NY 10307, USA. This address places it directly in the Tottenville section of Staten Island, known for its quiet, residential blocks and proximity to the water—often described as being right off the beach. The location provides a rare and desirable ambiance, as patrons can enjoy their Italian meal with the soothing backdrop of the shore and the Raritan Bay view, particularly appealing when utilizing the available outdoor seating.

Access to this part of Staten Island, while sometimes requiring a bit more travel time than the northern ferry-adjacent areas, is facilitated for local New Yorkers. For those traveling by car, Coral Bay Cafe is highly accessible and accommodating, offering both a Free parking lot and Free street parking, which is a significant amenity for a New York City restaurant. On-site parking makes visiting stress-free, especially for groups or families coming from across Staten Island or even from other boroughs via bridge connections.

For users relying on New York City public transportation, the Tottenville neighborhood is served by local MTA bus routes that connect to the Staten Island Railway (SIR) stations, which in turn connect to the St. George Ferry Terminal for a free ride to Manhattan. Visitors should consult current MTA schedules for the most direct bus lines to the vicinity of Rockaway Street, making the most of the Staten Island Railway’s furthest stop at Tottenville to minimize local bus transit.

Coral Bay Cafe provides a comprehensive range of dining services and accessibility features designed to maximize guest comfort and convenience across brunch, lunch, and dinner.

• Full Dining Options: Available for Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert, with comfortable seating and dedicated table service.
• Reservations Accepted: Guests can call ahead to reserve a table, which is highly recommended for peak times, ensuring a smoother dining experience without a long wait.
• Flexible Service Modes: Offers Dine-in, convenient Takeout, and seasonal Outdoor seating, perfect for enjoying the waterfront ambiance on pleasant New York days.
• Full Bar Service: A well-stocked Bar onsite offering a full range of Alcohol, including Beer, signature Cocktails, Hard liquor, and an adequate selection of Wine.
• Family-Friendly Amenities: Designed to be Good for kids, featuring a dedicated Kids’ menu and High chairs for the youngest diners.
• Accessibility Features: Fully accessible with a Wheelchair accessible entrance, Wheelchair accessible restroom, and Wheelchair accessible seating, ensuring comfort for all patrons.
• Payment Versatility: Accepts Credit cards, Debit cards, and modern NFC mobile payments, with the welcome surprise, as noted by a customer, of not adding a credit card surcharge.

Several exceptional features make Coral Bay Cafe a standout choice for Italian and seafood enthusiasts in the New York area:

• Stunning Waterfront Location: Positioned "right off the beach" in Tottenville, the cafe offers one of Staten Island's precious few seaside dining options, with a beautiful view that enhances the dining atmosphere.
• Exceptional Seafood Menu: The extensive menu focuses heavily on fresh seafood, featuring premium choices like Alaskan King Crab Legs, Frutta Di Mare, Sea Scallops, and Zuppa Di Pesce, catering perfectly to "big seafood lovers."
• Atmosphere and Ambiance: The restaurant successfully balances a Casual and Cozy feel with a Romantic and slightly Trendy vibe, making it an excellent backdrop for intimate dinners, group gatherings, or even a comfortable solo dining experience.
• Fast Service (When Not Busy): The service is highlighted as typically "Fast service," ensuring a quick and efficient meal. Even during busy periods that may cause longer waits, the food quality is noted as "really amazing," validating the wait.
• Desserts and Cocktails: Patrons consistently praise the quality of the Great cocktails and the satisfying variety and quality of the Great dessert selection, rounding out the full meal experience.
• Comfort Food and Italian Classics: Alongside the seafood, the menu features Italian comfort food staples like Penne Marinara, Rigatoni Filetto, and Cheese Ravioli, offering familiar favorites for all palates.
• Parking Convenience: The provision of both a Free parking lot and Free street parking is a major highlight in NYC, making the drive to Tottenville highly practical and accommodating.

To make a reservation, inquire about outdoor seating availability, or arrange a takeout order, please contact Coral Bay Cafe using the information below:

Address: 722 Rockaway St, Staten Island, NY 10307, USA

Phone: (718) 356-3501

Mobile Phone: +1 718-356-3501

For New Yorkers looking for a genuinely special dining outing that combines the best of Italian culinary tradition with a spectacular setting, Coral Bay Cafe is absolutely worth choosing. The cafe provides a much-sought-after escape from the hustle and bustle, offering one of the few places in the borough where you can enjoy fine Italian seafood right by the water. The combination of a cozy, romantic atmosphere and the picturesque location makes it an ideal spot for celebrating milestones or simply elevating a regular weeknight meal.

What truly sets Coral Bay Cafe apart is its food and value proposition. The menu is robust and features premium options that satisfy the most serious seafood connoisseurs—from Alaskan King Crab Legs to the diverse offerings in the Frutta Di Mare. Customers consistently laud the "delicious" quality of the dishes. While some patrons have mentioned that portion sizes can feel small for the price, the general consensus is that the overall quality of the ingredients and the flavorful preparation are "really amazing" and justify the cost, especially given the unique waterfront location in New York.

Moreover, the small details enhance the experience significantly. Features like the great cocktails, excellent desserts, and the pleasant surprise of not charging a credit card fee demonstrate a commitment to a positive overall guest experience. Choosing Coral Bay Cafe is choosing a meal where the food is incredible, the setting is unique, and the extensive menu provides something comforting and exciting for every member of the family or group. It is the perfect choice for a sophisticated yet relaxed Italian seafood experience in Staten Island.

Coral Bay Cafe

722 Rockaway St, Staten Island, NY 10307, USA